October 3, 2012: ‘Hamilton dropped the ball!’ A’s clinch AL West crown in season finale against Rangers
The Oakland A’s celebrate winning the AL West Division on the last day of the season, October 3, 2012. Alone in first place for just one day, the only one that counts. (Courtesy of the Athletics.)
The A’s had been chasing the Rangers all season. Well, not so much chasing as trying not to completely lose sight of the two-time defending American League champions. Oakland lost nine in a row to close out May. By the end of June, they were five games under .500 and 13 games out of first place. A win at Texas on July 1 helped them avoid a four-game sweep and prompted reliever Brian Fuentes to utter, “Now we’re only 12 games back.”1
But the magic of the baseball gods struck the O.co Coliseum during a 19–5 July, punctuated by seven walk-off wins. Right fielder Josh Reddick’s postgame cream-pie-in-the-face celebrations became appointment viewing.2
The month of August ended with seven straight wins, a streak that stretched to nine by Labor Day. With 30 games to play and only three games separating them from Texas, the A’s were firmly in the pennant race.
Entering the season’s final six-game homestand, Oakland remained four games behind Texas. After sweeping Seattle out of the East Bay, the A’s were two back with three left, all against the Rangers. After winning the first two games of the series, Oakland finally caught Texas. Each was 93–68 heading into Game 162.
Then-A’s beat writer Susan Slusser aptly called the 2012 A’s a team of “odds and ends.”3 They were built on the second-lowest payroll in the sport. The only team with a payroll lower in 2012 was the Astros, mired in the middle of a three-year stretch that would see them lose 324 games.
The previous winter, Oakland traded All-Star starting pitchers Gio Gonzalez and Trevor Cahill and All-Star closer Andrew Bailey. Three more starters—Brandon McCarthy, Brett Anderson and Bartolo Colón—were sidelined during the season, the first two with injuries. Colón was suspended 50 games after testing positive for PEDs in August, ending his season.4 By September, five rookies manned the starting rotation.
Josh Donaldson, the starting third baseman, was drafted and developed as a catcher but was installed at the hot corner after season-ending injuries to Scott Sizemore and Brandon Inge. Left fielder and three-hole hitter Yoenis Céspedes was a Cuban defector playing his first season in the major leagues. Cleanup hitter and first baseman/DH Brandon Moss arrived at spring training on a minor-league contract as an outfielder. The A’s signed Manny Ramirez to a minor-league deal in February hoping he would provide power in the middle of their order. Instead, Ramirez was never promoted and ultimately was released in June. Reddick, the right fielder, hit 32 home runs after hitting 10 in his first three big-league seasons combined. Shortstop Stephen Drew was acquired in a late-August trade with Arizona. Odds and ends indeed.
Abundant sunshine and 77-degree temperatures greeted the teams and a standing-room only crowd at O.co Coliseum for the Wednesday afternoon season finale. The A’s handed the ball to A. J. Griffin, one of their cadre of rookie pitchers. Griffin was a midseason call-up who contributed seven wins in eight decisions. Texas countered with 15-year veteran Ryan Dempster, a trade deadline acquisition from the Cubs. Neither made it past the fourth inning.
The Rangers countered a single Oakland run in the first with a five-run third to chase Griffin. A dropped popup off the bat of Mike Napoli led to the fifth run and foreshadowed the game’s biggest play an inning later.
With Texas ahead, 5–1, Moss led off the bottom of the fourth with a four-pitch walk. Following three straight hits, the Rangers closed the gap to 5–3 and ended Dempster’s day. Rangers manager Ron Washington brought lefty starter Derek Holland on in relief, and Oakland skipper Bob Melvin countered by pinch-hitting for his catcher.
