<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	>

<channel>
	<title>Essays.Native-American-Major-Leaguers &#8211; Society for American Baseball Research</title>
	<atom:link href="https://sabr.org/journal_archive/essays-native-american-major-leaguers/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link>https://sabr.org</link>
	<description></description>
	<lastBuildDate>Tue, 19 May 2026 19:30:39 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<language>en-US</language>
	<sy:updatePeriod>
	hourly	</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>
	1	</sy:updateFrequency>
	<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5</generator>
	<item>
		<title>Introduction: Native American Major Leaguers</title>
		<link>https://sabr.org/journal/article/introduction-native-american-major-leaguers/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[wpadmin]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 07:20:54 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://sabr.org/?post_type=journal_articles&#038;p=326029</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[In the early days of baseball, Native players were often identified not by their actual heritage but by perceived facial features or stereotypes. The label “Chief” was frequently used by opponents, fans, management, teammates, and coaches alike. Far from honoring the players, the term was an appropriation and caricature, and was perpetuated by the sportswriters [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="calibre_link-3" class="calibre1">
<p class="first-paragraph"><a href="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Native-American-Major-Leaguers-Cover-front.jpg"><img fetchpriority="high" decoding="async" class="alignright  wp-image-321554" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Native-American-Major-Leaguers-Cover-front.jpg" alt="Native American Major Leaguers, edited by Rob Daugherty and Bill Nowlin" width="225" height="326" srcset="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Native-American-Major-Leaguers-Cover-front.jpg 900w, https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Native-American-Major-Leaguers-Cover-front-207x300.jpg 207w, https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Native-American-Major-Leaguers-Cover-front-711x1030.jpg 711w, https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Native-American-Major-Leaguers-Cover-front-768x1112.jpg 768w, https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Native-American-Major-Leaguers-Cover-front-487x705.jpg 487w" sizes="(max-width: 225px) 100vw, 225px" /></a>In the early days of baseball, Native players were often identified not by their actual heritage but by perceived facial features or stereotypes. The label “Chief” was frequently used by opponents, fans, management, teammates, and coaches alike. Far from honoring the players, the term was an appropriation and caricature, and was perpetuated by the sportswriters to garner sensationalized headlines. This practice was not meant to respect Native Americans; rather it reduced them to stereotypes.</p>
<p class="body">I encountered similar attitudes firsthand while playing college ball in the early 1970s. Fortunately, the open name-calling has diminished over time, but the use of monikers and caricatures still continues. At a community leaders conference hosted by the Cherokee Nation, I had the privilege of introducing my friend and fellow Haskell alumnus Mr. Billy Mills – a proud Citizen of the Lakota Sioux from Pine Ridge, South Dakota. Billy Mills was a gold medalist in the 10,000-meter race in the 1964 Olympics in Japan. I asked him in a conversation about the use of the term “Chief” and other stereotypical names our Native athletes have been called over the years. Billy, with his characteristic grace, smiled and replied, “You don’t mind being known as an Indian, but you don’t want it to be your whole identity.” I had come across that quote in a book before, but having Billy say it in person made the moment – and the message – all the more meaningful.</p>
<p class="body">I have always known that several Native ballplayers made their mark in major-league baseball, and over the years I casually sought out their cards and memorabilia. Whenever I was asked to speak or emcee at Native events, I’d share a bit about my collection and research, highlighting players from the Tribe or Nation connected to the community I was visiting. To my surprise, very few were familiar with the names I would mention. It quickly became clear to me that this history wasn’t being shared – and it needed to be.</p>
<p class="body">What began as a personal interest to correct a misnomer in baseball turned into a focused mission. By that I mean to make the sports world aware that the very first person to break the color barrier in the major leagues was in fact a Native American named Louis Sockalexis from the Penobscot Tribe in Maine. That was in 1897 with the Cleveland Spiders. The requests for presentations started increasing, and soon media inquiries followed. When asked to provide proof for my talks, I began organizing my collection into a formal exhibit, showcasing the 28 Native men who made it to the major leagues 50 years prior to Mr. Jackie Robinson. I continue to travel across the country searching for more cards and photos, and artifacts tied to these Indigenous icons. This journey has been more than a hobby; it’s a deeply rewarding experience – one that only those driven by passion for history and heritage can truly understand. Sadly, many of those 28 Native players are overlooked by sports media and rarely mentioned. Some played for many seasons but many played for a season, a month, or, in some cases, just a single game. When people questioned the legitimacy of these players, it only fueled my determination to shine the light on these sports heroes whose stories have long gone untold. This is why it matters to me. Someone needs to tell their story. And I intend to make sure it’s heard.</p>
<p class="body1">*****</p>
<p class="body">After becoming aware of the Society for American Baseball Research and eventually joining the organization, I began exploring research conducted by other SABR members, specifically Native and those who played between 1897 and 1947. I discovered that some research had already been done. I was fortunate to connect with Mr. Bill Nowlin, a sitting board member of SABR. He was very helpful and encouraging as I delved deeper into my effort to document and research Native major-league baseball players. Our correspondence quickly became regular and it eventually led to co-editing a book – <a href="https://sabr.org/e-books/sabr-digital-library-native-american-major-leaguers/"><em>Native American Major Leaguers</em></a> – that focused on Native Americans in major-league baseball. As my research expanded beyond 1947, I remained committed to verifying tribal affiliations of these players using the same application process I had applied to the earlier group of players. This application ensures that the consistency and the integrity and accuracy of the research are maintained throughout.</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>CRITERIA</strong></p>
<p class="body">From the very start of my research, the established process to verify and authenticate the identities of Native ballplayers was by contacting the enrollment and registration offices of their respective Tribes. The initial publication of this project was made possible through a grant from two Tribes, the Cherokee Nation and the Chickasaw Nation, both from Oklahoma. The grant involved the use of federal funding; as a result, it was necessary to include only those players who were enrolled citizens of federally recognized Tribes, as listed by the Office of Federal Acknowledgement in the Bureau of Indian Affairs, part of the US Department of the Interior.</p>
<p class="body">There are former major-league players whose names are associated with Native heritage, but do not meet the established criteria for inclusion in this book. One example is Hall of Fame catcher Johnny Bench of the Cincinnati Reds. While Bench is Choctaw by blood, he is not officially enrolled, but is certainly eligible. As such, he does not meet the enrollment-based standards required for inclusion. There are Dwight Lowry, a former player for the Tigers and the Twins, and Gene Locklear, a former player for the Reds, Padres, and the Yankees. Both are from the Lumbee Tribe in North Carolina. The Lumbee are actively seeking full federal recognition. Currently, the Lumbee are recognized in North Carolina as a state recognized Tribe. In 1956 the US Congress passed the Lumbee Act, recognizing Lumbees as being Native Americans, but denying the benefits of a federally recognized Tribe.</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>ACKNOWLEDGMENTS</strong></p>
<p class="sources">Throughout this project, I was fortunate to receive support from many individuals – far too many to name them all. However, there are several whose special contributions kick-started my work. First and foremost, my family. Kelly, with her computer navigation skills, and to BC and Jay who always from the beginning helped me sort and catalog my collection. You each tolerated the countless boxes of cards lining the hallways and into your closets. Special thanks to Catherine Foreman Gray, who was the first to ask me to make a presentation on this work. To Dr. Gourd, for the idea of an exhibit. Deep gratitude to Tonya Hogner-Weavel, who took charge to curate my entire collection at the Cherokee Heritage Center that brought my vision to life. I am also grateful to Nathan Rueckert and Ethan Bryan for selecting my story for their publication and connecting me with Matt Strahm of the Philadelphia Phillies, who kindly featured me on his show on Bally Sports, a national syndicated production.</p>
<p class="sources">A heartfelt thanks to Bill Nowlin, whose guidance and encouragement have been instrumental throughout this project. And finally, to many friends, colleagues, and supporters who discussed this work with me or offered kind words to keep me going forward – I say WaDo!</p>
<p class="sources">To Bo, Callie, Cassidy, Uncle Curt, Dave, Donetta, Hunter, James, Jason, Joaquin, Joe, John, Lin, Matt, Molly, Paul, Ron, Tammy, Thomas, Todd, Travis, Cherokee Nation, Cherokee Phoenix, Chickasaw Nation, NCAI, 97.1 Sports Animal, the Tulsa Drillers and the <em>Tulsa World</em>.</p>
<p class="sources">WADO, SGI, THANK YOU!!!</p>
<p><em><strong>ROB DAUGHERTY</strong> is an Enrolled Citizen of the Cherokee Nation in Oklahoma. Rob is a retired educator from the Bureau of Indian Affairs and most recently from the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma. A graduate of Haskell Indian Nations University. He has been a lifelong geek fan of Baseball, having played and coached collegiately. His passion for Native baseball players has evolved into one of the largest collections of Native American baseball cards. Focused exclusively on Indigenous players prior to 1947. Through extensive research 28 have been verified as Natives who played in what is now MLB from the years 1897 to 1947. Rob is a huge, huge Yankees fan.</em></p>
<ul>
<li><strong>Read more: </strong><a href="https://sabr.org/e-books/sabr-digital-library-native-american-major-leaguers/">Click here to read all player biographies and essays from <em>Native American Major Leaguers </em>in the SABR Research Collection</a></li>
</ul>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Today’s Native American Ballplayer: Identity and Resilience</title>
		<link>https://sabr.org/journal/article/todays-native-american-ballplayer-identity-and-resilience/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[wpadmin]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 07:19:37 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://sabr.org/?post_type=journal_articles&#038;p=325894</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Brandon Bailey takes immense pride in his Native American heritage. A Chickasaw citizen, he has ancestors who walked the Trail of Tears and attended Indian boarding schools. “My Chickasaw identity is part of who I am every day,” he said. Bailey, pitching coach for the Los Angeles Dodgers Class-A affiliate in Rancho Cucamonga, California, pitched [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="calibre_link-90" class="calibre1">
<p class="first-paragraph">Brandon Bailey takes immense pride in his Native American heritage. A Chickasaw citizen, he has ancestors who walked the Trail of Tears and attended Indian boarding schools.</p>
<p class="body">“My Chickasaw identity is part of who I am every day,” he said.</p>
<p class="body">Bailey, pitching coach for the Los Angeles Dodgers Class-A affiliate in Rancho Cucamonga, California, pitched briefly in the majors for the Houston Astros.<a id="calibre_link-3093" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3076">1</a></p>
<p class="body">Heritage underscores a foundational belief he applies to his baseball career: “Representation matters.”</p>
<p class="body">Some Natives who play and coach professional baseball today were born and raised in communities close to their twentieth-century predecessors, particularly those from rural Oklahoma and other areas in the Southwest and Southeast with Native tribes and communities. Others, like Bailey, were raised in more suburban environments.</p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="courtesy">In addition to their success in baseball, they’re keenly aware of their Indigenous backgrounds and are comfortable speaking out on the topic – with colleagues and reporters and in social media. They plan to become involved in their Native communities when their careers wind down. These players and coaches also recognize the cultural complexities of race in baseball.</p>
</div>
<p class="body">This article includes perspectives from five such major leaguers – Ryan Helsley, Jon Gray, Adrian Houser, Anthony Seigler, and Bailey – along with Tyler Gillum, head coach of the Savannah Bananas, a popular barnstorming team. Their stories share some common elements, especially how their Native identities inform their personal beliefs.</p>
<p class="body">Some recent Native American major leaguers, such as Jacoby Ellsbury and Joba Chamberlain, have full SABR biographies. Dylan Bundy, a Cherokee Nation citizen from Oklahoma, retired after the 2022 season and does not yet have a full SABR biography.<a id="calibre_link-3094" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3077">2</a> He did have a substantive career as a starting pitcher who won 54 games for the Baltimore Orioles, Los Angeles Angels, and Minnesota Twins.</p>
<p class="body">Ellsbury was profiled in a Florida newspaper about his involvement with a baseball camp for young Natives:</p>
<p class="blockquote">Baseball plays an important role in his life, but serving as a role model to Native American kids does as well. Ellsbury combined those passions and teamed up with Nike in 2011 to run the N7 Jacoby Ellsbury Baseball Camp on the Sale Rover-Maricopa Indian Community in Scottsdale, Arizona.</p>
<p class="blockquote">“This is a way to give back,” Ellsbury said. “If the kids take one thing from camp, it’s that they can work hard, go to school, get good grades and have a dream and goal in mind.”<a id="calibre_link-3095" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3078">3</a></p>
<p class="body">The article also includes a section about the modern player’s experience with racial stereotypes, with observations from Helsley, Bailey, and <em>New York Times</em> correspondent Kurt Streeter.</p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000048.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Ryan Helsley (Courtesy of the St. Louis Cardinals)</em></p>
<div id="calibre_link-90" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>RYAN HELSLEY, CHEROKEE</strong></p>
<p class="body">New York Mets reliever Ryan Helsley gets most of his Native heritage from his mother’s side, though his father is also Cherokee.</p>
<p class="body">Helsley was born and raised in Tahlequah, Oklahoma, a city that is the capital of the state’s two federally recognized Cherokee tribes, the <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.cherokee.org/">Cherokee Nation</a> and the <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.ukb-nsn.gov/">Keetoowah Band of the Cherokee Indians</a>.</p>
<p class="body">Helsley, a right-handed flamethrower who set a Cardinals franchise record while leading the National League with 49 saves in 2024, said Cherokee culture was more in the background during his childhood.</p>
<p class="body">“My grandma would watch us during the summer when we were kids,” he said. “We didn’t have a lot of Cherokee culture in our daily lives, but we did attend powwows. My grandma spoke the language fluently and taught us a few phrases.”<a id="calibre_link-3096" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3079">4</a></p>
<p class="body">He attended local schools, including Sequoyah High School, a boarding school for Native Americans. He played multiple sports but did not attend showcases, so was not noticed much.</p>
<p class="body">“I was a late bloomer,” he said. “I didn’t throw crazy hard back then. I threw hard enough for local colleges. I wanted to play football, but my college coach encouraged me to focus on baseball.”</p>
<p class="body">Helsley attended Northeastern State University in Tahlequah, not planning to play professional baseball. About a quarter of NSU’s student population identifies as Cherokee, and the school offers many Cherokee linguistics courses — including a major in the Cherokee language. Some courses are taught in Cherokee.</p>
<p class="body">“My plan was to get a degree – NSU was a four-year school. My mom works in radiology, reading MRIs, and I always thought that was cool growing up. I admired her work helping people. Initially, I wanted to go to medical school, but I changed my path to physical therapy. My next thought was helping athletes recover from injuries.”</p>
<p class="body">Those plans changed when he began to bloom on the diamond.</p>
<p class="body">“Going to college allowed me to focus on one sport and train my body. I was athletic enough to play multiple sports and be decent at all of them, but once I focused solely on pitching, I improved significantly,” he said.</p>
<p class="body">After two years at NSU, he was drafted by and signed with the Cardinals in 2015. He moved up through the farm system, eventually making his major-league debut in 2019.</p>
<p class="body">As a major leaguer, Helsley frequently returns to Tahlequah to visit family and friends. “I try to show my face in the community because it’s important for people to understand that I’m not a celebrity,” he said. “I’m just like them, trying to make it day by day.”</p>
<p class="body">Helsley is a good friend of Adrian Houser, a major-league pitcher who was also raised in Tahlequah.</p>
<p class="body">Helsley and his family were profiled in an article in <em>The Athletic</em> during his rookie season.<a id="calibre_link-3097" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3080">5</a> The article notes that the morning after he was drafted, Helsley helped run a baseball camp for kids in his hometown.</p>
<p class="body">“I try to be the best I can be, live in the moment, and make the most of every opportunity,” he said.</p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body"> </p>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000049.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Jon Gray (Courtesy of the Texas Rangers)</em></p>
</div>
<div id="calibre_link-90" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>JON GRAY, CHEROKEE</strong></p>
<p class="body">Texas Rangers pitcher Jon Gray was born in Shawnee, Oklahoma, and raised in Chandler, less than 30 miles away. His Cherokee roots come from his mother’s side. He cites his grandfather, who grew up near Tahlequah, in Cherokee County, as a major influence on his Native awareness.<a id="calibre_link-3098" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3081">6</a></p>
<p class="body">“My grandfather grew up with four brothers. His father was an Irish immigrant, and his mother was a full-blooded Cherokee. They had a small farm near Tahlequah, where the boys were raised,” Gray said.<a id="calibre_link-3099" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3082">7</a></p>
<p class="body">After serving in the military, his grandfather bought land near Chandler.</p>
<p class="body"><span class="bold">“</span>A lot of my learning came later, but my grandfather spoke a little Cherokee and told us stories about growing up in Tahlequah,” he said. “He shared what he knew, and I always appreciated that.”</p>
<p class="body">Gray took several Native studies courses in college, including Cherokee language classes.</p>
<p class="body">“I feel like language is so important – if you keep it alive, it will stay forever,” he said.</p>
<p class="body">Before that, Gray played American Legion baseball in Ada, Oklahoma, and high-school baseball in Chandler, along with wrestling, football, and basketball.</p>
<p class="body">“I also played against great Native American ballplayers,” he said. “They were amazing athletes. I grew up not far from the Sac and Fox Nation, where Jim Thorpe was from. In eastern Oklahoma, we often played against them in football and basketball.”</p>
<p class="body">He recalled games against Sequoyah High School, a Cherokee boarding school in Tahlequah, being “fun matchups.”</p>
<p class="body">From there, Gray attended Eastern Oklahoma State College before transferring to the University of Oklahoma for two seasons. He was drafted by the Colorado Rockies in the June 2013 amateur draft and made his major-league debut for the Rockies two years later. In 2023 Gray appeared in two games, winning one, for the Rangers in the World Series.</p>
<p class="body">Raised in the heart of Cherokee country, Gray said he feels his heritage played a role in his development as a professional baseball player.</p>
<p class="body">“I do feel like my heritage has given me an edge – playing on North American soil, or just instinctively. I’ve always seen it as a positive thing. Plenty of teammates have asked me about Cherokee language and culture.”</p>
<p class="body">“Getting financial help for my college books made a big difference – we didn’t have much money. That support meant a lot to me, and now I want to find ways to give back,” he said. “After baseball, I want to get involved – whether in sports, health, or something else within the community. That’s a big goal of mine.”</p>
<p class="body">Gray has a message for young Native ballplayers: “If you have a dream, you can achieve it.”</p>
<p class="body">“Sometimes it might feel like you can’t escape your circumstances – but you can go out into the world, chase your goals, and bring that success back to your community. I’m living proof of that.”</p>
<p class="body">He added: “I want to see more Cherokee athletes rise up. The talent is there, and I want young players to know they shouldn’t feel held back at all.”</p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body"> </p>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w2" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000050.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Adrian Houser (Eddie Kelley, Round Rock Express)</em></p>
</div>
<div id="calibre_link-90" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>ADRIAN HOUSER, CHEROKEE</strong></p>
<p class="body">Pitcher Adrian Houser was born in a Cherokee Nation hospital in Tahlequah, Oklahoma. He is Cherokee through his mother’s side of the family.</p>
<p class="body">“I grew up in Locust Grove, about 25 minutes north of Tahlequah,” he said. “Locust Grove is a small town with only two stoplights, while Tahlequah has 20 times as many. My high school had a graduating class of about 100 students.”<a id="calibre_link-3100" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3083">8</a></p>
<p class="body">Houser described Locust Grove as a quiet, close-knit town where everybody knows everybody else. “Through my mom’s side alone, I’m related to half the town,” he said. “I spent a lot of time outside, playing in the dirt, running through fields, hanging out with friends, and playing sports. I had an awesome childhood, riding my bike to my friend’s house – that’s how small the town was.”</p>
<p class="body">Houser said that for most of his childhood, his Cherokee identity remained in the background.</p>
<p class="body">“When I was young, I attended Cherokee Nation Head Start, which was similar to preschool. All the kids there were Cherokee. My grandma and aunt had Cherokee Nation photos on the walls, and we learned how to count and speak a little Cherokee. I didn’t keep up with the language, though.”</p>
<p class="body">Baseball was a big part of his upbringing. Throughout his elementary-school years, he played baseball on a team coached by his father that traveled to nearby states and even Puerto Rico. He joined a travel team in high school, then in his junior year he played for a team based in Dallas, about five hours away.</p>
<p class="body">“That’s when we started playing in bigger tournaments and getting attention from scouts and agents,” he said.</p>
<p class="body">He was friends with Ryan Helsley and Dylan Bundy as they played against each other in youth tournaments and high school.</p>
<p class="body">Houser was drafted in 2011 by the Houston Astros and broke in with the Milwaukee Brewers, debuting in 2015. He last pitched in the majors for the New York Mets in 2024. In 2025, he was signed by the Chicago White Sox and traded to the Tampa Bay Rays.</p>
<p class="body">Houser’s heritage drives many of his personal beliefs, especially those connected to baseball.</p>
<p class="body">“Sometimes, I think about the fact that I’m representing more than just myself,” he said. “Being a small-town kid, I want to show that you don’t have to come from a big city to reach your dreams. And as a Cherokee, some kids in Oklahoma know about my background and can look up to that – they can see that someone with their heritage has reached their dreams too.”</p>
</div>
<p class="body"> </p>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000052.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Brandon Bailey with Corpus Christi in the spring of 2019. (Courtesy of Wikeah Vigil)</em></p>
</div>
<div id="calibre_link-90" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>BRANDON BAILEY, CHICKASAW</strong></p>
<p class="body">To Bailey, baseball is a game of resilience – a word that resonates with every Indigenous community.</p>
<p class="body">“Growing up, as far back as my memory can take me, <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.chickasaw.tv/profiles/brandon-bailey-profile">my Chickasaw heritage</a> has always been a part of my life,” Bailey said during spring training 2025. “My grandfather is half Chickasaw and my great-grandfather was full-blooded. My grandfather frequently talks about this – getting involved in the tribe, going to reunions.”<a id="calibre_link-3101" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3084">9</a></p>
<p class="body">Though Bailey was born and raised in Colorado, he feels deeply connected to the Chickasaw Nation in Oklahoma.</p>
<p class="body">“My family’s history is tied to the Trail of Tears – some of my ancestors walked it. My great-grandfather attended an Indian boarding school in Oklahoma, where he met his future wife. They eventually planted their roots in Colorado,” Bailey said.</p>
<p class="body">“Because of his experience in boarding school, my great-grandfather swore he would never return to Oklahoma. That has always stuck with me. Even though I didn’t experience that firsthand or grow up on the reservation, I strive to be an example for young Indigenous children interested in sports.”</p>
<p class="body">He added: “I want to learn more about Chickasaw culture. As I made my way through the minor leagues, I had big dreams of being involved with the community. Injuries led me to retire, but staying in baseball allows me to make an impact – teaching youth the game and helping them grow.”</p>
<p class="body">“I’d love to work with Chickasaw youth and other tribal communities to help make baseball a sport of interest for Native American kids.”</p>
<p class="body">Bailey believes sport is medicine.</p>
<p class="body">“Movement is one of the greatest things we can do as human beings. Baseball is truly special. You play outdoors, run on dirt and grass under the sunshine – it lifts your spirits, makes you feel healthy and alive.”</p>
<p class="body">Bailey has conversations about this heritage with colleagues.</p>
<p class="body"><span class="bold">“</span>These conversations come up often. I frequently discuss my background with coworkers. My boss knows how proud I am to be Indigenous, and I’m always happy to share my perspective.”</p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="courtesy"> </p>
</div>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000051.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Anthony Seigler (Courtesy of the St. Louis Cardinals)</em></p>
</div>
<div id="calibre_link-90" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>ANTHONY SEIGLER, NAVAJO</strong></p>
<p class="body">On July 1, 2025, Anthony Seigler became the second Navajo (Diné) player in major-league history.</p>
<p class="body">That’s the day the 26-year-old switch-hitting infielder was selected by the Milwaukee Brewers from the team’s AAA-affiliate, the Nashville Sounds of the International League.</p>
<p class="body">When he got the call, the Brewers were in New York for a series against the Mets — a long way from the Navajo reservation where Seigler was born.</p>
<p class="body">Seigler was chosen by the New York Yankees in the first round of the 2018 draft, out of Cartersville High School in Cartersville, Georgia. A year earlier, he played catcher for the USA team that won the U-18 Baseball World Cup. Nearly all his teammates eventually played professional baseball, including several in the major leagues.</p>
<p class="body">Seigler learned about Jacoby Ellsbury — the first player of Navajo descent to make the major leagues — only after being drafted. Now, he is fully aware of being one of the few Native American players in professional baseball.</p>
<p class="body">“I carry it as a badge of honor,” he said shortly after joining the Brewers. “There aren’t a lot of Native Americans in professional sports, and the ones who are there are not always widely known. So for us, especially being on the stage I’m at, it’s awesome to be able to represent and play for my Navajo Nation.”<a id="calibre_link-3102" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3085">10</a></p>
<p class="body">Seigler was born in Fort Defiance, Arizona, a small community of fewer than 4,000 people located in the Navajo Nation on the border with New Mexico. Over 90 percent of the population of Fort Defiance is Native American, according to the 2010 U.S. Census.</p>
<p class="body">“Everyone calls it <em>The Fort</em>,” said Seigler’s mother Alysia Webb, herself born and raised on a reservation in Window Rock, Arizona, capitol of the Navajo Nation. Webb speaks the Navajo language, Diné bizaad, as do her parents. Her grandfather was a Navajo code talker in World War II.<a id="calibre_link-3103" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3086">11</a></p>
<p class="body">Webb said her family, including Anthony and his three siblings, have always focused on basketball.</p>
<p class="body">“On the rez, basketball is <em>it</em>,” she said. “We probably have nine or 10 state high school basketball championships in our family.”</p>
<p class="body">In fact, Webb had never been off the reservation until she went to college, where she played basketball. As Seigler said: “We’re a love-to-hoop family.”</p>
<p class="body">But Webb knew her son was a gifted athlete in baseball too. “We knew he was a good ballplayer but for us it felt normal, as crazy as that may sound,” she said.</p>
<p class="body">It wasn’t until Seigler entered professional baseball that he began to understand how much his heritage meant — not just to him, but to others. Messages started to come in from family, community members, even strangers on Instagram.</p>
<p class="body">“They tell me how I’m representing the Navajo Nation really well,” he said. “Kids on the rez started playing baseball when they heard about me. It gives them hope, whatever situation they’re in.”</p>
<p class="body">His identity often sparks curiosity, especially in a sport where Native American players are few and far between. “Usually if I show up somewhere new, the Latino guys start talking Spanish to me because of how I look,” he said. “My teammates usually get curious when they learn I’m Native American. If they ask, I talk with them. It does come up.”</p>
<p class="body">Though he moved off the reservation as a child, he doesn’t take for granted the challenges others still face. “Native Americans who live on the rez have harder lives — I can’t speak fully to that. But I do believe in understanding where people come from and treating them how they want to be treated.”</p>
<p class="body">Seigler never set out to be a symbol—but as his profile has grown, so too has his sense of responsibility. What began as a love for sports has become a way to carry his heritage with him, everywhere the game takes him.</p>
<p class="body">That connection became especially clear during his time with USA Baseball.</p>
<p class="body">“I remember my mom bringing the Navajo Nation flag,” he recalls. “When I went out on the field, I was representing Team USA, but I wanted the Navajo community to know I was there for us.”</p>
<p class="body">“It’s awesome to have a community, a whole big Navajo Nation, cheering for me, pulling for me, praying for me.”</p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body"> </p>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000053.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Tyler Gillum (Courtesy of Wakeah Vigil)</em></p>
</div>
<div id="calibre_link-90" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>TYLER GILLUM, CHICKASAW</strong></p>
<p class="body">Chickasaw citizen <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.chickasaw.tv/profiles/tyler-gillum-profile">Tyler Gillum</a> is head coach of the <a class="calibre2" href="https://thesavannahbananas.com/">Savannah Bananas</a>, a barnstorming team that in 2024 drew more fans than one major-league team.</p>
<p class="body">Gillum was born in 1986 in a Chickasaw hospital in Ada, Oklahoma.</p>
<p class="body"><span class="bold">“</span>Growing up in Ada, I was surrounded by Native American culture all the time. There were so many aspects of Chickasaw heritage that I took part in,” he said shortly after kicking off the 2025 Bananas tour.<a id="calibre_link-3104" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3087">12</a></p>
<p class="body">In 2024 the team played in 29 cities, drawing more than one million fans – more than the home attendance of the Oakland Athletics. In 2025 the team expected to play in 18 major-league ballparks, two NFL stadiums, and one college football stadium, with overall attendance expected to double.<a id="calibre_link-3105" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3088">13</a></p>
<p class="body">The Chickasaw Nation played a major part in Gillum’s baseball journey.</p>
<p class="body">“It started with Chickasaw baseball camps in high school. The first one I attended was in Ardmore, Oklahoma, at Ardmore High School,” he said. “That camp was one of the best I’ve ever been a part of – high-level coaching with former major-league players, scouts, crosscheckers, current players, and college coaches from Division I schools.”</p>
<p class="body">That experience was a huge stepping stone for Gillum – it inspired him to want to play college baseball. He ended up attending Seminole State Junior College in Seminole, Oklahoma.</p>
<p class="body">“While I was in college, I started coaching at Chickasaw baseball camps,” he recalled. “Along that route, the Chickasaws provided multiple opportunities for me. They helped pay for my school, clothing, and full Pell financial aid. Their support made a huge difference in helping me chase my baseball dream.</p>
<p class="body">“If it weren’t for the Chickasaws investing in me, I wouldn’t have had the same opportunities.”</p>
<p class="body">Gillum transferred to East Central University in Ada, where he earned undergraduate and graduate degrees in education. He did not play baseball after college — instead, he pursued his passion for coaching.</p>
<p class="body">“I started coaching at East Central University, but they didn’t have paid assistant positions – only two graduate assistant roles. I was making about $5,000 a year while working 100 hours a week.</p>
<p class="body">At 23 years old, I was the recruiting coordinator, infield coach, and working in the office too,” he said.</p>
<p class="body">“It was an incredible opportunity. I wasn’t in it for the money – and I still am not. I do it for the experience and the impact.”</p>
<p class="body">Gillum’s personal motto is “Bet on Yourself,” and his goal is to make a positive impact on one single person every day. He surpassed that goal by about a million in 2024.</p>
<p class="body">“Whenever I think about the Chickasaw Nation, I come back to one of their main principles – servant leadership,” Gillum said. “I always view myself through that lens – how can I serve? How can I make an impact?”</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>OLD STEREOTYPES, NEW OUTSPOKENNESS</strong></p>
<p class="body">Generations ago, Native players were commonly nicknamed “Chief” and cultural stereotypes were the norm for sports reporters covering Native athletes in baseball and other sports. While today’s Native ballplayers aren’t subjected to those caricatures, others persist – mascots, team names, and more.</p>
<p class="body">One example: The 2021 World Series between the Atlanta Braves and Houston Astros averaged over 11 million television viewers per game. (The Braves’ Series-clinching win in Game Six drew over 14 million viewers.<a id="calibre_link-3106" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3089">14</a> ) During the three Braves home games, television viewers saw thousands of fans doing the “tomahawk chop” and chanting a supposed war cry, accompanied by thumping, Native-sounding music.</p>
<p class="body">The old trope isn’t as acceptable as it once was; today’s players and those who write about them are at ease sharing their perspectives.</p>
<p class="body">In the <em>New York Times</em>, columnist Kurt Streeter called the chop a “spectacle of ignorance.”<a id="calibre_link-3107" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3090">15</a> In a conversation more than three years later, Streeter added: “It’s crazy that we’re still doing that and that it’s still considered acceptable.”<a id="calibre_link-3108" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3091">16</a></p>
<p class="body">Streeter’s article and other coverage noted Commissioner Rob Manfred’s statements that local Native communities support the chop, despite widespread opposition from those who find it a stereotypical and offensive representation of Native culture.</p>
<p class="body">“It wasn’t hard to find people within these tribes who were disgusted by their connection to the Braves,” Streeter said. “There’s nothing uniform about the way Native communities view these affiliations and imagery. There is a range of opinions.”</p>
<p class="body">At least two of today’s Native ballplayers reflect that range.</p>
<p class="body">Ryan Helsley, then pitching for the Cardinals, was widely quoted about the chop during the 2019 National League Division Series, when the Cardinals played the Braves. Reporters asked him about the chant after the first two games, both played in Atlanta. He called it “a misrepresentation of the Cherokee people or Native Americans in general.”<a id="calibre_link-3109" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3092">17</a></p>
<p class="body">It was his rookie season and his first visit to Atlanta. He looked back on the experience two years later in a conversation during a Cardinals visit to Boston.</p>
<p class="body">“I understand why they do it for the fans, but there are better ways to honor Native culture,” Helsley said. “Mascots and teams often use regalia and headdresses – which are deeply important to our culture – as costumes. Many people don’t understand the meaning and think it’s harmless, but there needs to be more respect for people’s wishes. The narrative painted by this imagery isn’t who we are.”</p>
<p class="body">Helsley credits the Braves for hosting an all-Native baseball camp and for educating fans about Natives. “They’re doing some good things to show who Native Americans are,” he said.</p>
<p class="body">Brandon Bailey noted that Native race and culture are often uncomfortable topics and added that he feels schools do not teach enough about Indigenous history. He said he tries to understand both sides of the issue.</p>
<p class="body">“There’s some shame, honestly, in how the federal government treated Native peoples – cultural genocide happened at the hands of the government,” he said. “History matters so that it doesn’t repeat itself. None of us today made those decisions, but we are in control of our actions now. Treating people with respect is something we can all commit to.”</p>
<p class="body">He added: “I appreciate when teams, like the Cleveland Guardians, take a step back and acknowledge the effect on people. They ask, ‘How can we still be proud of our colors, our team’s energy, and history, while finding common ground to make changes that matter?’”</p>
<p class="body">“Pride shouldn’t come at the cost of traumatizing people who’ve endured hardships.”</p>
<p class="body">Streeter concluded: “Sports are more transcendent and saturated now – more visible and powerful than ever. The imagery is stronger because sports are cathedrals, players are celebrities, and with the internet, access to these symbols is everywhere.”</p>
<p class="body">“When you see the chop and hear the chants, they carry a greater influence.”</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>NATIVE PROGRESS, NATIVE TERMS</strong></p>
<p class="body">As heritage continues to be important to Ryan Helsley, Brandon Bailey, Jon Gray, and others, today’s players and coaches can continue to speak out and participate in programs to gather cultural influence, helping to shape goals for Native progress on Native terms. They may not achieve these goals soon, but they can help set the track and maintain progress.</p>
<p class="body">“I love the word <em>unconquerable</em>,” said Gillum. “Move the needle, impact the world, and do good things – so you can keep moving forward.”</p>
<p><em><strong>JOE LEISEK</strong> lives in Petaluma, California, with his wife Tracy and Irish setter Liam. Joe is a citizen of the Chickasaw Nation.</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Sources</strong></p>
<p class="sources">In addition to the sources cited in the Notes, the author accessed a file provided by the Giamatti Research Center at the National Baseball Hall of Fame, <a class="calibre2" href="http://retrosheet.org/">Retrosheet.org</a>, and <a class="calibre2" href="http://baseball-reference.com/">Baseball-Reference.com</a>.</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Notes</strong></p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3076" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3093">1</a></span> Andy McCullough, “Baseball’s 2020 Club: Five Years Ago They Realized a Dream, but COVID-19 Stopped Anyone From Seeing It,” <em><span class="italic">The Athletic</span></em>, March 12, 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3077" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3094">2</a></span> A player must be retired for five years before becoming a subject for a SABR biography.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3078" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3095">3</a></span> Beverly Bidney, “Indian Country Profile: Jacoby Ellsbury,” <em><span class="italic">Seminole Tribune</span></em> (Florida), April 29, 2014.For more on Ellsbury, see Jon Schwartz, “Yankees Magazine: In His Blood,” MLB.com, April 3, 2017. <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.mlb.com/news/ellsbury-honors-his-native-american-heritage-c222040346">https://www.mlb.com/news/ellsbury-honors-his-native-american-heritage-c222040346</a>, accessed July 6,2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3079" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3096">4</a></span> Ryan Helsley’s perspectives shared in conversation with the author, June 2023.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3080" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3097">5</a></span> Mark Saxon, “Cardinals Pitcher Ryan Helsley and His Family Work to Keep Cherokee Heritage Alive,” <em>New York Times</em>, August 29, 2016.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3081" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3098">6</a></span> Thomas Harding, “Gray Humbled by Cherokee Nation Roots,” MLB.com, August 25, 2016.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3082" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3099">7</a></span> Jon Gray’s perspectives shared in conversation with the author, January 2024.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3083" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3100">8</a></span> Adrian Houser’s perspectives shared in conversation with the author, January 2023.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3084" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3101">9</a></span> Brandon Bailey’s perspectives shared in conversation with the author, February 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3085" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3102">10</a></span> Anthony Seigler’s perspectives shared in conversation with the author, July 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3086" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3103">11</a></span> Alysia Webb’s perspectives shared in conversation with the author, July 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3087" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3104">12</a></span> Tyler Gillum’s perspectives shared in conversation with the author, February 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3088" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3105">13</a></span> Benjamin Hoffman, “The Savannah Bananas Needed a Bigger Stage,” <em>New York Times</em>, October 4, 2024.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3089" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3106">14</a></span> Jabari Young, “14.3 million people watched the Atlanta Braves win the 2021 World Series,” CNBC.com, November 3, 2021.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3090" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3107">15</a></span> Kurt Streeter, “M.L.B. Commissioner Can’t Hear Native Voices Over Atlanta’s Chop,” <em>New York Times</em>, October 29, 2021.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3091" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3108">16</a></span> Kurt Streeter’s perspectives shared in conversation with the author, January 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3092" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3109">17</a></span> Alan Blinder, “Braves Pivot from ‘Tomahawk Chop’ Chant After a Cardinal’s Criticism,” <em>New York Times</em>, October 9, 2021.</p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>The Carlisle Indian School: Baseball as a ‘Civilizing’ Influence</title>
