The Time the Baseball Gods Played Matchmakers in Oakland
This article was written by Kevin Shafer
This article was published in Celebration: The A’s at the Oakland Coliseum (2026)

A chance meeting on BART to a playoff game leads to love and marriage. (Courtesy of Kevin Shafer.)
October can be a magical time in the Bay Area, especially when Fall baseball pops up on the calendar. In the 1990 season, Oakland A’s steamrolled their way through the AL West with a 103-59 record, and the Boston Red Sox clinched the AL East title with an 88-74 record. That set up the ALCS matchup of A’s and Red Sox for the AL pennant.
The A’s carried their momentum from the regular season into Boston. Behind their ace, Dave Stewart, the A’s prevailed in Game One and followed that up with a victory in Game Two. When the series reconvened in Oakland, the A’s again won Game Three in the best-of-seven series.
Desperate to prevent a sweep, the Red Sox tapped their ace Roger Clemens (a 21-game winner in 1990) as the starter for Game Four in Oakland, and the A’s slotted in their ace, Stewart. Bay Area fans were blessed with the chance to watch one of the most legendary pitching rivalries in major-league baseball history, and the pennant was on the line.
Through the years, Stewart proved dominant in this head-to-head matchup. When a young Stewart was playing for the Texas Rangers, Clemens defeated him in August 1987. Once he became an Oakland Athletic, however, Stewart blossomed. He no-hit the Blue Jays in June 1990 and defeated Clemens all three times they were paired in regular-season head-to-head matchups that year (the last being about a month prior to the ALCS). Coming into this series, Stewart was 4-1 against Clemens.
On game day, October 10, 1990, the weather was gorgeous. It was 70 degrees without a cloud in the sky. And the A’s expected a sellout crowd, which, in the “old” Coliseum of the 1990s meant more than 49,000 fans. This was most definitely the hottest ticket in town. Would the baseball gods smile on the Oakland A’s and send them to their third consecutive World Series appearance? The baseball gods were smiling, alright. On that warm Fall day, the baseball gods decided not only to smile on the A’s, but also on their fans—and two die-hard fans in particular.
I had two seats as a season-ticket holder in 1990. When the postseason rolled around, I was able to purchase two additional tickets to each game. The catch was that two seats would be in one section and two seats in another. Obviously, this wasn’t a problem. I offered two seats to a couple of friends as a reward for them listening to me incessantly rant about how good my A’s were throughout the year. They immediately accepted the offer. We attended Game Three on Tuesday night and were treated to 4-1 victory by the A’s.
Because of the expected crowd size, we decided to travel to the Wednesday matinee Game Four on BART (Bay Area Rapid Transit, a public transportation rail system). BART had a stop right outside the Coliseum gates which was extremely convenient, but we would have to switch trains once during the route, which was somewhat inconvenient but a small price to pay to avoid traffic and parking.
Transferring BART trains at the McArthur station entails getting off one train and merely walking across the platform to board a waiting train. As we were doing this, my attention unexpectedly focused on a woman about to board the same car of the new train. A horde of people who had also decided to take the train to the game madly began funneling through the car door. Once on the car, I noticed that this woman was sitting, and against all odds in the universe, there was an open seat next to her—literally the last available seat on the car. I grabbed it as quickly as I could.
As she politely joined our conversation about the Tuesday game, it became apparent that this was a die-hard A’s fan who intelligently contributed to our conversation not only about the A’s, but the season in general. She told us her name was Dori and before she had gone to work that day, she knew that she wanted to attend this game in the worst way. Although she didn’t have a ticket to the game, she had taken clothes for the game to work—just in case. Her two bosses were both out of town that day, and since it was a little slow, she decided to take a half-day vacation and try to go to the game. She figured she could buy a scalper’s ticket for a decent price since she needed only one.
Wait a minute. What’s going on here? I’m able to get the last seat on the train next to a woman I am attracted to, and I just happen to have an extra ticket that she covets. Of course, I offered it to her for free since I was willing to eat the unused ticket anyway. But this was a woman of principle, and she refused to accept the ticket without paying. I accepted her offer to pay face value, and nothing more.
When we arrived at the Coliseum and were heading to the entry gate, one of my friends offered to sit with Dori. I politely explained how that was never going to happen. I gave my two friends the pair of season ticket seats in Section 224, on the second deck down the third base line. Dori and I would use the two seats in section 405, the first row in the bleachers.
