October 17, 1974: Bedlam! Swingin’ A’s win their third consecutive World Series title
On a warm autumn Thursday evening, a packed house of 49,347 fans hoped the Oakland Athletics would achieve a feat not seen in over 20 years: winning three consecutive World Series championships. Oakland defeated the Cincinnati Reds in seven games to win the 1972 title and defeated the New York Mets in seven games to win the 1973 title. Entering Game Five of the 1974 World Series, the Athletics led the Los Angeles Dodgers three games to one. A single run decided the first three games; all three games ended 3-2 with the losing team coming within striking distance of tying the game during the ninth inning.
In Game One, a ninth-inning Jim Wynn home run brought Los Angeles within one run, and the game ended with the winning run at the plate.1 In Game Two, two ninth-inning Oakland runs brought the Athletics within one run. In Game Three, Willie Crawford’s home run brought Los Angeles within a run once again, but a double play saved the game for the Athletics. Oakland won Game Four 5-2, sparked by a four-run sixth inning.
The reigning World Series champion Athletics, managed by Alvin Dark, had compiled a 90-72 regular-season record and won their fourth straight AL West title, this time by five games over the Texas Rangers. The A’s defeated the Baltimore Orioles in four games to win the American League Championship Series. Slugging right fielder Reggie Jackson (29 home runs, 93 RBIs, .905 OPS, 5.7 WAR), first baseman/catcher Gene Tenace2 (26 HR, 73 RBIs, league-leading 110 walks, 5.0 WAR), and third baseman Sal Bando (22 HR, 103 RBIs, 4.9 WAR) powered the offense. Left fielder Joe Rudi paced AL hitters with 39 doubles and Oakland batters with 174 hits while center fielder Bill North led AL runners with 54 stolen bases and 26 times caught stealing. Catfish Hunter, the 1974 AL Cy Young Award winner, finished with a 25-12 record and 2.49 ERA over 318⅓ innings.
The 102-60 Dodgers, managed by Walter Alston, won the NL West, fending off the powerful Cincinnati Reds by four games, and knocked off the Pittsburgh Pirates in four games to win the National League Championship Series. Center fielder Wynn (32 HR, 108 RBIs, 108 BB, .884 OPS) led the team in several offensive categories, first baseman and NL Most Valuable Player Steve Garvey joined the 200-hit club while slugging 21 homers and driving in 111 runs. The LA pitching staff was even more impressive: Three Dodgers finished in the top four positions for the NL Cy Young Award. Reliever Mike Marshall, who led NL hurlers with 106 games pitched, 83 games finished, and 21 saves, won the award. Staff ace Andy Messersmith finished second while compiling a 20-6 record and a 2.59 ERA over 292⅓ innings. Don Sutton finished fourth with a 19-9 record and a 3.23 ERA.
Game Five featured a rematch of Game Two starters, the Athletics’ Vida Blue and Sutton. Sutton earned the Game Two win with eight strong innings, while Blue absorbed the loss.
The 24-year-old Blue was pitching in his fourth full season. The 1971 AL Cy Young Award winner compiled a 17-15 record and 3.25 ERA over 282⅓ innings pitched. He increased his strikeout total and reduced his walks issued over the previous season. During this early stage of his career, he threw a fastball, curveball, and changeup.3
The 29-year-old Sutton was already a nine-year big-league veteran. A solid workhorse, he had reached double-digit wins and 200 innings pitched in every year of his career, all with the Dodgers. Sutton led NL hurlers with 40 games started, tied for second with 19 wins, finished fifth with 276 innings, and finished fifth with a 2.24 strikeout-to-walk ratio. He threw a curveball, fastball, slider, screwball, and changeup, with the occasional knuckle-curve.4
Blue quickly retired the Dodgers during the top of the first inning as Davey Lopes grounded out, Bill Buckner popped out, and Wynn popped out in foul territory. Conversely, Bert Campaneris sparked Oakland’s offense with a leadoff single. North hit into a fielder’s choice, then stole second and advanced to third on Steve Yeager’s throwing error. Bando drove in the game’s first run on a sacrifice fly lineout. An ensuing walk and single put runners at the corners. Claudell Washington’s fly out ended the inning with Oakland ahead 1-0.