		<link>https://sabr.org/journal/article/the-carlisle-indian-school-baseball-as-a-civilizing-influence/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[wpadmin]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 07:18:38 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://sabr.org/?post_type=journal_articles&#038;p=325901</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[1885 Carlisle student baseball team (Carlisle Indian School Digital Resource Center) &#160; Children played baseball at the United States Training and Industrial School at Carlisle Barracks. On one level, they were children like any others, playing a game, having fun running about. But to the children, their teachers and coaches, school administration, the federal government, [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="calibre_link-92" class="calibre1">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w2" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000054.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>1885 Carlisle student baseball team (Carlisle Indian School Digital Resource Center)</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="first-paragraph">Children played baseball at the United States Training and Industrial School at Carlisle Barracks. On one level, they were children like any others, playing a game, having fun running about. But to the children, their teachers and coaches, school administration, the federal government, and even the nation, that same baseball was also so much more, as was every activity these children undertook. To understand the impact of their baseball we must understand the nature and significance of the school; we must know the children themselves: who they were, where they came from, and what the school meant to them and their families. We must also understand its founder, Captain Richard Henry Pratt. Jim Thorpe, “Chief” Albert Bender, and Glenn “Pop” Warner may be the names most commonly associated with the school, but there is much more to the story.</p>
<p class="body">The United States Training and Industrial School at Carlisle Barracks, more often referred to as the Carlisle Indian School, was not the first boarding school for Native American children. It was, however, intentionally the first one to be well removed from the children’s homes and families. In 1879, when the school was founded, the US government was still in the process of relocating Native nations onto reservations, but south-central Pennsylvania, where Carlisle is located, is nowhere near any of those reservations. The chronological context is important here; in 1879, George Armstrong Custer’s “Last Stand” was only three years in the past, and the 1890 massacre at Wounded Knee was still to come. Warring between the US military and various Indian Nations was not history, but very current events.<a id="calibre_link-3137" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3112">1</a> The Civil War had not yet been over for 20 years, and it was during that conflict that Richard Henry Pratt began the set of experiences that would culminate in his idea of a different kind of boarding school for Native American children.</p>
<p class="body">Today, Pratt is perhaps most infamous for being the originator of the phrase “Kill the Indian, save the man,” but to use that phrase as the only lens through which to view the man is a drastic simplification. Historian Robert Utley wrote that “Carlisle [Indian School] was the institutional embodiment of Richard H. Pratt, as he was its personification.”<a id="calibre_link-3138" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3113">2</a></p>
<p class="body">So, who was Richard Henry Pratt? A native Indianan, he tried his hand at the trades of printing and tinsmithing. He was 21 when the Civil War broke out and he enlisted in a volunteer regiment. Achieving some success in the Army, he rose to the rank of first lieutenant of cavalry by the time the war ended. Having acquired a bride, he and his bride opened a hardware store in Indiana, but an unsuccessful business made him yearn for Army life. He applied for a commission in the regular Army and was appointed a second lieutenant in the 10th US Cavalry. The 10th was a unit of “Buffalo Soldiers,” made up of African American enlisted men but led by White officers.</p>
<p class="body">Assigned to Fort Gibson in Indian Territory [now Oklahoma], Pratt worked well with the enlisted men and with the “Indian Scouts” and found himself attached to the scout units with greater frequency. Pratt described himself (writing in the third person) as looking “upon them as men and brothers, lacking in attainment only, and that through no fault of theirs. His contention &#8230; was that the Indians were entitled to a full, fair chance for development in every way, and until they had that, our people had no right to form adverse opinions of them, or to condemn them as incorrigibly savage.”<a id="calibre_link-3139" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3114">3</a></p>
<p class="body">In the mid- through late 1870s Pratt had further encounters with Native Peoples being held as prisoners of war at Fort Marion in St. Augustine, Florida. He found “three years of imprisonment resulted in English speaking, in the adoption of civilized dress and habits and in a hungering on their part for a career in the larger life of the nation.”<a id="calibre_link-3140" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3115">4</a></p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="caption">A school at Fort Marion provided the prisoners “with daily training in industries” and the opportunity to meet “multitudes of our own people.”<a id="calibre_link-3141" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3116">5</a> Pratt took the initiative to organize the younger men along military lines into a company. He armed them and made them into a guard unit, allowing him to assign the regular soldier guards to other duties.</p>
</div>
<p class="body">This combination of experiences caused Pratt to conclude: “In Indian civilization I am a Baptist, because I believe in immersing the Indians in our civilization and when we get them under holding them there until they are thoroughly soaked.”<a id="calibre_link-3142" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3117">6</a> That meant removing them from reservations so they could be immersed in the culture of which they were to become a part. And what better way to achieve a complete cultural conversion than to start with the young? Pratt got permission and private funding for 17 of “his” young Indian men to attend the Hampton Normal and Industrial School, but it was a school intended for Black Americans; Pratt felt the Native American students should have one of their very own.<a id="calibre_link-3143" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3118">7</a></p>
<p class="body">What we now refer to as the Progressive Era was just getting underway by the time Pratt founded the school. Changes in social attitudes that accompany the period are inherent in the philosophy underlying not only Pratt’s desire to found the school, but the support it received from the government and certain public sectors. Not that late nineteenth-century racial views mirrored our own; Europeans and Euro-Americans believed deeply in their own superiority, whether it was socioculturally, politically, or religiously. But they had come to believe that at least some of the non-White peoples could (and should) be taught to live/act/function “like whites did.” In urban centers along the East Coast, this attitude was increasingly apparent when it came to views on Native Americans living within the country.<a id="calibre_link-3144" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3119">8</a></p>
<p class="body">Physical distance from sites of violence between the military and Native communities or settlers and Native communities allowed Easterners the freedom to sympathize with those Native communities, usually in a paternalistic way. That colonial paternalism was important to the success of the school, which was funded in part by the federal government; however, the funding never seemed sufficient. Pratt and his successors made tours to raise funds, entertained wealthy visitors who could be appealed to for donations. They also employed the students themselves whenever possible to save money, and earned income for the school by renting out student labor to farms and businesses across Pennsylvania.<a id="calibre_link-3145" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3120">9</a> The program was not referred to as “renting”; it was called “putting out” and was intended to provide the students with the opportunity to use and grow their vocational skills in real environments such as shops, offices, and farms.</p>
<p class="body">The space that became the school’s campus had inadequate facilities when the students arrived in the fall of 1879, so while local businesses and labor were employed to get things started, the school always relied on student labor. Permission and cooperation from the federal government – specifically the Bureau of Indian Affairs, then under the War Department – had come with the stipulation that girls be educated at the new school as well as boys.<a id="calibre_link-3146" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3121">10</a> Newspapers and newsletters to donors were printed in the school’s print shop; girls were taught laundering by washing their schoolmates’ clothing, but also worked in the print shop. The girls were taught how to “keep house” as defined by Euro-American standards, which saved the school more money since the girls could then also clean and cook.</p>
<p class="body">Pratt seems to have been the one to suggest the Carlisle Barracks as the location for his school when he proposed the idea to the secretaries of the interior and war, with whom he met in person for that purpose. He liked it in part because it was far from any reservations, meaning the children would be removed from their homes and families and those influences. Additionally, it was good farming country, and the current generations of residents had never personally experienced perceived threats to their homes by regional Native communities, and so were “long free from the universal border prejudice against the Indians.”<a id="calibre_link-3147" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3122">11</a></p>
<p class="body">Over the life of the school, children were brought from dozens of Indian nations from across what we know as the United States: as near to Carlisle as upstate New York, and as far away as Alaska and the Southwest. They carried with them an equal array of languages and customs, and varying degrees of previous exposure to the English language, Euro-Americans, and Christianity. The journey alone exposed them to a whirlwind of new experiences, such as train or steamship travel, and complete isolation from family and loved ones.</p>
<p class="body">Once the children arrived at the school, they were forbidden to use their own languages or practice their traditions. Play became one of the universal languages; there is evidence that the children played with local Carlisle children sometimes. Pickup teams formed in open areas on the school grounds during free time after supper. Baseball may not have been entirely new to at least some of the children, depending on where they had lived prior to their arrival at the school. Baseball was played at most, if not all, US military facilities across the West; we know of teams consisting of Native American scouts and POWs at Fort Sill, in Oklahoma, playing teams made up of various cavalry units, from the 1880s through the end of the century.<a id="calibre_link-3148" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3123">12</a> It was, apparently, quite popular with the children themselves: “Ball, back of the hospital; ball, back of the schoolhouse; ball, in front of the Girls Quarters; ball, all around, has been the order of the hour after supper, this week.”<a id="calibre_link-3149" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3124">13</a></p>
<p class="body">Teams were formed from the trades’ schools and residence halls, and some of the most enthusiastic students were on more than one team. There were both boys’ and girls’ teams, though they didn’t mix (it <span class="italic">was</span> the Victorian era), and it wasn’t long before there were varsity and junior varsity teams as well as intramural teams with such societally approved names as the “Unions,” “Young Americans,” “Union Reserves,” and “Unions Carlisle.”</p>
<p class="body">Pratt was not a sportsman or athlete by nature, but anything that could be seen as an “Americanizing force” was worth trying. By June of 1886, Pratt provided official recognition of a baseball program by authorizing the purchase of uniforms. Baseball was seen to be making citizens of the students, and uniforms were emblazoned with “C.I.T.S” for Carlisle Indian Training School. “Citizenship” was considered equivalent to assimilation into the broader culture. As the superintendent pointed out in a speech for the 1890 Decoration Day game with the team from the Educational Home (of) Philadelphia, “See how near that (C.I.T.S.) comes to being an abbreviation of ‘citizens,’ which they are all aspiring to become?”<a id="calibre_link-3150" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3125">14</a></p>
<p class="body">By 1888 Carlisle had a baseball coach, in the model of later coaches whose main responsibilities were elsewhere; Fisk “Tim” Goodyear was a teacher and also doubled as a clerk, overseeing the students who were part of the school’s summer outing program. He was the 19-year-old eldest son of a local merchant and sheriff and left the school after six years, in 1893, when his father turned the family business over to Tim and his brother. Lacking the background or prestige of later coaches like Glenn “Pop” Warner, he was described as well-liked by the boys.<a id="calibre_link-3151" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3126">15</a> In the early days of his tenure in the spring of 1888 his teams played a mostly intramural schedule and also played nearby town teams and the Dickinson College freshman squad. As of 1890, they played a wider schedule that included the Dickinson College varsity in Carlisle, as well as Bucknell, Gettysburg, the University of Pennsylvania, and Pennsylvania State.</p>
<p class="body">Carlisle had a highly esteemed coach in Warner as well as coaching from some major-league players – Charlie Bender, Harry L. Taylor, and Charlie Pittinger.<a id="calibre_link-3152" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3127">16</a> Eugene Bassford had no major-league coaching experience but was an experienced college coach. The team’s record never rose much above the .500 level and for the period from 1895 till the end of the program in 1909, their overall record was 124-142-5 (.466). Bassford had the distinction of being Carlisle’s final baseball coach but, curiously, was described in a <em>New York Times</em> report of January 31, 1909, as the first.</p>
<p class="body">“The athletic officials of the Carlisle Indian School have engaged for the first time a baseball coach. He is Eugene E. Bassford, who coached Fordham College at baseball for the last four years. The Carlisle baseball schedule will contain nearly thirty games. Practice will begin about the middle of February.”<a id="calibre_link-3153" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3128">17</a></p>
<p class="body">Whatever hair-splitting criteria were used to name Bassford the “first” baseball coach, he was definitely the last. Pop Warner preferred to concentrate on the more famous football program in the fall and on track and field in the spring. After an 11-16 baseball season in 1909, that was it: The baseball program was ended.</p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body"> </p>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w2" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000055.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Union Reserve baseball team, ca. 1891 (Carlisle Indian School Digital Resource Center)</em></p>
</div>
<div id="calibre_link-92" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body">While baseball was the unwanted stepchild in Warner’s athletic program, the school turned out seven major leaguers in its 23 years of competition with college, semipro, and town teams. Jim Thorpe was Carlisle’s most famous athletic product, and Hall of Famer Charlie Bender was the best-known alumnus in baseball, but there were five others who matriculated at Carlisle and went on to play in the major leagues. (The SABR BioProject includes biographies of all seven.) The lives and careers of Thorpe and Bender are well documented, so we’ll focus on George Johnson, Louis LeRoy, Mike Balenti, Frank Jude, and Charlie Roy.</p>
<p class="body">Three of the five – Johnson, LeRoy, and Roy – were pitchers, and Robert Charles Roy had a background quite similar to that of Charles Albert Bender. Both were from northern Minnesota, and they are known to have been childhood friends. Roy’s career was also the shortest, consisting of seven games with the Phillies in 1906. He also pitched for Newark of the Class-A Eastern League in 1906. In 1907 he was back at Newark, but he was released in June and had subsequent trials at Class-B Wilmington, Delaware, and Class-D Steubenville, Ohio. Charlie Roy is described as a deeply religious man, and he decided to quit baseball at the age of 23 to become a Christian evangelist.</p>
<p class="body">Louis LeRoy’s career in the major leagues wasn’t much longer. He pitched three games for the New York Highlanders in 1905, 11 games for them in 1906, and one game for the Boston Red Sox in 1910. However, his minor-league career was extensive; only Hall of Famer Charlie Bender, with 4,292 innings across all levels, pitched more innings than LeRoy did with 3,621. Beginning in Buffalo in 1902, LeRoy’s career took him literally from coast to coast, Boston to Seattle, across the border to Montreal, and to St. Paul, Indianapolis, and Salt Lake City before he finished up in Mitchell, South Dakota, in 1920.</p>
<p class="body">George Johnson pitched 10 years at all levels and carried a heavy workload in his three years in the majors, at Cincinnati in 1913 and 1914. During the 1914 season he jumped to Kansas City of the Federal League, for which he also pitched in 1915. Relying mostly on a fastball and a spitball, Johnson went 14-16 in 269 innings with the Reds in 1913. In 1914 he was idled for three months while courts worked out whether he was to pitch for the Reds or the Federal League’s Kansas City Packers, but turned in a 9-10 record in 138 innings. With Kansas City in 1915, Johnson went 17-17 while pitching 281⅓ innings.</p>
<p class="body">Johnson pitched 200 innings for Vernon of the Pacific Coast League in 1916 and an astonishing 398⅔ dividing his time between Vernon and San Francisco of the Pacific Coast Lague in 1917. Described as “rotund” in the press of the time, George Johnson failed to show up for a game on June 16. 1918, and was “fired” by San Francisco Seals President Charles Strub. He played some semipro ball over the next few years and his life ended abruptly when he was shot to death after a dice game. He was 36.</p>
<p class="body">There were two stars in the backfield of the Carlisle Indians in 1908. One was Jim Thorpe; the other wasn’t.<a id="calibre_link-3154" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3129">18</a> Mike Balenti was the quarterback at Carlisle when Jim Thorpe was the running back. Balenti was also captain of the baseball team in 1908 and ’09 and went on to play 10 years in professional baseball.</p>
<p class="body">Balenti signed with the Philadelphia Athletics and reported to them after Carlisle’s 1909 season. The A’s assigned him to the Milwaukee Brewers and the Brewers optioned him to Dayton of the Class-B Central League. He was released in July but caught on with El Reno of the Class-C Western League. Balenti spent 1910 with Savannah of the South Atlantic League, and a .326 season at Macon in 1911 resulted in his being purchased by the Cincinnati Reds in July. He appeared in only eight games for the Reds and spent 1912 having a good season batting .288 for Chattanooga of the Class-A Southern Association, who sold his contract to the St. Louis Browns in September.</p>
<p class="body">Balenti played in 70 games for the Browns in 1913, hitting only .180, and St. Louis sent him back to Chattanooga after the 1913 season. Another year at Class-A Chattanooga in 1914, when he hit only .157, meant he spent 1915, 1916, and part of 1917 with San Antonio of the Class-B Texas League before drifting down to Tulsa of the Class-D Western Association. He made appearances again in 1923 and 1926 with lower-classification clubs before calling it a career.</p>
<p class="body">Frank Jude’s SABR biography tells that he caught the attention of Cincinnati Reds owner Garry Herrmann and Boston Americans manager Jimmy Collins with his play at Carlisle. He signed with Toledo of the Class-A American Association and began his professional career there, forgoing his senior year at the Indian Industrial School.</p>
<p class="body">According to Baseball-Reference.com, Jude began the 1906 season with the Toledo Mudhens and was hitting .315 after 72 games when the Reds traded two major leaguers to Toledo to acquire the speedy outfielder. In 80 games with the Reds, he managed only a .208 batting average. It was to be his only opportunity in the majors. After the season he was sold to Columbus of the American Association. His minor-league odyssey from 1907 to 1923 included stops from Columbus, Ohio, to Albany, New York, and from Mobile, Alabama, to Saskatoon, Saskatchewan.</p>
<p class="body">Jude hit .261 for Lincoln of the Class-A Western Association in 1910 when he played in 167 games. He hit .335 for his best season while with Saskatoon of the Class-B Western Canada Association; that was in 1921, when he was 36 and after he had taken five years away from professional baseball. The numbers are incomplete but with what we know, he is computed to have hit .275 in 1,329 minor-league games.</p>
<p class="body">Regardless of who was coaching, a few factors impacted how the Indian School’s teams fared against their collegiate rivals. While educational structures were different in the nineteenth century than they were before educational standardization became the norm in the twentieth, the boys on the Indian School teams may well have been several years younger than the opposing players.<a id="calibre_link-3155" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3130">19</a> Further, a majority of the opposition came from the middle and upper-middle classes and had time to dedicate to athletics as a hobby or leisure pastime. The Indian School boys were still required to fulfill the vocational aspects of their education, despite their roster spots. It seems unlikely that Bucknell or Yale students also learned and spent time on bricklaying or masonry for school buildings the way the Carlisle boys did.</p>
<p class="body">Those requirements didn’t mean the school community, or the larger community, was any less interested in how the teams did. Both the <span class="italic">Indian Helper</span> and the <span class="italic">Red Man</span>, newspapers put out by the school’s own printing office (one of the few vocations taught to both boys and girls), often included mentions of and stories about the teams and how they fared. The <span class="italic">Indian Helper</span> even included results of games played by other Indian schools from across the country. The <span class="italic">Philadelphia Times</span> covered the 1901 Carlisle season in some depth, including the hiring of former major leaguer Harry Taylor to coach the team as well as box scores and analysis of the games.<a id="calibre_link-3156" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3131">20</a></p>
<p class="body">The conscious use of organized athletics as a tool to Americanize children was implemented across the country with Native American children, as well as immigrant children in overcrowded urban slums. The late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries also saw an improved understanding of the health benefits of athletic play for children, especially as increasing numbers of them were slowly taken out of industrial environments and provided with educations.</p>
<p class="body">There are indicators that Carlisle students who were athletes may have had a better or easier time at school than those who were not. Letters sent to the school after a student had left, alumni questionnaires, and attendance at reunions, provide evidence that some students retained good memories of their time at the school, and valued the education and training they received there.<a id="calibre_link-3157" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3132">21</a> Charlie Bender chose to stay in Pennsylvania even after retiring from baseball, although he certainly could have gone back to Minnesota.</p>
<p class="body">And yet Jim Thorpe and others ran away from the school and from their assigned “putting out” work locations. The school’s guardhouse doubled as “jail,” in which such students were sometimes held when they were returned to the school. Countless miles from everyone they knew and loved, forbidden to speak the language of their very thoughts, forced into clothing completely foreign – and often associated with an “enemy” – made to participate in classes, activities, and religious observation in a language they didn’t know or understand: These experiences can only have been bewildering and frightening. Some children arrived at the school as young as 3 or 4 years old. Boarding school was an individual experience as well as a collective one, and some children fared better than others, depending on countless factors.</p>
<p class="body">The same was true after the children left the school; some got the few federal jobs available on their home reservations or neighboring ones, some taught at the Indian schools proliferating across the country. Most, however, went home to their communities and tried to fit in again. The duration of their absence could contribute to that success or failure; if you no longer speak the language or know the customs, how will you fit in? Your food ways, speech, dress, appearance (especially for boys) have all changed – how will you fit in? Returning students had to learn all over again, just as they had when they went off to school in the first place. Some were able to support themselves with the skills they had been taught at the school, such as building trades like masonry, carpentry, and bricklaying. For others, there was no market for those skills if they went back to the reservation.</p>
<p class="body">As this article was completed in 2024, there were small red plastic flags at a dozen or so of the markers in the graveyard at the Carlisle Indian School, now the Army War College, indicating this year’s group to be disinterred and taken home to their relations and communities. Native families and communities still battle with bureaucracy, the courts, and the Army’s Office of Army Cemeteries to be permitted to receive their ancestors’ remains from the school grounds.<a id="calibre_link-3158" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3133">22</a> Those battles symbolize the extent to which the damage done by boarding schools is a factor for families and communities to this day. The loss of the family members who died at the school, and the impact of the separation and education to the ones who returned, permanently changed the shape of Native lives and communities across the continent.</p>
<p class="body">Fannie Charging Shield, Oglala Lakota, was 16 when she arrived at the Carlisle Indian School. It was early in 1891, only a couple of months after the December 1890 massacre at Wounded Knee, South Dakota. It must have disconcerting, if not terrifying, to arrive at a place run by the very same agency that had so recently killed people you knew. In June 1891 she was sent to a work assignment with a family near the Delaware border and did not return to school until January 1892, by which time she had probably already contracted tuberculosis. Not long after, the school sent for her father, which was unusual. Chief Charging Shield arrived with his good friend Chief American Horse, who may have visited the campus previously. Chief Charging Shield was able to be with his daughter when she died but was dismayed to learn that because the school had funded his trip to be with her, there was no money to allow him to take her body home with him. He returned home without her and Fannie was buried at the school, but he always hoped that someday her body could be returned to her home. Fannie Charging Shield was one of the students disinterred in the late summer of 2024. Her remains and those of two other Lakota children were taken back to their lands for reburial.<a id="calibre_link-3159" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3134">23</a></p>
<p class="body">Perhaps it is naïve, but it would be nice to hope that watching or playing baseball while at school, or teaching it to others after school ended, was a small bright spot for the children at the Carlisle Indian School.</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Postscript</strong></p>
<p class="sources">On October 25, 2024, President Joe Biden formally apologized for the federal government’s role in operating or promoting the operation of boarding schools for Native American children. During the speech in which he made the apology, the President called for a moment of silence for the children and the generations traumatized by the boarding school abuses.<a id="calibre_link-3160" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3135">24</a> In December Biden took another significant step in promoting generational healing in Native communities by declaring the grounds of what was the Carlisle Indian School a National Monument. Just over 24 acres are protected by this new status, including buildings and gateposts built by the students learning their trades at the school.<a id="calibre_link-3161" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3136">25</a> Together, these steps will hopefully help ensure that the boarding school experiences of the Native children and their families and communities will not be forgotten or swept aside.</p>
<p><em><strong>ROGER</strong> and <strong>DEENA PARMELEE</strong> live in south-central Pennsylvania, only a few miles from the former campus of the Carlisle Indian School. Roger is retired and spends his days reading about or watching baseball and meticulously recording SkeeterSoft replays of entire seasons of historic games. He has been a SABR member for many years, and a Red Sox fan since Ted Williams, Jimmy Piersall and Jackie Jensen roamed the outfield at Fenway Park. Deena has a PhD in US history, formerly taught US history at the college level, and currently works for the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Roger taught Deena to appreciate baseball 40 years ago by telling her stories about Germany Schaefer and Bobo Newsom.</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Sources</strong></p>
<p class="sources">In addition to the sources cited in the Notes, the authors also consulted</p>
<p class="source-header">Print Sources:</p>
<p class="sources"><em><span class="italic">Boston Post</span></em>. “Indians Played a Weak Game,” June 16, 1901.</p>
<p class="sources">Callow, Colin, ed. <em><span class="italic">First Peoples: A Documentary Survey of American Indian History</span></em>, Second Edition. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2004.</p>
<p class="sources">“Indian Education at Hampton and Carlisle,” <em><span class="italic">Harper’s New Monthly Magazine</span></em> 62, no. 320 (April 1881): 659-675.</p>
<p class="sources">Iverson, Peter. <span class="italic">“We Are Still Here,” <em>American Indians in the Twentieth Century</em></span>. Wheeling, Illinois: Harlan Davidson, Inc. 1998.</p>
<p class="sources">Maraniss, David. <em><span class="italic">Path Lit by Lightning: The Life of Jim Thorpe</span></em>. New York: Simon &amp; Schuster, 2022.</p>
<p class="sources">Standing Bear, Luther. <em><span class="italic">My People, The Sioux</span></em>. Kindle Edition. Hegne Publishing, August 2017.</p>
<p class="sources">Weeks, Philip. <em><span class="italic">Farewell, My Nation: The American Indian and the United States in the Nineteenth Century</span>.</em> Wheeling, Illinois: Harlan Davidson, Inc, 2001.</p>
<p class="sources">Weeks, Philip, ed. <span class="italic"><em>“They Made Us Many Promises,”: The American Indian Experience 1524 to the Present</em></span>. Wheeling, Illinois: Harlan Davidson, Inc., 2002.</p>
<p class="source-header">Digital Sources:</p>
<p class="sources">Rubinkama, Michael. “Native Children’s Remains to be Moved from Army Cemetery,” in <span class="italic">The Hill</span>, June 14, 2022. <a class="calibre2" href="https://thehill.com/homenews/ap/ap-u-s-news/native-childrens-remains-to-be-moved-from-army-cemetery/">https://thehill.com/homenews/ap/ap-u-s-news/native-childrens-remains-to-be-moved-from-army-cemetery/</a>.</p>
<p class="sources">Virtual tour of Carlisle Indian School video: Barbara Landis, 2017, <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hL8pa1ZDSGY">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hL8pa1ZDSGY</a>.</p>
<p class="sources">History of the Carlisle Indian School: Dickinson College, 2021, <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tfOKRglt8e8">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tfOKRglt8e8</a>.</p>
<p class="sources">Carlisle Indian School Digital Resource Center, <a class="calibre2" href="https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/">https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/</a>.</p>
<p class="sources">Yu, Jane. “Kill the Indian, Save the Man,” Spring, 2009, Pennsylvania Center for the Book, <a class="calibre2" href="https://pabook.libraries.psu.edu/literary-cultural-heritage-map-pa/feature-articles/kill-indian-save-man?fbclid=IwAR2spGR_isTVSYmPrxcDaO6bWvYOfoQKy3JVN8Vb9YZiwU58uEdjOE-ITh4">https://pabook.libraries.psu.edu/literary-cultural-heritage-map-pa/feature-articles/kill-indian-save-man</a>.</p>
<p class="sources">PBS Newshour broadcast segment June 23, 2021, <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRNcCCgnauI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRNcCCgnauI</a>.</p>
<p class="sources">Hedgpeth, Dana, “‘12 Years of Hell’: Indian Boarding School Survivors Share their Stories,” <em><span class="italic">Washington Post</span></em>, August 7, 2023.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Notes</strong></p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3112" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3137">1</a></span> On at least one documented occasion, teenage prisoners of war captured by the US military in ongoing conflicts with Native nations were sent as students to the school. <em><span class="italic">The Indian Helper</span></em> (Carlisle, Pennsylvania), Vol. 3, No. 47, July 6, 1888, 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3113" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3138">2</a></span> Robert M. Utley, introduction to <span class="italic"><em>The Indian Industrial School, Carlisle, Pennsylvania</em></span><em>,</em> by Brig. Gen. R.H. Pratt, 1979 reprint of the 1908 text, Cumberland County Historical Society Publications, Volume 10, No. 3, 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3114" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3139">3</a></span> Richard Henry Pratt, <em><span class="italic">The Indian Industrial School, Carlisle, Pennsylvania</span></em>, 1979 reprint of the 1908 text, Cumberland County Historical Society Publications, Volume 10, No. 3, 10.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3115" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3140">4</a></span> Pratt, <em><span class="italic">The Indian Industrial School, Carlisle, Pennsyl</span><span class="italic">vania,</span></em> 11.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3116" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3141">5</a></span> Pratt, <em><span class="italic">The Indian Industrial School, Carlisle, Pennsyl</span><span class="italic">vania,</span></em> 11.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3117" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3142">6</a></span> Pratt, <em><span class="italic">The Indian Industrial School, Carlisle, Pennsy</span><span class="italic">lvania,</span></em> 5.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3118" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3143">7</a></span> Richard Henry Pratt. <em><span class="italic">Battlefield and Classroom: Four Decades with the American Indian, 1867-1904</span></em> (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1964), 190. In 1868, General Samuel Chapman Armstrong founded the Hampton Normal and Industrial School in Hampton, Virginia, for the express purpose of educating freed slaves.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3119" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3144">8</a></span> The April 1881 issue of the popular <em><span class="italic">Harper’s Magazine</span>,</em> for example, included a lengthy, illustrated article on “Indian Education at Hampton and Carlisle.” <em><span class="italic">Harper’s New Monthly Magazine</span></em> 62, no. 320 (April 1881): 659-675.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3120" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3145">9</a></span> There are buildings on the campus today that were built by school students as they learned construction trades.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3121" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3146">10</a></span> Pratt, <em><span class="italic">The Indian Industrial School, Carlisle, Pennsylvan</span></em><span class="italic"><em>ia</em>,</span> 15.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3122" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3147">11</a></span> Pratt. <em><span class="italic">Battlefield and Class</span><span class="italic">room</span></em>, 216.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3123" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3148">12</a></span> <a class="calibre2" href="https://klaw.com/events-lawton/historic-base-ball-game-set-at-fort-sill/23-july-2011/">https://klaw.com/events-lawton/historic-base-ball-game-set-at-fort-sill/23-july-2011/</a>, accessed August 19, 2024.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3124" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3149">13</a></span> <span class="italic"><em>Indian Helper</em>.</span> Volume 3, No. 36, April 20, 1888: 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3125" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3150">14</a></span> <span class="italic"><em>Indian Helper</em>,</span> Volume 3, No. 36, April 20, 1888: 39.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3126" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3151">15</a></span> Jeffrey Powers-Beck, <em><span class="italic">The American Indian Integration of Baseball</span></em> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2004), 40.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3127" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3152">16</a></span> Jack Morris, &#8220;Charlie Pittinger,&#8221; SABR BioProject, <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/charlie-pittinger/">https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/charlie-pittinger/</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3128" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3153">17</a></span> “Carlisle Baseball Coach,” <em>New York Times</em>. January 31, 1909, Section 4, 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3129" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3154">18</a></span> Think of Mike Balenti as Carlisle’s Lou Gehrig to Jim Thorpe’s Babe Ruth.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3130" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3155">19</a></span> For example, during the 1901 season, Charlie Bender was only 17. Many of the players on the opposing college and town teams would have been well older – although it is also true that in the nineteenth century boys often went to college at a much younger age than is common today.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3131" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3156">20</a></span> “Indians Won Opening Game,” <em><span class="italic">Philadelphia Times</span></em>, April 13, 1901: 8.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3132" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3157">21</a></span> Dickinson College is the principal digital repository for Carlisle Indian School records, including student records: <a class="calibre2" href="https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/">https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/</a></p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3133" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3158">22</a></span> <a class="calibre2" href="https://ictnews.org/news/obscure-government-agency-at-center-of-carlisle-repatriation-dispute">https://ictnews.org/news/obscure-government-agency-at-center-of-carlisle-repatriation-dispute</a> accessed September 1 and 2, 2024. Families of children who died at Carlisle Indian School have a particularly complicated maze to navigate for the return of their kin’s remains because the property remains an active military facility.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3134" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3159">23</a></span> Charles Fox, “Home From Carlisle: A Father’s Wish Fulfilled After More Than 130 Years,” <em><span class="italic">Indian Country Today</span></em>, September 18, 2024. <a class="calibre2" href="https://ictnews.org/news/home-from-carlisle-a-fathers-wish-fulfilled-after-more-than-130-years">https://ictnews.org/news/home-from-carlisle-a-fathers-wish-fulfilled-after-more-than-130-years</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3135" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3160">24</a></span> Gabriel Pietrorazio, “Biden Apologizes for Government’s Role in Running Native American Boarding Schools,” NPR.org, October 26, 2024. <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.npr.org/2024/10/26/nx-s1-5165427/biden-apologizes-for-governments-role-in-running-native-american-boarding-schools">https://www.npr.org/2024/10/26/nx-s1-5165427/biden-apologizes-for-governments-role-in-running-native-american-boarding-schools</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3136" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3161">25</a></span> Cecily Hilleary, “Biden Designates National Monument at site of Carlisle Indian School,” VOANews, December 10, 2024. <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.voanews.com/a/biden-designates-national-monument-at-site-of-carlisle-indian-school/7896427.html">https://www.voanews.com/a/biden-designates-national-monument-at-site-of-carlisle-indian-school/7896427.html</a></p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>“Onward, Haskell”</title>
		<link>https://sabr.org/journal/article/onward-haskell/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[wpadmin]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 07:17:38 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://sabr.org/?post_type=journal_articles&#038;p=325903</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Haskell Institute baseball team, ca.1910. (Burke Library at Union Theological Seminary, Columbia University) &#160; The idleness and rhythm of baseball were a spring rite at the federally-operated Indian boarding schools of the late nineteenth century. Played passionately by the students on fields carved out of forests, the schools used baseball as another tool to impose [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="calibre_link-94" class="calibre1">
<p class="body"><img decoding="async" class="w2" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000056.jpg" alt="" /></p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="caption"><em>Haskell Institute baseball team, ca.1910. (Burke Library at Union Theological Seminary, Columbia University)</em></p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="first-paragraph">The idleness and rhythm of baseball were a spring rite at the federally-operated Indian boarding schools of the late nineteenth century. Played passionately by the students on fields carved out of forests, the schools used baseball as another tool to impose the federal assimilation policy to teach values of the American White society like teamwork and discipline. For the boys, it was a chance for fun, an escape from the harsh conditions. Many Native students excelled in baseball, achieving recognition and pride through their athletic prowess.</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>PART I. THE CEMETERY AND THE PAST</strong></p>
<p class="body">Behind a foul-smelling sewage plant, adjacent to woods and wetlands that had been sliced by the South Lawrence Trafficway, lies a half-acre cemetery abutting the campus of the Haskell Indian Nations University in Lawrence, Kansas. Buried are the remains of 103 Native American children/students who perished at Haskell from 1885 to 1943.<a id="calibre_link-3251" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3164">1</a> Each grave is marked with a name, a tribe, an age, and little else. In that bygone era, runaways made their escape through the cemetery, woods, and wetlands toward safety. Haskell students interred here died of diseases such as consumption (tuberculosis), influenza, and typhoid, buried with their memories and little to acknowledge their journey. None went home again, individually buried with a Christian Mass in a Christian cemetery, though a portion were not Christian. Many had been subjected to the American policy of forced assimilation.</p>
<p class="body">Strewn throughout are remembrances left behind by Native Americans. Spiritual symbols atop the burial sites such as the Native handmade willow dreamcatchers hung to protect the buried from evil. “I was thankful to have a beautiful place to pray. Who would I be if I didn’t fight to protect it,” said Pemina Yellow Bird in 2014 when she discovered the grounds.<a id="calibre_link-3252" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3165">2</a> She believed, as many do, that a spirituality existed in the cemetery.</p>
<p class="body">Each interred child may never have had a chance to play with new toys, thrive in their culture, grow to adulthood or even play a game of pickup baseball on a barren field. The cemetery has been vandalized and burials lost over time. In 2017 Haskell built an eight-foot iron fence around the grounds, restored vandalized stones, and gave the grounds a sense of security and protection. “We had a case of vandalism in the cemetery going back a year or a little more where an individual pulled up some of the headstones and just tossed them in the corner of the cemetery,” said Haskell spokesman Stephen Prue.<a id="calibre_link-3253" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3166">3</a></p>
<p class="body">On October 25, 2024, President Joseph Biden issued an apology to the Native American tribes and communities for the federal government’s role in operating the Native American boarding schools, including Haskell. The apology was for the forced assimilation and abuse of Native American children that separated them from their families and cultures in an attempt to eradicate their individual tribal identities.</p>
<p class="body">Biden said, “[T]he Federal Indian Boarding School policy and the pain it has caused will always be a significant mark of shame, a blot on American history. It’s a sin on our [Nation’s] soul.”<a id="calibre_link-3254" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3167">4</a> In the effort to right a wrong, the apology was a step in the process of acknowledgment and healing that was welcomed by some tribes and viewed with skepticism by others.</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>PART II THE HASKELL INDIAN NATIONS UNIVERSITY</strong></p>