The baseball gods were smiling from ear to ear, not only on us, but on the A’s as well. On a warm October afternoon, we shared lots of laughs and lots of stories. We had the time of our lives, simply a perfect day. By the end of the game, we had exchanged phone numbers. And, of course, the A’s pulled off a series sweep and headed to the World Series.
We enjoyed our first formal date a couple of nights later. We continued dating for the next five years, with many of those dates returning to the Coliseum to share our passion for baseball and for each other. We turned our “dates” into memorable experiences. We would not only attend games, but we also began perfecting the art of tailgating. This wasn’t just a simple matter of taking in a game; we were learning how to embellish not only our mutual love for baseball, but also a blossoming love for each other.
On the day that I proposed to Dori five years later, we stayed up almost all night sharing our exciting plans for spending the rest of our lives together. We continued to discuss our many shared interests, wants, and desires. We decided that we would embark on a lifelong journey to visit every major-league ballpark.
Planning a wedding can be difficult and stressful. But for us, it was neither. The choice was very simple. We decided that the theme of our wedding would be baseball (a no-brainer, given our history), and, in particular, A’s baseball.
Our color scheme was green and gold. When it came to seating, we tapped a friend of ours who worked for the A’s and secured some ticket card stock that was not yet printed with seat assignments. Our table assignments were made by “sections” that we printed on the blank A’s tickets along with the guest’s name. When the guests arrived, they would visit our “Will Call” table to find where they were sitting.
We asked a friend of mine from work (who was a very creative artist who did some catering on the side) if she would make our cake. She designed and baked a cake modeled after the Coliseum, complete with a replica of a BART train on the side. Our centerpiece was a plastic A’s helmet with a bouquet of green and gold flowers inserted into a hole cut in the top.
Baseball is such a feel-good phenomenon. It seemed that everyone involved in the execution of the ceremony and reception had no problem going with the flow. The venue was Scott’s Garden in Walnut Creek, an event space adjacent to Scott’s Seafood Restaurant. Our officiant unexpectedly incorporated a “Play Ball” at the end of the ceremony, and that wasn’t the last time we would hear those two words that day. As people were making the way to their “sections,” we noticed our DJ was nowhere to be seen.
As everyone took their seats, our DJ reappeared with someone in tow. It turned out he had sneaked away into the restaurant where a piano player was tickling the ivories and serenading dinner guests. This “someone” was the singer and the DJ handed him a microphone. He said, “Ladies and gentlemen, please rise for our national anthem.” When he finished his rendition of the “Star-Spangled Banner,” he repeated those two words— “Play Ball.” It was a very appropriate off-script moment.
Over the next several decades, our love and passion for each other has grown each and every day. As A’s season ticket holders, we attended about 40 home games a year, each preceded by our traditional tailgate celebration. Through the years we made so many friends (from vendors to ushers to security guards to fellow “baseball people”) who would often stop by our tailgate on their way into the game. The Coliseum quickly became our home away from home. We have now visited all but four major-league ballparks. But that has no end in sight, because with the introduction of every new stadium, we return to that city to check it off our list.
You can attribute this story to fate. Or, if you are a follower of the Religion of Baseball, you could make a case for the baseball gods writing this feel-good fairy tale. How else can you explain any of this?
On September 24, 2004, the A’s played their final home game at the Coliseum. It was a very sad day as we said goodbye to a very old and dear friend. But we still have each other, and our fairy tale will never end.
KEVIN SHAFER has been jilted twice by major-league baseball, but he is still in love with the game. His first Athletics game was at Kansas City’s Municipal Stadium, and his last Athletics game was at the Oakland Coliseum. Throughout a nearly 40-year run as an Oakland A’s season ticket holder, he cemented life-long friendships with fellow fans, learned about the inner workings of an MLB franchise through special relationships, and even met his future wife on the way to a 1990 ALCS game. Rather than turning to instinctive bitterness after the second jilting, he and his wife have learned to rely on Cactus League spring training, minor-league baseball, and Pioneer League baseball as a means for re-discovering how competition (rather than glitz, glamor, and compensation) forms the solid foundation for the essence of the game of baseball—a game that we will always love.
