Eddie Milner made a name for himself corralling pitchers’ mistakes with his glove in the outfield and burning up the basepaths with his legs in the 1980s – a name he knows he tarnished by allowing drug use to prematurely end his stay in the game he loved.
Born on May 21, 1955, in Columbus, Ohio, Milner was the fourth of seven children born to Eddie James Milner Sr. and Evangeline Milner. Athletics proved to be a passion for the diminutive speedster; he stood out enough in football to be offered chances to play at Ohio University and was a good enough wrestler the get an offer from the University of Iowa. But it was baseball that was his true calling, and he accepted the opportunity to play at the Division III level with Muskingum College in New Concord, Ohio.
Milner never played an inning for the college, injuring his back while lifting weights during preseason workouts. He returned home to Columbus and went to work in a steel mill. He played in a summer baseball league, where he caught the eye of the coaching staff of Central State University, an NAIA school in Wilberforce, Ohio. He was offered a scholarship, and he played there the next two years, well enough to be invited to work out in front of some professional baseball scouts.
“The coach took me and a few guys to this baseball clinic,” Milner recalled. “I didn't want to go to the clinic, but the guys talked me into it. I had never thought of myself as a professional baseball player, but the scouts told me I had professional skills.”
He was drafted in the 21st round of the 1976 amateur draft by the Cincinnati Reds, who also picked future big leaguers Paul Householder, Bill Dawley, Jay Howell, Tim Laudner, and Pat Sheridan in that draft. Milner signed for “little or nothing because I didn't know how the draft worked.” He was assigned to the Billings (Montana) Mustangs, the Reds Rookie League affiliate in the Pioneer League, where he hit .255 with two home runs and 14 doubles in 67 games. His three triples, 17 stolen bases, and 49 walks were team highs. The Pioneers finished second in the league, going 36-35, and Milner was named to the postseason All-Star team.
He was promoted for the 1977 season to the Shelby Reds, of the Class A Western Carolinas League. His hitting improved to .268-3-30 and he had a team-best 35 stolen bases. Shelby finished fifth with a 60-75 record. The team was at the bottom in attendance.
“Shelby had a gravel outfield,” Milner said. “Their field wasn’t done yet. It didn’t matter to me, but I had to have foot surgery after the season.”
A stop in Tampa, Florida, for the 1978 season brought more all-star accolades for the 23-year-old Milner. He led the Tarpons with 141 hits, a .284 batting average, 79 runs, 16 triples, 28 stolen bases, 55 walks, and 44 runs batted in. The Tarpons finished fourth in the Florida State League’s Northern Division with a 61-73 record.
Milner now was considered a legitimate prospect to become the Reds’ next center fielder, and even though he split the 1979 season between Double-A Nashville (.263-11-56 with 35 steals in 104 games) and Triple-A Indianapolis (.185-0-2 with two steals in 30 games), he got to be around those players who drove the Big Red Machine through their championship years.
“I got to learn from a whole team of superstars,” he said. “I learned a lot from them. They made the game much easier for me.”
Milner opened the 1980 season in the starting outfield of the Indianapolis Indians, and he led the team with seven triples to go along with a .252 batting average and 24 steals. His play earned him a late-season promotion to the big-league club, where he went hitless as a pinch-hitter three times but scored a run as a pinch-runner. After hitting .287, stealing 43 bases and leading Indianapolis with six triples, Milner received a late-season call-up to the Reds in the strike-plagued 1981 season. He cracked his first big-league hit on September 25, a run-scoring double off Atlanta reliever Steve Bedrosian.
“I rounded second and tripped,” Milner recalled. “The guys were really laughing at that. [Reds manager] John McNamara asked me if I could still play defense because I was slightly shaken up after falling. I was happy that nobody hit me the ball the rest of the game.”
Milner earned his way into the starting lineup for the 1982 season, hitting .268 in 113 games. As an outfielder, he threw out eight opposing baserunners and quickly began making a name for himself defensively. The Reds, however, saw the demise of their dominant days, losing 101 games after a 1981 season in which they had the best record in baseball. McNamara was replaced by Russ Nixon midway through the season.
“We knew that we could not live up to those [Big Red Machine] standards, so we just tried to do the best that we could do,” Milner said. “We were rebuilding. We just couldn’t manage to hurl ourselves into first place.”
Milner played in a career-high 146 games in 1983, hitting .261 with nine homers and 33 runs batted in. He swiped a career-best 46 bases. It was in the following season that the downward spiral that led to the end of his career began. Milner had tried drugs once previously, saying it happened while he was playing in the Instructional League just to shut up a person he would not identify.