<p class="body">As of 2025 Haskell was a public tribal land-grant university operated by the United States Bureau of Indian Affairs. The school is the only federally operated four-year university for Native American students, accepting students from all federally recognized tribes.<a id="calibre_link-3255" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3168">5</a> The evolution of Haskell has been pockmarked with good intentions, self-determination efforts by Native tribes, and the sins of American policy.</p>
<p class="body">Upon the conclusion of the American Civil War, the expansionary focus of the nation focused on the Plains and the West. The dilemma of whether to coexist with the Native American population occupied lawmakers and religious figures. What resulted was a period of American history focused on the eradication of Native American culture, lands, and independence. The US government viewed education as the best method of achieving that end with a particular focus on making Native children into “Americans.” Army Captain Robert Henry Pratt founded the Carlisle Indian Industrial School for the purpose of “civilizing” Indigenous children and implementing his theory of assimilating Indigenous peoples. His 1892 speech at the National Conference of Charities and Corrections in Denver used the wording that became the mantra of assimilation: “Kill the Indian in him, and save the man.”<a id="calibre_link-3256" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3169">6</a> In 1882 Congress authorized three new boarding schools to be established in Nebraska, Kansas, and the Indian Territory<a id="calibre_link-3257" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3170">7</a> with Carlisle as the model. Haskell was one of the three.</p>
<p class="body">Congressman Dudley Haskell (1842-1883), chairman of the House Committee on Indian Affairs, was instrumental in opening a boarding school in his hometown of Lawrence, with $10,000 from Lawrence citizens to “educate” Indigenous boys and girls under the age of 10.<a id="calibre_link-3258" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3171">8</a> He secured the legislation for the Indian school that still bears his name. Haskell was also responsible for the origins of baseball at the school. A local shoe merchant and player for the local Kaw Valleys, Haskell was known for his prodigious home runs.</p>
<p class="body">Initially known as the United States Indian Industrial Training School, Haskell opened its doors on September 17, 1884, with 22 students from the Ponca, Sac and Fox, Shawnee, Kiowa, Comanche, and Chippewa Munsee tribes. Training focused on agriculture and vocational trades such as blacksmithing, textiles, farming, and sewing in a curriculum rooted in the era’s English-only movement, enforced by corporal punishment.</p>
<p class="body">The students who attended Indian boarding schools were primarily Indigenous children, often forcibly removed from their families and communities by the federal government.<a id="calibre_link-3259" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3172">9</a> Each student who arrived at Haskell was required to stay for a minimum of one four-year term. The children arrived by train. All semblance of the children’s lives were stripped away, including clothing, photographs, toys, and keepsakes. Children were not allowed to speak their native languages. Contact with family was forbidden. The children were required to take English names.</p>
<p class="body">By 1894 Haskell had transitioned from elementary education to advanced schooling, offering eight grades of “industrial training” for boys and girls.<a id="calibre_link-3260" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3173">10</a> By 1927 the school taught both high school and postsecondary courses.</p>
<p class="body">At the start of the New Deal Era in 1933, Haskell chose its first Native Indian superintendent, Dr. Henry Roe Cloud (1884-1950), a full-blooded Ho-Chunk enrolled with the Winnebago Tribe.<a id="calibre_link-3261" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3174">11</a> With the racist language of the era, Cloud was described as a man “who rose from a bark wgiwam [<em>sic</em>] on the plains of Nebraska to recently become the superintendent of Haskell Institute, the largest institution of its kind.”<a id="calibre_link-3262" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3175">12</a> Reportedly he “early showed a desire for further learning in the white man’s school.”<a id="calibre_link-3263" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3176">13</a> Cloud was a Mason, Rotarian, Elk, and Presbyterian minister. Most importantly, he was a reformer and educator. Dismantling the assimilation curriculum and policies, he instituted a traditional style of schooling focused on arts, skills, advanced trades, and Native culture. Haskell became an Indigenous leader and advocate. In 1906 Cloud married Elizabeth Bender, a White Earth Chippewa. She was the sister of <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/charles-bender/">Albert “Chief” Bender</a>, who was a Hall of Fame pitcher for the Philadelphia Athletics.<a id="calibre_link-3264" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3177">14</a></p>
<p class="body">In 1970 Haskell began offering junior-college degrees and became known as the Haskell Junior College. The college then became Haskell Indian Nations University in 1993, offering a four-year baccalaureate degree program with a mission dedicated to Indian cultural preservation, research, and education.</p>
<p class="body">By 2024, Haskell offered bachelor’s degrees in Indigenous and American Indian studies, business administration, elementary education, and environmental science along with nine associate degrees. The average enrollment at Haskell is 900, with multi-tribal representation. To apply for admission, one must either be an enrolled member of a federally recognized tribe eligible for education benefits from the Bureau of Indian Affairs or at least a one-fourth total degree Indian blood direct descendant of an enrolled member of a tribe.<a id="calibre_link-3265" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3178">15</a></p>
<p class="body">Athletics is a pivotal component of the Haskell community. The university competes in 11 intercollegiate varsity sports. Men’s sports include basketball, cross-country, golf, and track and field (indoor and outdoor); women’s sports include basketball, cross-country, softball, track and field (indoor and outdoor), and volleyball. Club sports include baseball; varsity baseball was dropped in 2015. The school colors are purple, gold, and white. Haskell is home to the American Indian Athletic Hall of Fame.</p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body"> </p>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w2" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000057.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Haskell Institute&#8217;s 1921 baseball team, Lawrence, Kansas. (Courtesy of Kansas Memory)</em></p>
</div>
<div id="calibre_link-94" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>PART III. HASKELL’S AFFAIR WITH BASEBALL</strong></p>
<p class="body">A passion for baseball and other stick-and-ball games has long existed among Native American tribes, who created the game of lacrosse. The Choctaw developed an ancestral form of stickball called “Ishtaboli” that has been its national sport for centuries.<a id="calibre_link-3266" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3179">16</a> Those who attended Haskell were familiar with such games.</p>
<p class="body">Many Indigenous athletes at Haskell played both baseball and football. In the first part of the twentieth century, Haskell had a dominant football program, competitive against the powers of the time like Yale, Brown, Missouri, and Creighton. After the 1931 season, the school shifted the team to a high-school status and eventually dropped football in 1938. Sport was a “serious and integral part of [Native] life and as an important developmental activity of young people.”<a id="calibre_link-3267" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3180">17</a> At Haskell and elsewhere, Native Indian students accepted and excelled at “new” sports like baseball that were introduced to them.</p>
<p class="body">A handful of Haskell baseball players briefly made it the major leagues; <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/jim-thorpe/">Jim Thorpe</a>, <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/george-johnson/">George Johnson</a>, <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/ben-tincup/">Ben Tincup</a>, and <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/louis-leroy/">Louis LeRoy</a> went to Haskell. A host of Haskell athletes also played in the minor leagues.</p>
<p class="body">While Native American baseball players did not face “official” segregation as did African American players, the arrival of Native Americans into professional baseball was marked by racism, hazing, and hostility. The common practice of racially tinged nicknames like Chief or Injun marked Native athletes as different. The number of Native Americans playing major-league baseball ebbed after World War I, reviving only recently.<a id="calibre_link-3268" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3181">18</a></p>
<p class="body">The words that Cahuilla Band <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/jack-meyers/">John Tortes Meyers</a>, a former New York Giants catcher, wrote about his teammate Jim Thorpe can be applied to any Native players in any sport: “It would be false modesty on my part to declare that I am not thoroughly delighted with the fact that my race has proven itself competent to master the White man’s principal sport.”<a id="calibre_link-3269" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3182">19</a></p>
<p class="body">Haskell student <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/ike-kahdot/">Isaac “Ike” Kahdot</a> (1899-1999) mastered the game to become a major leaguer in 1922. Kahdot grew up in Georgetown, near present-day Konawa, Oklahoma. A Potawatomi Indian, he attended Sacred Heart School as a little boy. He was mistreated: “I didn’t like the priests, so I ran off every chance I got.”<a id="calibre_link-3270" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3183">20</a> Accusing him of smoking “tobacco,” the priests whipped him as punishment. He attended the Friends Mission School, then his father enrolled him at Haskell. He excelled at baseball. He told the <em>Tulsa World</em> in 1993, “My dad give me a bat and a ball and a glove when I was growing up. And I always had that with me. We had an Injun team when I was a young kid, and my dad wanted me to play ball on it.”<a id="calibre_link-3271" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3184">21</a> When he finished high school, Kahdot advanced in the minor leagues before Cleveland acquired his rights from the Coffeyville, Kansas, team he played on.</p>
<p class="body">As a shortstop and third baseman, Kahdot had a brief stay with the Cleveland Indians, from September 5 to 21, 1922, appearing in four games with two at-bats and no hits. In his first game, on September 5 against the St. Louis Browns, Kahdot came in to run for player-team manager <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/tris-speaker/">Tris Speaker </a>in the sixth inning. His final appearance in the major leagues was on September 21 in a 15-5 loss to Boston.<a id="calibre_link-3272" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3185">22</a> Speaker had Kahdot come into the game in the eighth during the blowout loss, substituting for <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/larry-gardner/">Larry Gardner</a> at third. He faced <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/jack-quinn/">Jack Quinn</a> and went 0-for-1, flying out to left in the bottom of the eighth. He had a putout and an assist executing a double play.<a id="calibre_link-3273" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3186">23</a></p>
<p class="body">Upon the completion of the 1923 minor-league season, Cleveland wanted Kahdot to play for its Grand Rapids minor-league team, where the Indians sent their top prospects. Kahdot lived in Kansas and “had a new wife, and a possible major league career didn’t seem worth the move.”<a id="calibre_link-3274" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3187">24</a> He paid the Indians $2,500 to release him from his contract.</p>
<p class="body">Kahdot played baseball for 15 years in several minor leagues until 1935.<a id="calibre_link-3275" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3188">25</a> Then he was a derrick man, driller, and rope choker in oilfields until 1958, when he went to work at Tinker Air Force Base until his retirement in 1969.<a id="calibre_link-3276" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3189">26</a></p>
<p class="body">In 1993 <em>Tulsa World</em> wrote that “‘Chief’ Kahdot’s only mark on the major leagues may have been but a line in four box scores. But his journey from a small community before statehood through the major and minor leagues, touched a part of the game, and America, that has long been forgotten except in history books.”<a id="calibre_link-3277" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3190">27</a> He lived to almost 100 and was the oldest living major leaguer when he died in Oklahoma City on March 31, 1999.</p>
<p class="body">Khadot’s solitary reminder that he was a major leaguer, other than memories, was a memento he received: a brand-new Reach baseball signed by his Cleveland teammates and treasured until his death.<a id="calibre_link-3278" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3191">28</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>PART IV. HASKELL BASEBALL STORIES</strong></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>APRIL 15, 1901</strong></p>
<p class="body">Haskell’s 1901 season began with a 5-5 tie with the University of Kansas in Lawrence. Haskell jumped to a 5-0 lead with four runs in the first and a run in the second. The contest “was devoid of features of great interest and would have been won by the Indians had they not got badly rattled and allowed the university boys to run five scores on errors.”<a id="calibre_link-3279" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3192">29</a> The bottom of the ninth was not played “as the university boys thought they had won the game, and left the field.”<a id="calibre_link-3280" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3193">30</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>SEPTEMBER 4, 1903</strong></p>
<p class="body">During the 1903 season, the <em>Howard</em> (Kansas) <em>Courant</em> wrote several colorful statements about the Haskell baseball team, reflecting the period’s simplistic attitudes toward Native Americans: 1) “They are a peaceable lot of braves, those Haskell boys, and they play fast ball.” 2) “There is nothing especially aboriginal about the names of the Haskell Indian boys as they appear on the hotel register.” 3) “Lots of ball players could learn good manners of the noble red men from Haskell.”<a id="calibre_link-3281" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3194">31</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>APRIL 18, 1905</strong></p>
<p class="body">An Oneida Indian, Chauncey Archiquette (1877-1949) was a unique athlete. It was announced that “the Indian star football half-back and base ball man, has left the Haskell Institute and has followed the two more of the best athletes Haskell ever had.”<a id="calibre_link-3282" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3195">32</a> He left the school on April 17, 1905, to “join Green’s Nebraska Indian base ball team.”<a id="calibre_link-3283" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3196">33</a> He followed Chas. Guyon and Joe Rapp to Green, both of whom had played with Archiquette on Haskell’s baseball and football teams. Archiquette, who graduated from high school at Carlisle before attending Haskell, was a popular figure who “won many honors for the Indian institute[,] and the people of the town as well as the students of Haskell dislike to see him go.”<a id="calibre_link-3284" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3197">34</a> At Haskell, Archiquette was the baseball team’s catcher and leading hitter.</p>
<p class="body">In the fall of 1898, an impressionable 11-year-old Sac and Fox student watched the Haskell football practice in awe of Archiquette. He told himself, “I’m going to be as tough as Chauncey.”<a id="calibre_link-3285" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3198">35</a> Archiquette asked the scrawny kid if wanted to play football and whether he wanted a football. Together, they went to the Haskell harness shop. Archiquette made him a makeshift football to play with. Thus began Archiquette’s mentoring of Jim Thorpe; they played football and baseball together at Haskell.<a id="calibre_link-3286" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3199">36</a></p>
<p class="body">Archiquette played football and baseball on barnstorming squads and later worked as a clerk for Carlisle in the book department and then went in 1906 to the Osage Indian Agency, for whom he worked until his retirement in 1942.<a id="calibre_link-3287" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3200">37</a> The agency described Archiquette as a member of a musical quartet and “as one of the most competent men around the agency.”<a id="calibre_link-3288" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3201">38</a></p>
<p class="body">Archiquette was an American Olympian at the 1904 St. Louis Olympic Games. He participated in Haskell’s two football games at Francis Olympic Field as part of the demonstration event of American football at the 1904 Summer Olympics.<a id="calibre_link-3289" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3202">39</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>MARCH 31, 1909</strong></p>
<p class="body">Spring was dawning on the Haskell campus and baseball coach Maurice Kent thought his was going to be one of the best teams in the region.<a id="calibre_link-3290" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3203">40</a> During the previous two seasons, “the Redskins through indifferent management, allowed the team to take the toboggan.”<a id="calibre_link-3291" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3204">41</a> Most of the games were taking place “on the opponents’ diamonds … because the Indians couldn’t make expenses when they bought visiting teams” to Haskell.<a id="calibre_link-3292" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3205">42</a> In past seasons, there was little interest in the baseball team and there “seemed to be little enthusiasm among the Haskell students. This year, “Kent proposes to stir up enthusiasm.”<a id="calibre_link-3293" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3206">43</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>AUGUST 23, 1910</strong></p>
<p class="body">A death resulted from a game against Lecompton. Haskell’s Henry Rigert was badly injured playing his first game for a “Cherokee Indian ball team.”<a id="calibre_link-3294" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3207">44</a> A star football and baseball player, Rigert attempted to slide into home plate when he “struck his head against the catcher’s knee, paralyzing him from the neck down.”<a id="calibre_link-3295" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3208">45</a> Rigert was “conscious, … awaiting death realizing that there is scarcely one chance in a thousand for his recovery. …”<a id="calibre_link-3296" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3209">46</a> Two doctors who treated Rigert concluded that he suffered “a dislocated vertebra pressing on the spinal cord.”<a id="calibre_link-3297" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3210">47</a> In early September, a press article noted that Rigert “was killed at a baseball game.”<a id="calibre_link-3298" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3211">48</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>MAY 7, 1915</strong></p>
<p class="body">Played in Emporia, Kansas, the Haskell Indian team defeated State Normal 6-2 on Normal’s home turf. Haskell’s lefty pitcher Delorme scattered three hits “while the Indians connected with nine of the Norman’s twirler’s offerings.”<a id="calibre_link-3299" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3212">49</a> The field conditions were poor and as the players fought the muddy grounds and “the bunting in which the redskins indulged brought a victory.<a id="calibre_link-3300" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3213">50</a> The fifth inning was “when the Indians annexed half their runs.”<a id="calibre_link-3301" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3214">51</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>MAY 17, 1916</strong></p>
<p class="body">Haskell was about to play the Kansas Aggies in Manhattan when the team suffered a serious blow. Its 1916 prospects declined dramatically as it “received a serious bump by the ‘withdrawal’ from school of Pitcher McCloskey and Catcher James White Bull.”<a id="calibre_link-3302" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3215">52</a> The school superintendent announced that the two Sioux Indians went back home to “Dakota.” Rumors circulated among the student body “that the two have gone to join an Indian baseball team which will tour the middle west this summer.”<a id="calibre_link-3303" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3216">53</a> The duo were “an interesting feature of the game this spring has been their native talk which they pulled as battery mates.”<a id="calibre_link-3304" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3217">54</a> According to their teammates, the pair “intend to tour the country with an Indian baseball aggregation.”<a id="calibre_link-3305" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3218">55</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>SEPTEMBER 21, 1918</strong></p>
<p class="body">Like all parts of the country during World War I, “every Indian at Haskell engaged in war work.”<a id="calibre_link-3306" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3219">56</a> Out of 832 students enrolled, 141 were registered for the draft; 325 graduates and current students ended up in the armed forces, and “one Haskell boy has been reported as a casualty.”<a id="calibre_link-3307" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3220">57</a> The Miami tribesman and former Haskell baseball player Sandy Timothy “now holds the championship for hand grenade throwing in a Georgia cantonment.”<a id="calibre_link-3308" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3221">58</a> In a photograph in full uniform, Timothy demonstrated his grenade-throwing form in an advertisement for Americans to “buy bonds till you sacrifice” since “backing up the Brave is the noblest duty of an American today.”<a id="calibre_link-3309" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3222">59</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>APRIL 8, 1925</strong></p>
<p class="body">John Thomas Levi (1898-1946) was a major-league outfield prospect with a rare mix of power and speed.<a id="calibre_link-3310" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3223">60</a> Considered the school’s greatest recruit, Levi graduated from Haskell in 1924. Levi was awarded more letters than any other student who attended Haskell up to that time.<a id="calibre_link-3311" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3224">61</a></p>
<p class="body">A full-blooded Arapaho, Levi was an elite athlete with a great talent not only in baseball, but in football and track as well.<a id="calibre_link-3312" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3225">62</a> Jim Thorpe called Levi “the greatest athlete I have ever seen.”<a id="calibre_link-3313" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3226">63</a></p>
<p class="body">A leg injury playing baseball quashed any desire to be like his hero Thorpe and fulfill his potential as a decathlete in the 1924 Paris Olympic Games. On December 1, 1924, “the charging buffalo” signed a contract with the New York Yankees based on reputation, since the Yankees scouts had never seen him play.<a id="calibre_link-3314" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3227">64</a> The Yankees believed Levi could “approximate the style of <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/bob-meusel/">Bob Meusel</a>, the Yankees’ left fielder.”<a id="calibre_link-3315" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3228">65</a></p>
<p class="body">Levi played with the Yankees during the 1925 spring training and joined them on a barnstorming trip. On April 8, the Yankees boarded a players’ train in Nashville to Asheville, North Carolina to continue their money-making tour. Babe Ruth, though not feeling well physically, had been playing in the games. On the train, Ruth complained of chills, fever, and a headache. The trainers gave him medicine to relieve his symptoms, but it did not work. The train arrived in Asheville and as Ruth climbed off the train, “he collapsed in the arms of John Levi, the Haskell Indian.”<a id="calibre_link-3316" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3229">66</a></p>
<p class="body">Yankees manager <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/miller-huggins/">Miller Huggins</a> never offered Levi an opportunity in spring training to demonstrate his skills. Levi was sent to the Harrisburg Senators of the Class-B New York Penn League on April 14 for further “seasoning.” Levi became homesick for his people and never made it the majors, playing through 1930 for low-level minor-league teams and also played professional football.<a id="calibre_link-3317" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3230">67</a> Levi was an assistant football coach at Haskell for 10 years and was head coach in 1936, going 0-7-1.</p>
<p class="body">In 1946 Levi was employed in a Denver packing house at 70 cents an hour.<a id="calibre_link-3318" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3231">68</a> On January 22 the Denver police found him mortally wounded in a hotel room. A newspaper account said that during a heated argument, Fannie Stabler stabbed Levi with a six-inch knife as she tried to leave. Levi slapped her when she screamed at him, “[T]ake your hands off me or I’ll kill you.”<a id="calibre_link-3319" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3232">69</a> Levi died at Denver General Hospital within an hour. Stabler was convicted of involuntary manslaughter.<a id="calibre_link-3320" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3233">70</a> At the time of his death, Levi was divorced from his wife Helen who was living in Wahpeton, North Dakota, with a son and daughter.<a id="calibre_link-3321" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3234">71</a></p>
<p class="body">During a 2012 interview about his father, Levi’s son, John Jr., observed that whenever visiting Haskell, “I feel his spirit and Haskell means an awful lot to our family. … I’m proud to have his name. …”<a id="calibre_link-3322" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3235">72</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>APRIL 23, 2000</strong></p>
<p class="body">Once a Haskell baseball pitcher, William Mehojah (1917-2000), the last full-blooded Kaw Indian, died at 82 on Easter morning, April 23, 2000, of lung failure.<a id="calibre_link-3323" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3236">73</a> In the seventeenth century, about 2,000 Kaw flourished on the Plains.<a id="calibre_link-3324" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3237">74</a> “The reality of being the last full blood to me is sad and lonely,’’ he said in the Kaw newsletter in 1997.<a id="calibre_link-3325" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3238">75</a> As a child he had spoken his native language with his father, Jesse, losing the skill after Jesse died in 1935. However, he always understood his people’s language.</p>
<p class="body">Born in 1917 on a land allotment in Washunga, Oklahoma, Mehojah received an associate’s degree in business administration from Haskell. His mission in life was to help Native Americans.<a id="calibre_link-3326" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3239">76</a> “He was a living treasure,” said his son William Mehojah, Jr., “because he represented a people that have been eradicated.”<a id="calibre_link-3327" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3240">77</a> His mother decided he needed to go to college so “he could work in an office somewhere,” her son recalled.<a id="calibre_link-3328" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3241">78</a></p>
<p class="body">Mehojah served in the Army in World War II and later worked for the Veterans Administration’s regional office in Muskogee, Oklahoma, and then for the Bureau of Indian Affairs. In 1964 he became the superintendent of the Bureau of Indian Affairs Turtle Mountain Agency in Belcourt, North Dakota.<a id="calibre_link-3329" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3242">79</a> He retired in 1976.</p>
<p class="body">In 1987, Mehojah was elected Chairman of the Kaw Nation for a three-year term.<a id="calibre_link-3330" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3243">80</a> In 1995 Haskell named him alumnus of the year. “He spoke to the graduating class in his simple, measured way and from his heart,” his son said.<a id="calibre_link-3331" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3244">81</a> Oklahoma Governor Frank Keating proclaimed August 6, 1999, as William A. Mehojah Day. Fredericka Mehojah, his wife of 57 years, said he was an avid golfer and had always been a good athlete.<a id="calibre_link-3332" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3245">82</a></p>
<p class="sub-sub-heading"><strong>V. CONCLUSION</strong></p>
<p class="body">The Indian Boarding Schools began in 1819 when Congress appropriated the funding under the Indian Civilization Act of March 3, 1819.<a id="calibre_link-3333" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3246">83</a> The peak enrollment for Indian Boarding Schools occurred in the 1970s.<a id="calibre_link-3334" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3247">84</a> The schools exist to this day. The landscape changed after 1933 when the tribes increasingly had more say over the schools and students were no longer forced by the Federal government to go to boarding schools.</p>
<p class="body">The Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 – called the “Indian New Deal” – attempted to improve the lives of Native Americans as it halted the policy of forced assimilation and promoted greater tribal self-governance.<a id="calibre_link-3335" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3248">85</a> Led by Bureau of Indian Affairs Commissioner John Collier (1884-1968), it was an era of advocating for tribal rights, preserving Native American cultures and traditions and ending the policy of forced assimilation.</p>
<p class="body">Boarding schools like Haskell were created as an instrument to “‘whiten’ Native Americans and supplant their culture and language with American ideals and English.”<a id="calibre_link-3336" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3249">86</a> Countless Native Americans were forced to attend the boarding schools, forbidden to speak their native languages, forced to renounce native beliefs and to abandon their native identities.<a id="calibre_link-3337" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3250">87</a> History may never fully account for what the students who played baseball and other sports for Haskell &#8211; all the students- suffered due to the assimilation policy of the federal government.</p>
<p class="body">From its creation as boarding school designed to erase all vestiges of Native American life, Haskell has come to be a beacon of such life and in the vanguard of research, preservation, and celebration of Native American culture and history.</p>
<p class="body">Since its beginning, the insatiable appetite for achievement in sports like baseball has been strong at Haskell. Each year, as spring marches onto the campus, the traditional sounds of the game are still heard from the Haskell club baseball team.</p>
<p><em><strong>LUIS A. BLANDÓN JR.</strong>, a Washington, DC native, is a pro- ducer, writer, and historical researcher. He has garnered numerous awards, including three regional Emmys and Edward R. Murrow Awards. He served as the principal researcher for several authors recently The Mysterious Mrs. Nixon: The Life and Times of Washington’s Most Private First Lady by Heath Hardage Lee. Luis has a Masters of Arts in International Affairs from the George Washington University.</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Acknowledgments</strong></p>
<p class="sources">With deep gratitude to my wife, Teri, for putting up with the author.</p>
<p class="sources">Much thanks and appreciation to noted and award-winning Native American Indian historian Dr. Edward Angel, for his review of this essay and consultations offering his expert opinion and advice.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Sources</strong></p>
<p class="sources">In addition to the sources cited in the Notes, the author consulted Haskell University, the Kaw Nation, the Choctaw Nation of Oklahoma, the Cheyenne and Arapaho Tribes, the National Museum of the American Indian, Library of Congress, The Archival Collection of Gustavus Elmer Emanuel Linquist Native American Papers in the Missionary Research Library Archives at the Burke Library, Columbia University, National Archives and Record Administration, the Department of the Interior, Bureau of Indian Affairs, the National WWI Museum and Memorial, <a class="calibre2" href="http://baseball-reference.com">baseball-reference.com</a>, <a class="calibre2" href="http://retrosheet.org">retrosheet.org</a>, <a class="calibre2" href="http://mlb.com">mlb.com</a>, and <a class="calibre2" href="http://youtube.com">youtube.com</a>.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Notes</strong></p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3164" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3251">1</a></span> For more information about Haskell Cemetery, including a list of the 103 buried there, see <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.haskellhistory.com/cemetery">https://www.haskellhistory.com/cemetery</a>. In addition to the 103 marked graves in the Haskell Cemetery, there are eight individuals who are believed to be buried there, but whose graves are not marked.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3165" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3252">2</a></span> Brenna Daldorph, “US Freeway to Pave over History of Native American Suffering,” <a class="calibre2" href="http://france24.com">france24.com</a><span class="italic">,</span> January 28, 2014. See <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.france24.com/en/20140128-us-freeway-pave-over-history-native-american-suffering">https://www.france24.com/en/20140128-us-freeway-pave-over-history-native-american-suffering</a>, accessed November 26, 2024.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3166" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3253">3</a></span> “Haskell Installs New Fence Around Cemetery After Vandalism,” <span class="italic">Lawrence</span> (Kansas) <span class="italic">World Journal,</span> January 2, 2018. See <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.ljworld.com/news/2018/jan/02/haskell-installs-new-fence-around-cemetery-after-s/">https://www2.ljworld.com/news/2018/jan/02/haskell-installs-new-fence-around-cemetery-after-s/</a>, accessed November 26, 2024. Efforts began in 2024 to clean each headstone, replace the faded historical marker and discover more about the lives behind those interred.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3167" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3254">4</a></span> National Council of Urban Indian Health press release: “President Biden Formally Apologizes for Federal Government Involvement in Indian Boarding Schools,” October 28, 2024. <a class="calibre2" href="https://ncuih.org/2024/10/29/press-release-president-biden-formally-apologizes-for-federal-government-involvement-in-indian-boarding-schools/">https://ncuih.org/2024/10/29/press-release-president-biden-formally-apologizes-for-federal-government-involvement-in-indian-boarding-schools/</a>, accessed May 15, 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3168" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3255">5</a></span> The Southwestern Indian Polytechnic Institute in Albuquerque, New Mexico, a two-year college, is the other federally operated institution. Native American tribes also operate 35 colleges that received federal funding.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3169" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3256">6</a></span> Carlisle Indian School Digital Resources, “‘Kill the Indian in Him, and Save the Man’: R. H. Pratt on the Education of Native Americans,” <a class="calibre2" href="https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/teach/kill-indian-him-and-save-man-r-h-pratt-education-native-americans">https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/teach/kill-indian-him-and-save-man-r-h-pratt-education-native-americans</a>, accessed May 16, 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3170" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3257">7</a></span> The Indian Territory became the State of Oklahoma on November 16, 1907.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3171" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3258">8</a></span> Natalie Vondrak, “Haskell Institute: The Roots From Which We Bloom 1884-1930),” Watkins Museum of History online exhibit. <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.watkinsmuseum.org/online-exhibits/haskell-institute-the-roots-from-which-we-bloom-1884-1930/">https://www.watkinsmuseum.org/online-exhibits/haskell-institute-the-roots-from-which-we-bloom-1884-1930/</a>, accessed November 6, 2024.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3172" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3259">9</a></span> The federal government used various methods to bring/lure Native children to the boarding schools: a) forced attendance: In many cases, government agents would forcibly remove children from their homes and reservations to attend these schools; b) government pressure and coercion: Federal agents were responsible for gathering children and getting them to schools using tactics like withholding food or other vital supplies from parents who resisted sending their children; c) seizure by authorities: If parents were unwilling to comply with the demand to send their children to boarding school, the police were sent to seize the children; d) compulsory attendance laws: Congress in 1891 made it mandatory for Native children to attend school, giving federal officers the authority to forcibly take them from their homes; e) families choosing to send children (often out of necessity). Some Native parents chose to send their children to boarding schools because there were no other educational options available in their tribal communities. Research released in February 2025 by the National Native American Boarding School Healing Coalition says there have been 526 Indian boarding schools in the United States. See <a class="calibre2" href="https://boardingschoolhealing.org/list/">https://boardingschoolhealing.org/list/</a>, accessed June 30, 2025. By 1900 there were 20,000 children in Indian boarding schools. By 1925, this number had more than tripled, reaching 60,889 children, according to the National Native American Boarding School Healing Coalition. By 1926, over 80 percent of Indigenous school-age children (more than 60,000) were attending federal or religiously run boarding schools. See “US Indian Boarding School History,” <span class="italic">National Native American Boarding School Healing Coalition,</span> <a class="calibre2" href="https://boardingschoolhealing.org/education/us-indian-boarding-school-history/">https://boardingschoolhealing.org/education/us-indian-boarding-school-history/</a>, accessed June 30, 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3173" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3260">10</a></span> Keith A. Sculle, “The New Carlisle of the West: Haskell Institute and Big-Time Sports, 1920-1932,” <span class="italic">Kansas History</span>, Autumn 1994, Vol. 17, No. 3, 195.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3174" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3261">11</a></span> Dr. Cloud was the first full-blood Native American to attend Yale University. He graduated with a bachelor of arts in psychology and philosophy from Yale College in 1910 and earned a master of arts degree in anthropology from Yale University in 1914.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3175" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3262">12</a></span> Associated Press, “Indian Climbs From Tepee to Exalted Office,” <span class="italic">Washington Post</span>, August 13, 1933: 10.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3176" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3263">13</a></span> “Indian Climbs From Tepee to Exalted Office.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3177" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3264">14</a></span> “Indian Climbs From Tepee to Exalted Office.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3178" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3265">15</a></span> The verification of tribal enrollment can be presented by one of the following means: a) Student is an enrolled member of a federally recognized tribe. Provide an official Certificate of Degree of Indian Blood (CDIB) card or other official tribal enrollment information with the student’s name, other identifying information such as date of birth or social security number, and an enrollment (membership) number from the BIA agency or federally recognized tribe. b) Direct descendant of an enrolled member of a tribe eligible for BIA education benefits. Provide official documentation of at least one-fourth degree Indian blood descendant of an enrolled member of a federally recognized tribe eligible for BIA education benefits, signed by the appropriate BIA agency or federally recognized tribe.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3179" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3266">16</a></span> Ishtaboli served as a social and diplomatic tool for the Choctaw. The Tribe used the game to train their warriors. “Stickball,” <span class="italic">Choctaw Nation of Oklahoma</span>. See <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.choctawnation.com/about/culture/traditions/stickball/">https://www.choctawnation.com/about/culture/traditions/stickball/</a>, accessed June 7, 2025. Jeffrey Powers-Beck, <span class="italic">The American Indian Integration of Baseball</span> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2004), 17.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3180" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3267">17</a></span> David Oxendine, <span class="italic">American Indian Sports Heritage</span> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1995), 181.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3181" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3268">18</a></span> In 2014, there were only three active non-Hispanic Native American players in the major leagues: <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/joba-chamberlain/">Joba Chamberlain</a> (Ho-Chunk/Winnebago), <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/kyle-lohse/">Kyle Lohse </a>(Nomlaki), and <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/jacoby-ellsbury/">Jacoby Ellsbury</a> (Navajo). See Vincent M. Mallozzi, “The American Indians of America’s Pastime,” <em>New York Times</em>, June 8, 2014: SP11.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3182" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3269">19</a></span> Charlie Vascellaro. “The Real Indians of Baseball,” <span class="italic">NMAI Magazine</span>, Summer 2012, Vol. 12, No.2. See <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.americanindianmagazine.org/story/real-indians-baseball">https://www.americanindianmagazine.org/story/real-indians-baseball</a>, accessed November 18, 2024.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3183" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3270">20</a></span> “‘Chief” Kahdot – A Real Cleveland Indian,” Potawatomi Nation, October 20, 2021, <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.potawatomi.org/blog/2021/10/20/chief-kahdot-a-real-cleveland-indian/">https://www.potawatomi.org/blog/2021/10/20/chief-kahdot-a-real-cleveland-indian/</a>, accessed December 3, 2024.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3184" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3271">21</a></span> Burl Spencer, “‘Chief’ Was an Indian in Ruthian Age of Dreams,” <em>Tulsa World</em>, September 22, 1993: Sports-1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3185" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3272">22</a></span> See box score in <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/SLA/SLA192209050.shtml">https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/SLA/SLA192209050.shtml</a>/.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3186" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3273">23</a></span> See box score in <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/1922/B09210CLE1922.htm">https://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/1922/B09210CLE1922.htm</a>/.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3187" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3274">24</a></span> Burl Spencer, “Oldest Living Cleveland Indian Remembers the Good Year: 1922,” <em>Tulsa World</em>, September 22, 1993: Sports &#8211; 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3188" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3275">25</a></span> “‘Chief’ Kahdot – A Real Cleveland Indian.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3189" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3276">26</a></span> C. Richard King, <span class="italic">Native Americans in Sports</span> (New York: Routledge, 2015), 167. Burl Spencer, “‘Chief’ Was an Indian in Ruthian Age of Dreams.” Tinker Air Force Base is in Oklahoma City.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3190" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3277">27</a></span> Burl Spencer, “‘Chief’ was an Indian in Ruthian Age of Dreams.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3191" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3278">28</a></span> “‘Chief’ Kahdot – A Real Cleveland Indian”; “Oldest Living Cleveland Indian Remembers the Good Year: 1922.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3192" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3279">29</a></span> “The Game at Haskell,” <span class="italic">Lawrence Daily World,</span> April 16, 1901: 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3193" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3280">30</a></span> “The Game at Haskell.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3194" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3281">31</a></span> “Clippings,” <span class="italic">The Indian Leader</span> (Lawrence, Kansas), September 4, 1903: 2. “Base Ball Talk,” <span class="italic">Howard</span> (Kansas) <span class="italic">Courant,</span> August 28, 1903: 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3195" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3282">32</a></span> “Archiquette Leaves Haskell,” <span class="italic">Topeka</span> (Kansas) <span class="italic">Daily Herald,</span> April 18, 1905: 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3196" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3283">33</a></span> “Archiquette Leaves Haskell.” Green’s Nebraska Indians was early pro all-Indian touring team for which Archiquette played as a catcher.