October 11, 1973: Coliseum Clutch: Catfish Hunter and A’s shut out Orioles to repeat as AL champions
Hall of Fame pitcher Jim “Catfish” Hunter was a fan favorite in Oakland. (SABR-Rucker Archive.)
It wouldn’t be a playoff push by Charlie Finley’s Oakland Athletics without a touch of the absurd. The 1973 ALCS began with Reggie Jackson under police protection. It ended with Jackson (briefly) in police custody. Between Mr. October’s polarized interactions with law enforcement, the Oakland A’s and Baltimore Orioles played a back-and-forth series, culminating on October 11, 1973, at the Oakland Coliseum.
In the 1972 ALCS, Jackson tore his left hamstring stealing home against the Detroit Tigers in the second inning of the decisive Game Five. While he scored on the play, the injury sidelined him the rest of the year. The A’s program for the 1973 ALCS concludes its profile of Jackson with a bold, and prescient, prediction: “Reggie missed the 1972 World Series, but he’ll make it to another one.”1
The FBI wasn’t so sure.
Before the start of the playoffs, Athletics broadcaster Monte Moore received a letter, ostensibly from the Weather Underground, threatening to kill Jackson should he dare to play in the ALCS.2 Concerned, the FBI placed Jackson under its direct protection. Jackson told the press after the 1973 World Series that, following Moore’s receipt of the threatening letter “…[I]ncluding the final weeks of the season, the playoffs, and now the World Series, I had a couple of FBI men with me all the time.”3
The winner-take-all Game Five of the 1973 ALCS was played in front of a crowd of 24,265, the smallest crowd for an ALCS or NLCS game through the 2025 season.4 This modest gathering saw Orioles pitcher Doyle Alexander, in his only appearance in the series, square off with Game Two winner Jim “Catfish” Hunter.
Alexander had gone 12–8 for the Orioles during the regular season, including two appearances against the A’s. On April 29th, he threw 4 1/3 innings in relief of Dave McNally at the Oakland Coliseum. He allowed no runs, no hits, and no walks while striking out three Athletics batters. The Orioles, however, lost, 4–3.
The second game was in Baltimore on May 7 when Alexander threw a complete game, allowing two runs (one earned) on five hits while walking three and striking out two. The Orioles won, 8–2.
Hunter was making his second appearance in the 1973 ALCS, having earned the win in Game Two in Baltimore on October 7. He went 7 1/3 innings in that game, allowing three Baltimore runs on seven hits and three walks while striking out five. Rollie Fingers earned a five-out save with the A’s winning the game, 6–3.
Hunter started Game Five by issuing a leadoff walk to Baltimore left fielder Al Bumbry. When the count fell to 2–2 to the next batter, right fielder Rich Coggins, Oakland pitching coach Wes Stock came out for a mound visit. Hunter regrouped and retired the side, stranding Bumbry at second.
Alexander surrendered a single in the first to A’s third baseman Sal Bando and hit first baseman Gene Tenace with a pitch in the second. He was able to hold Oakland off the board in both of those frames, however.5
What would ultimately turn out to be the mortal blow was struck in the bottom of the third, courtesy of a rare Brooks Robinson error, his first in 14 ALCS games he had played to that point.6 Robinson, when attempting to field a ground ball from A’s catcher Ray Fosse, tripped over his own spikes,7 or the infield dirt,8 causing him to lose control of the ball and allowing Fosse to reach first safely.
The A’s took advantage of Robinson’s rare miscue. The next batter, second baseman Dick Green, executed a successful sacrifice bunt down the first-base line, putting Fosse on second.
Two batters later, Joe Rudi drove in Fosse on a single to left. Bumbry’s throw was cut off by Robinson, who then threw out Rudi, who was trying to stretch the single into a double. Still, Fosse made it safely across home plate with what would be the winning run.
In the home half of the fourth, Bumbry made an athletic play to rob Sal Bando of likely extra bases, leaping to catch a well-hit foul ball at the wall in left. Second baseman Bobby Grich made his own excellent play to get out Jackson and put the A’s in a two-out hole.9
However, the A’s weren’t ready to return to the field just yet. Tenace hit a single up the middle and Vic Davalillo followed with a triple off the wall in right field just past Coggins, who initially took the wrong route to catch the ball. With Tenace scoring Oakland’s second run and Davalillo on third, the A’s had one last blow to strike against Alexander: designated hitter Jesús Alou singled into left-center, bringing the final run of the 1973 ALCS across the plate.
With Alexander having given up three runs in 3 2/3 innings, manager Earl Weaver went to Jim Palmer, making a rare relief appearance a mere day after giving up three runs to Oakland in 1 1/3 innings. Palmer was in much better form for Game Five, despite the negligible rest, and effectively silenced the A’s offense, allowing only two hits and no additional runs in 4 1/3 innings pitched.
But the damage was done. While Palmer kept Baltimore in the game, the Orioles could not get a runner past second base or drive Hunter from the mound.
While the game was going well for the A’s on the field, mischief was brewing in the stands of the Coliseum. Although comparatively small, the Oakland crowd was decisively passionate, perhaps to a fault.