With two outs and runners on second and third, Coco Crisp sent the Coliseum faithful into a Bernie Lean5 frenzy with a two-run double down the right-field line, tying the score. Stephen Drew laid off a borderline 3–2 slider from Holland, bringing Céspedes to the plate with two on and two out. Holland got him out in front of an off-speed pitch, and Céspedes popped it up to shallow center. Josh Hamilton drifted in, and Holland and the Rangers moved toward their dugout. But, at the last second, Hamilton dropped the ball for a two-run error that gave the A’s a 7–5 lead. When asked about the play afterward, Hamilton did his best to summarize the inexplicable. He said, “I just missed it, man.”6
The story of the 2012 A’s cannot be written without several pages dedicated to their stellar bullpen. That group, like it had all year long, came through in the season finale. Evan Scribner, pitching in his first full big-league season, supported Griffin with three scoreless innings of relief. Lefty Jerry Blevins closed out the sixth, getting Hamilton swinging. Rookie Ryan Cook escaped a second and third, no-out jam in the seventh. Another of the A’s odds and ends, former first-base prospect turned lights-out lefty set-up man Sean Doolittle, worked around a two-out walk to Elvis Andrus in the top of the eighth. In the process, he struck out Hamilton swinging, Josh’s third strikeout of the game and second since his fourth-inning drop.
After watching his offense bank four insurance runs in the bottom of the eighth, A’s closer Grant Balfour raged into his fifth straight game. Two routine fly balls sandwiched around a strikeout of Nelson Cruz closed out a “12–5 neighborhood block party of a win.”7 The A’s were finally in first place, becoming just the third team to never hold the top spot alone until the last day of the season.8
The previous day, which saw the A’s clinch at least a wild card spot, Slusser’s game story stretched for words to describe the team’s season: Improbable. Implausible. Absurd. Sensational.9 After the finale, Melvin called it a “magical-type thing.”10 Regardless of the specific superlative, October 3, 2012, the day Hamilton dropped the ball and the A’s stole the AL West crown away from the Rangers, was one of the most memorable games in Coliseum history.
Sources
In addition to the sources cited in the Notes, the author consulted Baseball-Reference.com.
https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/OAK/OAK201210030.shtml
https://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/2012/B10030OAK2012.htm
Notes
1 Susan Slusser, 100 Things A’s Fans Should Know & Do Before They Die (Chicago: Triumph Books, 2015), 69–74.
2 “Magic Behind Amazing Pie-derman Revealed” NBC Sports Bay Area, August 4, 2012. https://www.nbcsportsbayarea.com/mlb/magic-behing-amazing-pie-derman-revealed/1279144/, accessed October 30, 2025.
3 Slusser, 69–74.
4 “Oakland’s Colon Suspended,” MLB.com, August 22, 2012. https://www.mlb.com/news/oaklands-colon-suspended/c-37148196, accessed October 30, 2025.
5 Kevin Mendez, “An Exclusive Interview with Rapper ATM, The Artist of the ‘Bernie Lean,’” White Cleat Beat, September 12, 2012. https://whitecleatbeat.com/2012/09/13/an-exclusive-interview-with-rapper-atm-the-artist-of-the-bernie-lean/, accessed October 30, 2025.
6 Associated Press, “Athletics Overwhelm Rangers; Complete Improbable Run to AL West Title” ESPN, October 3, 2012. https://www.espn.com/mlb/recap/_/gameId/321003111, accessed October 30, 2025.
7 Tom Verducci, “A’s historic run to AL West Title reminds us why we love this game,” Sports Illustrated, October 4, 2012. https://www.si.com/more-sports/2012/10/04/athletics-win-al-west, accessed October 30, 2025.
8 Slusser, 69–74.
9 Ken Korach and Susan Slusser, If These Walls Could Talk: Stories from the Oakland A’s Dugout, Locker Room and Press Box (Chicago: Triumph Books, 2019), 231–232.
10 Associated Press, “Athletics overwhelm Rangers.”
Additional Stats
Oakland Athletics 12
Texas Rangers 5
O.co Coliseum
Oakland, CA
Box Score + PBP:
Corrections? Additions?
If you can help us improve this game story, contact us.