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3197" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3284">34</a></span> “Archiquette Leaves Haskell.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3198" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3285">35</a></span> Lars Anderson, <span class="italic">Carlisle vs. Army: Jim Thorpe, Dwight Eisenhower, Pop Warner, and the Forgotten Story of Football’s Greatest Battle</span> (New York: Random House, 2008), 91.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3199" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3286">36</a></span> Anderson. Jim Thorpe attended and played baseball, track and field, and football for Haskell before going to the Carlisle Indian Industrial School.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3200" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3287">37</a></span> “C.E. Archiquette, Early Grid Star, Dies in Claremore,” <em>Tulsa World</em>. March 13, 1949: 80.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3201" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3288">38</a></span> “C.E. Archiquette,” <span class="italic">Osage Journal and County News</span> (Pawhuska, Oklahoma), December 17, 1926: 29.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3202" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3289">39</a></span> “Chauncey Archiquette,” <a class="calibre2" href="http://olympedia.com">olympedia.com</a>, <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.olympedia.org/athletes/892472">https://www.olympedia.org/athletes/892472</a>, accessed May 18, 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3203" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3290">40</a></span> A University of Iowa football star in 1905 and 1906, Kent was also Haskell’s football coach. See “Haskell Athletics: Indian School Has Got an Instructor from Iowa,” <span class="italic">Lawrence Daily Gazette,</span> February 14, 1908: 2.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3204" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3291">41</a></span> “Will Have Good Nine,” <span class="italic">Leavenworth</span> (Kansas) <span class="italic">Post,</span> March 3, 1909: 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3205" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3292">42</a></span> “Will Have Good Nine.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3206" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3293">43</a></span> “Will Have Good Nine.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3207" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3294">44</a></span> “Indian Hurt in Ballgame,” <span class="italic">Topeka State Journal,</span> August 25, 1910: 7.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3208" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3295">45</a></span> “Indian Athlete Will Die,” <span class="italic">Leavenworth Post,</span> August 25, 1910: 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3209" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3296">46</a></span> “Indian Hurt in Ballgame.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3210" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3297">47</a></span> “Indian Hurt in Ballgame.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3211" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3298">48</a></span> “Intercollegiate,” <span class="italic">Bethany Messenger</span> (Lindsburg, Kansas), September 9, 1910: 6</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3212" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3299">49</a></span> “Beat Normalites,” <span class="italic">Leavenworth Daily Gazette,</span> May 8, 1916: 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3213" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3300">50</a></span> “Beat Normalites.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3214" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3301">51</a></span> “Beat Normalites.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3215" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3302">52</a></span> “Gone to Join Indians,” <span class="italic">Lawrence Daily Gazette,</span> May 17, 1916: 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3216" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3303">53</a></span> “Gone to Join Indians.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3217" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3304">54</a></span> “Gone to Join Indians.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3218" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3305">55</a></span> “Haskell Baseball Team Weakened, Stars Quit,” <span class="italic">Topeka Daily Capital,</span> May 18, 1916: 11.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3219" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3306">56</a></span> “Every Indian at Haskell Engaged on War Work,” <span class="italic">Lawrence Daily Journal-World,</span> September 21, 1918: 2.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3220" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3307">57</a></span> “Every Indian at Haskell Engaged on War Work.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3221" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3308">58</a></span> “Every Indian at Haskell Engaged on War Work.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3222" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3309">59</a></span> “Are You With Us?” <span class="italic">Lawrence Daily Journal-World,</span> October 12, 1918: 2.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3223" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3310">60</a></span> Levi was born on June 14, 1898, in Arapaho Indian country in the Bridgeport Territory (now Oklahoma).</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3224" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3311">61</a></span> “John Levi,” <span class="italic">Kansas Sports Hall of Fame.</span> See: <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.kshof.org/team/john-levi">https://www.kshof.org/team/john-levi</a>, accessed May 15, 2025. Levi graduated from Chilcco (Oklahoma) Indian School in 1917. He arrived at Haskell in 1921. “Skee” was Levi’s nickname while he was at Haskell.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3225" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3312">62</a></span> Levi was a first-team Walter Camp All-American in 1923 as a fullback.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3226" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3313">63</a></span> Kansas Sports Hall of Fame. Levi was posthumously indicated into the American Indian Athletic Hall of Fame (1972), the Oklahoma Athletic Hall of Fame (1973), and the Kansas Sports Hall of Fame (1975).</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3227" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3314">64</a></span> “Flashback Friday: John Levi,” <span class="italic">Haskell Athletics</span>, <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.haskellathletics.com/article/134.php">https://www.haskellathletics.com/article/134.php</a>, accessed August 22, 2022.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3228" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3315">65</a></span> “Yanks Sign John Levi, the ‘Charging Buffalo,’” <span class="italic">Washington Post</span>, January 1, 1925: S1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3229" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3316">66</a></span> “Ruth Is Laid Up with Grip,” <span class="italic">Washington Post</span>, April 8, 1925: 17.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3230" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3317">67</a></span> Levi played in Harrisburg in 1925-26. He also played in the Class-A Western League in 1929 and 1930 for Topeka and St. Joseph respectively.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3231" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3318">68</a></span> “Woman Admits She Slew Levi,” <span class="italic">Webb City</span> (Missouri) <span class="italic">Sentinel,</span> May 24, 1946: 4.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3232" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3319">69</a></span> “Woman Admits She Slew Levi.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3233" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3320">70</a></span> “Levi, Ex-Haskell Indian Ace, Found Stabbed to Death,” <span class="italic">Washington Post</span>, January 24, 1946: 12. Stabler, a Native American, was ultimately given a one- to five-year sentence. She was 38 years old in 1946 and a mother of three children. See Associated Press, “Convicted in Levi Death,” <span class="italic">Kansas City Times</span>, May 24, 1946: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3234" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3321">71</a></span> United Press, “Levi, Once Haskell Grid Star, Slain,” <span class="italic">Fargo</span> (North Dakota) <span class="italic">Forum and Daily Republican,</span> January 23, 1946: 1. Levi’s first wife, Helen Hilda Levi, died in 1995 at the age of 90.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3235" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3322">72</a></span> “Flashback Friday: John Levi.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3236" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3323">73</a></span> Douglas Martin, “William Mehojah, a Kaw Leader, Dies at 82,” <em>New York Times</em>, May 5, 2000: 24. Mehojah’s Indian name was Little Star and he was a member of the Night Clan of a Plains tribe known as the Wind People. Before his death, the last other four remaining purebred Kaws passed away; all were related to him.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3237" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3324">74</a></span> Also known as Kanza, Kansa, or Kona.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3238" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3325">75</a></span> Martin, “William Mehojah, a Kaw Leader, Dies at 82.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3239" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3326">76</a></span> Kaw Nation, “Last Kanza Full Blood,” October 19, 2002. See <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.kawnation.gov/last-kanza-full-blood/">https://www.kawnation.gov/last-kanza-full-blood/</a>, accessed June 3, 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3240" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3327">77</a></span> Stacy Downs (New York Times News Service), “Last Full-Blooded Kaw Indian Buried,” <span class="italic">Wichita Eagle</span>, April 30, 2000: 22A.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3241" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3328">78</a></span> Downs. The land allotments were distributed to individual Indians after the Kaw reservation was dissolved in 1902.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3242" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3329">79</a></span> “Kaw Indian Named Superintendent of Turtle Mountain Agency,” United States Department of Interior, Indian Affairs, November 12, 1964. See <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.bia.gov/as-ia/opa/online-press-release/kaw-indian-named-superintendent-turtle-mountain-agency">https://www.bia.gov/as-ia/opa/online-press-release/kaw-indian-named-superintendent-turtle-mountain-agency</a>, accessed November 25, 2024.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3243" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3330">80</a></span> During his tenure, Mehojah ordered a new tribal constitution drafted that enabled the Kaw to develop a variety of businesses such as a bingo parlor, a motel, and a truck stop. Under his leadership, the Kaw brought $13.5 million in assets and an additional 1,000 acres of commonly-held land. See Douglas Martin, “William Mehojah, a Kaw Leader, Dies at 82,” <em>New York Times</em>, May 5, 2000: 24.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3244" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3331">81</a></span> Downs. William Mehojah, Jr. is a member of the Kaw Tribe of Oklahoma and was the director of the federal government’s Office of Indian Education Programs.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3245" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3332">82</a></span> Fredericka L. Mehojah died on July 26, 2022. She and her husband were married in 1943 in Tulsa. She also attended Haskell.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3246" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3333">83</a></span> “American Indian Boarding Schools,” <span class="italic">Georgia State University Library,</span> <a class="calibre2" href="https://exhibits.library.gsu.edu/health-is-a-human-right/displacement/american-indian-boarding-schools/">https://exhibits.library.gsu.edu/health-is-a-human-right/displacement/american-indian-boarding-schools/</a>, accessed June 18, 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3247" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3334">84</a></span> Tens of thousands of American Indian children attended the boarding schools, peaking in the 1970s, with an estimated enrollment of 60,000 in 1973.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3248" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3335">85</a></span> To review the Indian Reorganization Act, see National Archives and Record Administration’s record <a class="calibre2" href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/7873515">https://catalog.archives.gov/id/7873515</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3249" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3336">86</a></span> Howard University School of Law Research Guides, “A Brief History of Civil Rights in the United States: The Allotment and Assimilation Era (1887 &#8211; 1934),” <a class="calibre2" href="https://library.law.howard.edu/civilrightshistory/indigenous/allotment">https://library.law.howard.edu/civilrightshistory/indigenous/allotment</a>, accessed May 27, 2025.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3250" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3337">87</a></span> Equal Justice Initiative, “‘Cultural Genocide’ and Native American Children,” September 2, 2014, See <a class="calibre2" href="https://eji.org/news/history-racial-injustice-cultural-genocide/">https://eji.org/news/history-racial-injustice-cultural-genocide/</a>, accessed May 27, 2025.</p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>The Old Ball Game: Sherman Indian baseball, Est. 1903</title>
		<link>https://sabr.org/journal/article/the-old-ball-game-sherman-indian-baseball-est-1903/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[wpadmin]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 07:16:38 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://sabr.org/?post_type=journal_articles&#038;p=325907</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Color postcard view of Sherman Institute, c. 1903. (Collection of the author) &#160; On February 21, 1903, a warm and sunny Saturday, the baseball team of the nation’s newest Native American boarding school played its first game. The Sherman Institute was set among citrus groves outside Riverside, California, 60 miles east of Los Angeles. The [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="calibre_link-96" class="calibre1">
<p class="section"><img decoding="async" class="w" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000058.jpg" alt="" /></p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="caption"><em>Color postcard view of Sherman Institute, c. 1903. (Collection of the author)</em></p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="first-paragraph">On February 21, 1903, a warm and sunny Saturday, the baseball team of the nation’s newest Native American boarding school played its first game. The Sherman Institute was set among citrus groves outside Riverside, California, 60 miles east of Los Angeles. The Institute was the 25th and last major link in a federal Indian-school chain spanning the nation. The first school in the system, Carlisle in Pennsylvania, had opened in 1879. It had taken five years to string the chain westward to midcontinent Lawrence, Kansas, and Haskell.<a id="calibre_link-3378" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3340">1</a> But it had taken almost 20 years more to cross the rugged Southwest and create the line’s Southern California terminus. Sherman’s basic mission, though, was the same as the first schools: prepare Indian students for assimilation into mainstream American life and culture, at the expense of tribal languages, customs, and even family. The approach was to nestle into a supportive community, impose a reassuring discipline model, and build college-town pride with sports as an entry point. On this Saturday, Sherman had been open barely five months. It had beaten a college team at football. Now its athletes were out to show they could play baseball.<a id="calibre_link-3379" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3341">2</a></p>
<p class="body">Sherman wasn’t exactly a new team. It had a strong core of mature ballplayers from a resource-challenged rural school serving the Mission tribes of Southern California. It also had a remarkable young point man. Joe Scholder (Diegueño, Mesa Grande) had flourished at an Indian school in the San Diego back country. His superintendent nominated him to transfer to Carlisle, spend a year studying its success, and come home to emulate it. Scholder turned out to be just the man for the job.<a id="calibre_link-3380" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3342">3</a> He became a starter on Carlisle’s nationally recognized football team, played baseball, studied coaching, honed a natural flair for promotion and leadership, and even recruited his football mentor to return with him.<a id="calibre_link-3381" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3343">4</a> This was a sensational coup. Bemus Pierce (Seneca, New York) was a famous Carlisle captain and All-American in the decade before Jim Thorpe. In California, Pierce became a celebrity football player-coach. Scholder would energetically fill many roles: athletic director, promoter, player-coach in both football and baseball. For this day’s inaugural baseball game on Sherman’s home grounds, he was playing second base.</p>
<p class="body">Another notable athlete on the diamond for Sherman was Ben Neafus, a multisport star from Northern California (Round Valley confederation, Klamath). In November 1902 Neafus starred in Sherman’s 34-0 football victory over Occidental College. For the first baseball game, he was in center field.<a id="calibre_link-3382" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3344">5</a></p>
<p class="body">The opposition was Riverside’s fast town team. It had one name player: catcher Jack “Chief” Meyers (Cahuilla). Still six years away from the major leagues and stardom with John McGraw’s New York Giants, Meyers was a local role model for the Sherman players (and kinsman to several of them). The Riverside paper noted that “among the locals Jack Meyers is as sure with the bat as ever.” In this hastily arranged game, Sherman started an untested pitcher and lost, 14-8. But everybody noticed Ben Neafus. “He knocked the only three-bagger tapped out,” the <em>Press</em> reported, “and covers nearly the whole field from center. He never misses.” Neafus was also the pitcher Sherman should have started. He worked the last two innings, giving up just one run (likely unearned).<a id="calibre_link-3383" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3345">6</a></p>
<p class="body">By summer, Neafus’s baseball reputation was outgrowing Sherman. He was recruited to be “the regular ‘twirler’” in weekend games for the crack Santa Fe Railroad team in neighboring San Bernardino. His regular catcher with Santa Fe was Jack Meyers.<a id="calibre_link-3384" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3346">7</a> Imagine: A marquee semipro team with a battery of two rising Native American stars. But it was not to be. Neafus’s first commitment was to Sherman football, and his burst speed and long kicks were key to Sherman’s game. He refocused. That fall, in quick succession Sherman beat Stanford, St. Vincent’s, USC, Occidental, and Pomona to claim bragging rights as Southern California college football champion (though Sherman did not even confer high-school diplomas).<a id="calibre_link-3385" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3347">8</a> Yet by 1905, Ben Neafus was in his 20s and aging out of Sherman. There were responsibilities back home, there were absences, and by 1906 he was gone. A decade later, Los Angeles sportswriters were still recalling his gridiron exploits. But how good a baseball player might he have been? That can only be imagined.</p>
<p class="body">What might have been: This is a theme that plays out over and over in the baseball stories from Sherman’s glory years. There were plenty of big baseball games, big exhibitions. Before the Golden Age of Native American sport began to play out – before the Thorpe Olympics controversy, the onset of World War I and the closure of Carlisle – Sherman would produce a steady stream of solid, even prospect-grade ballplayers. Yet in all that time, no prominent Sherman players ever got a foothold in either the major leagues or the Pacific Coast League (established the same year as Sherman baseball). What accounts for that? The back story.</p>
<p class="body">In 1900 the sprawling Southwest was still an American frontier. Arizona, New Mexico, and Oklahoma were sparsely populated territories, not states. For Native Americans, there were misbegotten federal Indian policies, broken treaties, conflicts, and reservation dispossessions. Most Native Americans were not citizens. California’s context was equally dark. In the rapacious chaos of the Gold Rush, native tribes were decimated by epidemic, violence, fraud, legal snares, and high-handed servitude. The state’s indigenous population, perhaps 150,000 before the Gold Rush, had shrunk to an estimated 25,000 by the turn of the twentieth century.<a id="calibre_link-3386" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3348">9</a> And this was not in the past. On May 12, 1903, speculators with court authority evicted the Cupeño Indians from their ancestral lands at Warner Hot Springs. They were wagon-trained 35 miles west to Pala and left to start a new life from scratch. This was Sherman’s own Trail of Tears. Some students from these evicted families had played in Sherman’s inaugural baseball game less than three months earlier.<a id="calibre_link-3387" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3349">10</a></p>
<p class="body">But Sherman was putting fans in the stands. In May of 1905, Sherman recorded its first victory over a college baseball team. In Los Angeles, Sherman beat USC 7-4 in 10 innings. Barely two weeks later, Sherman was back in LA for a well-publicized contest with the touring team of Japan’s Waseda University. Waseda played the steadier game and won, 12-7, but Sherman prompted wild cheering with an explosive six-run sixth inning. With that, Sherman had hit a remarkable milestone. In its third year of baseball, the Indian school had won a populous fan base in Los Angeles as well as Riverside.<a id="calibre_link-3388" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3350">11</a></p>
<p class="body">July 1905: In this moment another Native American team passed through Riverside. “The famous Sioux Indian Baseball Club” had contrived to blend baseball, the ginned-up novelty of an Indian semipro team, and a flickering glimpse of the future, and it sold. The Sioux meandered the West by train (apparently with soldier chaperones). At each stop they set up with circus efficiency. They shrouded the ball field with a 12-foot-high canvas fence and played a twin bill against the locals. The promotional kicker was that they played a real nightcap under their own jury-rigged portable lights. “With the great lights burning at intervals over the entire field,” promoters promised, “the diamond and outfield is made as light as day.”<a id="calibre_link-3389" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3351">12</a> The Sioux had been doing this for seven years, averaging about 190 games a year. In Riverside they played a town team and lost the first game by one run in extra innings. “As little will be said of the night game as possible,” the Riverside paper huffed. A big crowd had paid 50 cents a seat and the game was played with an oversized ball. “In reality, the field was very poorly lighted with some 25 or 30 gasoline lights, hung from five poles placed about the diamond. It was too dark to catch, too dark to hit and almost too dark to run the bases. But it was unique, don’t forget that.”<a id="calibre_link-3390" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3352">13</a></p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000059.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Sherman Braves team warming up before a spring 2024 game on Sherman&#8217;s home diamond. Foreground is Sherman assistant coach Raymond Tarin. (Courtesy Sherman Indian Museum Archives)</em></p>
<div id="calibre_link-96" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body">As Sherman became a baseball success, its top players began to be noticed. One of the first was Lou Lockart (Sherwood Valley, Pomo), a right-hander with a surprising fastball. “Lockie” had a breakout year at Sherman in 1907 and played a while in the frenetic, all-season world of California semipro baseball. In 1911 he made spring camp with the Pacific Coast League Angels. This was his boyhood dream. “I used to read about Bender and Sockalexis in the papers and determined that I would be like them if I could,” he recalled.<a id="calibre_link-3391" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3353">14</a> Lockart pitched decently in two games that spring but was let go with two other rookie pitchers. Manager Cap Dillon went with his veterans. Unhappy call. The Angels finished last, 39½ games out. Lockart would become a regular in circuits like LA’s Trolley League, pitching another seven years before his arm gave out.<a id="calibre_link-3392" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3354">15</a></p>
<p class="body">But Lockart was an exception at Sherman. A career on the endless professional road, away from family and culture, did not fit with baseball’s place in the cosmos of most Sherman athletes. It was true that some Sherman students, new to a jarringly regimented existence, endured wrenching cultural deprivation, homesickness, fear, anxiety. Imagine family separation.<a id="calibre_link-3393" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3355">16</a> But Sherman also reflected a generation of change. Modern historians of the boarding school experience have recognized that many Sherman students learned to subtly adjust. In historian Clifford Trafzer’s phrase, students learned to “turn the power” of their own culture to live blended lives; they adapted to school and new possibilities even as they refused to abandon tradition and their people in a zero-sum exchange.<a id="calibre_link-3394" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3356">17</a> Sherman Museum curator Lorene Sisquoc (Fort Sill Apache/Mountain Cahuilla) caught the sense of it. Remembering her own years in the multitribal mix of Sherman students, she observed that Sherman became “our reservation.”<a id="calibre_link-3395" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3357">18</a> In that evolutionary pan-Indian environment, the diamond was common ground.</p>
<p class="body">Sherman students could embrace baseball because in its component skills it was like their own ancient games of shinney or lacrosse.<a id="calibre_link-3396" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3358">19</a> Students played baseball joyfully, for release. They played it hard, as a competitive outlet; in a telling phrase, they played to show what an Indian could do.<a id="calibre_link-3397" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3359">20</a> At big games, student fans rocked the home stands like a cheer squad, with Sherman’s famous band booming a Sousa soundtrack. Sherman’s vocational teams played for intramural pennants. Back home, reservation teams played one another, and the game became an integral part of traditional cultural events like fiesta.</p>
<p class="body">Sherman was in its element in those years. A free Sherman education started with English as a second language and up to eight grades of instruction. By 1908, 550 students were enrolled. By 1909, 48 tribes were represented. Academics were taught in the morning; in the afternoon there was vocational instruction; there were extracurricular offerings from music and literary societies to sports. Advancement was by exam, and students could persist into their early 20s. By today’s sensibilities, this may seem like a low educational bar. In its time, it was not. In 1900, according to the US Department of Education, only 6.4 of every 100 American 17-year-olds had a high-school diploma. And census data in this period found that 1.75 million American children were not in school at all but were working in mines, mills, and factories. Sherman’s educational model was destined to fall out of step with regulated high-school sports. But until then, Sherman had a steady flow of mature students in their physical prime. That was how it could play head-to-head with college teams, and show what an Indian could do.<a id="calibre_link-3398" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3360">21</a></p>
<p class="body">In 1909 Sherman had a young right fielder named Kenny Marmon (Laguna Pueblo, New Mexico). Marmon’s parents had been educated at Carlisle, but for his education, they looked west to Sherman. There was rising awareness that Sherman was more than the last Indian school. It also gave life to a larger pan-Indian institution – a transportation network that stretched common-ground accommodations from coast to coast. It started with Joe Scholder’s marriage to a Carlisle graduate. The Scholders would make their lifelong home in Riverside. Sylvas Lubo (Cahuilla), another early Sherman baseball star and career staffer, also married a Carlisle grad. So the ripples spread: Friends connected, there were marriages, families were begun. Carlisle sent out questionnaires to keep track of alumni, networking followed: jobs were sought and found, educational opportunities multiplied, students and alumni moved back and forth along this secure cultural line.</p>
<p class="body">Sports recruiting followed, too, though 1909 also delivered an ominous sign: This was the year Carlisle’s Jim Thorpe was paid to play baseball for the Class-D Rocky Mount Railroaders. Carlisle actually eliminated its own baseball program in 1910. (Too many Carlisle ballplayers were being lured off to play for pay.)<a id="calibre_link-3399" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3361">22</a> Thorpe was famously awarded his Olympic medals in 1912 and stripped of them in 1913. But traffic along the continental Native American highway was established. By 1918, a Seneca athlete from Oklahoma named Bert Jamison had become a multisport star at Haskell, in Kansas, had married a Sherman grad, and had come west to coach at a smaller Arizona Indian school. He was “discovered” there and came to the Pacific Coast League Los Angeles Angels spring camp as a pitching prospect. He was the last man cut, but things worked out. He took a long-term Sherman coaching job.<a id="calibre_link-3400" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3362">23</a> And that was the year they closed Carlisle. By then, Carlisle had carried many former Sherman students on its rolls, including 75 from Southern California Mission tribes alone. But now, like Kenny Marmon, students sought other options up and down the line.<a id="calibre_link-3401" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3363">24</a></p>
<p class="body">The year of 1913 would be long remembered by baseball fans in Riverside. On March 25 the Chicago White Sox came to town to play a spring-training game against Sherman. This was the A team: Big Ed Walsh, Ray Schalk, Buck Weaver, Shano Collins, Joe Benz, and Harry Lord. The result was a real old-time baseball carnival. Town leaders hosted a ceremonial luncheon at the Mission Inn Hotel. Some of the White Sox got to teasing pitcher Joe Benz about something and he took umbrage and stalked out. Later, nobody wanted to take batting practice when Benz was throwing. But the giddy festivities were unaffected. The Sherman band marched and played at the head of an auto parade to the city park; downtown merchants all closed at noon and 3,000 fans filled seats and standing room while 280 Sherman students were infectiously noisy in reserved seating. The White Sox won 14-3. They scored five while Sherman’s players were still awestruck. With one out in the top of the first, there was a walk and a balk and a hit and Harry Lord came rounding third. But the throw to the plate beat him easily. He stopped and strolled up to the catcher, then suddenly sprang past him and scored. Later in the game, when Buck Weaver got a sharp grounder with nobody on, he sent it around the horn anyway, Weaver to Morrie Rath to Babe Borton at first. But the excitement was undiminished. Sherman’s players would remember it as the day they got to face Ed Walsh (he worked three innings, no hits), and Sherman did have its moments. Kenny Marmon, playing second this day, had two hits and stole two bases (here imagine Ray Schalk fuming); Saturnino Calac (Luiseño, Rincon) played airtight shortstop and had a booming triple. From the locals’ perspective, it was My Greatest Day in Baseball.<a id="calibre_link-3402" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3364">25</a></p>
<p class="body">In 1914 Emil Benson (Mono) emerged as both a notable student and arguably the finest pitcher to come out of Sherman in this Golden Era. This year, he threw a 13-strikeout no-hitter against the University of Redlands.<a id="calibre_link-3403" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3365">26</a> He also edited the <em>Sherman Bulletin</em>, participated in the literary society, and was the only male in the small graduating class of ’14. He next pitched for Riverside High School. In the spring of 1917, when America entered World War I, Benson dropped out of school and enlisted in the US Army.<a id="calibre_link-3404" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3366">27</a> Almost overnight, on a broad coastal plain north of San Diego, the Army built Camp Kearny for the urgent processing of Doughboys. The parade ground was laid out with space for 43 baseball diamonds. On October 30, 1917, Emil Benson made himself a star, pitching and winning both games of a doubleheader.<a id="calibre_link-3405" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3367">28</a> In mid-1918 he was sent to France. In April 1919 he came back a sergeant, mustered out in San Diego and went directly to Sherman. That weekend Sherman happened to have a home baseball game with the University of Redlands. The <em>Sherman Bulletin</em> reported, “Emil Benson, a former student who has just returned from France, was here, and helped win the game.” Benson struck out seven in relief and Sherman collected a walk-off win, 8-7.<a id="calibre_link-3406" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3368">29</a> Benson shortly took a staff position at Sherman. It was the beginning of a long career in the Bureau of Indian Affairs that would take him and his wife (a former Sherman staffer) to Keams Canyon Indian School in remote Hopi country east of the Grand Canyon. In 1934 (at age 39) Benson played shortstop and batted cleanup for a Keams Canyon team that went 19-2 and finished third in the Northern Arizona baseball tournament. The team was notable, the papers said, because the players all had been educated at Indian schools, including Sherman and Haskell.<a id="calibre_link-3407" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3369">30</a></p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="caption">The postwar career of Wallace Newman (Luiseño, La Jolla) is a useful marker for the eclipse of the Golden Era. Newman entered Sherman in 1913 at age 12. As he grew, he was seen to be an all-sport natural. He graduated from Sherman in 1919, but he continued to reside there while suiting up for Riverside High School and Junior College. The competition complained. So Newman took a two-sport scholarship to USC, starred as a passing quarterback, graduated, and became coach at a suburban LA high school. There he arranged to adopt two Sherman football stars so they could play for his high-school team. Newman’s team went to the state championships, but the competition cried foul again. Which is how Wallace “Chief” Newman wound up coaching at Whittier College from 1929 to 1964, winning 10 conference championships in baseball (and seven in football), and being elected to both the NCAA Coaching and American Indian Athletic Halls of Fame.<a id="calibre_link-3408" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3370">31</a></p>
</div>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Postscript</strong></p>
<p class="body">On May 29, 1919, the <em>Sherman Bulletin</em> published a memorial list of Sherman students who had served and died in World War I. There were 10 names. There would be others. The list included an Olympic-class distance runner and four baseball players.<a id="calibre_link-3409" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3371">32</a> (A University of Arkansas database lists 126 Native American World War I veterans with some connection to Sherman.<a id="calibre_link-3410" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3372">33</a> )</p>
<p class="body">By the 1920s, an alumni-varsity ballgame was a perennial feature of Sherman’s commencement week. In May of 1939, the “Sherman Institute All Stars” defeated the Soboba reservation nine (Luiseño), 10-2, to win the third annual Southwest Indian baseball tournament. The umpires were Jim Thorpe and Jack Meyers. The game was played on the home field at Sherman where Meyers had helped inaugurate baseball nearly four decades earlier.<a id="calibre_link-3411" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3373">34</a></p>
<p class="body">As for Kenny Marmon: At Sherman he won the shortstop job and established himself as a top student. He graduated from Sherman in 1911. In 1912 he helped Riverside High School win a championship and was, emphatically, all-league at shortstop. “There has never been an infielder in the Citrus Belt League who could approach the Indian,” the <em>Riverside Enterprise</em> declared.<a id="calibre_link-3412" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3374">35</a> When World War I began, Marmon was at New Mexico State. He was another who left school, joined the Army, and served in France (as a sergeant).<a id="calibre_link-3413" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3375">36</a> Like Emil Benson, he returned to Sherman, where he taught for a decade before leaving for promotion within the Bureau of Indian Affairs. By 1940 Marmon was one of just six Native American field agents on special assignment with the bureau to help tribes write constitutions, hold elections, and promote economic development. He was superintendent of the Seminole Indian Agency in Florida when he retired in 1958.<a id="calibre_link-3414" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3376">37</a></p>
<p class="body">And so to 2024. Sherman had survived through many iterations. Budgets were chronically tight. Its student population ballooned, then shrank back in the Great Depression. For some years it was a dedicated Navajo institution. Its baseball team remained in small-school competition. In time Sherman won accreditation. It struck a career-pathways partnership with the San Manuel Band of Mission Indians. It persevered.</p>
<p class="body">In June of 2024, US Secretary of the Interior Deb Haaland – the first Native American to attain Cabinet rank and, like Kenny Marmon, a Laguna Pueblo – reflected on the legacies of Native American character in a guest essay for <em>Native News Online</em>. A child of a military family, she remarked on how military service among Indians honored the tradition of defending lands that had been theirs long before the coming of the Mayflower. She recalled a grandfather who “galvanized his peers around pastimes like coaching an all-Indian baseball team, which he led to the state championship.”<a id="calibre_link-3415" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3377">38</a></p>
<p class="body">And on a sunny spring day in 2024, longtime coach Matt Townsend brought the Sherman Braves out for another home opener on the Sherman diamond. While ball fields may have shifted around the grounds across the decades, tradition was still at work here. On a part of this same spreading acreage where Jack Meyers and Joe Scholder and Ben Neafus played the first Sherman ballgame 121 years before, Sherman’s students were still playing baseball. Still celebrating their own Native American pastime.</p>
<p><em><strong>TOM WILLMAN</strong>, a Southern California native, spent 35 years writing for newspapers, including two decades of editorial page work. His earliest ballpark souvenirs (with memories attached) are the last yearbook of the Pacific Coast League Angels and the first yearbook of the Los Angeles Dodgers. He first joined SABR in 1986 and has been an occasional contributor to its products.</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Acknowledgments</strong></p>
<p class="sources">I wish to thank to Lorene Sisquoc, curator of the Sherman Indian Museum, for her indispensable hospitality, guidance, and assistance to this project. As usual. The museum invites research inquiries. For more information, see <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.facebook.com/shermanindianmuseum">https://www.facebook.com/shermanindianmuseum</a>.</p>
<p class="sources">A growing archive of Sherman images and documents is now available on the web, through a partnership with the library of the University of California, Riverside. Visit <a class="calibre2" href="http://Calisphere.org">Calisphere.org</a> at <a class="calibre2" href="https://calisphere.org/collections/27124/?start=912&amp;q=&amp;sort=a">https://calisphere.org/collections/27124/?start=912&amp;q=&amp;sort=a</a>.</p>
<p class="sources">Thanks for all assistance, as well, to Richard Tritt, archives and library photograph curator of the Cumberland County (Pennsylvania) Historical Society. Among other collections, the Historical Society is the keeper of the rich historical archive and image collection of Carlisle Indian Industrial School.</p>
<p class="sources">For information on other boarding schools in the national chain, see <a class="calibre2" href="https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/teach/locations-reservation-indian-boarding-schools-us">https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/teach/locations-reservation-indian-boarding-schools-us</a>.</p>