The night before in Queens, a mob had severely damaged the playing surface and fences of Shea Stadium in celebration of the Mets clinching the National League title. In Oakland, while fans flooded the field, shenanigans ensued; the mob was noticeably less destructive than in New York, partially due to the defensive action of the Oakland grounds crew.10
Indeed, the disorder began before the last out and may have even helped Hunter and the A’s neutralize the last Orioles threat.
With two outs in the ninth, Robinson doubled into the gap in right-center past Jackson. However, before Grich came up to bat next, time was called due to fans who were sitting on top of the fence in right field. The umpires, with the assistance of A’s manager Dick Williams, coaxed and cajoled the fans off the fences, allowing Hunter to throw to Grich.
However, after a second stoppage due to fans pushing opening a door in the center-field fence, (fended off by the Oakland grounds crew with help from Davalillo), Williams took the opportunity to come out and talk to Hunter.11
Hunter, who said he was tiring at that point in the game, claimed that both the delay and Williams’ visit helped him regain composure during the would-be Baltimore rally, just as Stock’s visit in the first had. “It calmed me down,” Hunter said. “I was getting tired but there was no way I was coming out.”12
Once order was restored for the second time, Hunter induced Grich into hitting a ground ball to shortstop Bert Campaneris, who threw to Tenace at first base for the final out, keeping Robinson at second and the Orioles off the board for good.
Despite shutting out the Orioles, Hunter gave his performance a mixed review. He wrote years later, “I didn’t have my best stuff that day, and Jim Palmer said he thought they’d get to me. No way. This was special, a game I wanted to pitch.”13 Hunter finished the game with only one strikeout, yes, but with a decisive victory.
The Orioles would be returning to a Maryland already reeling from the headlines. The day before, former Maryland governor Spiro Agnew had resigned the vice presidency. One unnamed Oriole quipped after their defeat: “I can see the home town headlines now. Baltimore drops double-header. Agnew loses first, Orioles second.”14
Government response to the A’s victory was mixed. California governor Ronald Reagan sent a telegram to Finley proclaiming, “Thanks to the A’s, California is still the baseball capital of the world.”15
However, following Oakland’s victory celebrations, Jackson found himself driving in neighboring San Francisco. He was pulled over by two SFPD motorcycle officers, allegedly after Jackson blew his horn at the officers, and was arrested and detained for two hours over two outstanding traffic warrants back in Oakland.16 It was not reported where his FBI security detail was at the time of his arrest, but Jackson was soon bailed out.
Poet Tom Clark summarized the incident with a bit of salt and snark, writing simply, “Some towns have no gratitude.”17
That may have been true of the big city across the bay, but Oakland showed its gratitude to the A’s as the ballclub advanced to a second straight World Series. As the mob scene at the end of Game Five of the ALCS suggested, Oakland fans were passionate and fully supportive of their Mustache Gang, absurdities and all.
Sources
In addition to the sources listed in the Notes, the author used the Baltimore Orioles 1973 ALCS Program for background reading, and Baseball-Reference.com, and the recording of the Baltimore Orioles radio broadcast of the game for the lineups, play-by-play accounts, player statistics for the game, and general game information:
https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/OAK/OAK197310110.shtml
https://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/1973/B10110OAK1973.htm
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Xm4hgi1HsE
Notes
1 “Reggie Jackson,” Oakland A’s vs. Baltimore Orioles Scorecard & Souvenir Yearbook, October 1973: 25.
2 ”F.B.I. Guarded Jackson for Playoffs, Series,” New York Times, October 22, 1973. https://www.nytimes.com/1973/10/22/archives/fbi-guarded-jackson-for-playoffs-series.html.
3 Tom Clark, Champagne and Baloney: The Rise and Fall of Finley’s A’s (New York: Harper & Row, 1976), 187.
4 George Minot Jr., “Hunter, A’s Extinguish Orioles 3-0: Five-Hitter Gains Pennant,” Washington Post, October 12, 1973: D1.
5 Jim Elliot, “Orioles Held to Five Hits; Oakland Takes on Mets,” Baltimore Sun, October 12, 1973: C5.
6 Elliot.
7 Minot Jr.
8 Elliot.
9 Elliot.
10 United Press International, “A’s Fans Flood Field,” Press Democrat (Santa Rosa, California), October 12, 1973: 20.
11 Bob Stevens, “Hunter Pitches A’s Into Series,” San Francisco Chronicle, October 12, 1973: 64.
12 Minot Jr.
13 Jim “Catfish” Hunter and Armen Keteyian, Catfish: My Life in Baseball (New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1988), 117.
14 Art Rosenbaum, “Bad Week in Maryland,” San Francisco Chronicle October 12, 1973: 66.
15 Associated Press, “Reagan Sends A’s Telegram,” Oakland Tribune, October 12, 1973: E51.
16 “Reggie Jailed, Bailed in SF,” Oakland Tribune, October 12, 1973: E51.
17 Clark, Champagne and Baloney, 173.
Additional Stats
Oakland Athletics 3
Baltimore Orioles 0
Game 5, ALCS
Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum
Oakland, CA
Box Score + PBP:
Corrections? Additions?
If you can help us improve this game story, contact us.

