October 5, 2013: Sonny Gray outduels Justin Verlander to win it for A’s in Game 2
Ask an Athletics fan for a scary Halloween costume idea, and the answer you might get is Justin Verlander, serial killer of their Octobers.
The big right-hander burst onto the scene in 2006, leading surprising Detroit to the World Series and getting his first playoff victory against Oakland in the American League Championship Series. In 2012 he crushed the A’s in the AL Divisional Series, winning the opening game and the decisive fifth game while allowing only one run – a Coco Crisp homer – in 16 innings.
When Verlander’s turn came up again in Game Two of the 2013 ALDS after Max Scherzer outpitched Bartolo Colon in Game One for a 3-2 Tigers victory, matters looked bleak.
The A’s appeared outmatched on the mound, especially after they left starter A.J. Griffin, suffering from tendinitis, off the playoff roster. To counter Verlander, manager Bob Melvin made the surprise choice to elevate Sonny Gray over Jarrod Parker in the rotation, preferring to use the rookie Gray at home while saving the third-year playoff veteran Parker for Comerica Park and Game Three.1
Gray, Oakland’s first-round draft pick from Vanderbilt two years earlier, had been called up in July for two games of relief work.. His command of multiple pitches was noticed, and he was returned to the minors to get stretched out to start. He was recalled for a spot start in August and became a fixture in the rotation, finishing the season 5-3 with a 2.67 ERA and 67 strikeouts in 64 innings.
Gray knew what he was up against, having watched Verlander on TV while in college.
“It seemed to be that he was the only guy people were talking about,” he said. “I remember we were at a restaurant on the road and watching him pitch, watching him throw 100 MPH in the ninth inning.”2
By contrast, Gray’s fastball topped out at just above 90. He stood 5-feet-10 compared with Verlander’s 6-feet-5. He relied on a fastball, sinker, and curve, showing an exceptional groundball rate above 50 percent.3
Gray took inspiration from texting with Pittsburgh’s Gerrit Cole, a former opponent from UCLA who was drafted the same year.
“We played in college and he shot me a text today, and I was like, ‘This is weird.’ We’re both throwing in the playoffs when a year and a half ago we were facing each other in college. I wished him luck and he wished me luck.”4
Cole got his win first, beating St. Louis in the National League Division Series the day before Gray took the mound.
It was one of those rare balmy Bay Area nights, the kind that occur mostly in the fall rather than summer – 82 degrees. Without the usual cool, moist marine layer that slowed fly balls, the Coliseum tended to turn into a hitters’ park. But the ball seemed anything but lively this Saturday night.
Verlander posted a clean sheet over the first 3⅔ innings, recording six of his 11 strikeouts before Josh Donaldson finally got a single.
The Tigers had their best scoring threat in the fifth, when Omar Infante walked and got to third on a single by Jose Iglesias. That brought up leadoff man Austin Jackson with one out, but Gray struck him out and catcher Stephen Vogt threw out Iglesias attempting to steal second for a double play.5 That kept the game scoreless.
In the bottom of the inning, with two on and nobody out, Josh Reddick popped out on a bunt attempt and Verlander struck out the next two hitters.
Another chance came in the seventh, when Brandon Moss walked. With two out, Reddick singled to right and went to second when Torii Hunter tried to throw out Moss at third. The threat was extinguished when Vogt struck out for the third time.
Verlander was done after seven innings, finishing with no runs allowed, 11 strikeouts, 4 hits, and a walk. Tigers manager Jim Leyland brought in Drew Smyly and Al Albuquerque for the eighth.
Gray lasted through eight innings, striking out nine (tied for a career high), allowing no runs, four hits, and two walks on 111 pitches. Grant Balfour pitched an uneventful top of the ninth.
With the game still scoreless in the bottom of the ninth, Albuquerque came out again. Yoenis Cespedes led off with a single to left and Seth Smith singled past a diving first baseman Prince Fielder to get him to third. Reddick got an intentional pass to set up a force at the plate.
Leyland brought in Rick Porcello, a starter during the regular season, to face Vogt. This time, the lefty-hitting catcher came through, slapping a low, inside pitch the other way for a looping single between shortstop Iglesias and third baseman Miguel Cabrera.6
The walk-off sent the A’s bench rushing the field to mob Vogt; the crowd of 46,959 exploded in delirium.
It was the sixth postseason game when both starters went at least seven scoreless innings.7
While the A’s hadn’t gotten a run off Verlander, the idea that he could be outlasted by a rookie brought a modicum of hope to fans that the team would get by the Tigers in their third playoff matchup in eight seasons.