<p class="sources">To access teaching and research guides on the history of Indian education, with links to the National Archives and Library of Congress, see <a class="calibre2" href="https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/teaching">https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/teaching</a>.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Notes</strong></p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3340" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3378">1</a></span> Haskell’s original title was the United States Indian Industrial Training School.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3341" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3379">2</a></span> “Indians Defeated in a Good Game of Baseball,” <span class="italic">Riverside</span> (California) <span class="italic">Daily Press</span>, February 23, 1903.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3342" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3380">3</a></span> “The Perris Indian Boys Downed Berdoo,” <span class="italic">Riverside Enterprise</span>, October 28, 1900.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3343" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3381">4</a></span> “Ambitious Red Men: Indians Start Their Football Campaign With High Hopes,” <span class="italic">Philadelphia Inquirer,</span> September 10, 1899.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3344" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3382">5</a></span> “Indians on the Warpath,” <em>Los Angeles Times</em>, November 9, 1902.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3345" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3383">6</a></span> “Indians Defeated in a Good Game of Baseball.”</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3346" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3384">7</a></span> “Neafus Will Twirl,” <span class="italic">San Bernardino Sun</span>, June 7, 1903; “Foul Tips,” <span class="italic">San Bernardino County Sun</span>, July 17, 1903.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3347" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3385">8</a></span> “Analysis of Sherman Team,” <span class="italic">Riverside Press and Horticulturalist</span>, December 2, 1904.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3348" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3386">9</a></span> Estimates vary. Contemporary ethnographer C. Hart Merriam thought low ebb was closer to 15,500. See “Nation to Nation: Treaties Between the United States and American Indian Nations,” exhibit at the National Museum of the American Indian, Washington, DC. See <a class="calibre2" href="https://americanindian.si.edu/explore/exhibitions/washington">https://americanindian.si.edu/explore/exhibitions/washington</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3349" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3387">10</a></span> Phil Brigandi, “In the Name of the Law: The Cupeño Removal of 1903,” <span class="italic">Journal of San Diego History,</span> San Diego History Center Quarterly. Winter 2018, Volume 64, Number 1. Accessed at <a class="calibre2" href="https://sandiegohistory.org/journal/2018/august/in-the-name-of-the-law-the-cupeno-removal-of-1903/">https://sandiegohistory.org/journal/2018/august/in-the-name-of-the-law-the-cupeno-removal-of-1903/</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3350" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3388">11</a></span> “Jap Team Scalps Sherman Braves,” <span class="italic">Los Angeles Herald,</span> May 21, 1905.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3351" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3389">12</a></span> “Sioux and Locals Break Even at Ball,” <span class="italic">Riverside Enterprise</span>, July 28, 1905.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3352" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3390">13</a></span> “Sioux and Locals Break Even at Ball.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3353" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3391">14</a></span> “Berry’s New Indian Pitcher Is Making Good with the Angels,” <em>Los Angeles Times</em>, March 9, 1911.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3354" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3392">15</a></span> “At the Training Camps,” <em>Los Angeles Times</em>, March 16, 1918.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3355" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3393">16</a></span> On August 4, 2023, Interior Secretary Deb Haaland took daylong testimony at Sherman as part of her “Road to Healing” Tour of Indian schools. The day’s full transcript is accessible at <a class="calibre2" href="http://www.doi.gov/sites/default/files/rth-ca-sherman-indian-high-school-transcript.pdf">www.doi.gov/sites/default/files/rth-ca-sherman-indian-high-school-transcript.pdf</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3356" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3394">17</a></span> Diana Meyers Bahr, <span class="italic">The Students of Sherman Indian School: Education and Native Identity Since 1892</span> (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2014), 7.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3357" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3395">18</a></span> Bahr, 61.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3358" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3396">19</a></span> For shinney, imagine field hockey as it might have been approximated by joyful children at recess, or in a twin-ball variant, played more like lacrosse by women’s teams. “Games Bring Us Together,” 2024 exhibit, the National Museum of the American Indian, Washington, DC. Also 2024, Sherman Cultural Director Lorene Sisquoc included shinney instruction and play in “Native Toys &amp; Games” summer workshops at the school. She first introduced the sport at Sherman in 1995, in competitive play with area reservations. Accessed at <a class="calibre2" href="http://www.shermanindianmuseum.org">www.shermanindianmuseum.org</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3359" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3397">20</a></span> John Bloom, <span class="italic">To Show What an Indian Can Do: Sport at Native American Boarding Schools</span> (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2000), 64. Phrase turned by an unidentified Navajo boxer of the 1930s.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3360" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3398">21</a></span> “The Subtle Evolution of Native American Education,” <a class="calibre2" href="http://www.shermanindianmuseum.org">www.shermanindianmuseum.org</a>; Thomas D. Snyder, ed., <span class="italic">120 Years of American Education: A Statistical Portrait</span> (National Center for Education Statistics, 1993), table 19, 55.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3361" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3399">22</a></span> “Baseball Teams at the Carlisle Indian School,” <span class="italic">Smithsonian Collections Blog,</span> July 12, 2010. Accessed at <a class="calibre2" href="https://si-siris.blogspot.com/2010/07/baseball-teams-at-carlisle-indian.html">https://si-siris.blogspot.com/2010/07/baseball-teams-at-carlisle-indian.html</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3362" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3400">23</a></span> “Tigers Brace Up and Win,” <em>Los Angeles Times</em>, March 29, 1918; Sherman Institute column, <span class="italic">Riverside Daily Press</span>, March 26, 1928.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3363" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3401">24</a></span> “Records of the Carlisle Indian School at the National Archives and Records Administration,” Carlisle Indian School Digital Resource Center, Archives &amp; Special Collections, Waidner-Spahr Library, Dickinson College, Carlisle, Pennsylvania. Accessed online at <a class="calibre2" href="https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/additional-resources/records-carlisle-indian-school-national-archives-and-records-administration">https://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/additional-resources/records-carlisle-indian-school-national-archives-and-records-administration</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3364" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3402">25</a></span> “White Sox Defeat Red Skins 14 to 3,” <span class="italic">Chicago Inter Ocean</span>, March 26, 1913: 10; “Play Y.M.C.A. Benefit Ball Game: The Largest Crowd in the History of Riverside’s Big Ball Park See the Chicago White Sox Defeat Sherman,” <span class="italic">Sherman Bulletin</span>, March 26, 1913: 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3365" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3403">26</a></span> “Riverside Wins in Three Games,” <span class="italic">Riverside Enterprise</span>, March 16, 1914.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3366" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3404">27</a></span> “Sherman Institute Notes,” <span class="italic">Riverside Daily Press</span>, May 16, 1917: 14.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3367" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3405">28</a></span> “Indian Benson Mainstay in Box,” <span class="italic">San Diego Union</span>, October 31, 1917: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3368" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3406">29</a></span> “Sherman Wins from Redlands,” <span class="italic">Sherman Bulletin</span>, April 24, 1919: 2.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3369" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3407">30</a></span> “Twenty-Eight Entered in State Tournament,” <span class="italic">Arizona Republic</span> (Phoenix), July 26, 1934: 8.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3370" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3408">31</a></span> John S. Dahlem, PhD, “History of the California Interscholastic Federation Southern Section (CIFSS): Sherman Indian High School.” <a class="calibre2" href="https://cifss.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/CIFSS-History-31-Sherman-Indian-School.pdf">https://cifss.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/CIFSS-History-31-Sherman-Indian-School.pdf</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3371" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3409">32</a></span> “In Memoriam,” <span class="italic">Sherman Bulletin</span>, May 29, 1919: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3372" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3410">33</a></span> “Modern Warriors of World War I,” Sequoyah National Research Center (Little Rock: University of Arkansas, 2008). Database identifying 12,000 American Indian and Alaska Native veterans of World War I. Searchable at <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.worldwar1centennial.org/index.php/american-indians-in-ww1-modern-warriors-of-world-war-i/5565-american-indians-wwi-servicement.html">https://www.worldwar1centennial.org/index.php/american-indians-in-ww1-modern-warriors-of-world-war-i/5565-american-indians-wwi-servicement.html</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3373" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3411">34</a></span> “Soboba Nine Drops Titular Game to Sherman All-Stars,” <span class="italic">Hemet</span> (California) <span class="italic">News</span>, May 26, 1939: 12.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3374" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3412">35</a></span> “All Star Team of Citrus Belt Picked,” <span class="italic">Riverside Enterprise</span>, June 7, 1912: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3375" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3413">36</a></span> US World War One Centennial Commission, database.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3376" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3414">37</a></span> “Harrington to Take Over as Seminole Agency Superintendent,” press release, May 6, 1958, US Department of the Interior, Indian Affairs. <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/photograph-of-kenneth-marmon-who-was-a-pueblo-indian-and-bureau-of-indian-affairs-field-agent">https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/photograph-of-kenneth-marmon-who-was-a-pueblo-indian-and-bureau-of-indian-affairs-field-agent</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3377" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3415">38</a></span> “Interior Secretary Deb Haaland: Native Americans Have Always Been Citizens,” <span class="italic">Native News Online</span>, June 2, 2024. <a class="calibre2" href="https://nativenewsonline.net/opinion/interior-secretary-deb-haaland-deb-haaland-native-americans-have-always-been-citizens">https://nativenewsonline.net/opinion/interior-secretary-deb-haaland-deb-haaland-native-americans-have-always-been-citizens</a>.</p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>American Indian Barnstorming Teams</title>
		<link>https://sabr.org/journal/article/american-indian-barnstorming-teams/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[wpadmin]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 07:15:38 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://sabr.org/?post_type=journal_articles&#038;p=325908</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Phoenix Indian School Baseball Team c. 1910. (Author’s collection) &#160; To understand why America’s first peoples joined exhibition baseball teams that toured the country from the 1890s through the 1930s, it helps to review the US government’s boarding schools for native children. The stories of these exhibition teams and the federal boarding schools are closely [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="calibre_link-98" class="calibre1">
<p class="section"><img decoding="async" class="w" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000061.jpg" alt="" /></p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="caption"><em>Phoenix Indian School Baseball Team c. 1910. (Author’s collection)</em></p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="first-paragraph">To understand why America’s first peoples joined exhibition baseball teams that toured the country from the 1890s through the 1930s, it helps to review the US government’s boarding schools for native children. The stories of these exhibition teams and the federal boarding schools are closely intertwined. The boarding schools offered baseball, among other sports, as a means of assimilating native children into American culture.</p>
<p class="body">The so-called Progressive era of American history continued the federal government’s legacy of violence against native peoples. This violent legacy, recognized by generations of scholars, has been documented officially now through the Federal Indian Boarding Schools Initiative, commissioned by former Interior Secretary Deb Haaland and conducted by Assistant Secretary for Indian Affairs Bryan Newland.<a id="calibre_link-3468" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3418">1</a> Newland’s study cited extensively the US Senate’s subcommittee report on Indian Education in 1969, known as the Kennedy report, which stated: “Beginning with President Washington, the stated policy of the Federal Government was to replace the Indian’s culture with our own.”<a id="calibre_link-3469" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3419">2</a> That forced separation of American Indians from their lands, families, languages, and cultures and forced assimilation into Anglo culture was the goal of the government from the founding, but it was implemented systematically starting in 1878 with the federal boarding school system. In 1879, Army Captain Richard Henry Pratt founded Carlisle Indian Industrial, the first such federal residential boarding school, in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, with his often-quoted slogan, “Kill the Indian in him, and save the man.”<a id="calibre_link-3470" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3420">3</a> The first native inhabitants of the school were principally Chiricahua Apache children, whose parents were imprisoned after the surrender of <em>Goyaalé</em> (Geronimo), although Pratt’s boarding school soon took on hundreds of children forcibly separated from their families from many native nations. At least in Pratt’s eyes, Carlisle became the Bureau of Indian Affairs model for more federal boarding schools that removed children from their families as well as from their indigenous languages and cultures.<a id="calibre_link-3471" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3421">4</a></p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="caption">The boarding school system was promoted by Pratt and others as an exemplary solution of “the Indian problem,” and athletics were one featured component of the program. As Bentley, Bloom, and other scholars have noted, the success of Carlisle Indian Industrial School athletes on sports fields, especially celebrity athletes like <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/jim-thorpe/">Jim Thorpe</a>, hid the violence of the system.<a id="calibre_link-3472" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3422">5</a> In her biography of Thorpe, Kate Buford likewise explains how native scholars describe the cultural destruction of the boarding schools as a “soul wound.”<a id="calibre_link-3473" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3423">6</a> While Pratt and fellow superintendents trumpeted the athletic successes of Thorpe and his native classmates as epitomes of assimilation, the true stories of these athletes merit telling, starting with the traumas. Stripping Thorpe of his Olympic medals is only the most memorable trauma.<a id="calibre_link-3474" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3424">7</a> On September 25, 2024, at Gila River Indian Community in Chandler, Arizona, President Joseph Biden formally apologized to generations of American Indians for the federal boarding school system, calling it “a sin on our souls.”<a id="calibre_link-3475" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3425">8</a></p>
</div>
<p class="body">As detailed in <em><span class="italic">The American Indian Integration of Baseball</span></em> and as this volume makes clear, native athletes were successful as major-league, minor-league, semipro, and college players, starting with baseball games on federal boarding school fields. The semiprofessional part of the story connects the trauma of the boarding schools with other exploitation of native athletes especially on native barnstorming or exhibition teams. The most famous of these teams, the Nebraska Indians, was inspired by the popularity of the Genoa (Nebraska) Indian Industrial School’s baseball team.<a id="calibre_link-3476" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3426">9</a> Guy W. Green, as the manager of the Stromberg baseball team in 1895, witnessed the crowds that the Genoa team drew, and like other Progressive era entrepreneurs, he was eager to exploit the spectacle of native athletes. Green wrote, “When I counted my money after that game [Stromberg vs. Genoa Indian School], the idea of the Nebraska Indians was born.”<a id="calibre_link-3477" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3427">10</a> He reasoned, “If an Indian base ball team was a good drawing card in Nebraska, it ought to do wonders further east if properly managed. I accordingly determined to organize ‘The Nebraska Indians.”<a id="calibre_link-3478" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3428">11</a></p>
<p class="body">The Nebraska Indians, which began touring in 1897 and continued, with an ownership change, into the 1920s, were not the first or last such team – in fact, their success led to many imitations. Because Green wrote two short books about the team and because it was often featured in newspaper stories, features, and postcards, it was certainly one of the best-documented such teams. And almost all these teams depended on federal boarding schools and local reservation schools for recruiting athletes. In their heyday, these exhibition teams played across the United States and Canada, and they featured talented native athletes who later signed minor-league and major-league contracts. These teams included Green’s Nebraska Indians (c. 1897-1912), James and Oren Beltzer’s Nebraska Indians (1912-1918), the Nebraska Indians of the 1920s (c. 1921-1928), Harry Homewood’s Sioux Indians Baseball Team (c. 1896-1906), John Olson’s Cherokee All Stars of Watervliet Michigan (c. 1904-1912), Gus Whitewing’s “All-Indian Baseball Team” (c. 1907), the Oxford (Nebraska), Indians (c. 1910), the Indian Ball Team of Bradley, Michigan (c. 1910), the All-Indian Baseball Team of Guthrie (Oklahoma, c. 1912), Kate J. Becker’s Carlisle Indian Baseball Club, not affiliated with the boarding school (1916), the Mayetta (Kansas) Indian Baseball Team (c. 1925), Moses Poolaw’s Indian Baseball Team (c. 1933), the Dakota Eagles of Flandreau (South Dakota, c. 1933), and Ben Harjo’s Oklahoma Indians or All-Indian Baseball Club (1932-1933), which included Jim Thorpe in 1933. Some of these teams played only for a partial season, but the longest tenured teams, the Nebraska Indians, the Sioux Indian Baseball Team, and Cherokee All-Stars, drew large crowds across the country for years.<a id="calibre_link-3479" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3429">12</a></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
</div>
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000060.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Green&#8217;s Indian Baseball Team, 1898. (Author’s collection)</em></p>
<div id="calibre_link-98" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body">In many ways, the native barnstorming teams, like the Wild West shows of the era, thrived on popular fascination with and exploitation of native stereotypes. This fact is clear in Green’s account of the formation of the team as well as in photos and postcards of the team as well as the illustrations of Green’s books. His <em>The Nebraska Indians: A Complete History</em> and <em>Fun and Frolic with an Indian Ball Team</em> were illustrated with grotesque cartoons of the native players in headdresses and loincloths lofting bats like spears. Ensuing illustrations show native figures in leather riding horses, pointing long rifles, and performing carnival tricks.<a id="calibre_link-3480" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3430">13</a> Similarly, press coverage of the games in many local newspapers usually included frequent mentions of “red men,” “Poor Lo,” “redskins,” “braves,” scalps and scalping, tomahawks, bows and arrows, braves, blows, bloodshed, and war chants – the sensational imagery of Western novels and Wild West shows. Baseball team owners like Guy Green and Harry Homewood trucked in these stereotypes to sell tickets, and obliging local newspapers promoted the games with all the grotesqueries.</p>
<p class="body">Green’s anecdotes of his players are replete with Western stereotypes. One clear example is his portrait of Juzicanea, a Pascua Yaqui man, apparently from Arizona. Green wrote:</p>
<blockquote>
<p class="body">In all my experience, I have had but one Yaqui ball player. The Yaquis are a savage tribe living in the extreme southwestern part of the United States, and I hesitated a long time before I added Juzicanea to my team. He was the meanest looking Indian I have ever seen. He wore his hair long, surveying everything suspiciously with piercing black eyes, and when he came down the street people moved to the edge of the sidewalk and apprehensively watched him pass. Juzicanea would not sleep in a bed. He could rest comfortably on the floor or the ground. …</p>
<p class="body">Another of Juzicanea’s peculiarities was his craving for raw meat; he demanded one to two pounds of this delicacy each day, and unless he obtained it, he was surly as a caged tiger. I used to fill my pockets with raw meat when we went out to the grounds, and after Juzicanea made a particularly brilliant catch or a long hit, I fed him a liberal chunk of the succulent delicacy, which invariably caused him intense delight and greatly amused the natives who watched him perform. I was compelled to line my pockets [with] oilcloth in order to provide suitable receptacles for Juzicanea’s gory lunches. &#8230;</p>
<p class="body">At Burlington, Kentucky … the savage tossed his tangled hair out of his eyes, growled ominously, and in broken English cried, “Bring me a pound of raw meat.”<a id="calibre_link-3481" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3431">14</a></p>
</blockquote>
<p class="body">Here, Juzicanea’s long hair and “broken English” are associated with his character as a “savage,” his lunches are “gory,” and he is described as a “caged tiger” and is fed treats like an animal, inspiring both popular fear and fascination. That combination of native stereotypes and intense emotions was gist for the coverage of the Nebraska Indians, Sioux Indians, Cherokee All-Stars, and other exhibition teams of the era.</p>
<p class="body">Guy Wilder Green (1873-1947) was the founder and most successful owner of the Nebraska Indians, although later owners included James Beltzer, Oren “Buck” Beltzer (James‘s brother and a Nebraska Cornhusker legend), Pat Kelsey, and Ed Hamman.<a id="calibre_link-3482" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3432">15</a> As the most successful promoter of the team, Green also provided the most extensive documentation of American Indian exhibition teams in his two books and many newspaper interviews from 1897 to 1912, when he sold the team to the Beltzer brothers. In the team’s first season, 1897, the season was short, the team was ill equipped to succeed, and the travelling arrangements were rugged at best. In “Experiences with an Indian Ball Team,” a feature that Green wrote for the <em>Nebraska State Journal</em> in 1908, he recalled:</p>
<blockquote>
<p class="body">We took to the rocky trails of public amusement in wagons. I had two lumber trucks, six horses, a bale of hay and a dog as my traveling outfit. Four of the horses were hitched side-by-side to one wagon.<a id="calibre_link-3483" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3433">16</a></p>
</blockquote>
<p class="body">In its first season, the team was hastily recruited from Genoa Indian School, the Winnebago reservation in Nebraska, and Sioux reservations in South Dakota, and Green recalled that the team lost its first game against the town baseball team in Wahoo, Nebraska, in late June by a score of 10-5. He noted: “Our disastrous experience at Wahoo is easily explained. Most of my players had come directly from their reservations to the place of opening. They were stiff from travel, were out of condition and lacking in practice. I was surprised to see them make as good a showing as they did.”<a id="calibre_link-3484" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3434">17</a> And the going did not get easier in 1897 for the first team, as the team travelled and slept in wagons, as they ventured from town to town in Nebraska and Iowa, and as Green sent letters and telegrams to arrange games and drum up crowds. Green reflected that the first season “was only moderately successful whether surveyed from an artistic or from a financial standpoint,” as the team disbanded on August 14, having won 21 games and lost 28. He observed that “[t]he boys were literally worn out” by the travel conditions.<a id="calibre_link-3485" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3435">18</a></p>
<p class="body">Starting in 1898, Green made several changes that contributed to greater success for the team. First, he abandoned the horse-and-wagon travel and began taking the team by train from town to town, followed by a livery wagon. That season the team also brought tents, to sleep on baseball fields at night. Green also worked relentlessly to recruit more players and to promote the team with photos, postcards, and the team’s frequent monikers, “Green’s Nebraska Indians: Greatest Aggregation of Its Kind,” and “Green’s Nebraska Indians: Only Ones on Earth” The team’s season expanded to four states (Nebraska, Iowa, Missouri, and Illinois), and its record improved markedly to 81-22.<a id="calibre_link-3486" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3436">19</a> Green remarked that “the Indians were nervous and ill-at-ease while cooped up in hotels. But the minute they were furnished with tents they felt at home and gave me their best efforts.”<a id="calibre_link-3487" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3437">20</a> The tent dwelling was also characterized by local press according to the stereotypes. <em>The Headlight</em> (Stromsburg, Nebraska) commented: “They camp right on the grounds where they play and live in true savage style.”<a id="calibre_link-3488" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3438">21</a></p>
<p class="body">In fact, ironically, while the native barnstorming businesses thrived on the use of anti-Indian stereotypes, Green also expressed considerable sympathy for the mistreatment his players suffered. This mistreatment included his players being barred from hotels, accused by local citizens of crimes, ridden by local constables and shopkeepers, and constantly mocked by crowds. Some typical allegations leveled against players included fraternization with White women, thefts of clothes, food, watches, and baseball equipment, and accounts of a holdup and even a kidnapping.<a id="calibre_link-3489" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3439">22</a> While Green defended his players against such bogus charges, he also expressed a weary acquaintance with the rough treatment: “Strangers are always safe objects of suspicion.”<a id="calibre_link-3490" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3440">23</a></p>
<p class="body">The raucous crowds that hooted at players were a constant fixture of the games played by the Nebraska Indians, Cherokee All-Stars, and other exhibition teams of their time. In an interview with the <em>Sioux City Journal</em> in 1909, Green described the typical treatment endured by his Winnebago (Ho-Chunk) pitcher <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/george-johnson/">George Howard Johnson</a> (who would later pitch in the major leagues). Green stated:</p>
<blockquote>
<p class="body">He has never stepped to the mound to pitch a game anywhere on earth that three things have not happened. Numerous local humorists have started what they imagine to be Indian war cries, others have yelled ‘Back to the reservation,’ and a third variety of town pump jester has shrieked, ‘Dog soup! Dog soup!<a id="calibre_link-3491" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3441">24</a></p>
</blockquote>
<p class="body">Of course, Green’s three examples were not the only barbs and epithets hurled at the native players. They were also typically called “Chief (Johnson was one of many in the major and minor leagues), “Heap Big-Injun,” “Poor Lo,” “Redskin,” “Savage,” and so on.<a id="calibre_link-3492" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3442">25</a></p>
<p class="body">In keeping with the practices of owners of native exhibition teams, Green often recruited players from the leading federal boarding schools, Carlisle and Haskell, as well as smaller schools nearby such as Genoa. Some of his boarding-school recruits included Jean Baptiste, a Winnebago from Nebraska, who pitched for Carlisle in 1891-92; Jacob Buckheart (or Buckhardt), a powerful Shawnee from Oklahoma, who caught for both Carlisle and the Nebraska Indians; George Green, a Sac and Fox pitcher and speedy infielder for Carlisle, who also pitched for the Nebraska Indians; George Howard Johnson, the talented Winnebago pitcher from Walthill, Nebraska, who briefly attended Carlisle, Haskell, and Flandreau, before starring as a pitcher with the Nebraska Indians; Walter Nevitt, a Delaware who pitched at Haskell before joining Green’s team as a third baseman; Thomas Reed, an Ojibwe, who played second base at Haskell before joining the Nebraska Indians as an infielder; White Boy, a Winnebago of Nebraska, who pitched for Genoa before joining Green’s team; and Jessee Youngdeer, an Eastern Cherokee, who played center field for Carlisle before joining Green’s team for its 1911 season.<a id="calibre_link-3493" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3443">26</a> This preference of the exhibition team owners for boarding-school players was practical, as these talented athletes had been trained by experienced coaches and tested against college-level competition. However, it was also in keeping with the Progressive era agenda of assimilating native youth into American culture.</p>
<p class="body">While Green’s preference for boarding-school athletes was clear, the most emphatic champion of the assimilationist model was Harry Homewood, owner and manager of the Sioux Indian Baseball Team, which toured the United States and Canada from 1896 to 1906. A feature story on the team appeared in the <em>Marysville Daily Appeal</em> in 1905, when the team was touring California, and it specified Homewood’s enthusiasm for the assimilation of indigenous youth. The terms used in the feature are strikingly like the vision of Carlisle Superintendent Pratt. According to M.T. Clark, a contracting agent for the team interviewed for the article:</p>
<blockquote>
<p class="body">To educate the Indian in the ways of civilized life, therefore, is to preserve him from extinction, not as an Indian, but as a human being.</p>
<p class="body">Mr. Homewood says there seems to be only two phases of the Indian question. One, that the American Indian should remain in the country as a survival of the aboriginal inhabitants, a study for the ethnologist, a toy for the tourist, a vagrant at the mercy of the State, and a continual pensioner upon the bounty of the people, the other that he shall be educated to work, live, and act as a reputable, moral citizen, and thus become a self-supporting member of society.</p>
<p class="body">The latter is the policy of the management of the Sioux Indian baseball club, and if it would be followed out by those in direct charge of the Indians, he will then pass out of our national life as a painted, feather-crowned hero of the novelist to add the current of his free American blood to the hearts of this great nation.</p>
<p class="body">Manager Homewood will not allow any Indian literature on the sleeper in which they travel, and each week gives a prize to the Indian writing the best article on What I would do if I were President and other subjects which will have a tendency to educate and elevate the Indian.<a id="calibre_link-3494" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3444">27</a></p>
</blockquote>
<p class="body">This emphasis on eliminating native culture to “educate and elevate the Indian” could have been written by Pratt himself. The essays that Homewood asked his players to write were like Carlisle and Haskell lessons, and the forbidding of native languages and cultures (“any Indian literature”) were standard practices at the boarding schools.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000062.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Olson&#8217;s Cherokee Baseball Team c. 1905 (Author’s collection)</em></p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body">Homewood’s Sioux Indian Baseball Team included some Sioux players, but was constituted of players from many indigenous nations, and was well-funded, traveling by train across the US and Canada. The team boasted a roster of 17 players from 1904 to 1906, two Pullman cars with showers, and extensive equipment. Like the Nebraska Indians, they maintained team records and boasted a record of 1,263 wins vs. 304 losses (an astounding .810 winning percentage) from 1898 to 1905.<a id="calibre_link-3495" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3445">28</a> To draw larger crowds, the team was an early innovator of night baseball games. Accounts of the Sioux Indians team noted that they played day games and night games differently, with the team often erecting a large canvas circus tent along with a portable grandstand for the night games. The team carried its own electric generator, which powered a circuit of incandescent bulbs at the top of the tent, and players used a larger, softer ball (more like a modern softball) and narrower bats for the evening games. The double novelties of native players and night games proved popular with the crowds. The night games also made for frequent newspaper accounts, and the native players’ familiarity with baseball in semi-darkness also provided them with a competitive advantage. A few quotations from the press accounts in 1905 and 1906, intended to draw interested spectators to the games, suffice to explain the novelty:</p>
<blockquote>
<p class="body">In a novel, exciting, and interesting baseball game here by electric light at night the Exeter Clippers defeated the Sioux Indians. This was the first game ever played here at night. It was enjoyed by a large crowd.<a id="calibre_link-3496" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3446">29</a></p>
<p class="body">This will be a baseball game at night. The game will be played with a team of Sioux Indians who are touring the state. They carry a generator and all the paraphernalia for lighting up the grounds as light as day and from papers where the Indians have played it describes the bleachers as being in twilight while the grounds are illumined with 50,000 candle power arc lights.<a id="calibre_link-3497" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3447">30</a></p>
<p class="body">The ball used at night is about twice the size of the regular baseball. It is soft and bouncy, and it sounds like a pumpkin when it hits the bat. The bat is as small as the ball is large, and this combination prevents the ball being batted too far beyond the circle of electric lights. The electric lights look like a lot of railroad lanterns, and they hang so low that if the ball is thrown or batted very high it is very difficult to see it.<a id="calibre_link-3498" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3448">31</a></p>
</blockquote>
<p class="body">While the idea of night baseball came soon after Thomas Edison’s invention of the lightbulb in 1880, the attempts in the nineteenth century were few and halting.<a id="calibre_link-3499" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3449">32</a> The development of new arc lights early in the twentieth century led entrepreneurs like Homewood to develop the concept, but night baseball as we know it now would wait until the 1920s, when General Electric developed more powerful floodlights, which were adopted first by minor-league teams, before they came to the major leagues on May 24, 1935, at Crosley Field. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt switched on the stadium lights from the White House, affirming the importance of electrification for sports and entertainment in the United States.<a id="calibre_link-3500" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3450">33</a></p>
<p class="body">Although baseball was included in the athletic programs of the federal boarding schools as part of their assimilation efforts, there is another chapter of the story worth telling. The success of native students as athletes in football, track, baseball, and other sports gave opportunities that exceeded the manual and vocational labor available to the students through the boarding schools’ “summer outings.” Those summer outings were manual labor employment (e.g., farm work, ditch digging, lumbering, livestock and dairy work, sewing, carpentry, cooking, etc.) intended to provide vocational training to the students while supporting the boarding schools financially. <em>The Federal Boarding School Initiative Report</em> found that manual child labor was an entrenched feature of the schools, which “[predominantly] utilized manual labor of [the students] to compensate for the poor conditions of school facilities and lack of financial support from the Federal Government.”<a id="calibre_link-3501" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3451">34</a> The talented young athletes at boarding schools, like Jim Thorpe, <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/louis-leroy/">Louis Leroy</a>, <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/charles-bender/">Charles Bender</a>, Joe Libby, Jesse Youngdeer, and George Howard Johnson, found better paying and more enjoyable opportunities playing summer baseball for minor-league and exhibition teams, often playing under pseudonyms. Some of them also, including Thorpe, nursed dreams of major-league careers, and all of them found playing baseball in the summer preferable to the work they would do on summer outing programs.<a id="calibre_link-3502" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3452">35</a> As scholar Wade Davies observed: “Native people gravitated to &#8230; Indian school sports, not only because it allowed them to express their indigenous athleticism, but also because they could exert some personal and collective control over this activity in otherwise authoritarian environments.”<a id="calibre_link-3503" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3453">36</a></p>
<p class="body">Likewise, Alan J. Caldwell, the director of the Menominee Cultural Center in Kenosha, Wisconsin, and the son of James J. Caldwell, who played third base for the Cherokee All-Stars in 1912, described his father’s baseball career with pride. Caldwell wrote about his father’s stint with Olson’s Cherokee All-Stars:</p>
<p class="body">My father was not the type of person to talk much about his past. What little he told us about his baseball playing days was about the part of the country he traveled to such as the southeastern region. He didn’t say anything that I recall about how they were treated or received in the towns that they played in. I think my father played for the pleasure of playing baseball and as a source of income. I think he may have also joined the team as a way to satisfy his sense of adventure. I envied my father. Though he only played semi-pro baseball he was a terrific player based on stories I heard from his peers.<a id="calibre_link-3504" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3454">37</a></p>
<p class="body">Evident in this account and other interviews done with other native players from the 1930s and 1940s was joy in playing baseball and pride in athletic accomplishment. This pride was also expressed by Lumbee athlete and scholar Joseph Oxendine, who wrote in his foreword to <em>The American Indian Integration of Baseball</em>: “Baseball is a noble game, a game of tradition, of allegiance and camaraderie. &#8230; The character of baseball is consistent with traditional American Indian traits and attitudes toward sport. Consequently, young Indians ‘took’ to the game as soon as it was introduced to them in boarding schools.”<a id="calibre_link-3505" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3455">38</a> While Oxendine was under no illusions about the injuries done by federal boarding schools, he also spent a career celebrating the athletic heritage that native players created in the twentieth century.</p>
<p class="body">A related part of this athletic heritage was the teams of native players organized by the players themselves. While relatively few native players had the financial and social support to launch exhibition teams on extended tours, there were certainly native teams that deserve recognition. The most famous Oklahoma example of a native baseball team under native ownership was Ben Harjo’s All-Indian Baseball Club of 1932-1933. Harjo founded the team in Wewoka, Oklahoma, equipped it for long tours and signed some major-league and minor-league players including <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/ike-kahdot/">Ike Kahdot</a>, Bill Wano, <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/art-daney/">Lee Daney,</a> Williston Bohannon, Israel “Izzy” Wilson, <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/ben-tincup/">Ben Tincup</a>, and <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/rip-collins/">Harry “Rip” Collins</a>. The team was financed generously by Ben and his wife, Susey Walker Harjo, who had inherited lucrative Seminole oil fields in Oklahoma. The team had its own customized touring bus, and after tryouts and practice in Holdenville, it began a well-publicized tour in May of 1922 from Oklahoma into Texas and Louisiana.<a id="calibre_link-3506" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3456">39</a></p>
<p class="body">Starting auspiciously, the team achieved its first major victory, a 4-1 win against the Muskogee Tigers of the Western Association, and it continued to win in Texas (playing at Temple, Killeen, Bartlett, Taylor, and Austin) and in Louisiana (Lakes Charles, Deridder, Arcadia).<a id="calibre_link-3507" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3457">40</a> Led by the strong pitching of Collins, by late June the team had recorded 41 wins against only 4 losses and was invited to the <span class="italic">Denver Post</span> Tournament, known by some as the Western World Series.<a id="calibre_link-3508" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3458">41</a> The team continued its torrid pace in Denver. On July 28, the <em>Denver Post</em> reported:</p>
<blockquote><p>With 6,000 palefaces chanting the call to victory, the All-Indians of Holdenville, Oklahoma reached baseball’s happy hunting grounds Wednesday night when they defeated the Sioux Falls Canaries, 6 to 5, in a great 12-inning game to win the championship of the <span class="italic">Denver Post</span> tournament.<a id="calibre_link-3509" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3459">42</a></p>
<p class="body">And with this success at Denver, the All-Indians received a championship check of $4,167. The team would finally disband for 1932 with an impressive record, but a debt of $1,800 from touring. In cases like this, Ben and Susey Harjo depended on the superintendent of the Five Civilized Tribes of Oklahoma (A.J. Landman) to release Susey’s funds to pay the debts.<a id="calibre_link-3510" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3460">43</a></p>
</blockquote>
<p class="body">In 1933 the Harjos’ All-Indians planned a much larger tour, up to 140 games, from Oklahoma through the Midwest to New York City, and they also recruited new players for the team, including <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/earl-huckleberry/">Earl Huckleberry</a>, Rudy Jones, and, most famously, Jim Thorpe. When Thorpe joined the team, Ben Harjo’s announcement of his hiring made newspaper headlines and led to a Jim Thorpe Day celebration and parade in Holdenville on May 11.<a id="calibre_link-3511" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3461">44</a> As in 1932, the team played well against local and Western League competition and determined to find larger crowds and fiercer competition in the East. As they traveled to Kansas City, they faced some of the strongest competition possible against the Kansas City Monarchs. That tough competition would continue as they faced strong teams in Pittsburgh and Philadelphia before reaching New York. Thorpe, who served as a player-manager for much of the season, occasionally played the field and often pinch-hit. A. Grant Carrow, a young fan who watched Thorpe play against the Lowell Lauriers, a Massachusetts minor-league team, admired his “beautifully executed fade-away slide” for a double, accentuated by Thorpe’s wide grin at second base.<a id="calibre_link-3512" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3462">45</a> The <em>Holdenville Daily News</em> reported on September 14 that the team had played 128 games in 15 states, amassing a record of 87-41, with Thorpe leading the team in batting with a .341 average in 93 games.<a id="calibre_link-3513" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3463">46</a> However, by the end of the tough 1933 season, Ben and Susey Harjo were over $6,000 in debt, and Susey requested the agent of the Five Nations to release $10,000 to pay the players and also to pay debts related to the death of the Harjos’ young daughter. The agent refused, leading Thorpe to send a telegram to Bureau of Indian Affairs Commissioner John Collier and a letter to California Senator William Gibbs McAdoo. Susey Harjo was only able to pay Jim Thorpe $500 of the $2,050 owed to him for the 1933 tour, and other players, such as Huckleberry, had to return their uniforms to the Muskogee agent before receiving partial payments. As in so many other cases, despite the athletic prowess on which they prided themselves, native managers and players were at the mercy of a federal system that treated them with condescension.<a id="calibre_link-3514" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3464">47</a></p>
<p class="body">Another outstanding example of a native touring team is Moses Edward (Mose) Poolaw’s All-American Indian Baseball Team of 1933, which toured from Texas into Mexico, from September through December of 1933. Mose Poolaw (whose name also appears as Poolah) was a Kiowa from Mountain View, Oklahoma. He apparently attended Haskell Indian Industrial School and may have played for Beltzer’s Nebraska Indians in 1917 before serving with the US Army in World War I, reaching the rank of sergeant.<a id="calibre_link-3515" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3465">48</a> Soon after his Army service, he joined Chickasha in the Western Association, playing infield. His greatest strength was as a pitcher, and he amassed a record of 60-53 in the Western Association, including a 20-win season in 1924.<a id="calibre_link-3516" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3466">49</a> Poolaw was listed as the manager, pitcher, and booking agent for the All-American Indian Baseball Team, and its itinerary included Houston, Monterey, Laredo, and Mexico City. Other players listed on the team included Tommy Cussens, Spencer Thomas, Woodrow Arketa, and Bill Collins.<a id="calibre_link-3517" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3467">50</a> Most of these players lived in Oklahoma, giving the team a local character, and some press accounts refer to the club as the Harjoche All-American Indian Baseball Team. Perhaps Poolaw saw the team as a fitting sequel to Harjo’s team, given the team’s Southern tour (like Harjo’s in 1932), or perhaps he hoped to capitalize on the excitement recently generated by Harjo’s team.</p>
<p class="body">The story of native baseball players on touring exhibition teams begins with the boarding schools and agency schools that taught baseball as a means of assimilation, a history imbued with trauma. While that trauma persisted in the experiences of native youth from the 1890s through the 1930s, the athletic successes those players enjoyed were savored by them and their communities. For both the record of the trauma the native players endured and the record of athletic triumph they achieved, the stories of these barnstorming teams are worth preserving.</p>
