September 21, 2018: ‘Krush’ Davis bookends Athletics’ win with home runs to same spot
By late September, some teams are fighting for postseason positioning, while others are playing out the string. Sometimes, teams in each camp face one another. Such was the case for a late-season 2018 clash between the Oakland Athletics and Minnesota Twins. The Athletics entered the September 21 contest in the thick of the American League playoff race with a solid hold on a Wild Card spot. With nine games to play, Oakland was 92–61, 3 1/2 games behind the Houston Astros in the AL West and 6 1/2 games in front of the Tampa Bay Rays for the second Wild Card. The Athletics confirmed their postseason intent with a 21–3 win over the Los Angeles Angels the previous night. At 71–81, the Twins were just playing out the season.
Oakland manager Bob Melvin named Liam Hendriks as the starter for the game but the long-time reliever really served as an opener. Hendricks opened eight games for the 2018 Athletics. Hendriks struck out Joe Mauer and Robbie Grossman between a walk to Jorge Polanco and a single by Jake Cave. The inning ended on a Max Kepler groundout. No runs, mission accomplished.
In the bottom of the first, Nick Martini and Matt Chapman struck out against Minnesota starter José Berríos. The Twins pitcher entered the game 11–11 with a 3.81 ERA and was approaching both 200 innings and strikeouts as he enjoyed the most productive campaign of his major-league career. After striking out the first two batters, Berríos walked Jed Lowrie to bring cleanup hitter Khris Davis. The Athletics’ slugger was enjoying his third consecutive 40-homer campaign and would finish the season by batting .247 for the fourth straight year. Davis punished Berríos’s walk by slamming the ball over the Xfinity sign on the right-center-field wall near the 388-foot marker for a 2–0 Oakland lead.
For the second inning, Hendriks gave way to a more recognized starter in Chris Bassitt. Oakland’s featured pitcher, a native of Toledo, Ohio, came to the Coliseum in a good mood. Bassitt arrived for work in a Cleveland Browns jersey, celebrating a 21–17 win over the New York Jets the prior evening that ended a 635-day winless streak for his favorite football team.1 Bassitt put the Twins down in order. For the home half, Berríos induced a ground out from Stephen Piscotty before back-to-back singles by Ramón Laureano and Marcus Semien placed runners at the corners. Jonathan Lucroy lofted a sacrifice fly to Kepler in right field that scored Laureano for a 3–0 Oakland advantage. Martini reached on an error by third baseman Ehire Adrianza, but Chapman’s groundout ended the second.
Berríos struck out the side in the Oakland third but hit Piscotty to open the bottom of the fourth. Laureano sharply grounded into center field through an infield gap, moving Piscotty to third and Laureano taking second on the throw. Piscotty scored on Semien’s long sacrifice fly to Kepler. Berríos then walked Martini, but Chapman’s grounder to Adrianza ended the frame with Oakland leading, 4–0.
The Twins and Athletics traded zeros in the fifth. Bassitt gave way to Lou Trivino in the top of the sixth. The rookie reliever entered the game with an 8–3 record and 2.50 ERA in 66 appearances. He unraveled quickly in his 67th appearance. Cave led off the Minnesota sixth with a double into left-center. Grossman smacked the first pitch he saw over the wall into the right-field seats to cut the Oakland advantage in half, 4–2. Kepler and Tyler Austin singled in subsequent at-bats to send Trivino to an early shower without recording an out. Adrianza doubled off right-hander Shawn Kelley to score Kepler as Austin advanced to third. Oakland finally retired a Twins batter when Willians Astudillo flied out to Piscotty in right field. Piscotty gathered the second out of the inning by catching Gregorio Petit’s fly ball in foul territory. Kelley gave an intentional walk to Mauer to load the bases and set up the force play, a move that backfired when Jorge Polanco cleared the bases by lifting the ball over Laureano’s head toward the center-field wall for a 6–4 Twins lead. The inning ended when Polanco was tagged out in a rundown between second and third.