“It was no big deal the first time,” he said. “It was more of a peer-pressure thing, something to just get him off my back.”
But in 1984, upset by the lack of playing time, the death of his mother, and some nagging injuries, Milner turned to cocaine as a way to battle the frustrations.
“I always had to win a position every year,” he said. “I had never sat on the bench. I always thought that if a guy produced, he was the one who should play. When I found out that it wasn’t fair, that’s when I crossed the line. I got discouraged because I thought I should be playing, and that’s when I started partying too much.”
His batting average dropped to .232 in 1984, and he stole 21 bases in 34 attempts. He bounced back to hit .254 with 35 steals and a career-best 82 runs scored in 1985, manager Pete Rose’s first full year back with the Reds.
To go along with a 20-game hitting streak, Milner had a career-high 15 homers and 47 RBIs in 1986, his last full season with Cincinnati. He was traded to San Francisco on January 8, 1987, for pitcher Frank Williams and minor-league pitchers Mike Villa and Timber Mead. It was during that season that Milner, who by now was making $490,000 a year, entered a drug-abuse treatment program for the
first time. After hitting .252 in 101 games for the division-winning Giants, Milner was granted free agency after the season.
He caught back on with the Reds in 1988 but relapsed in March and was suspended for a year. The suspension was reduced to 81 days, and Milner was reinstated after completing another rehabilitation program. He spent time with Double-A Chattanooga and Triple-A Nashville that season before playing 23 games and batting just .176 for the Reds. He retired after the season, finishing with a .252 batting average, 42 homers, and 195 RBIs, along with 145 stolen bases, in 804 games. Milner shared a major-league record (as of 2013) with Cesar Tovar as the only players to get a hit in five one-hitters.
“His problems might have cost Eddie about $10 million,” said Reds special assistant Gene Bennett. “He was Deion [Sanders] before Deion. He was that good.”
The bitterness of what might have been clung to Milner after his playing days. When spring rolled around, he would remind himself that he should still be playing. He would then turn to drugs to deal with the frustration and pain. It became an all-too-familiar cycle for him.
“I kept trying to quit,” Milner said. “I knew if I kept hanging around the wrong people and in the wrong places, it would keep hitting me.”
Milner has worked a series of odd jobs since his playing days, including a stint with the postgame cleaning crew at Cincinnati’s Cinergy Field in 1996. Still, the vicious cycle of drug abuse and rehabilitation continued until one day he looked for help from above. A Christian since 1985, Milner turned to the Lord for help. “He said, ‘You have to accept me as your Lord and Savior, and you have to work as hard on this as you did on your baseball,’ ” Milner said. “It took me a long time to accept that.”
Milner and his wife, Retha, divorced in 2000 after 16 years of marriage, another tragic aspect he attributed to drug abuse. That marriage produced three children, Elisha, Erin, and Janis. “I lost my wife, my job in a game I really love. I lost just about everything,” he said. “I was even homeless a few times.”
In May 1997 Milner became an ordained evangelist, and he began using his struggles to minister to those who were going through the same thing. Milner said he has stumbled along the path a few times himself, falling prey to temptations, and he said he has learned how easy it is to “change from focusing on God to doing drugs.” But he said he hoped he could use his past to help others have a better future.
“These are not my words, but His words,” Milner said of his inspirational efforts. “The enemy is going to attack. I just don’t have the devil as my enemy, I have myself. It doesn’t always come at you from a physical standpoint. It can come at you mentally and emotionally.”
He added, “I tell them not to forget the past, to remember it so we can make better decisions in the future. I still attend NA and AA meetings. I try to stick around baseball. I do some construction jobs. It’s all part of my recovery that I put into God’s hands.”
“Being a former major leaguer ain’t my claim to fame,” Milner said. “My claim to fame is being a son of God. I’m on a mission to share how Christ has saved my life. The glory belongs to the Lord. I’m ready to be a soldier in the Lord’s army. It’s always going to be a battle, and I’ve accepted the responsibility of being a Christian. It’s better than any home run I’ve ever hit.”
Eddie Milner died at age 60 on November 2, 2015.
Lloyd Johnson and Miles Wolff, Encyclopedia of Minor League Baseball, 2nd edition (Durham, North Carolina: Baseball America, 1997).
Mark Curnutte, “Going to Bat With Faith,” Cincinnati Enquirer, September 10, 1998.
Mark Morrison, “Milner Shares Knowledge With Kids,” Marietta (Ohio) Times, June 20, 2012.
“Eddie Milner in Drug Program,” Los Angeles Times, April 17, 1989.
Author interview with Eddie Milner, July 2012.