<p><em><strong>JEFFREY P. BECK</strong> is the author of The American Indian Integration of Baseball (University of Nebraska Press) among other works. He currently serves as Director of the School of Humanities at Penn State Harrisburg. He is a member of the Mathewson-Plank chapter of the Society for American Baseball Research. He lives with his wife Marjorie and daughter Maddie in Palmyra, Pennsylvania.</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Notes</strong></p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3418" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3468">1</a></span> Bryan Newland, <span class="italic">Federal Boarding School Initiative Investigative Report</span>, May 2022, volume 1, <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.bia.gov/sites/default/files/dup/inline-files/bsi_investigative_report_may_2022_508.pdf">https://www.bia.gov/sites/default/files/dup/inline-files/bsi_investigative_report_may_2022_508.pdf</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3419" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3469">2</a></span> Committee on Labor and Public Welfare, <span class="italic">Indian Education: A National Tragedy – A National Challenge</span>, United State Senate Report (1969), 143.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3420" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3470">3</a></span> Henry Louis Pratt quoted in Matthew Bentley and John Bloom, <span class="italic">The Imperial Gridiron: Manhood, Civilization, and Football at the Carlisle Indian Industrial School</span> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2022), 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3421" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3471">4</a></span> Jacqueline Fear-Segal and Susan D. Rose, eds., Introduction, <span class="italic">Carlisle Indian Industrial School: Indigenous Histories, Memories, &amp; Reclamations</span> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2016), 2-3.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3422" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3472">5</a></span> Bentley and Bloom, 2.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3423" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3473">6</a></span> Kate Buford, <span class="italic">Native American Son: The Life and Sporting Legend of Jim Thorpe</span> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2010), 41.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3424" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3474">7</a></span> Buford, <span class="italic">Native American Son</span>, 159-168; James Ring Adams, “The Jim Thorpe Backlash: The Olympic Medals Debacle and the Demise of Carlisle,” in <span class="italic">American Indian: The Magazine of Smithsonian’s National Museum of the American Indian</span>, 13.2 (2012). Online. Accessed Dec. 23, 2024. <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.americanindianmagazine.org/story/jim-thorpe-backlash-olympic-medals-debacle-and-demise-carlisle">https://www.americanindianmagazine.org/story/jim-thorpe-backlash-olympic-medals-debacle-and-demise-carlisle</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3425" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3475">8</a></span> Mary Annette Pember, Shondiin Mayo, and Mark Trahant, “Historic Apology: Boarding School History ‘a Sin on Our Souls.’” <span class="italic">ICT News</span>, October 25, 2024. <a class="calibre2" href="https://ictnews.org/news/historic-apology-boarding-school-history-a-sin-on-our-soul">https://ictnews.org/news/historic-apology-boarding-school-history-a-sin-on-our-soul</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3426" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3476">9</a></span> Guy W. Green, <span class="italic">The Nebraska Indians and Fun and Frolic with an Indian Ball Team</span>, ed. Jeffrey P. Beck (Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland &amp; Co., 2010), 9-10.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3427" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3477">10</a></span> Green, “Experiences with an Indian Baseball Team,” <span class="italic">Nebraska State Journal</span>, December 20, 1908: C6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3428" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3478">11</a></span> Green, <span class="italic">The Nebraska In</span><span class="italic">dians</span>, 10.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3429" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3479">12</a></span> Jeffrey P. Beck, aka Jeffrey Powers-Beck, “‘A Role New to the Race,’: A New History of the Nebraska Indians,” <span class="italic">Nebraska History</span> 85 (2004): 186-203, 198; Buford, 283-284.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3430" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3480">13</a></span> Green, <span class="italic">The Nebraska Indians</span>, 9, 10, 33, 53, 66, 118.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3431" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3481">14</a></span> Green, <span class="italic">The Nebraska Indians</span>, 117-118.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3432" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3482">15</a></span> Jeffrey P. Beck, “Introduction,” <span class="italic">The Nebraska Indians</span>, xii, xliii.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3433" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3483">16</a></span> Guy Green, “Experiences with an Indian Baseball Team,” C6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3434" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3484">17</a></span> Green, <span class="italic">The Nebraska Ind</span><span class="italic">ians</span>, 11.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3435" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3485">18</a></span> Green, <span class="italic">The Nebraska In</span><span class="italic">dians</span>, 15.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3436" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3486">19</a></span> Green, <span class="italic">The Nebraska Indi</span><span class="italic">ans</span>, 145.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3437" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3487">20</a></span> Green, <span class="italic">The Nebraska Ind</span><span class="italic">ians</span>, 27.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3438" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3488">21</a></span> “Other Locals,” <span class="italic">Stromsburg</span> (Nebraska) <span class="italic">Headlight</span>, April 25, 1901: 4.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3439" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3489">22</a></span> Beck, “‘A Role New to the Race,’” 193.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3440" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3490">23</a></span> Green, <span class="italic">The Nebraska Indi</span><span class="italic">ans</span>, 115.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3441" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3491">24</a></span> “Raps Bleacher Jokesters,” <span class="italic">Sioux City</span> (Iowa) <span class="italic">Journal</span>, June 3, 1909: 9.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3442" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3492">25</a></span> Beck<span class="italic">, The American Indian Integration of Baseb</span><span class="italic">all</span>, 125.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3443" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3493">26</a></span> Beck, <span class="italic">The American Indian Integration of Baseball</span>, 182, 209-212.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3444" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3494">27</a></span> “Not All Sioux Indians,” <span class="italic">Marysville</span> (California) <span class="italic">Daily Appeal</span>, August 26, 1905: 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3445" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3495">28</a></span> “Indian Team May Come,” <span class="italic">Vancouver</span> (British Columbia) <span class="italic">Daily News Advertiser,</span> August 5, 1906: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3446" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3496">29</a></span> “Games at Night,” <em>Boston Globe</em>, quoted in the <span class="italic">San Luis Obispo</span> (California) <span class="italic">Morning Tribune,</span> July 26, 1905: 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3447" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3497">30</a></span> “Baseball at Night,” <span class="italic">Salinas</span> (California) <span class="italic">Daily Index</span>, August 4, 1906: 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3448" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3498">31</a></span> “Sioux Indians Scalped Local Players Again,” <span class="italic">Bakersfield</span> (California) <span class="italic">Morning Echo,</span> August 26, 1906: 5.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3449" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3499">32</a></span> Tim Wiles, “Night Games Gave Access to Baseball to Millions,” National Baseball Hall of Fame, Cooperstown, New York. Accessed Oct. 24, 2024. <a class="calibre2" href="https://baseballhall.org/discover/night-games-gave-access-to-baseball-to-millions">https://baseballhall.org/discover/night-games-gave-access-to-baseball-to-millions</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3450" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3500">33</a></span> Peter Morris, <span class="italic">A Game of Inches: The Story Behind the Innovations that Shaped Baseball</span> (Chicago: Ivan R. Dee, 2010), 378-379; General Electric Company<span class="italic">, The Light That Started Sports at Night</span> (Schenectady, New York: GE, 1930), 4-10. Thanks to Cassidy Lent, library director of the National Baseball Hall of Fame, for providing information on the history of night baseball.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3451" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3501">34</a></span> Newland<span class="italic">, Federal Boarding School Initiative R</span><span class="italic">eport</span>, 92.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3452" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3502">35</a></span> Buford, <span class="italic">Native American Son</span>, 92; Fear and Seagal, eds., <span class="italic">Carlistle Indian Industrial School</span>, 2, 97-98.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3453" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3503">36</a></span> Wade Davies<span class="italic">, Native Hoops: The Rise of American Indian Basketball, 1895-1970</span> (Lawrence, Kansas: University Press of Kansas, 2020), 29.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3454" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3504">37</a></span> Caldwell quoted in Beck, <span class="italic">The American Indian Integration of Base</span><span class="italic">ball</span>, 61.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3455" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3505">38</a></span> Oxendine, Foreword, <span class="italic">The American Indian Integration of Base</span><span class="italic">ball</span>, ix.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3456" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3506">39</a></span> Buford, <span class="italic">Native American Son</span>, 290-293.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3457" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3507">40</a></span> Royse Parr, “Ben Harjo’s All-Indian Baseball Club,” <span class="italic">Nine: A Journal of Baseball History and Culture</span>, 17.2 (2009): 90-91.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3458" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3508">41</a></span> Parr, “Ben Harjo’s All-Indian Baseball Club”: 92.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3459" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3509">42</a></span> Quoted in Parr, “Ben Harjo’s All-Indian Baseball Club”: 93.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3460" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3510">43</a></span> Parr, “Ben Harjo’s All-Indian Baseball Club”: 93.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3461" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3511">44</a></span> Parr, “Ben Harjo’s All-Indian Baseball Club”: 94.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3462" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3512">45</a></span> Lauriers quoted in Buford, <span class="italic">Native American</span> <span class="italic">Son</span>, 285.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3463" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3513">46</a></span> Parr, “Ben Harjo’s All-Indian Baseball Club”: 98.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3464" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3514">47</a></span> Buford, <span class="italic">Native American Son</span>, 284-285.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3465" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3515">48</a></span> Bob Lemke, “Photos Evoke Minor League Time Travel,” blog, August 21, 2014, <a class="calibre2" href="https://boblemke.blogspot.com/2014/08/photos-evoke-minor-league-time-travel.html">https://boblemke.blogspot.com/2014/08/photos-evoke-minor-league-time-travel.html</a>. “Sgt. Moses Edward ‘Mose’ Poolaw,” <span class="italic">Find a Grave</span>. Website. Accessed December 1, 2024. <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/25013152/moses-edward-poolaw">https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/25013152/moses-edward-poolaw</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3466" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3516">49</a></span> “Mose Poolaw,” Baseball Reference. Website. Accessed December 1, 2024. <a class="calibre2" href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/register/player.fcgi?id=poolaw001mos">https://www.baseball-reference.com/register/player.fcgi?id=poolaw001mos</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3467" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3517">50</a></span> “Indian Ball Players to Visit Old Mexico,” <span class="italic">Anadarko</span> (Oklahoma) <span class="italic">American Democrat,</span> September 28, 1933: 1.</p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>The Relationship of Legendary Managers Connie Mack and John McGraw with Their Native American Players</title>
		<link>https://sabr.org/journal/article/the-relationship-of-legendary-managers-connie-mack-and-john-mcgraw-with-their-native-american-players/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[wpadmin]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 07:14:38 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://sabr.org/?post_type=journal_articles&#038;p=325909</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Before the first game of the 1911 World Series, legendary managers John McGraw (left) of the New York Giants and Connie Mack (right) of the Philadelphia Athletics are pictured shaking hands. Also shown are the pitching aces of the two teams, Hall of Famers Christy Mathewson (left) of the Giants and Charles Albert Bender (right) [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="calibre_link-100" class="calibre1">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w4" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000065.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Before the first game of the 1911 World Series, legendary managers John McGraw (left) of the New York Giants and Connie Mack (right) of the Philadelphia Athletics are pictured shaking hands. Also shown are the pitching aces of the two teams, Hall of Famers Christy Mathewson (left) of the Giants and Charles Albert Bender (right) of the Athletics. Bender was a Native American popularly known by the nickname “Chief,” but Mack always addressed him as Albert. Not shown is the star catcher of the Giants, John Tortes Meyers, also a Native American known as “Chief.” Like Mack and Bender, McGraw and Meyers had a good relationship. (SABR-Rucker Archive)</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="first-paragraph">Without question two of the greatest managers in the history of major-league baseball were Connie Mack (1862-1956) and John McGraw (1873-1934).</p>
<p class="body">Cornelius McGillicuddy, better known as Connie Mack, piloted 7,466 games in a 50-year career as Philadelphia Athletics skipper. He managed an additional 289 games for the Pittsburgh Pirates for a total of 7,755 games, by far the most of any major-league manager.</p>
<p class="body">John McGraw managed the Baltimore Orioles for 2½ years and the New York Giants for 31 years, for a total of 4,769 games.</p>
<p class="body">Connie Mack, 6-feet-1 and 150 pounds, was known as The Tall Tactician for his stature and his baseball acumen, and “the grand old gentleman” for his quiet reserve and dignity. He always wore a business suit rather than a uniform in the dugout during games. He guided the Mackmen to nine American League pennants and five World Series titles. He was famed for developing young players and then, after their A’s teams had won championships, selling their contracts to keep the club solvent. Then he would repeat the cycle, building another winning team. One of the young players he tried to lure was Christy Mathewson. Mack succeeded in signing the Giants pitcher, but probably influenced by John McGraw, Mathewson broke the contract and returned to the Giants.</p>
<p class="body">Mack is best remembered for his longevity and civility. His entire career as a journeyman catcher, manager, and owner lasted 71 years. He addressed his players by their given names, not nicknames, and they invariably called him “Mr. Mack.” As the <em>New York Times</em> observed in Mack’s obituary, “The old-time leaders ruled by force, often thrashing players who disobeyed orders on the field or broke club rules off the field. … [Mack] always insisted that he could get better results by kindness. He never humiliated a player by public criticism. No one ever heard him scold a man in the most trying times of his many pennant fights.”<a id="calibre_link-3571" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3520">1</a></p>
<p class="body">Players on other teams applauded Mack’s approach to managing. Writing just before the 1913 World Series, Christy Mathewson compared the A’s to a college team, saying, “There is never any dissension. … You never hear one member of the team knocking some fellow player.” According to Mathewson, the A’s harmony was due to Connie Mack, who was “a marvel at handling men.” By contrast, Mathewson claimed, the hard-driving McGraw had the players wound up tight.<a id="calibre_link-3572" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3521">2</a></p>
<p class="body">In 1937, 13 years before he retired as A’s manager, Mack was inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame. His Hall of Fame plaque calls him “Mr. Baseball.” Outside Citizens Bank Park in Philadelphia there is a life-sized statue of Mack, wearing a business suit, waving the rolled-up scorecard he invariably held during games.</p>
<p class="body">In contrast to the lanky Connie Mack, the pudgy John McGraw was only 5-feet-7. However, his reputation far exceeded his size. McGraw has been praised as the epitome of “what a baseball manager was supposed to be: smart, shrewd, pugnacious, tough and demanding with his players.”<a id="calibre_link-3573" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3522">3</a> After McGraw’s death, Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis called him “one of the greatest natural leaders any sport has ever known,” adding, “Baseball to him was more than a game. It was a religion and war combined. … He was emblematic of the fire and dash that belongs to the national game. He knew ballplayers and he knew how to handle them.”<a id="calibre_link-3574" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3523">4</a></p>
<p class="body">From 1902 to 1932, McGraw led the New York Giants to 10 National League pennants, three World Series championships, and 21 first- or second-place finishes.</p>
<p class="body">Known as Mugsy and Little Napoleon (both nicknames he resented), McGraw developed his reputation for pugnaciousness as an infielder for the Baltimore Orioles and perfected it as a manager. As Arlie Latham, one of his coaches, said of McGraw’s famous irate charges across the diamond to confront an umpire, he “eats gunpowder every morning and washes it down with blood.”<a id="calibre_link-3575" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3524">5</a> He was ejected from 118 games as a manager and 14 as a player during his career, a record for total game ejections that stood until it was surpassed by Atlanta Braves manager Bobby Cox in 2007.</p>
<p class="body">McGraw was an innovator. He introduced what has been called the inside game or scientific baseball, a style of play that emphasized strategy and deceit over raw power. The Giants manager stressed solid defense, situational hitting, and aggressive baserunning</p>
<p class="body">McGraw was known to keep such close tabs on players that he would review hotel meal checks to see which of his players might be overeating. One of his heavier players once convinced a waiter to write down “asparagus” on his check when he had actually ordered pie a la mode.<a id="calibre_link-3576" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3525">6</a></p>
</div>
<p class="body"> </p>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000063.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>For three years (1913-1915) John Tortes Meyers (left) roomed with famed Olympian Jim Thorpe (right) while both played for the New York Giants. Unlike Meyers, Thorpe had a tempestuous relationship with their manager, John McGraw. (Author’s collection)</em></p>
</div>
<div id="calibre_link-100" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body">At first many of McGraw’s players were in awe of him, even afraid of him, but they often grew to admire him. As Josh Devore said of McGraw, “He was this gruff, angry guy sometimes, but the reputation was worse than the reality. How do you think he got so many different kinds of players to play so well for him through the years?”<a id="calibre_link-3577" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3526">7</a></p>
<p class="body">McGraw was posthumously elected to the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1937 and inducted with the class of 1939. Though flamboyant as a manager, his Hall of Fame plaque read simply “For 30 years manager of the New York Giants. … Under his leadership the Giants won 10 pennants and 3 world championships.”</p>
<p class="body">Connie Mack, whom McGraw recognized as an outstanding manager, called the Giants skipper in 1927 more effusively “the greatest baseball manager of all time.”<a id="calibre_link-3578" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3527">8</a></p>
<p class="body">Both Mack and McGraw managed Native American ballplayers who were among the stars of the Deadball Era.</p>
<p class="body">On a pitching staff that included greats like Lefty Grove, Herb Pennock, Eddie Plank, and Rube Waddell, Connie Mack considered Charles Albert Bender (1884-1954) his ace.<a id="calibre_link-3579" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3528">9</a></p>
<p class="body">A member of the Chippewa nation (also known as the Ojibwe, and in their own language Anishinaabe, for “original people”) Bender spent part of his childhood on the White Earth Reservation in Minnesota. His mother was Chippewa and his father was of German-American ancestry. Bender learned to pitch at the famed Carlisle Indian School in Pennsylvania, where he spent five years, graduating in 1902. He also developed at Carlisle a sharp mind, applying his acuity to the craft of pitching. However, like other Carlisle students, he experienced the disparaging of his Native American heritage, which had a lasting effect on him.</p>
<p class="body">Bender was signed by Connie Mack to a contract with the Philadelphia A’s in 1903. In his rookie year he had an impressive 17 wins. Although various ailments limited his pitching stamina, Bender developed a reputation as a reliable and effective hurler. He especially excelled in his World Series performances. In the only game the A’s won in the 1905 Series, Bender outdueled Joe McGinnity in a four-hit 3-0 shutout. Facing the New York Giants in the 1911 World Series, Bender pitched brilliantly, winning two of three starts, posting a 1.04 ERA, and striking out 20 batters in 26 innings.</p>
<p class="body">Over a 16-year major-league career, Bender won 212 games and posted a .625 winning percentage. He “led the American League in winning percentage three times, tossed a no hitter in 1910, and was one of the early World Series stars, posting a 2.44 earned run average in five career Series.”<a id="calibre_link-3580" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3529">10</a></p>
<p class="body">Like other Native American ballplayers, Bender had to endure constant, sometimes vicious, racism. For example, during the 1905 Series against the Giants, Bender was bombarded with racist taunts like “Back to the tepee for yours.” John McGraw even joined in, saying, “It will be off the warpath for you today, Chief.”<a id="calibre_link-3581" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3530">11</a> Bender resented the bigotry, as evident in the moniker “Chief” given to virtually all American Indian major leaguers. When applied to all Native American ballplayers, “Chief” “assumed the same patronizing overtone as the term ‘boy’ when applied generically to all African American males.”<a id="calibre_link-3582" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3531">12</a></p>
<p class="body">Bender always signed autographs with “Charles” rather than the racist nickname he rejected. “I do not want my name to be presented to the public as an Indian, but as a pitcher,” he told <em>Sporting Life</em> in 1905. However, he was called “Chief” so often during his career that he even allowed the nickname to be etched into his tombstone. Bender’s obituary in <em>The Sporting News</em> carried the headline, “Chief Bender Answers Call to Happy Hunting Grounds.”<a id="calibre_link-3583" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3532">13</a></p>
</div>
<p class="body"> </p>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000064.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Connie Mack (with scorecard), manager of the Philadelphia Athletics, had a close relationship with his Hall of Fame pitcher Charles Albert Bender. (Bain Collection, Library of Congress)</em></p>
</div>
<div id="calibre_link-100" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body">In an October 1905 article in <em>Sporting Life,</em> sportswriter Charles Zuber praised Bender for a World Series shutout victory over the Giants, but then added that the success was due to the influence of his manager Connie Mack, for “like the negro on stage, who … ‘will work himself to death’ if you jolly him, the Indian can be ‘conned’ into taking up any sort of burden.”<a id="calibre_link-3584" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3533">14</a></p>
<p class="body">For the most part, despite journalists’ assumptions, Bender enjoyed a positive, respectful relationship with Connie Mack. Although other players and coaches, including his own teammates on the Philadelphia Athletics, invariably called Bender “Chief,” Mack never used the label when talking to Bender. Instead, the A’s manager called Bender by his middle name “Albert.” Mack said of his ace pitcher, “If I had all the men I’ve ever handled, and they were in their prime, and there was one game I wanted to win above all others, Albert would be my man.”<a id="calibre_link-3585" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3534">15</a></p>
<p class="body">Mack called Bender “the greatest money pitcher the game has ever known,” at a time when the phrase, commonly used in sports, meant “one who excels when the pressure is greatest.”<a id="calibre_link-3586" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3535">16</a> That perspective was put into practice when Mack surprised observers by bringing Bender back to pitch the sixth and deciding game of the 1911 World Series against the Giants. In the 1913 World Series, Mack cited Bender’s “baseball smarts” when the pitcher repositioned Athletics outfielders. It was a move, Mack said, that few in the stands would have recognized but which was crucial to winning the game and the Series.<a id="calibre_link-3587" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3536">17</a></p>
<p class="body">Connie Mack was not the only one to recognize Bender’s contributions. Christy Mathewson, who faced Bender in the World Series, said of the A’s pitcher that he was “a student of baseball and a deeper student than many fans and writers are willing to admit. His presence on the bench or coaching lines would naturally mean much to a ball club, for I have never met a player who could grasp situations as quickly as the Indian.”<a id="calibre_link-3588" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3537">18</a> Mathewson observed that Bender had “a cool head and a fine arm and plenty of courage.”<a id="calibre_link-3589" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3538">19</a></p>
<p class="body">John Tortes Meyers also paid tribute to Bender, calling him “one of the main dependencies of Connie Mack’s wonderful Athletics” and adding, “Fandom has endorsed him as one of the greatest pitchers of the age.”<a id="calibre_link-3590" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3539">20</a></p>
<p class="body">At a time when one of the stereotypes often applied to Native American athletes was that they were lazy and lacked the will to win, Albert Bender was a consummate competitor. He “did not simply want to win baseball games, he burned with a white heat to win them.” Sportswriters often described Bender’s demeanor on the mound as “stern,” “cool,” “stoical,” and “impassive,” but there was no doubting his intensity in crucial games. What made him such a competitor was not only “a blazing fastball, a very good slider and change-up, and an ardent desire to win, [but also] keen intelligence.” Sometimes reporters would set aside their racial prejudice and note, as one wrote, that Bender pitched “with brain and nerve rather than brawn.”<a id="calibre_link-3591" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3540">21</a></p>
<p class="body">However, it is important to note that Connie Mack’s relationship with Bender was not always positive. After the 1908 season, one of Bender’s weakest on the mound, Mack was told that his starting pitcher was contemplating leaving the A’s to devote himself to trap shooting, another sport at which he excelled. Mack responded by saying, “[H]e did very little work for us last year and it is immaterial to me whether he pitches for the Athletics this season.”<a id="calibre_link-3592" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3541">22</a> Bender relented and signed a contract with a 50 percent pay cut, but it left a bitter taste in his mouth.</p>
<p class="body">Bender’s pitching also faltered during the 1912 season, in part as a result of his abuse of alcohol, which some believe began after the sudden death of his younger brother, John, who was also a baseball player.<a id="calibre_link-3593" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3542">23</a> Reporters took notice that Bender was at times so obviously inebriated that Mack had to respond. Drawing on common stereotypes, sportswriter F.C. Lane wrote in <em>Baseball Magazine</em> that Mack blasted Bender when his star hurler “blew in [to the team hotel] after a somewhat prolonged dalliance with the fire water which the soul of the red man craveth.”<a id="calibre_link-3594" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3543">24</a> Mack tried tolerating Bender’s drinking, but after more incidents, he suspended Bender and his drinking buddy, outfielder Rube Oldring.<a id="calibre_link-3595" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3544">25</a></p>
<p class="body">Before the 1913 season, Bender apologized to his manager for his behavior during the 1912 campaign and promised to remain sober. Mack once again cut Bender’s salary in half and wrote into his contract that he would receive his full salary only if he “refrains from intoxicating liquors.”<a id="calibre_link-3596" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3545">26</a> Bender’s stellar record during the 1913 season suggests that he kept his promise, and his relationship with Mack improved.<a id="calibre_link-3597" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3546">27</a></p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="caption">Before the 1913 World Series, Mack called Bender into his office and told him, “Albert, I’m counting on you to win this Series.” Bender won two games against the Giants in the Series and in so doing became the first pitcher to win six World Series games.<a id="calibre_link-3598" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3547">28</a> After the Series Mack called Bender once again into his office and handed him a check for $2,500 to pay off what the pitcher owed on his mortgage. The bonus may have been Mack’s way of repaying the salary cut in the 1913 season.<a id="calibre_link-3599" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3548">29</a></p>
</div>
<p class="body">The next year tension between Mack and Bender reemerged. The A’s manager told Bender to scout the Boston Braves, whom the A’s would face in the 1914 World Series. Instead, Bender went on a fishing trip. When Mack confronted him, Bender’s excuse was that the Braves were just a “bunch of bush leaguers.”<a id="calibre_link-3600" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3549">30</a> The “Miracle” Braves,” as they were known, proved him wrong, sweeping the A’s four games to none in the Series.</p>
<p class="body">During the 1930s, after his playing career had ended and he had overcome his drinking problems, Bender reconciled with Mack.<a id="calibre_link-3601" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3550">31</a> He was named a scout for the A’s and continued in that role into the 1940s. In 1951 he served as the team’s pitching coach.<a id="calibre_link-3602" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3551">32</a> Mack and Bender remained friends for the rest of their lives. A clearly emotional Mack attended Bender’s funeral in 1954.</p>
<p class="body">Charles Albert Bender knew both Connie Mack and John McGraw, as a player and coach. He summarized their styles well, saying, “They were different types, but both were real leaders. Mr. Mack was the fatherly, soft-spoken type while Mugsy was the hard-boiled, swashbuckling hell-for-leather type.”<a id="calibre_link-3603" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3552">33</a></p>
<p class="body">John McGraw also managed several Native Americans during his career, including Jim Thorpe. However, the best ballplayer among the Indians for whom McGraw was skipper was John Tortes Meyers of the Cahuilla tribe of Southern California. He was also known by the racist moniker “Chief.” McGraw signed Meyers, who was playing for the St. Paul Apostles (later the Saints), for $6,000 in 1908, a substantial sum for the time. Connie Mack had tried to trade with the Apostles for Meyers but lost in the bidding war to McGraw.</p>
<p class="body">The investment paid off as Meyers, a catcher, became a power hitter and trusted batterymate of the great Christy Mathewson from 1909 until Meyers left the Giants to join the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1916.</p>
<p class="body">Early in his professional career, when playing for the Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, minor-league team, Meyers demonstrated that he was willing to challenge his manager, a man named Calhoun. Meyers was sent into a game to catch a pitcher who threw a spitball, a pitch Meyers had at the time never seen. He couldn’t handle it and Calhoun pulled him. Instead of retiring meekly to the bench, Meyers confronted his manager and, in Meyers’ own words, “balled [<em>sic</em>] him out like a veteran.” Calhoun apologized and from that point on Meyers was accepted by his manager and teammates.<a id="calibre_link-3604" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3553">34</a> This was a story Meyers often told, because it illustrated in his mind that he was being harassed not only because he was a rookie, but because he was an Indian. A half-century later he told Lawrence Ritter, “I don’t like to say this, but in those days, when I was young, I was considered a foreigner. I didn’t belong. I was an Indian.”<a id="calibre_link-3605" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3554">35</a></p>
<p class="body">Meyers’ relationship with John McGraw was different. He was among the players who respected the Giants manager. The Cahuilla catcher credited McGraw with changing the way ballplayers were viewed and how they were paid. At a time when baseball players were considered ruffians and second-class citizens, forced to stay in inferior hotels, Meyers claimed, “Mr. McGraw was the one who changed all that. He was the one who paid the price, and even more than the price, to get his ball team into the best hotels. Now, the ballplayer is respected.”<a id="calibre_link-3606" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3555">36</a></p>
<p class="body">According to Meyers, McGraw’s insistence upon respect was not only for members of his own team, but for other players as well. On one occasion the Giants manager chewed out fans during a game played in Pittsburgh, shaming them for booing the Pirates shortstop Honus Wagner when he made a fielding error. Meyers said that McGraw “stood up in front of the stands, held up his hands and gave those babies a piece of his mind. McGraw was a commanding figure, you know, and when he got through telling ’em about Wagner they were cheering instead of booing.”<a id="calibre_link-3607" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3556">37</a></p>
<p class="body">Meyers also admired McGraw as “a master of invective and irony.” He couldn’t stand a player telling him “I thought.” According to Meyers, “Mr. McGraw didn’t use cuss words. He could cut you down without them.” Once when McGraw questioned Meyers’ pitch selection, the catcher responded, “I thought …” Before he could finish, McGraw said scornfully, “What with?”<a id="calibre_link-3608" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3557">38</a></p>
<p class="body">Meyers sometimes got the better of his manager in these feisty exchanges. On one occasion the Giants catcher noticed that a Dodgers pitcher with a great pickoff move to first base was tipping the throw. On the bench Meyers asked his manager if he could steal second base the next time he reached first. McGraw fumed, “Don’t ever steal a base. That’s not your job.” Meyers said he could not resist taking advantage of the opportunity and stole second anyway. McGraw fined him $10, but then asked the slow-footed catcher how he was able to steal the base so easily. Meyers responded by asking if the fine would be dropped if he told him. McGraw agreed and Meyers explained how the pitcher was tipping the throw. “After that,” Meyers remembered, “we ran the poor guy out of the league.”<a id="calibre_link-3609" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3558">39</a></p>
<p class="body">What did John McGraw think of Meyers? In a 1912 article, when Meyers was at his peak, McGraw called him “a vicious hitter … the greatest natural hitter in the game.” He also described him as “one of the best catchers in the National League,” “a quick thinker,” “a team leader,” and “all around a very valuable man.”<a id="calibre_link-3610" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3559">40</a></p>
<p class="body">On another occasion, after Meyers had caught George Wiltse in a one-hitter against the Pirates, the Giants manager gave his catcher nearly as much credit as he did Wiltse, saying, “It was one of the greatest exhibitions of outguessing skilled batters that [I] ever saw.” He went on to praise Meyers as a hitter, commenting, “[H]e is the only man that [I] ever saw who is more likely to hit that ball when a hit will bring in runs than he is when the bases are clear.”<a id="calibre_link-3611" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3560">41</a></p>
<p class="body">All things considered, Meyers’ relationship with McGraw was enigmatic. Like many other players and managers at the time, McGraw could act in a racist manner. He was the Baltimore Orioles’ third baseman in 1897 when Louis Sockalexis, one of the first Native Americans to play in the major leagues, signed with Cleveland. The first time Sockalexis appeared in Baltimore, McGraw took the field before the game “wearing a war bonnet with feathers reaching down below the seat of his baggy pants” and chanted “war whoops.” The crowd got the point. “Every time Sockalexis came to the plate, ear-splitting war whoops erupted in the stands. For the remaining games in the series many Baltimore fans wore feathered headdresses.”<a id="calibre_link-3612" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3561">42</a></p>
<p class="body">In 1901 McGraw was still managing the Orioles. In a scheme to circumvent the “gentleman’s agreement” that banned Blacks from playing major-league baseball, he signed Charlie Grant, an African American who played in the Negro leagues. McGraw gave Grant the moniker “Charlie Tokahoma,” a play on “poke a homer,” and passed him off as a “full-blooded Cherokee.” The ploy was discovered by Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey, who recognized Grant and put out the word that he was not an Indian, but a Negro “fixed up with war paint and a bunch of feathers.” McGraw would not have objected to Comiskey’s stereotypical description of Grant’s garb, for he had used it himself in demeaning Sockalexis.<a id="calibre_link-3613" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3562">43</a> Meyers had to endure some of the fallout of the Grant incident. Because of his dark skin, Meyers often heard shouts of the “n-word” from the stands.<a id="calibre_link-3614" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3563">44</a></p>
<p class="body">Meyers’s Native American teammate Jim Thorpe rebelled against McGraw’s overt racism and abusive tactics while playing for the Giants. Once, after Thorpe missed one of McGraw’s signs, the manager yelled at him, “You dumb Indian!” It took half the team to restrain Thorpe from physically attacking his manager.<a id="calibre_link-3615" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3564">45</a> On another occasion, after learning that Thorpe had visited a New York bar, McGraw said to him, “A young fellow like you shouldn’t ever drink. Besides no Indian knows how to drink.” A clearly irked Thorpe responded, “What about the Irish,” to which McGraw, sensitive about his heritage and his many barroom escapades, said, “Listen, don’t get smart with me!” “I’m not,” replied Thorpe. “It just happens I’m Irish too.”<a id="calibre_link-3616" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3565">46</a></p>
<p class="body">Unfortunately, Meyers involved himself in an incident that showed McGraw’s distrustful supervision of Thorpe. When Thorpe joined the Giants, McGraw instructed Meyers to open Thorpe’s mail, even love letters from Thorpe’s fiancée. When Thorpe found one of the intimate notes in Meyers’ locker, he exploded and chased the catcher around the locker room. Thorpe couldn’t catch him, and McGraw, who was observing the scene, chuckled and said, “Looks as though the wrong Indian competed in the Olympic games.”<a id="calibre_link-3617" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3566">47</a></p>
<p class="body">In the final analysis, although certainly aware of McGraw’s racist temperament and behavior, Meyers really believed that his manager looked for talent regardless of the player’s ethnicity.<a id="calibre_link-3618" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3567">48</a> He also was convinced that in addition to imparting baseball knowledge and skills, McGraw cultivated in players willing to look beyond his bluster and bias “a professional attitude, maturity, and self-respect.”<a id="calibre_link-3619" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3568">49</a> Although he was only seven years younger than his manager, John Tortes Meyers considered John McGraw a mentor from whom he learned not only baseball knowledge but valuable life lessons as well.</p>
<p class="body">Meyers summed up his attitude toward his manager in his 1964 interview with Lawrence Ritter for <em>The Glory of Their Times</em>: “What a wonderful man he was. Honest and forthright and charitable in the deepest sense of the word. We always called him Mr. McGraw. Never John or Mac. Always Mr. McGraw.”<a id="calibre_link-3620" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3569">50</a></p>
<p class="body">According to Meyers’ grandnephew, the Cahuilla catcher’s most precious possession was not the bat Babe Ruth gave him but rather a gold watch fob in the shape of a catcher’s mitt with a diamond on the clasp and a pearl to represent a baseball. It was presented to him by John McGraw.<a id="calibre_link-3621" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3570">51</a></p>
<p><em><strong>WILLIAM A. YOUNG</strong> is Professor Emeritus of Religious Studies at Westminster College, Fulton, Missouri. The books he has written on baseball include John Tortes Meyers: A Baseball Biography and J. L. Wilkinson and the Kansas City Monarchs Trailblazers in Black Baseball. For the latter book, he received a SABR Research Award. He also contributed essays to the SABR volumes on Jackie Robinson and the Kansas City Monarchs. He is the author of Quest for Harmony: Native American Spiritual Traditions and several other books on religion. Young is a lifelong St. Louis Cardinals fan. He and his wife, Sue, also a retired educator and Cardinals fan, reside in Columbia, Missouri.</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>ACKNOWLEDGMENTS</strong></p>
<p class="sources">An earlier version of this essay appeared in William A. Young, <em><span class="italic">John Tortes “Chief” Meyers: A Baseball Biography</span></em> (Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland &amp; Co., 2012).</p>