Second-inning singles by Joe Ferguson and Ron Cey resulted in Los Angeles threatening with two outs and runners at the corners. Blue struck out Yeager to end the threat. Oakland quickly reached Sutton again, as Ray Fosse started the bottom half with a home run on an 0-and-1 count. Sutton retired the next three hitters. Oakland increased its lead to 2-0.
The Athletics benefited from two close plays in the fourth inning. Leadoff hitter Wynn hit Blue’s first pitch back to the mound. Blue jumped and slightly deflected the ball to Campaneris, who fielded the bounder cleanly and threw to first for the first out. With two outs, Ferguson walloped Blue’s first offering down the left-field line, but the blast drifted just foul rather than going for a home run. He struck out looking after watching Blue’s next two pitchers cross the plate.
Through five innings Blue kept Los Angeles scoreless on two hits but the feisty Dodgers kept battling. Though Sutton settled down after allowing two early runs, retiring 12 of the last 13 batters he faced, Alston removed him for pinch-hitter Tom Paciorek. Paciorek, a known first-ball hitter, started the visitors’ sixth-inning rally with a first-pitch leadoff double that rolled to the wall. Lopes walked on a full count. Buckner’s perfect sacrifice bunt advanced both runners. The Dodgers finally scored on Wynn’s sacrifice fly. Garvey, the next batter and the Series’ hottest hitter with a .412 batting average through the first four games, fouled off three straight pitches, then singled on a 1-and-2 pitch to plate Lopes with the tying run. Ferguson flied out to end the inning.
Marshall, who pitched six scoreless innings during this Series and three more during the NLCS, relieved Sutton for the sixth inning. He retired the Athletics on two groundouts and a strikeout.
With two outs during Los Angeles’ seventh inning, Blue walked Yeager on five pitches. After he pitched two more balls to opposing hurler Marshall, Blue Moon Odom relieved him. Odom also threw two balls, walking Marshall. Lopes hit into a fielder’s choice as Oakland escaped the inning.
Between the top and bottom halves of the seventh inning, the game was delayed for several minutes due to crowd shenanigans, including throwing cannon crackers, paper airplanes, and paper cups onto the field.5 Fans threw debris at Buckner, who noted, “An apple hit me in the back of my head in left field in the seventh inning. A whiskey bottle just missed me.”6 Several Dodgers fielders headed toward the dugout. During the delay, Marshall declined throwing any warm-up pitches, angering several of his teammates.
Fireworks erupted quickly as play resumed. Rudi launched Marshall’s first pitch over the left-field wall and returned the lead to the Athletics. An angry Marshall disposed of the next three hitters on a foul popout and two strikeouts. Oakland now led 3-2 with six outs remaining.
Rollie Fingers relieved Odom to start the eighth inning. Buckner lined an 0-and-2 pitch into right-center. The ball dribbled under North’s glove. Jackson, backing up North, threw to second baseman Dick Green, who relayed a perfect throw to third. Bando, blocking access to third base, slapped the tag on a sliding Buckner for the first out. Dodgers scouting reports suggested running on A’s outfielders but as Jackson commented, “Well, you can challenge me, but beware. I saw that Buckner wasn’t stopping and I came up throwing. Yes, I was surprised to see him go.”7 Wynn walked. Back-to-back fly outs by Garvey and Ferguson kept Wynn stuck at first, though Ferguson hammered another long foul ball down the left-field line that landed in the second deck. Marshall prevented the Athletics from adding to their slim lead in the bottom half.