Leading for the first time, Berríos helped to initiate Oakland’s rally by walking Piscotty on four pitches to start the bottom of the sixth. Berríos struck out Laureano and Semien, with each batter watching strike three, before some managerial gamesmanship took over. Melvin replaced Lucroy with left-handed batter Matt Joyce to face the right-handed Berríos. Twins manager Paul Molitor countered by calling lefty Gabriel Moya from the bullpen. Berríos had thrown 104 pitches by this point, and his effort might have merited a better pitching line than five earned runs in 5 2/3 innings pitched. About his effort, Berríos said, “I feel like I was commanding all my pitches. I felt strong out there. My only mistake was that pitch to Davis and he hit it out.”2
In one final move before another pitch was thrown, Melvin countered Molitor’s counter by replacing Joyce with right-handed Mark Canha. Melvin won the chess match when Canha drove Moya’s 2–2 pitch into the left-field seats to tie the game at 6. Canha was not necessarily expecting to hit the ball out of the park but enjoyed the achievement. He noted, “I love those moments. I wasn’t thinking about hitting a home run. I was just trying to have a good at-bat, but when something like that happens it just gets the blood flowing a little bit. It’s a lot of fun.”3 Another set of moves—Trevor May in for Moya and Chad Pinder hitting for Martini—proved much less decisive when Pinder lined out to Grossman in left and ended the sixth inning.
After that eventful inning, neither team did much to threaten the deadlock, failing to advance a runner beyond first until the bottom of the ninth. With two outs and Canha on first by way of a walk, Chapman doubled off Matt Magill to advance Canha within 90 feet of the win. Lowrie’s fly out quickly ended the rally and sent the game to extra innings.
Oakland reliever Blake Treinen set down the Twins in order in the ninth. He was enjoying a dream season. In 74 1/3 innings over 63 appearances entering this game, he had 94 strikeouts and sported a 7–2 record and microscopic 0.85 ERA. He put the down in order again in the 10th.
Magill returned to the mound for the bottom of the 10th. Since his first-inning blast, Davis had struck out, lined out, and popped out. With a 1–1 count, Davis blasted Magill’s pitch over the right-center wall in almost the exact location as his first-inning home run. About his game-winning blast, Davis observed “I thought it had a chance to go, but I thought it was a double. Initially, I was thinking: ‘Yeah, I can get on second. ‘Then, it just kind of carried. That’s even better.”4
As Davis rounded third, he removed his batting helmet and used it to take a jump shot into the crowd of teammates waiting for him at the plate. The home run counted as Davis’s 45th of the season and increased his RBI tally to 119, with fans chanting “M-V-P!” Melvin stated, “I was one of those chanting. You look at his numbers and what he’s meant to this team, he definitely needs to be in the conversation.”5 In the end, Davis led the majors in home runs with 48 but did not factor into the MVP voting. Mookie Betts won the award for the AL, while Davis finished eighth.
With the postseason nearing, the Athletics’ offense was electric. This evening marked the eighth consecutive home game that the Athletics had scored at least seven runs, breaking that very specific franchise record that dated to 1913 and 1932 when the club was in Philadelphia.6 The loss clinched a losing season for the Twins and marked their 14th walk-off loss of 2018. Molitor said, “It was tough today because we did have a nice rally.”7 The Twins had indeed rallied in the middle innings, but Khris Davis owned the beginning and the end of the game.
Photo credit
Khris Davis, Trading Card Database.
Sources
In addition to the sources cited below, the author also used the following sources:
MLB Film Room game highlights accessible at: https://www.mlb.com/video/?q=september+21,+2018&qt=FREETEXT
https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/OAK/OAK201809210.shtml
https://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/2018/B09210OAK2018.htm
Notes
1 Rusty Simmons, “Assurances from execs,” San Francisco Chronicle, September 22, 2018: B5.
2 Rhett Bollinger, “Twins squander 6-run 6th in walk-off loss,” MLB.com, September 22, 2018, accessed at https://www.mlb.com/news/twins-waste-6-run-inning-in-loss-to-a-s-c295595348?game_pk=531706
3 Jane Lee, “Khrush’s walk-off HR cuts A’s magic number to 3,” MLB.com, September 22, 2018, accessed at https://www.mlb.com/news/khris-davis-homers-twice-hits-walk-off-blast-c295594946?game_pk=531706
4 Simmons, “Strength decides it as Davis belts two,” San Francisco Chronicle, September 22, 2018: B1.
5 Simmons.
6 Simmons.
7 Bollinger.
Additional Stats
Oakland Athletics 7
Minnesota Twins 6
10 innings
Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum
Oakland, CA
Box Score + PBP:
Corrections? Additions?
If you can help us improve this game story, contact us.