<p class="sources">Background information on Connie Mack is drawn from his SABR biography by Doug Skipper: <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/connie-mack/">https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/connie-mack/</a>, on John McGraw from Don Jensen’s BioProject biography: <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/john-mcgraw-2/">https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/john-mcgraw-2/</a>. <a class="calibre2" href="http://Baseball-reference.com">Baseball-reference.com</a> was consulted for statistics.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>NOTES</strong></p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3520" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3571">1</a></span> <em>New York Times,</em> February 9, 1956.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3521" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3572">2</a></span> Norman Macht, <em><span class="italic">Connie Mack and the Early Years of Baseball</span></em> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2007), 588.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3522" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3573">3</a></span> Charles Alexander, <em><span class="italic">John McGraw</span></em> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1995), 3-4.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3523" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3574">4</a></span> <span class="italic"><em>Los Angeles Times</em>,</span> February 26, 1934, 10; cited in Richard Adler, <em><span class="italic">Mack, McGraw and the 1913 Baseball Season</span></em> (Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland &amp; Co., 2008), 39.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3524" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3575">5</a></span> Tom Simon, ed. <em><span class="italic">Deadball Stars of the National League</span></em> (Washington: Brassey’s, 2004), 39.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3525" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3576">6</a></span> Frank DeFord, <em><span class="italic">The Old Ball Game: How John McGraw, Christy Mathewson, and the New York Giants Created Modern Baseball</span></em> (New York: Atlantic Monthly Press, 2005), 158.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3526" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3577">7</a></span> Mike Vaccaro, <em><span class="italic">The First Fall Classic: The Red Sox, the Giants, and the Cast of Players, Pugs, and Politicos Who Reinvented the World Series in 1912</span></em> (New York: Doubleday, 2009), 114.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3527" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3578">8</a></span> Norman Macht, <em><span class="italic">Connie Mack: The Turbulent &amp; Triumphant Years 1915-1931</span></em> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2012), 451.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3528" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3579">9</a></span> Background information on Charles Albert Bender drawn from SABR BioProject article on Bender by Tom Swift. <a class="calibre2" href="https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/charles-bender/">https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/charles-bender/</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3529" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3580">10</a></span> Robert Peyton Wiggins, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender: A Baseball Biography</span></em> (Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland &amp; Co., 2010), 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3530" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3581">11</a></span> Jeffrey P. Beck, <em><span class="italic">The American Indian Integration of Baseball</span></em> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2004), 74-75.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3531" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3582">12</a></span> William C. Kashatus, <em><span class="italic">Money Pitcher: Chief Bender and the Tragedy of Indian Assimilation</span></em> (University Park: Pennsylvania State University, 2006), 59.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3532" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3583">13</a></span> Tom Swift, SABR BioProject article.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3533" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3584">14</a></span> Beck, 73.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3534" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3585">15</a></span> Tom Swift, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender’s Burden: The Silent Struggle of a Baseball Star</span></em> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press<span class="italic">,</span> 2008), 252.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3535" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3586">16</a></span> Swift, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender’s B</span><span class="italic">urden</span></em>, 83.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3536" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3587">17</a></span> Beck, 71.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3537" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3588">18</a></span> Swift, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender’s Bu</span><span class="italic">rden</span></em>, 251.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3538" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3589">19</a></span> Swift, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender’s Bu</span><span class="italic">rden</span></em>, 215.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3539" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3590">20</a></span> John T. Meyers, “Meyers Lauds Jim Thorpe, Olympic Hero,” <em><span class="italic">New York American</span></em>, May 25, 1913.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3540" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3591">21</a></span> Beck, 70-71.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3541" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3592">22</a></span> <span class="italic"><em>Washington Post</em>,</span> February 21, 1909; cited by Wiggins, <span class="italic"><em>Chief Bender: A Baseball Biography</em>,</span> 105, and Swift, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender’s B</span></em><span class="italic"><em>urden</em>,</span> 46.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3542" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3593">23</a></span> Kashatus, <em><span class="italic">Money Pi</span></em><span class="italic"><em>tcher</em>,</span> 95.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3543" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3594">24</a></span> F.C. Lane, “Greatest by Manager in Organized Baseball,” <span class="italic"><em>Baseball Magazine</em>,</span> May 1913, vol. X, no. 7; cited by Wiggins, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender:</span> <span class="italic">A Baseball Biogr</span></em><span class="italic"><em>aphy</em>,</span> 152.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3544" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3595">25</a></span> Swift, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender’s Bu</span><span class="italic">rden</span></em>, 222.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3545" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3596">26</a></span> Swift, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender’s Bu</span><span class="italic">rden</span></em>, 224.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3546" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3597">27</a></span> Wiggins, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender: A Baseball Biogr</span></em><span class="italic"><em>aphy</em>,</span> 156.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3547" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3598">28</a></span> Wiggin<em>s, </em><span class="italic"><em>Chief Bender: A Baseball Biography</em>,</span> 6; Swift, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender’s Bu</span><span class="italic">rden</span></em>, 193.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3548" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3599">29</a></span> Swift, <em>Chief Bender’s Burden</em>, 208, 224; Kashatus, <em><span class="italic">Money Pit</span></em><span class="italic"><em>cher</em>,</span> 102.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3549" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3600">30</a></span> Wiggins, <span class="italic"><em>Chief Bender: A Baseball Biography</em>,</span> 175; Swift, <em>Chief Bender’s Burden</em>, 209; Kashatus, <em><span class="italic">Money Pit</span></em><span class="italic"><em>cher</em>,</span> 112.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3550" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3601">31</a></span> Kashatus, <em><span class="italic">Money Pitche</span></em><span class="italic"><em>r</em>,</span> 145-47.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3551" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3602">32</a></span> Wiggins, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender: A Baseball Biogr</span><span class="italic">aphy</span></em>, 225.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3552" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3603">33</a></span> Swift, <em><span class="italic">Chief Bender’s Burde</span><span class="italic">n</span></em>, 194-95.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3553" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3604">34</a></span> <span class="italic"><em>St. Louis Globe-Democrat</em>,</span> August 29, 1909.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3554" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3605">35</a></span> Lawrence Ritter, “Chief Meyers,” <em><span class="italic">The Glory of Their Times: The Story of the Early Days of Baseball Told by the Men Who Played It,</span> <span class="italic">Enlarged Edition</span></em> (New York: HarperCollins, 2002), 172.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3555" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3606">36</a></span> Ritter, <em><span class="italic">The Glory of Their T</span></em><span class="italic"><em>imes</em>,</span> 172.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3556" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3607">37</a></span> Grantland Rice, “A Talk with Chief Meyers,&#8221; February 4, 1947 (John Tortes Meyers File, National Baseball Hall of Fame, Cooperstown, New York).</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3557" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3608">38</a></span> Paul Zimmerman, “Sportscripts,” <span class="italic"><em>Los Angeles Times</em>,</span> August 13, 1947, 10; Beck, <em><span class="italic">The American Indian Integration of Baseba</span><span class="italic">ll</span></em>, 85-86.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3558" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3609">39</a></span> Jim Dawson, “McGraw Rescinded Fine After Talk with Chief,” <em><span class="italic">Riverside</span></em> (California) <em><span class="italic">Press-Enterprise</span></em>, June 25, 1969<span class="italic">.</span></p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3559" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3610">40</a></span> John McGraw, “Making a Pennant Winner,” <span class="italic"><em>Pearson’s Magazine</em>,</span> November 1912: 121.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3560" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3611">41</a></span> Unidentified, unattributed, undated article, John Tortes Meyers file, National Baseball Hall of Fame, Cooperstown, New York.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3561" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3612">42</a></span> Brian McDonald, <em><span class="italic">Indian Summer: The Forgotten Story of Louis Sockalexis – the First Native American in Major League Baseball</span></em> (Emmaus, Pennsylvania: Rodale Press, 2003), 131.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3562" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3613">43</a></span> Kashatus, <em><span class="italic">Money Pi</span></em><span class="italic"><em>tcher</em>,</span> 58.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3563" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3614">44</a></span> Beck, 81.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3564" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3615">45</a></span> Kate Buford, <em><span class="italic">Native Son: The Life and Sporting Legend of Jim Thorpe</span></em> (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2010), 215.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3565" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3616">46</a></span> Beck, 92-93.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3566" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3617">47</a></span> Beck, 93.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3567" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3618">48</a></span> Ritter, <em><span class="italic">The Glory of Their T</span></em><span class="italic"><em>imes</em>,</span> 174.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3568" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3619">49</a></span> Alexander, <em><span class="italic">John</span> </em><span class="italic"><em>McGraw</em>,</span> 5.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3569" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3620">50</a></span> Ritter, <em><span class="italic">The Glory of Their Time</span></em><span class="italic"><em>s</em>,</span> 174-75.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3570" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3621">51</a></span> Colonel John V. Meyers, personal interview, September 22, 2008.</p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>How William “Big Chief” Watkins Began his Career as a Japanese: Early Native American and Japanese Baseball Interaction</title>
		<link>https://sabr.org/journal/article/how-william-big-chief-watkins-began-his-career-as-a-japanese-early-native-american-and-japanese-baseball-interaction/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[wpadmin]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 07:13:38 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://sabr.org/?post_type=journal_articles&#038;p=325910</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[William “Naga” Watkins on the Japanese Base Ball Association, 1911. (Author’s collection) &#160; Harry Saisho had a problem. He wanted to transform his Los Angeles-based Japanese baseball club from an amateur squad to a professional barnstorming team and he needed a pitcher. In the first decade of the twentieth century, high-quality Japanese pitchers were rare [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="calibre_link-102" class="calibre1">
<p class="section"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000066.jpg" alt="" /></p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="caption"><em>William “Naga” Watkins on the Japanese Base Ball Association, 1911. (Author’s collection)</em></p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="first-paragraph">Harry Saisho had a problem. He wanted to transform his Los Angeles-based Japanese baseball club from an amateur squad to a professional barnstorming team and he needed a pitcher.</p>
<p class="body">In the first decade of the twentieth century, high-quality Japanese pitchers were rare in the US. In November 1908 Saisho and his team’s president, Dr. Takejiro Ito, went to Oakland to recruit a pitcher. A long article in the <em>Reno Evening Gazette</em>, probably republished from a Bay Area newspaper, describes their elusive search:</p>
<p class="body">For three years [Harry Saisho] has been developing a little squad of Nippon athletes until he has one of the fastest fielding teams in the southern part of the state. He has infielders that are above the ordinary, outfielders that are certain and a good catcher – but the pitcher is lacking. That is the weakness in the Japanese ball team that Saisho must overcome. He has brought pitchers from every town along the coast south of Vancouver and they have failed to develop a pitching arm. &#8230;</p>
<p class="body">Dr. Ito and Captain Saisho are in Oakland looking for a pitcher. &#8230; When you ask Ito what is the matter with having a Japanese pitcher, he throws up his hands, bites his underlip suggestively and &#8230; gives an explanation of his native countrymen. “Japanese are not built for pitching. &#8230; They haven’t a throwing arm. One reason is that the arm is too short, another is that the shoulder is too close set against the body. Our people are the greatest contortionists in the world but they can’t stand the strain of pitching for their shoulders always give out. The players can’t curve the balls either like you Americans. I thought at first it was the height, but I have seen the boys play against white pitchers smaller than our own and he would beat us. We are simply not people adapted to play ball and I can’t remedy the defect.</p>
<p class="body">Furthermore, he never expects to develop a pitcher among his people. It is a hopeless task that he has been disappointed so many times that he will not attempt again. The team, which is known as the Nanka Japanese for Southern California will tour the state next spring and will appear in Oakland probably with an Indian pitcher in the box out of respect for a harmony of the complexion of the player.<a id="calibre_link-3685" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3624">1</a></p>
<p class="body">It was not unusual for Issei (first-generation Japanese immigrants) teams to recruit Native American players and have them pretend to be Japanese.<a id="calibre_link-3686" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3625">2</a> This chapter will examine early baseball interaction between Native Americans and Issei in greater Los Angeles and then focus on William “Big Chief” Watkins, who began his professional career as the ace of the Japanese Base Ball Association.</p>
<p class="body">Between 1901 and 1908 over 100,000 Japanese entered the United States. Baseball had been introduced to Japan in 1872 and by 1900 was played at most of the high schools and colleges across the nation. Many Japanese immigrants had learned the game in their native land and some formed amateur baseball teams soon after arriving in the United States. The first known team was the Fuji Athletic Club, founded in San Francisco about 1903. The Kanagawa Doshi Club of San Francisco and a loosely organized club from the <em>Rafu Shimpo</em> newspaper in Los Angeles were formed the following year.</p>
<p class="body">In 1905 the Waseda University baseball team from Tokyo visited the West Coast, playing 26 games against American college, high-school, amateur, and professional teams. It was the first time a foreign team came to the United States to challenge Americans at their national pastime. The games attracted thousands of spectators and were covered in nearly all of the West Coast newspapers.</p>
<p class="body">On May 20 Waseda met a squad from the Sherman Institute of Riverside, California. The game was closely covered by the local and national press as, according to <em>Sporting Life,</em> it “marked an epoch in the history of our national game … [as] the first time a base ball game was played by teams whose players were from two races that have adopted a sport heretofore distinctively that of the white man.”<a id="calibre_link-3687" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3626">3</a></p>
<p class="body">Founded and operated by the United States government in 1892, the Sherman Institute was the first “off-reservation” boarding school for Native Americans in California. It educated children from 5 to 20 years old with the explicit goal of assimilating them into White American society. Like many government-sponsored Native American schools, the Sherman Institute encouraged the boys to play football and baseball to help instill “American values.” The school soon became known for its outstanding football squad and would produce a number of professionals, but its baseball team was weak. To bolster the lineup against Waseda, the school recruited local Native American John Tortes Meyers. The son of German-American former Union Army officer and saloon owner John Mayer and Felicite Tortes of the Cahuilla tribe, Meyers would be raised by his mother, partly on the Santa Rosa reservation and partly in Riverside, before becoming a local semipro star and eventually the star catcher known as Chief Meyers for John McGraw’s New York Giants.</p>
<p class="body">The game began at 3:00 and “the largest crowd of the [season’s] series gathered at Fiesta Park &#8230; and cheered loud and long.”<a id="calibre_link-3688" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3627">4</a> The Institute team took the field in dark trousers, high white socks, and white jerseys. The visiting Japanese wore buff uniforms with maroon socks. Waseda scored a quick run in the first on an error by the Sherman shortstop Padillo and added three more in both the fourth and sixth innings. Meanwhile, Waseda starter Atsushi Kono shut out the opposition for five innings. “The teams formed a curious contrast,” the <em>Los Angeles Times</em> noted. “The Red Men, burly and muscular, seemed to tear through their game. The Brown men, lithe and wiry, slipped around them and out-played them.”<a id="calibre_link-3689" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3628">5</a></p>
<p class="body">In the bottom of the sixth, down 7-0, the Institute fought back, scoring six as Meyers “tried to remove the cover from the ball by knocking it to the score board.”<a id="calibre_link-3690" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3629">6</a> But Waseda’s slick fielding held the Native Americans. “The little warriors from Waseda dashed around the field, taking down the long drives of the red man with ease and grace that was surprising.”<a id="calibre_link-3691" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3630">7</a> The Japanese padded their lead to win, 12-7. All the newspapers agreed that it was a sensational game “replete with lively hitting, speedy base-running and good and bad fielding.”<a id="calibre_link-3692" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3631">8</a></p>
<p class="body">With the novelty of opponents from different races, the newspapermen could not resist racial stereotypes, allusions, and metaphors in their game descriptions. “Jap Team Scalps Sherman Braves,” “Wiry Japs Wallop Reds,” and “Japs Stop a Break from Reservation,” declared the next morning’s headlines.<a id="calibre_link-3693" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3632">9</a> Not surprisingly the articles were replete with references to scalping, reservations, and the Russo-Japanese war. Typical was the <em>Los Angeles Herald</em>’s lede: “determined to win against a team which they considered in every way equal in strength to a company of Russian soldiers, nine little Japs from Waseda college across the sea took into camp the scalps of nine of the hardiest braves from the Sherman reservation school of Riverside yesterday afternoon and sent the big bucks crashing back to defeat with a one-sided score of 12 to 7.”<a id="calibre_link-3694" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3633">10</a></p>
<p class="body">Accompanying an article loaded with racial stereotypes and demeaning terminology, the <em>Los Angeles Examiner</em> published a large montage covering the top of the sports section under the headline “Orientals Win Ball Game From the Aborigines.”<a id="calibre_link-3695" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3634">11</a> The centerpiece is a drawing of a Native American and a Japanese man in traditional clothing each holding a baseball bat (Figure 1). On either side of this centerpiece are the photographs of three players from the respective teams.</p>
<p class="body">The game initiated a long relationship between Japanese ballplayers and the Sherman Institute. Harry Saisho recruited Native American players from the Institute to fill out his teams and in 1921 he organized and financed a tour of Japan for a Native American ballclub called the Sherman Indians, which contained a number of Sherman graduates. The team arrived in Yokohama on September 29 and spent the month of October playing eight games in Osaka and Tokyo. The squad did not do well on the diamond, winning only two games. Plagued by poor weather as well as a lack of talent, the tour lost money, bankrupting Saisho. The Native American players, however, returned home happy, having enjoyed their expenses-paid trip to Japan.<a id="calibre_link-3696" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3635">12</a></p>
<p class="body">Intrigued by the press coverage of the Waseda games and the large attendance, Guy Green, the owner of the famed Nebraska Indians Baseball Team, decided to create an all-Japanese baseball club to barnstorm across the Midwest. It would be the first Japanese professional team on either side of the Pacific, as pro ball would not come to Japan until the 1920s.</p>
<p class="body">Although Green would claim that he had “scour[ed] the [Japanese] empire for the best players obtainable,” he did nothing of the sort.<a id="calibre_link-3697" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3636">13</a> In early 1906 Green instructed Dan Tobey, the Caucasian captain of the Nebraska Indians, to form a team from Japanese immigrants living in California. The players congregated in Lincoln, Nebraska, in early April to practice with Tobey and assistant coach Sandy Kissell, a Native American who had played on Green’s Nebraska Indians.<a id="calibre_link-3698" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3637">14</a></p>
<p class="body">After a few days, the Nebraska Indians joined the Japanese at the practice field. Although the Japanese recruits knew the Indians’ reputation as top semipros, their skill surprised them. They were particularly impressed with the shortstop Juzicanea, a Yaqui from Arizona whom Guy Green described in <em>Fun and Frolic with an Indian Ball Team</em> as “the meanest looking Indian I have ever seen.”<a id="calibre_link-3699" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3638">15</a> According to Green, Juzicanea “wore his hair long, surveyed everything suspiciously with piercing black eyes, and when he came down the street people moved to the edge of the sidewalk and apprehensively watched him pass.”<a id="calibre_link-3700" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3639">16</a> “Although he was small like us,” a Japanese player wrote, he could throw the ball “like an arrow” so hard that the receiver sometimes dropped the ball from the sting of the impact. “Knowing that a small man could play that well, gave us a motive to practice harder. In poor English, we told the Indians’ captain that we were newcomers and inexperienced, and our skin color is very similar, so please teach us.”<a id="calibre_link-3701" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3640">17</a></p>
<p class="body">It soon became evident that not all of the Japanese were skilled enough to play on a professional independent squad, so Green and Tobey decided to bolster the roster with Native Americans – hoping that most spectators would not be able to tell the difference. Dan Tobey stayed with the team as a player-coach and shared pitching duties with Sandy Kissell. Seguin, occasionally called Sego in box scores, would catch most of the games. Both Kissell and Seguin would play on Green’s Nebraska Indians in 1907. Two other men, known only by their nicknames Doctor (first and third base), and Noisy (first base, third base, and catcher), joined the squad.<a id="calibre_link-3702" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3641">18</a></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
</div>
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000067.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>William “Big Chief” Watkins on the Nebraska Indians, circa 1915. (Author’s collection)</em></p>
<div id="calibre_link-102" class="calibre1">
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body">In mid-April Green’s Japanese Base Ball Team embarked on a 24-week tour that covered over 2,500 miles through nine Midwestern states. From April 15 to October 10, the team played about 170 games against town teams and independent clubs. Although the team did well, winning 122 of the 142 games with known results, Green disbanded the club at the end of the season.<a id="calibre_link-3703" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3642">19</a></p>
<p class="body">Green’s Japanese players returned to the West Coast and formed their own amateur and professional barnstorming teams. Harry Saisho began by organizing the amateur Nanbu Karifournia (Southern California) Base Ball Club, known as Nanka. For several years the team played other amateur clubs in the Los Angeles area but Saisho longed to turn the squad into a professional barnstorming team. Despite not being able to find a strong Japanese pitcher in Oakland in the fall of 1908, the following spring he renamed his squad the Japanese Base Ball Association (JBBA) and readied to barnstorm across the country. They began with three games in Los Angeles. But after consecutive one-sided loses to the African American L.A. Giants, L.A. High School, and a Riverside semipro nine, Saisho realized that the team was not ready and canceled the planned tour.<a id="calibre_link-3704" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3643">20</a></p>
<p class="body">In 1911 the JBBA was ready to try again. The team spent April and early May honing its skills with weekly games in the Los Angeles area. Still lacking a quality Japanese pitcher, Saisho recruited Louis Lockhart, a Native American who had attended the Sherman Institute, along with two other non-Japanese. Fans, however, became suspicious during the May 10 game against the University of Southern California when the three “appeared strangely bewildered when the manager forgot and gave them some instructions in the Japanese language. In order to quiet the suspicions of the onlookers one of these players addressed the umpire with a string of gibberish that had a strong Spanish accent.”<a id="calibre_link-3705" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3644">21</a></p>
<p class="body">On May 11, 1911, the JBBA headed east to begin a 25-week tour across seven states during which they would play 128 games. After starting the first few games, Lockhart left the squad and Saisho turned the mound over to Lockhart’s Sherman Institute teammate, 21-year-old William Watkins. A Shoshone Indian, born in Round Mountain, Nevada, on March 16, 1886, Watkins enrolled at the Sherman Institute on November 4, 1909.<a id="calibre_link-3706" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3645">22</a> The next spring, he was elected captain of the school’s baseball team. He grew into a powerful young man for his time, standing 5-feet-10½-inches and weighing over 160 pounds.<a id="calibre_link-3707" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3646">23</a> Saisho gave Watkins the stage name Naga and attempted to pass him off as Japanese, but with his size and distinctive Native American features, few were fooled.</p>
<p class="body">The JBBA was not a strong team. Playing mostly town nines and a few independent clubs, they won just 25 of the 87 games for which results are known. Although reporters often singled out Watkins, who played third base when he was not pitching, as the team’s top player, he was not dominating on the mound. Few box scores survive from the JBBA tour, but the existing statistics and newspaper articles show that he won just four of his 21 known starts and surrendered 5.86 runs per game. He did, however, strike out an average of 7.69 batters per game.<a id="calibre_link-3708" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3647">24</a></p>
<p class="body">Pitching nearly every other day, Watkins matured as a pitcher during that summer. On July 10 the <em>Quincy</em> (Illinois) <em>Daily Herald</em> noted that he “was a real twirler. He had steam and he had control. His curves broke nicely and in a way that was bewildering.”<a id="calibre_link-3709" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3648">25</a> By the end of the tour, he threw some gems, including a 1-0 shutout with 11 strikeouts in Centerville, Iowa.<a id="calibre_link-3710" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3649">26</a></p>
<p class="body">In his last start, Watkins faced the St. Louis Giants, one of the top African American clubs in the Midwest. Their lineup included future Hall of Famer Ben Taylor, his brothers Steel Arm Johnny and Candy Jim Taylor, captain Dick Wallace, and Tullie McAdoo. A tremendous crowd came out to Athletic Park, expecting the locals to demolish the visiting Japanese, but to everyone’s surprise Naga baffled the Giants. The two teams were locked, 2-2, after nine innings before the Giants squeaked out a 3-2 victory in the 11th. The outing may have changed Watkins’ life as it drew the attention of St. Louis Cardinals manager Roger Bresnahan.<a id="calibre_link-3711" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3650">27</a></p>
<p class="body">Bresnahan signed Watkins to a professional contract and tested him against major leaguers in the annual postseason matchup between the Cardinals and the crosstown rival Browns. The Cardinals were already down 4-1 when Watkins came on in the fifth inning with no outs and runners on first and second. Pitching against the toughest hitters he had ever faced, Watkins set down the side, although the Browns did push a run across. Bresnahan decided to keep the young pitcher in for the remainder of the game but Watkins could not contain the Browns, who scored another in the sixth, three in the seventh, and one in the eighth. At day’s end, Watkins had surrendered five runs on six hits with a walk and a hit batsman in four innings.<a id="calibre_link-3712" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3651">28</a></p>
<p class="body">Although his hometown newspaper, the <em>Riverside Daily Press</em>, proclaimed on December 30, 1911, that “Watkins will have no trouble in the big league. … [H]e is looked upon as a second Bender and every fan in the country knows what that means,” Bresnahan decided that Watkins needed more seasoning and sent him to the Erie Sailors in the Class-B Central League for the 1912 season.<a id="calibre_link-3713" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3652">29</a></p>
<p class="body">The Sailors had finished in third place in the Ohio-Pennsylvania League in 1911 and had just joined the Central League. Nonetheless, the town had high hopes for their team, and they yearned for their new phenom to appear. “Watkins … is a descendant of the same tribe as Chief Bender,” the <em>Erie Daily Times</em> incorrectly reported. He “is a young and powerful specimen of the aborigine race. … Bresnahan wired him to start immediately for Erie and it is expected that he will put in an appearance in about five days.”<a id="calibre_link-3714" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3653">30</a></p>
<p class="body">Watkins arrived on May 7 with a new name and a refined spitball.<a id="calibre_link-3715" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3654">31</a> He was now known as Chief Watkins or Big Chief Watkins. “The Chief is husky,” gushed the <em>Erie Daily Times</em>. “He is an imposing specimen of the American Indian. He is about five feet, eleven inches tall with massive shoulders and athletic physique. He … [is] said to have everything that is needed for a first class pitcher.”<a id="calibre_link-3716" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3655">32</a> Over the next week, the newspaper reported on when the fans would get to watch their new hero.</p>
<p class="body">Watkins finally debuted on May 16 against the Youngstown Steelmen but the fans were disappointed. The Chief was hit hard, giving up 10 hits including two home runs and two doubles, as the Steelmen won 7-1. Catcher Bobby Schang had trouble handling Watkins’ spitter, which took “a quick, deceptive break right at the plate and are hard to judge.”<a id="calibre_link-3717" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3656">33</a> The local newspaper was forgiving. “While the Chief was batted hard in his debut on the mound, it was not entirely his fault. &#8230; We might say right now that the Chief looks like a real pitcher and we predict that he will stand more than a few of the batters in this league on their heads before the curtain is rung down. But you can’t win a ball game without some runs to win as much as the red man’s supporting cast was way below its high pinnacle of perfection. … The crew had four slipups which may be connected with the run getting and were over-zealous in their base running.”<a id="calibre_link-3718" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3657">34</a></p>
<p class="body">Four days later Watkins was given a second chance as he came on in relief in the second inning and “pitched superb ball,” shutting out the Wheeling Stogies for the remainder of the game.<a id="calibre_link-3719" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3658">35</a> The <em>Daily Times</em> predicted that “he will be one of the pitching stars in … [the] circuit this season.”<a id="calibre_link-3720" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3659">36</a> But it was not to be. Watkins remained erratic, alternating meltdowns with brilliant outings. The <em>Fort Wayne Weekly Sentinel</em> noted, “[H]is worst fault was lack of control, but when he got ’em over he was hard to beat.”<a id="calibre_link-3721" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3660">37</a> At those times he dominated – striking out eight and throwing six no-hit innings in a 4-2 win over Dayton on June 14 and a three-hit shutout over Terre Haute on June 24. But on his wild days, opponents feasted – Watkins surrendered eight runs off nine hits and three walks against the Grand Rapids Black Sox on June 26. After a disastrous start against Akron on July 11, when he was knocked out in the third inning after already surrendering four hits, two walks, and a wild pitch, Erie released Watkins.<a id="calibre_link-3722" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3661">38</a></p>
<p class="body">Watkins returned to the West Coast and played for a few weeks with the Vancouver Beavers of the Northwest League before finishing the season with the semipro Richmond Clothiers in San Francisco.<a id="calibre_link-3723" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3662">39</a></p>
<p class="body">The Big Chief spent the next two years bouncing around the minor leagues. During the winter of 1912-13, he received a contract from the Fort Wayne Champs of the Central League but did not report until May 7. As a result, the Champs required him to train at his own expense until he could “demonstrate that he is ready to work.”<a id="calibre_link-3724" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3663">40</a> They also withheld his pay until he officially made the squad.<a id="calibre_link-3725" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3664">41</a> Watkins debuted in relief on May 16 against the Springfield Reapers. “All Hail the Chief!” exclaimed a subheadline in the <em>Fort Wayne Journal Gazette</em> as Watkins gave up just two hits in five shutout innings.<a id="calibre_link-3726" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3665">42</a> The next game did not go as well as Watkins suffered one of his meltdowns. The Champs already trailed Springfield 2-0 when he came on in relief in the first inning on May 22. “Watkins’ downfall came in the second when the visitors started bunting on him. He had his trouble holding his feet while racing about on the muddy infield and the first thing he knew he was forced into a deep dark hole.”<a id="calibre_link-3727" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3666">43</a> Despite giving up three runs in the inning, manager Jimmy Burke left Watkins on the mound for the next seven innings and “it was awful.”<a id="calibre_link-3728" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3667">44</a> By the end of the game, Watkins had allowed 20 hits and 4 walks, and threw four wild pitches in the 18-7 loss.</p>
<p class="body">The next morning, the Champs cut Watkins and sent him to the Steubenville Stubs of the Interstate League. “He has never shown anything here that would justify keeping him, and is of no value to the pitching staff,” concluded the <em>Fort Wayne Sentinel</em>.<a id="calibre_link-3729" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3668">45</a> Watkins’ stay with Steubenville was short-lived as the franchise disbanded in mid-July and he was transferred to the Battle Creek Crickets of the Southern Michigan Association.<a id="calibre_link-3730" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3669">46</a> He began well in Class-D ball, winning his first start with a four-hitter against Jackson on July 21 and shutting out Jackson on five hits four days later.<a id="calibre_link-3731" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3670">47</a> But as the season continued, opponents began to rack up the hits. Nonetheless, Watkins persevered and maintained a spot in the rotation until season’s end.<a id="calibre_link-3732" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3671">48</a></p>
<p class="body">Watkins spent the winter in Detroit, working in a post office, before signing with the Jackson Chiefs of the Southern Michigan Association on March 2, 1914.<a id="calibre_link-3733" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3672">49</a> His stint with Jackson did not last long as he was trying out for the Toledo Mud Hens of the same league by May 19.<a id="calibre_link-3734" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3673">50</a> Watkins did not make the squad and may have injured his arm in the process.<a id="calibre_link-3735" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3674">51</a></p>
<p class="body">By late July, Watkins found his home with the Nebraska Indians.<a id="calibre_link-3736" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3675">52</a> Founded in 1897, the Native American squad was one of the top barnstorming teams in the nation prior to World War I. Capitalizing on the American public’s fascination with Native Americans and the rapidly disappearing Wild West, the Nebraska Indians would entertain spectators with ball tricks, gags, and stereotyped “Indian” behavior like war whoops. Green gave players “Indian names” and created stories about them. Often these tales were filled with gross exaggerations based on ethnic stereotypes. Naomas, an ancient outfielder, could regenerate limbs after injury, and Juzicanea slept on the ground and ate only raw meat.<a id="calibre_link-3737" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3676">53</a> When they arrived in town, captain Dan Tobey would dress as a clown and lead the players in buckskin and headdresses through the town streets in a parade to the ballpark. At night they would pitch tepees and camp on the ballfields, living “in true savage style.” Spectators loved the act, and the Indians became one of the most popular squads on the barnstorming circuit.<a id="calibre_link-3738" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3677">54</a></p>
<p class="body">But the squad was not just a circus show. The team contained some of the best Native American players in the country. Each season the Indians would travel throughout the US, playing about 150 games against town teams and other independent clubs. From 1897 until 1914, the team put up a record of 1237 wins, 336 losses, and 11 ties.<a id="calibre_link-3739" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3678">55</a></p>
<p class="body">In 1912 Green sold the team to James E. Beltzer. Beltzer attempted to make the team even more “Indian.” His players went by stereotypical names, such as White Bull, Little Deer, and Sweetgrass. He adopted uniforms that looked like buckskin with fringe, and players would often wear full-feathered headdresses. Watkins, playing under the name Big Chief, became one of the team’s top pitchers. He finished the 1914 season with the club and then, after an unsuccessful tryout with the Muscatine (Iowa) Muskies of the Central Association the following April, rejoined the Indians in May 1915. According to the <em>Muscatine Journal,</em> that season he started 37 games, winning 28. The records of the Indians after 1914 are not available, but newspaper advertisements and articles feature “Big Chief” as one of the club’s marquee players. Watkins continued pitching for the Indians until the team disbanded in 1918.<a id="calibre_link-3740" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3679">56</a></p>
<p class="body">By 1920, Watkins had married Louise Galloy (1898-1971) and moved to Chicago.<a id="calibre_link-3741" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3680">57</a> The couple had two children: William L. (born 1921) and Charles (born 1924).<a id="calibre_link-3742" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3681">58</a> William L. served as a pilot in World War II and was killed in a plane crash off the island of Kwajalein in the Pacific Ocean on September 26, 1950.<a id="calibre_link-3743" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3682">59</a> Charles died in 2009 with no known offspring.</p>
<p class="body">While in Chicago, Watkins worked as a machinist for the Acme Steel Company.<a id="calibre_link-3744" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3683">60</a> He continued to pitch for semipro clubs into the mid-1930s and, according to his obituary, barnstormed with Jim Thorpe (although the date and team of this tour is not yet identified).<a id="calibre_link-3745" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3684">61</a> William Watkins died on November 8, 1966.</p>