Fingers returned to the mound for the ninth inning. Cey flied out to the warning track in right field. Pinch-hitter Crawford popped out as the cheering grew louder. Pinch-hitter Von Joshua grounded out to Fingers. Oakland won 3-2.
The Athletics converged onto the mound and enthusiastically celebrated their third consecutive World Series championship. Oakland fans wildly rejoiced throughout the evening – “Oakland was the biggest steam bath in the world last night,” according to one account8 – and the players were treated to a victory parade the following morning.9
After the win, Rudi exclaimed, “They were like the others, they thought they were better than us – now they have all winter to think about it.”10
Odom earned the Game Five win. Marshall took the loss by allowing Rudi’s homer – the only run he allowed during the 1974 postseason. Fingers earned the save with two shutout innings; he received the World Series MVP award with four appearances covering 9⅓ innings, including one win and two saves. For the first time in over 20 years, since the 1949-1953 New York Yankees won five straight titles, baseball fans witnessed the elusive three-peat.
Oakland Coliseum outfield wall signage honors all nine World Series Championships in A’s history: five in Philadelphia and four in Oakland. (Courtesy of Kevin Shafer.)
Acknowledgments
The author thanks Len Levin, Bill Nowlin, and Glen Sparks for their editing, Carl Riechers for his fact-checking, and Lisa Gattie for her meaningful input.
Sources
Besides the sources cited in the Notes, the author consulted Baseball-Reference.com, Retrosheet.org, and the following:
https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/OAK/OAK197410170.shtml
https://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/1974/B10170OAK1974.htm
1974 World Series Game Five (radio broadcast first hour, video broadcast staring with Ron Santo’s third-inning plate appearance): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yPKQcFhPOaA
Greene, Chip, Greg Erion, Len Levin, and Bill Nowlin. Mustaches and Mayhem: Charlie O’s Three-Time Champions The Oakland Athletics. (Phoenix: Society for American Baseball Research, 2015).
Libby, Bill, and Vida Blue. Vida: His Own Story. (Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1972).
Neyer, Rob, and Eddie Epstein. Baseball Dynasties: The Greatest Teams of All Time. (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2000).
Notes
1 Mark S. Sternman, “Joe Ferguson’s Fantastic Throw Only a Footnote as Oakland Wins World Series Opener,” SABR Games Project, https://sabr.org/gamesproj/game/october-12-1974-joe-fergusons-fantastic-throw-only-a-footnote-as-oakland-wins-world-series-opener/. Accessed January 26, 2025.
2 During the 1974 regular season, Gene Tenace played 106 games at first base (starting 97 games), 79 games at catcher (starting 58 games), and three games at second base (starting zero games). During the 1974 postseason, Tenace played nine games at first base (starting seven games) and no games at catcher.
3 Bill James and Rob Neyer, The Neyer/James Guide to Pitchers: An Historical Compendium of Pitching, Pitchers, and Pitches (New York: Fireside Books, 2004), 136.
4 James and Neyer, 398.
5 George Ross, “Zanies Sensed A’s 7th-Inning Uprising,” Oakland Tribune, October 18, 1974: 39.
6 Pat Frizzell, “Buckner Defends Mad Dash,” Oakland Tribune, October 18, 1974: 38.
7 Bill Shirley, “A’s Win, 3-2, and Take the Triple Crown,” Los Angeles Times, October 18, 1974: 55.
8 Noel Liberman, “It’s Bedlam as A’s Win Series Again,” Oakland Tribune, October 18, 1974: 1.
9 “World Series Heroes Get Oakland Parade,” Oakland Tribune, October 18, 1974: 1.
10 Phil Collier, “A’s Give Dodgers Some Humility,” Torrance (California) Daily Breeze, October 18, 1974: 25.
Additional Stats
Oakland Athletics 3
Los Angeles Dodgers 2
Game 5, WS
Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum
Oakland, CA
Box Score + PBP:
Corrections? Additions?
If you can help us improve this game story, contact us.