The series moved to Detroit, where Jarrod Parker vindicated the decision to leave him for a road start, winning 6-3. The Tigers evened it up the next day with an 8-6 win.
Back at the Coliseum for the decisive fifth game, Verlander allowed only two hits over eight innings, Cabrera homered off Gray in the fourth, and the Tigers won 3-0. The San Jose Mercury News said the game “cemented Verlander’s stance as the A’s supervillain.”8
Still, Game Two marked the arrival of Gray as the team’s ace. Even Cabrera was impressed, saying, “He pitched like Josh Beckett or Curt Schilling. Wow.”9
It also helped cement catcher Vogt as a fan favorite. He would play six seasons with the A’s to chants of “I Believe in Stephen Vogt!” He’d also play for four National League clubs before getting his last hurrah with the A’s in 2022, topping off his career with a game-winning home run against the Angels at the Coliseum.
Interviewed when the A’s left the Coliseum in 2024, Vogt, by then Cleveland’s manager, had fond memories.
“The playoff atmosphere here is better than any in baseball,” Vogt said. “I’ve experienced a number of different playoff atmospheres, but the Oakland Coliseum packed at playoff time, it’s tough to beat.”10
Verlander agreed. He recalled the playoff crowd being so raucous that even during an uneventful part of the game he couldn’t hear Fielder standing next to him.
“So honestly, I’ve had some personally great moments here. But the energy this place brought for those years where the (A’s) and us faced off in the playoffs, that was something I’ll always remember here.”11
Sources
In addition to the sources cited in the Notes, the author consulted Baseball-Reference.com and Retrosheet.org:
https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/OAK/OAK201310050.shtml
https://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/2013/B10050OAK2013.htm
Notes
1 John Hickey, “Oakland A’s Loses [sic[ Griffin for ALDS; Sonny Gray to Pitch Game 2,” San Jose Mercury News, October 1, 2013. https://www.mercurynews.com/2013/10/01/oakland-as-loses-griffin-for-alds-sonny-gray-to-pitch-game-2/. Accessed March 26, 2026
2 Carl Steward, “A’s Game 2 Starter Sonny Gray Hopes to Keep Up with Pittsburgh’s Gerrit Cole,” San Jose Mercury News, October 4, 2013. https://www.mercurynews.com/2013/10/04/as-game-2-starter-sonny-gray-hopes-to-keep-up-with-pittsburghs-gerrit-cole/.
3 Nick Pollack, “Going Deep: the Evolution of Sonny Gray,” pitcherlist.com, April 15, 2018. https://pitcherlist.com/going-deep-the-evolution-of-sonny-gray/.
4 Steward, “A’s Game 2 Starter Sonny Gray Hopes to Keep Up with Pittsburgh’s Gerrit Cole.”
5 Connor Moylan, “Tigers vs. Athletics, 2013 ALDS Game 2 Results: Stephen Vogt Hits Walk-Off Single to Give Oakland 1-0 Victory,” SB Nation, October 6, 2013. https://www.sbnation.com/mlb/2013/10/6/4807680/athletics-tigers-2013-alds-game-2-score-results-stephen-vogt-walkoff.
6 Moylan.
7 Moylan.
8 Tim Kawakami, “Tigers’ Justin Verlander Cements Status as A’s Supervillain,” San Jose Mercury News, October 10, 2013. https://www.mercurynews.com/2013/10/10/kawakami-tigers-justin-verlander-cements-status-as-as-supervillain/. Accessed March 26,2026.
9 Ken Lucchesi, “Sonny Gray Brilliant as A’s Walk-Off with ALDS Game Two,” AroundtheFoghorn.com, October 5, 2013. https://aroundthefoghorn.com/2013/10/05/win-game-two-1-0/.
10 Justice Delos Santos, “‘I’m Going to Miss It a Lot’: Visiting Players, Managers Bid Farewell to Oakland Coliseum,” San Jose Mercury News, September 24, 2024. Updated September 25, 2024. https://www.mercurynews.com/2024/09/24/im-going-to-miss-it-a-lot-visiting-players-managers-bid-farewell-to-oakland-coliseum/. Accessed March 26,2026.
11 Delos Santos.
Additional Stats
Oakland Athletics 1
Detroit Tigers 0
Game 2, ALDS
O.co Coliseum
Oakland, CA
Box Score + PBP:
Corrections? Additions?
If you can help us improve this game story, contact us.