<p><em><strong>ROBERT FITTS&#8217;s</strong> articles have appeared in numerous journals, magazines, and websites. He is also the author of 10 books on Japanese baseball and Japanese baseball cards. Fitts is the founder of SABR’s Asian Baseball Committee and a recipient of the society’s 2025 Chadwick Award; the 2013 Seymour Medal for the Best Baseball Book of 2012 (Banzai Babe Ruth); the 2019 and 2023 McFarland-SABR Baseball Research Awards; the 2012 Doug Pappas Award for the best oral research presentation at the annual convention; and the 2006, 2021, 2023, and 2024 SABR Research Awards. He has twice been a finalist for the Casey Award and has received two silver medals at the Independent Publisher Book Awards. His latest book, In the Japanese Ballpark, will be released in November 2025.</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Notes</strong></p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3624" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3685">1</a></span> “Little Brown Men Cannot Put Twist on a Baseball and Abandon Great Game,” <span class="italic">Reno Evening Gazette</span>, October 27, 1908: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3625" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3686">2</a></span> Besides the examples discussed in the chapter, William “Chief Chouneau” Cadreau pitched for the Seattle Nippon against Keio University on April 9, 1914. “Redskin Is a Good Jap,” <span class="italic">Seattle Star</span>, April 10, 1914: 21.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3626" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3687">3</a></span> R.S. Ranson, “A New Departure. An Epoch-Making Game of Base Ball,” <em>Sporting Life</em>, June 10, 1905: 19.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3627" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3688">4</a></span> “Orientals Win Ball Game from the Aborigines,” <span class="italic">Los Angeles</span> <span class="italic">Examiner</span>, May 21, 1905: 41.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3628" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3689">5</a></span> “Wiry Japs Wallop Reds,” <span class="italic">Los Angeles</span> <span class="italic">Times</span>, May 21, 1905: III 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3629" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3690">6</a></span> “Jap Team Scalps Sherman Braves,” <span class="italic">Los Angeles</span> <span class="italic">Herald</span>, May 21, 1905: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3630" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3691">7</a></span> “Jap Team Scalps Sherman Braves.”</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3631" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3692">8</a></span> “Orientals Win Ball Game from the Aborigines.”</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3632" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3693">9</a></span> “Jap Team Scalps Sherman Braves”; “Wiry Japs Wallop Reds”; “Orientals Win Ball Game from the Aborigines.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3633" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3694">10</a></span> “Jap Team Scalps Sherman Braves.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3634" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3695">11</a></span> “Orientals Win Ball Game from the Aborigines.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3635" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3696">12</a></span> Yoichi Nagata, Robert K. Fitts, and Mark Brunke, “The 1921 Native American Tours of Japan,” in Robert K. Fitts, Bill Nowlin, and James Forr, eds., <span class="italic">Nichibei Yakyu: US Tours of Japan, Volume I: 1907-1958</span> (Phoenix: Society for American Baseball Research, 2022), 87-101.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3636" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3697">13</a></span> “The Japanese Ball Players,” <span class="italic">Covington</span> (Indiana) <span class="italic">Friend</span>, June 22, 1906: 4.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3637" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3698">14</a></span> Robert K. Fitts, <span class="italic">Issei Baseball</span> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2020), 83-85.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3638" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3699">15</a></span> Guy W. Green (Jeffery P. Beck, ed.), <span class="italic">The Nebraska Indians and Fun and Frolic with an Indian Ball Team</span> (Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland, 2010), 117-18.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3639" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3700">16</a></span> Green, 117-18.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3640" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3701">17</a></span> Masaru Akahori, <span class="italic">Nanka Nihonjin Yakyushi</span> [History <span class="italic">of Japanese Baseball in Southern California</span>] (Los Angeles: Town Crier, 1956), 17-21.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3641" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3702">18</a></span> Fitts, 88-89.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3642" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3703">19</a></span> Fitts, 109.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3643" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3704">20</a></span> Fitts, 130-145.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3644" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3705">21</a></span> “Japanese Baseball Star Proves to Be an Indian,” <em>Los Angeles Times</em>, May 11, 1911: Sec. 3, 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3645" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3706">22</a></span> “Death Notices and Funeral Arrangements,” <span class="italic">South End</span> (Chicago) <span class="italic">Reporter</span>, November 16, 1966: 34; <span class="italic">Sherman Institute Registration Ledger (Number 7)</span>, Sherman Indian Museum Collection, <a class="calibre2" href="http://Calisphere.org">Calisphere.org</a>, 54, <a class="calibre2" href="https://calisphere.org/item/ark:/86086/n20c4x81/">https://calisphere.org/item/ark:/86086/n20c4x81/</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3646" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3707">23</a></span> “W.W. Watkins,” <span class="italic">The Sporting News Baseball Players Contract Cards Collection</span>, LA84 Foundation, <a class="calibre2" href="https://digital.la84.org/digital/collection/p17103coll3/id/175985/rec/7">https://digital.la84.org/digital/collection/p17103coll3/id/175985/rec/7</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3647" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3708">24</a></span> “Maroons Annex Opening Game of Season,” <span class="italic">Las Vegas</span> (New Mexico) <span class="italic">Daily Optic</span>, May 17, 1911: 3; “Honorable Trinidads Bingo Honorable Cork Center Very Much Japanese Boys No Can Hit Same,” <span class="italic">Trinidad</span> (Colorado) <span class="italic">Chronicle-News</span>, May 22, 1911: 1-2; “Japanese Will Never Beat Yankees at Ball,” <span class="italic">Hutchinson</span> (Kansas) <span class="italic">Daily Gazette</span>, May 25, 1911: 3; “Japs Won Out,” <span class="italic">Strong City</span> (Kansas) <span class="italic">News Current</span>, June 1, 1911: 8; “Greenfield Humbles Japan,” <span class="italic">Greenfield</span> (Illinois) <span class="italic">Argus</span>, June 9, 1911: 7; “Base Ball at Pavilion Park,” <span class="italic">Henry</span> (Illinois) <span class="italic">Times</span>, June 22, 1911: 1; “Base Ball News,” <span class="italic">Cuba</span> (Illinois) <span class="italic">Journal</span>, June 29, 1911: 1; “Potters Gain Victory in Ninth,” <span class="italic">Macomb</span> (Illinois) <span class="italic">Daily Journal</span>, July 3, 1911: 8; “The Japs Lost Out,” <span class="italic">Quincy</span> (Illinois) <span class="italic">Daily Herald</span>, July 10, 1911: 5; “Company L Whips Jap Team 4 to 1,” <span class="italic">Keokuk</span> (Iowa) <span class="italic">Daily Gate</span>, July 14, 1911: 6; “Japanese Trim Locals Sunday,” <span class="italic">Fort Madison</span> (Iowa) <span class="italic">Evening Democrat</span>, July 17, 1911: 7; “Home Team Victorious,” <span class="italic">Fairfield</span> (Iowa) <span class="italic">Weekly Journal</span>, July 19, 1911: 4; “[Illegible] Ball Team Versus Locals,” <span class="italic">Washington</span> (Iowa) <span class="italic">Evening Journal</span>, July 22, 1911: 3; “Marion Win Game from Japs,” <span class="italic">Cedar Rapids</span> (Iowa) <span class="italic">Evening Gazette</span>, July 28, 1911: 9; “Oelwein Won Over the Japs Sunday,” <span class="italic">Oelwein</span> (Iowa) <span class="italic">Daily Register</span>, July 31, 1911: 4; “Base Ball Results,” <span class="italic">Boone</span> (Iowa) <span class="italic">News Republican</span>, August 7, 1911: 5; “Suzuki Scores and Japs Win,” <span class="italic">Centerville</span> (Iowa) <span class="italic">Daily Citizen</span>, August 19, 1911: 4; “Nipponese Are Given Trimming,” <span class="italic">Council Bluffs</span> (Iowa) <span class="italic">Daily Nonpareil</span>, August 27, 1911: 6; “Semi-Pros and Amateurs,” <em>Des Moines Register</em>, August 29, 1911: 9; “Japs Defeated by All Stars,” <span class="italic">Des Moines Daily News</span>, September 4, 1911: 8; “Giants Meet Japs Today,” <span class="italic">St. Louis Star and Times</span>, September 27, 1911: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3648" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3709">25</a></span> “The Japs Lost Out.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3649" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3710">26</a></span> “Suzuki Scores and Japs Win.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3650" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3711">27</a></span> “Giants Meet Japs Today.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3651" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3712">28</a></span> “George Pitches in Clever Style Against Cards,” <span class="italic">St. Louis Post-Dispatch</span>, October 15, 1911: 37.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3652" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3713">29</a></span> “Sherman vs. Nine Stars,” <span class="italic">Riverside</span> (California) <span class="italic">Daily Press</span>, December 30, 1911: 3; “Rain Prevented Crew from Playing Third Game with Akron Yesterday; Another Pitcher from Cardinals,” <span class="italic">Erie Daily Times</span>, April 30, 1912: 20.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3653" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3714">30</a></span> “Rain Prevented Crew from Playing Third Game with Akron Yesterday; Another Pitcher from Cardinals.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3654" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3715">31</a></span> “Chief Watkins,” <span class="italic">Erie Daily Times</span>, May 8, 1912: 12.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3655" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3716">32</a></span> “Chief Watkins Arrived Today,” <span class="italic">Erie Daily Times</span>, May 7, 1912: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3656" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3717">33</a></span> “Sport Notes,” <span class="italic">Erie Daily Times</span>, May 16, 1912: 15.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3657" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3718">34</a></span> “Youngstown Runs Off with First Game,” <span class="italic">Erie Daily Times</span>, May 16, 1912: 15.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3658" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3719">35</a></span> “Sailors Win Third of Series in Game Featured by Brilliant Fielding and Schang’s Throwing,” <span class="italic">Erie Daily Times</span>, May 21, 1912: 11.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3659" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3720">36</a></span> “Sport Notes,” <span class="italic">Erie Daily Times</span>, May 21, 1912: 12.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3660" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3721">37</a></span> “Fort Wayne’s Indian,” <span class="italic">Fort Wayne Weekly Sentinel,</span> May 8, 1913: Sports 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3661" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3722">38</a></span> “Champs Take Last Game from Sailors Very Easily,” <span class="italic">Akron Beacon Journal</span>, July 12, 1912: 16.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3662" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3723">39</a></span> “Spokane Put Indian Sign on Former Teammate,” <span class="italic">Vancouver World</span>, July 25, 1912: 12; “Spokane Takes Last Two Baseball Games,” <span class="italic">Vancouver World</span>, July 29, 1912: 15; Lou Schroeder, “Independent Games,” <span class="italic">San Francisco Examiner</span>, August 25, 1912: 93.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3663" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3724">40</a></span> “Burke Ready to Take His Place,” <em>Fort Wayne Sentinel</em>, May 9, 1913: 5.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3664" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3725">41</a></span> “Burke Ready to Take His Place.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3665" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3726">42</a></span> “Bilikeners Suffer First Shut-Out of Season; Atkins Yanked in Favor of Chief Watkins, Who Goes Great,” <span class="italic">Fort Wayne Journal Gazette</span>, May 17, 1913: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3666" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3727">43</a></span> “Springfield Crowd Does Murder and Downs Biliken Gang, 18-7: Chief Watkins Is Handed a Fierce Drubbing,” <span class="italic">Fort Wayne Journal Gazette</span>, May 23, 1913: 14.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3667" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3728">44</a></span> “Springfield Crowd Does Murder and Downs Biliken Gang, 18-7: Chief Watkins Is Handed a Fierce Drubbing.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3668" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3729">45</a></span> Watkins to Get Another Chance, <span class="italic">Fort Wayne Sentinel,</span> May 23, 1913: 15.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3669" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3730">46</a></span> “Interstate Men Are Getting Busy,” <span class="italic">New Castle</span> (Pennsylvania) <span class="italic">News</span>, July 19, 1913: 9.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3670" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3731">47</a></span> “Indian Pitcher Beats Vets,” <span class="italic">Flint</span> (Michigan) <span class="italic">Journal</span>, July 21, 1913: 10; “The Figures,” <span class="italic">Jackson</span> (Michigan) <span class="italic">Citizens Press</span>, July 25, 1913: 13.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3671" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3732">48</a></span> “Senators Cannot Stop Crickets,” <span class="italic">Kalamazoo Gazette</span>, July 30, 1913: 6; “Beavers Take Series From Battle Creek,” <span class="italic">Kalamazoo Gazette</span>, August 6, 1913: 6; “Ducks Are Defeated by Crickets, 9 to 2,” <span class="italic">Kalamazoo Gazette</span>, August 7, 1913: 6; “Vallandingham Holds Crickets to Three Hits,” <span class="italic">Flint Daily Journal</span>, August 20, 1913: 10; “Double Header in Foodtown Divided,” <span class="italic">Kalamazoo Gazette</span>, August 24, 1913: 10; “Errors Give Game to Battle Creek,” <span class="italic">Kalamazoo Gazette</span>, August 27, 1913: 6; “Kazool Take Third Game From Adrian/Final Contest of the Year With Tots Sees Good Baseball,” <span class="italic">Kalamazoo Gazette</span>, August 29, 1913: 6; “Sandlotters Are Again the Heroes,” <span class="italic">Kalamazoo Gazette</span>, September 7, 1913: 7.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3672" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3733">49</a></span> Associated Press, “Jackson Club Signs Watkins,” <span class="italic">Bay City</span> (Michigan) <span class="italic">Daily Tribune</span>, March 3, 1914: 6.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3673" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3734">50</a></span> “Myersmen Return Wednesday for Five Games at Keeley Park/Toledo and Flint Come for Series,” <span class="italic">Jackson</span> (Michigan) <span class="italic">Citizen Patriot</span>, May 19, 1914: 7.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3674" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3735">51</a></span> “Strong Team to Oppose Indians Next Sunday,” <span class="italic">Montgomery</span> (Alabama) <span class="italic">Advertiser</span>, July 31, 1914: 9.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3675" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3736">52</a></span> “Strong Team to Oppose Indians Next Sunday.”</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3676" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3737">53</a></span> Green, 105-09, 117-18.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3677" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3738">54</a></span> Jeffrey P. Beck, “Introduction,” in Green, xviii.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3678" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3739">55</a></span> Beck, xvii.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3679" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3740">56</a></span> Beck, xxxvii-xliii.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3680" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3741">57</a></span> 1920 United States Federal Census, Enumeration District 604, Chicago Ward 9, Cook County, Illinois, Roll: T625_312: 1B.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3681" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3742">58</a></span> 1930 United States Federal Census, Enumeration District: 388, Chicago Ward 9, Cook County, Illinois, FHL Microfilm: 2340165: 6B.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3682" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3743">59</a></span> “Local Nay Pilot Dies in Crash Off Kwajalein,” <span class="italic">Suburbanite Economist</span> (Chicago), September 27, 1950: 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3683" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3744">60</a></span> “William Watkins,” U.S. World War II Draft Registration Cards, 1942, <a class="calibre2" href="http://Ancestry.com">Ancestry.com</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3684" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3745">61</a></span> “Heights Hammers Harvey to Sleep,” <span class="italic">Chicago Heights Star</span>, August 24, 1922: 1; “Durand 11, Chalmers-Hamilton 2,” <span class="italic">Chicago Heights Star</span>, May 31, 1923: 10; “Notes from the Diamond,” <span class="italic">Chicago Star Publications</span>, August 2, 1923: 2; “H.P. Elks Defeat Evanston Giants,” <span class="italic">Highland Park Press</span>, July 15, 1926: 7; “Baseball Extra!” <span class="italic">Riverdale</span> (Illinois) <span class="italic">Pointer</span>, June 18, 1926: 5; “St. Cyril Blank Colts in Final Game of Season,” <span class="italic">Blue Island</span> (Illinois) <span class="italic">Sun Standard</span>, October 4, 1935: 6: “Death Notices and Funeral Arrangements.”</p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Indigenous Baseball in the Northeastern Borderlands: From Lou Sockalexis to Charlie Paul</title>
		<link>https://sabr.org/journal/article/indigenous-baseball-in-the-northeastern-borderlands-from-lou-sockalexis-to-charlie-paul-2/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[wpadmin]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 07:12:39 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://sabr.org/?post_type=journal_articles&#038;p=325912</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Joe Neptune, a nephew of Lou Sockalexis, played minor-league and semipro baseball for over three decades in the northeastern borderlands. (Baltimore Sun, June 5, 1923) &#160; In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, baseball was a common pursuit among Indigenous peoples in the Northeastern borderlands. In Maine, competitive native clubs organized at Sipayik (Pleasant [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="calibre_link-104" class="calibre1">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000068.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Joe Neptune, a nephew of Lou Sockalexis, played minor-league and semipro baseball for over three decades in the northeastern borderlands. (Baltimore Sun, June 5, 1923)</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="first-paragraph">In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, baseball was a common pursuit among Indigenous peoples in the Northeastern borderlands. In Maine, competitive native clubs organized at Sipayik (Pleasant Point Reservation), near Old Town, at the Peter Dana Point Reservation and Indian Township, and elsewhere along the Penobscot River among Penobscot peoples. All-Maine Indian baseball championships date from the late nineteenth century. A regional cross-border championship including Maliseet clubs from New Brunswick became a fixture of the interwar years.<a id="calibre_link-3771" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3748">1</a> The Maliseets, who occupied territory on both sides of the border around Houlton, Maine, and in New Brunswick at Woodstock, Richibucto, and Tobique, fashioned a solid baseball reputation. The Richibucto Braves, for example, were regional champions on more than one occasion between the wars.<a id="calibre_link-3772" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3749">2</a> Farther east, the Mi’kmaq peoples in Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island actively involved themselves in the game and occasionally played other Indigenous teams in New Brunswick, Quebec, and Maine.<a id="calibre_link-3773" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3750">3</a></p>
<p class="body">At a time when movement across the Canadian-American border was uncomplicated, Indigenous teams competed against semipro teams and town teams on both sides of the line. Traveling by large motorboat up the coast into New Brunswick, for example, the Dana Point Nine Red Aces were frequent participants in matches against Grand Manan Island during Canada’s Dominion Day celebrations.<a id="calibre_link-3774" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3751">4</a> Even before the First World War, members of the Dana, Mitchell, Francis, Neptune, Sockalexis, Sabbatus, Ranco, Paul, and Sacobasin families were well known in semipro baseball in the Northeast, following in the shadow of the legendary Louis Sockalexis from Indian Island, Maine, who had a brief career with Cleveland of the National League.</p>
<p class="body">One of the most iconic Indigenous athletes of the first half of the twentieth century – along with multisport star Jim Thorpe and Canadian long-distance runner Tom Longboat – Lou Sockalexis was part of a celebrity triumvirate of First Nations athletes in the years before World War I. A hard-hitting outfielder, known for speed in the outfield and on the bases and a powerful arm that could throw 350 feet on a line to home plate, he played college ball at Ricker College in Bangor before attending Holy Cross. Sockalexis had a brief major-league career with Cleveland, hitting .313 over three seasons.</p>
<p class="body">For a dozen years after retiring from major-league baseball, Sockalexis continued to play semipro ball in Maine and New Brunswick. In 1911 he retired as an active player and joined the independent New Brunswick-Maine league’s umpiring contingent. He continued to officiate through the 1913 season, when the league affiliated with Organized Baseball. Later that same year, Sockalexis suffered a fatal heart attack while working in a lumber camp near Old Town. He was 42 years old.</p>
<p class="body">Although Sockalexis was the only Indigenous player from the borderlands to fashion a big-league career, there were others who went on to play in the minor leagues and on independent semipro teams in the Northeast. One of those was Joe Neptune, a nephew of the big leaguer from the same Indian Island community. In his teens Neptune attended the Carlisle Indian School in Pennsylvania and played with amateur teams throughout New England, including the highly regarded Lynn Amateur Athletic club. In 1907 he began his career in Organized Baseball with Lewiston of the Class-D Maine State League, playing alongside team captain Bill “Rough” Carrigan. Only 15, he was considered a “coming rival of Sockalexis,” who also played in the league that year. Of their first encounter, the <em>Lewiston</em> (Maine) <em>Daily Sun</em> reported that “Big Chief Neptune swung hard, sending the ball out into right field where it was eaten up by Sockalexis.”<a id="calibre_link-3775" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3752">5</a></p>
<p class="body">Despite his early entry into Organized Baseball, Neptune spent the next six years playing on semipro clubs in Maine, New Brunswick, and as far away as Glace Bay, Nova Scotia. He occasionally turned down opportunities to play for teams in the New England and Eastern Leagues since borderland teams in mill towns and fishing and mining communities often offered salaries that exceeded those in the minor leagues. Two other native performers – pitchers Sam Sacobasin and Henry “Chief” Mitchell – were also sought after by a number of clubs along the border. When a newly formed New Brunswick-Maine League, flooded with former and future big-leaguers, opened play in 1911, Neptune, Sacobasin, and Mitchell joined the border towns of Woodstock, St. Stephen, and Calais-St. Croix. The <em>Bangor Daily News</em> dubbed Mitchell a “real find” for the Calais club.<a id="calibre_link-3776" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3753">6</a></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<div class="au_image">
<div class="image"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000069.jpg" alt="" /></div>
<p class="caption"><em>Charlie Paul was one of the finest indigenous ballplayers in Canada during the 1920s. (Courtesy of the Nova Scotia Sport Hall of Fame)</em></p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="body">Although there were close connections between Indigenous baseball in Maine and New Brunswick, Mi’kmaq communities in Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island had taken to the game as well.<a id="calibre_link-3777" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3754">7</a> As early as August 1877, the <em>Acadian Recorder</em> reported that a Mi’kmaw baseball team played a “white” team in Halifax.<a id="calibre_link-3778" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3755">8</a> Over the next quarter-century, baseball appeared on Nova Scotian reserves at Bear River, Eskasoni, Chapel Island, Barra Head, Shubenacadie (Indian Brook), Milbrook, Big Cove, and Lennox Island in Prince Edward Island.</p>
<p class="body">Although baseball became the sport of choice, it existed alongside other bat-and-ball games that were more inclusive. One of these, Old Pussum or Old Fashion, resembled the British game of rounders with players running clockwise and being retired when hit by the thrown ball. This traditional game was played for decades, at least until World War II. Mi’kmaq elder John Basque recalled that when the war ended, “the year I got out, about ’45 or ’46, I had a team two years.”<a id="calibre_link-3779" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3756">9</a> With the growing popularity of softball as a social game, Old Pussum was no longer the only alternative to the more competitive game of baseball on reserves in Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island.<a id="calibre_link-3780" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3757">10</a></p>
<p class="body">Although there are few specific newspaper references before World War I to individual Mi’kmaq players, sport was a central component of life on the reserves, and traditional craftsmen produced necessary equipment. Already in the late nineteenth century, Mi’kmaq carvers were internationally acclaimed for producing both baseball bats and hockey sticks. In the 1890s the Starr Manufacturing Company in Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, began producing trademarked “Mic-Mac” handmade hockey sticks for the North American market, advertising in newspapers across the continent by 1900. Hockey and baseball clubs from Smith Falls, Ontario, to Vernon, British Columbia, adopted the name “Mic-Macs” as their team name.<a id="calibre_link-3781" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3758">11</a> Maliseet craftsmen also produced baseball bats, lacrosse sticks, and axe handles, but the reputation of Mi’kmaq bat and stick makers was unrivaled.</p>
<p class="body">The Mi’kmaw reputation for sporting craftmanship likely explains why the A.G. Spalding Company published <em>Altjematimgeol. Spalding’s Baseball Rules in Micmac</em> as part of its 1912 baseball publications.<a id="calibre_link-3782" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3759">12</a> Not only did the publication of baseball rules in the Mi’kmaq language clearly demarcate the game from more informal games such as Old Pussum, but furthered Spalding’s mission to expand the reach of the game. <em>The Spalding Canadian Baseball Guide</em> that same year provided a cross-country survey of baseball with a substantial section on the Maritimes and its connections across the border in New England.<a id="calibre_link-3783" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3760">13</a> Although there was shared interest, there is no evidence of the Spalding Company’s appropriation and distribution of Mi’kmaw-crafted equipment.</p>
<p class="body">The most accomplished Indigenous player in Northeastern North America after World War I was Charlie Paul, a Mi’kmaq left-handed pitcher from Springhill, Nova Scotia. Paul grew up playing for the Springhill town team during the war, but quickly developed a reputation as one of the most talented moundsmen in all of the Maritimes and New England. At the time he also worked in a colliery, going underground during the day, washing off the coal dust and heading to the ballfield for games late in the afternoon. Paul’s exploits over the next decade rivaled those of Jimmy Rattlesnake, who subsequently fashioned a marvelous career on the Prairies during the 1930s and has been recently inducted into the Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame. It is fair to say that Rattlesnake and Paul were the two finest Indigenous players in Canada between the wars.<a id="calibre_link-3784" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3761">14</a></p>
<p class="body">In 1919 Paul began the season at home but was later recruited to play for Dominion Colliery in the semipro Cape Breton League. Paid on a game-by-game basis, he dominated batters and averaged a dozen strikeouts per game despite working a regular day shift as a coal miner. After an appearance in Halifax, a reporter for the <em>Halifax Evening Mail</em> wrote that Paul “had the ‘Indian sign’ on the locals,” striking out the first five batters who faced him, and adding, “With his wonderful cross-fire [screwball] and fast ball he looked like a million dollars.”<a id="calibre_link-3785" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3762">15</a></p>
<p class="body">For a while Paul’s stuff was so dynamic that his catchers had difficulty holding on to his pitches, but this was remedied when Dominion recruited catcher Ralph Hall, who was playing in Detroit at the time. The two were batterymates for a number of years after that. Paul’s subsequent success against barnstorming Black clubs and others from the Boston twilight leagues quickly attracted the attention of big-league teams. A scout who had closely followed his career urged Boston Braves manager George Stallings to offer him a contract, comparing him to former big-leaguer Rube Waddell from the mining districts of Pennsylvania.<a id="calibre_link-3786" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3763">16</a></p>
<p class="body">When Stallings resigned as Braves manager at the end of the 1920 season and took on the same job with the Rochester Colts, his first priority was acquiring Paul as his left-handed starter. Rochester business manager Harry Hapgood sent ace pitcher Jack Wisner to Cape Breton to get Paul’s signature on a contract and accompany him to spring training in Darlington, South Carolina. After a few days, however, it became clear that Paul would not sign.<a id="calibre_link-3787" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3764">17</a> “Bright Light Is no Magnet for Indian Pitcher,” read a headline in the <em>Baltimore Sun</em>. The best that Wisner could get was an agreement that if Paul signed to play professional ball in the future, it would be with Rochester. He played instead with New Waterford of the three-cornered Cape Breton professional league, winning 16 games against only 4 losses during the 1921 season.<a id="calibre_link-3788" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3765">18</a></p>
<p class="body">The following spring Paul was courted again, this time by new Braves skipper Fred Mitchell, who received glowing reports from former big-leaguer Andy O’Connor and other Boston-area players who played against him in Cape Breton.<a id="calibre_link-3789" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3766">19</a> Aware of Paul’s reluctance to travel on his own, the Braves arranged for an escort to Boston, where he joined Braves executives, manager Mitchell and a half-dozen players for a train ride to spring training on the Federal Express. Competing for a job as a left-handed specialist against veteran Rube Marquard and young John Cooney, Paul had a good spring. Mitchell was “greatly impressed with his style” but the Braves decided to keep Marquard and Cooney.<a id="calibre_link-3790" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3767">20</a> Paul asked for and was granted his unconditional release so that he could return home to play for New Waterford. Over the next decade, Paul played a starring role with a number of teams in the Maritimes and New England and was subsequently inducted into the Nova Scotia Sport Hall of Fame.<a id="calibre_link-3791" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3768">21</a></p>
<p class="body">After his baseball career, Paul continued working as a coal miner. In August 1953 a cave-in at the 11,800-foot level in a Springhill mine took his life along with those of six others.<a id="calibre_link-3792" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3769">22</a> By that time baseball had been largely eclipsed by softball on reserves in the Maritimes and was in decline among Indigenous communities in Maine.<a id="calibre_link-3793" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3770">23</a> Today the rich history of baseball in Indigenous communities throughout the region has faded into a dim memory.</p>
<p><em><strong>COLIN HOWELL</strong> is Professor Emeritus (History) at Saint Mary’s University in Halifax, Nova Scotia. He is the author of Northern Sandlots (University of Toronto Press, 1995) and Hardscrabble Diamonds. Postwar Baseball in New England and the Maritimes (McFarland Publishers, 2023).</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Notes</strong></p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3748" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3771">1</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Lewiston</span></em> (Maine) <span class="italic"><em>Sun Journal</em>,</span> June 20, 1927: 8.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3749" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3772">2</a></span> <span class="italic"><em>Ottawa Journal</em>,</span> October 7, 1939: 13<span class="italic">.</span></p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3750" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3773">3</a></span> Colin D. Howell, <em><span class="italic">Northern Sandlots. A Social History of Maritime Baseball</span></em> (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1995) provides a more extensive look at Indigenous baseball in the Maritimes. See especially Chapter 9, “The ‘Others’”; Jeffrey P. Powers-Beck, <em><span class="italic">The American Indian Integration of Baseball</span></em> (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2009), 18-19.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3751" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3774">4</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Bangor</span></em> (Maine) <em><span class="italic">Daily News</span></em>, June 20, 1917: 8; July 4, 1925: 6; June 7, 1927: 16.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3752" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3775">5</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Lewiston Daily Sun</span></em>, June 3, 1907: 6. The nickname “Chief” was widespread for players of Indigenous origin. Jeffrey Powers Beck, “‘Chief.’ The American Integration of Baseball, 1897-1945,” <em><span class="italic">American Indian Quarterly</span></em>, Vol. 25 (Autumn, 2001): 508-38.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3753" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3776">6</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Bangor Daily News</span></em>, July 15, 1911: 3.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3754" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3777">7</a></span> In Mi’kmaq, the word Mi’kmaw is an adjective, while Mi’kmaq is the noun.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3755" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3778">8</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Acadian Recorder</span></em> (Halifax, Nova Scotia), August 7, 1877: 4.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3756" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3779">9</a></span> Howell, <em><span class="italic">Northern Sand</span><span class="italic">lots</span></em>, 189.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3757" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3780">10</a></span> Quoted in Howell, <em><span class="italic">Northern Sandlots</span></em>, 189. Basque’s remarks are drawn from a series of interviews with Mi’kmaq people by anthropologist Trudy Sable as part of this project on Indigenous bat-and-ball games in the Maritimes.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3758" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3781">11</a></span> See, for example, the <em><span class="italic">Halifax Herald</span></em>, December 29, 1900: 8; <em><span class="italic">Merrickville Star</span></em> (Merrickville-Wolford, Ontario), March 2, 1905: 8; <em><span class="italic">Vernon</span></em> (British Columbia) <em><span class="italic">News</span></em>, January 10, 1907: 5. Similar advertisements appeared in newspapers across Canada and the United States.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3759" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3782">12</a></span> <span class="italic">Altjematimgeol</span>. <em><span class="italic">Spalding’s Baseball Rules in Micmac</span></em> (Rimouskie, Quebec: Spalding Publishers, 1912).</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3760" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3783">13</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Spalding’s Official Canadian Baseball Guide, 1912</span></em> (Montreal: Canadian Sports Publishing).</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3761" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3784">14</a></span> “Bright Lights No Magnet for Indian Pitcher. Charlie Paul Turns Down Offer from George Stallings,” <em><span class="italic">Baltimore Sun</span></em>, March 20, 1921: 89.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3762" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3785">15</a></span> <span class="italic"><em>Halifax Evening Mail</em>,</span> August 25, 1919: 8.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3763" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3786">16</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Springfield</span></em> (Massachusetts) <span class="italic"><em>Union</em>,</span> December 1, 1921: 17.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3764" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3787">17</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Rochester Democrat and Chronicle</span></em>, March 6, 1922: 20.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3765" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3788">18</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Rochester Democrat and Chronicle</span></em>, March 6, 1922: 20.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3766" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3789">19</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Tampa Bay Times</span></em>, March 7, 1922: 7; “Pro Baseball Thrives in Cape Breton. Imported Americans Are Bolstering Up Dominion, Waterford and Glace Bay Teams,” <span class="italic"><em>Halifax Evening Mail</em>,</span> July 23, 1921: 8.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3767" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3790">20</a></span> <span class="italic"><em>Halifax Evening Mail</em>,</span> March 8, 1922: 8; <em>Boston Globe</em>, March 30, 1922: 16.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3768" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3791">21</a></span> Charles Elbert “Charlie” Paul, <span class="italic">Nova Scotia Sport Hall of Fame</span>. <a class="calibre2" href="https://nsshf.com">https://nsshf.com</a>.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3769" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3792">22</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Montreal Star</span></em>, August 25, 1953: 1.</p>
<p class="endnotes1"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3770" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3793">23</a></span> <em><span class="italic">Bangor Daily News</span></em>, May 17, 1961: 23.</p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Altjematimgeol: Translating the Spalding Rules of Baseball into the Mi’kmaq Language</title>
		<link>https://sabr.org/journal/article/altjematimgeol-translating-the-spalding-rules-of-baseball-into-the-mikmaq-language/</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[wpadmin]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 16 Oct 2025 07:11:38 +0000</pubDate>
				<guid isPermaLink="false">https://sabr.org/?post_type=journal_articles&#038;p=325913</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[The Spalding Rules booklet in the Mi’qmak language (Courtesy of the Canadian Research Knowledge Network) &#160; As was true in other Indigenous communities elsewhere, native peoples in the northeastern corner of North America played a wide array of traditional stick and ball games that celebrated “The Creator” while enhancing healthful recreation, physical skill, community solidarity [&#8230;]]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="calibre_link-106" class="calibre1">
<p id="calibre_link-107" class="byline"><img decoding="async" class="w1" src="https://sabrweb.b-cdn.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/native-american-major-leaguers-000070.jpg" alt="" /></p>
<div class="au_image">
<p class="caption"><em>The Spalding Rules booklet in the Mi’qmak language (Courtesy of the Canadian Research Knowledge Network)</em></p>
</div>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="first-paragraph">As was true in other Indigenous communities elsewhere, native peoples in the northeastern corner of North America played a wide array of traditional stick and ball games that celebrated “The Creator” while enhancing healthful recreation, physical skill, community solidarity and inclusiveness. In addition to lacrosse – by far the most ubiquitous Indigenous pastime – the native peoples in Quebec, Labrador, and farther north played games that were particularly suited to their environment. The Inuit, for example, played a form of baseball called Anaulataq on an often rocky landscape and sometimes on ice. To the south, the Mi’kmaq in Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, and Prince Edward Island played Oochamkunutk, a traditional stick and ball game, in the summer, and when the winter came switched to a form of hurley on ice that they called Alchamadijik.</p>
<p class="body">Over the years Mi’kmaq and Maliseet craftsmen in the Maritimes and Maine became especially proficient in fashioning both hockey sticks and baseball bats. Before the end of the nineteenth century, Mi’kmaq carvers had already developed an international reputation for the sticks they carved from the roots of alder and yellow birch trees. These lightweight hockey sticks, trademarked as the “Mic-Mac” hockey stick, were distributed across North America along with skates by the Starr Manufacturing Company of Dartmouth, Nova Scotia. Mi’kmaq craftsmen and the Starr hockey skate developed a reputation of quality in hockey equipment that rivaled that of the Spalding Company and its wide array of sporting goods.<a id="calibre_link-3800" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3796">1</a></p>
<p class="body">This explains to some extent the 1912 publication of <em>Altjematimgeol: The Spalding Baseball Rules in Mic Mac</em>. They were printed in Rimouski, Quebec, with the acknowledged permission of J.E. Sullivan, president of the Spalding Company. There is little indication of the project’s genesis, nor are there the names of those involved in the translation. The book was made available, however, by the manager of the Mi’kmaw baseball club in Rexton, New Brunswick, with the blessing of the Mi’kmaq chief at Burnt Cove.</p>
<p class="body">Obviously a 31-page translation like this would have involved considerable time and effort, and it remains a wonderful resource for those interested in studying and maintaining the Mi’kmaq language and Indigenous sporting life.<a id="calibre_link-3801" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3797">2</a> For the Spalding Company, the project was clearly in keeping with its broader interest in widening the acceptance and development of the sport and expanding the market for its sporting equipment. It also enhanced its array of baseball publications that included the annual official Baseball Guides and Spalding’s Baseball Rules. Spalding had an extensive sporting library at the time related to football, hockey, basketball, baseball, and beyond that to include physical culture, gymnastics, and healthful exercise.<a id="calibre_link-3802" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3798">3</a></p>
<p class="body">The publication of baseball rules in the Mi’kmaq language was important in delineating the difference between baseball and other stick and ball games that were played in Indigenous communities at the time. In the early 1990s, cultural anthropologist Trudy Sable was a research assistant on a project on Maritimes baseball funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. Working from the Gorsebrook Institute at Saint Mary’s University in Halifax, Sable undertook a number of interviews with Mi’kmaq elders on traditional stick and ball games like Old Pussum (Old Fashioned).</p>
<p class="body">Although the game’s origins are obscure, it was notable for its inclusion of everyone in the community, young and old, male and female, and for its celebratory and informal quality. People could enter or leave the game whenever they wished, and it usually ended with a feast. The influence of the British game of rounders was evident in the game’s development over time, with baserunners moving in a clockwise direction and being retired by being hit by the thrown ball.</p>
<p class="body">As baseball became increasingly popular in the last half of the nineteenth century, it diverged from the traditional games like Old Pussum in a number of ways, becoming a competitive rather than communal practice, played by men rather than women and often involving competition with other Indigenous and subsequently non-Indigenous players. As Indigenous players increasingly showed up playing alongside non-Indigenous ballplayers, conformity to the standard rules of the game was absolutely necessary. For Mi’kmaq players, the publication of the Spalding Rules in their own language was a particularly important part of the game’s development in Indigenous communities throughout Maritime Canada.<a id="calibre_link-3803" class="calibre3" href="#calibre_link-3799">4</a></p>
<p><em><strong>COLIN HOWELL</strong> is Professor Emeritus (History) at Saint Mary’s University in Halifax, Nova Scotia. He is the author of Northern Sandlots (University of Toronto Press, 1995) and Hardscrabble Diamonds. Postwar Baseball in New England and the Maritimes (McFarland Publishers, 2023).</em></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p class="source-header"><strong>Notes</strong></p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3796" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3800">1</a></span> See Alan Downey, <em><span class="italic">The Creator’s Game: Lacrosse, Identity and Indigenous Nationhood</span></em> (Vancouver: UBC Press, 2018); Colin Howell and Chris Fletcher, “Modernization Theory and the Traditional Sporting Practices of Native People in Eastern Canada,” <em><span class="italic">Journal of Physical Education and Sport</span> 19</em> (2), 1997: 79-84; Garth Vaughan, <em><span class="italic">The Puck Starts Here. The Origin of Canada’s Great Winter Game. Ice Hockey</span></em> (Fredericton, New Brunswick: Gooseland Publishers, 1996), 138-152.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3797" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3801">2</a></span> <em><span class="italic">ALTJEMATIMGEOL. Spalding’s Base Ball Rules in Mic Mac</span></em> (Rimouski, Quebec: Imprimerie Generale S. Vachon, 1912).</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3798" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3802">3</a></span> In the same year that <em><span class="italic">Altjematimgeol</span></em> appeared, <em><span class="italic">Spalding’s Official 1912 Canadian Base Ball</span> Guide</em> contained a lengthy section on baseball in the Maritimes and New England as well as playing rules and a diagram of a baseball field.</p>
<p class="endnotes"><span class="ntsp"><a id="calibre_link-3799" class="calibre2" href="#calibre_link-3803">4</a></span> This project led to the publication of Colin Howell, <em><span class="italic">Northern Sandlots. A Social History of Maritime Baseball.</span></em> (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1995). Sable’s research provides the foundation for much of Chapter Seven, “The Others,” especially pp. 184-95, which deals with the history of baseball and native people in the Maritimes.</p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
	</channel>
</rss>

<!--
Performance optimized by W3 Total Cache. Learn more: https://www.boldgrid.com/w3-total-cache/?utm_source=w3tc&utm_medium=footer_comment&utm_campaign=free_plugin

Object Caching 51/259 objects using Redis
Page Caching using Disk: Enhanced 
Content Delivery Network via sabrweb.b-cdn.net
Database Caching 3/31 queries in 0.362 seconds using Redis

Served from: sabr.org @ 2026-11-20 11:39:40 by W3 Total Cache
-->