Wes Westrum was a superb defensive catcher for the New York Giants in New York City’s post-World War II golden years, when the Yankees, Dodgers, and Giants won 17 of 24 league pennants and nine of 12 World Series between 1946 and 1957. Westrum was selected to the National League All-Star team in 1952 and 1953 and caught all six games of the Giants’ loss to the Yankees in the 1951 World Series and all four games of the Giants’ sweep of the Cleveland Indians in the 1954 Series. He was pictured with Milwaukee Braves slugger Eddie Mathews and umpire Augie Donatelli on the cover of the August 16, 1954, inaugural issue of Sports Illustrated. Westrum later managed the New York Mets and San Francisco Giants. It was quite a journey for the humble athlete who had been born Wesley Noreen Westrum on November 28, 1922, in tiny Clearbrook, Minnesota (1940 population: 425), nestled in the far northwestern part of the state, 250 miles from Minneapolis and a world away from the major leagues.
Westrum starred in football, basketball, and baseball in high school. He was a bruising fullback, and many of his old friends and opponents thought football was his best sport, but he got a chance to play professional baseball while still in high school. He signed with the Crookston Pirates of the Class D Northern League in 1940, while he was still a junior at Clearbrook High School. (Because of the scarcity of summer jobs at the time, schools permitted youngsters to retain their eligibility if they played summer professional baseball.) Westrum originally was slated as an understudy to catcher and manager Fred Neisler, a 10-year minor-league journeyman, but he got some extended playing time when Neisler injured a foot. Westrum lost three weeks in July when he severely cut his right wrist in the team bus—foreshadowing, perhaps, the many injuries that would later plague his career. He finished the season with a .275 batting average, three home runs, and 23 runs batted in (RBIs).
Westrum signed with the Minneapolis Millers of the American Association (then Class AA, the minors’ highest classification) after graduation in 1941 and was sent to play with Eau Claire in the Northern League, which had moved up to Class C. He had a great year, hitting .330 with seven home runs and 70 RBIs and was voted the league’s All-Star catcher.
Westrum went to spring training with the Millers in 1942 but was optioned to Little Rock of the Class A1 Southern Association. An injury and some weak hitting limited Westrum to 45 games that season. He sat on the bench behind 10-year minor-league catcher Herb Bremer, who had also played 70 games with the St. Louis Cardinals in the 1937 to 1939 seasons. Westrum finished with a .202 batting average in only 104 at bats.
Nevertheless, the Millers, who were considering switching Westrum to the outfield, brought him back to their spring-training camp in 1943. But, like most young players at the time, Westrum was drafted and spent the next three years in military service. He spent most of his time working security at the Green Haven Army Barracks, near Poughkeepsie, New York. Green Haven was a brand-new, still unused maximum-security state prison used by the Army to house deserters and other military miscreants.
In later years Westrum joked that the experience was valuable in helping him deal with the hapless New York Mets when he managed them in the mid-1960s. He met his future wife, Josephine, in Poughkeepsie, as well, and they made the city their year-round home after their marriage. Westrum worked as a youth coach at the Poughkeepsie YMCA, played some semipro basketball in the offseasons, and eventually became a deputy sheriff in Dutchess County.
Westrum became the property of the New York Giants in 1946 when the Giants purchased the Minneapolis Millers. The Giants sent him to their Jacksonville, Florida, farm team in the Class A Sally (South Atlantic) League, where he had a solid year, played in the league’s All-Star game, and hit .275 with eight home runs and 56 RBIs. Back in spring training with the Millers in 1947, Westrum confessed that he’d been too tense in spring training with the Millers in 1942 and that it had carried over and hurt his performance at Little Rock. He said he finally figured it out during his three years in military service, and it was the cruel reality that all baseball players must confront—that even the best hitters fail the majority of the time. “I reached the natural baseball conclusion,” he told Minneapolis Tribune writer Halsey Hall: “You do or you don’t. So I stepped up to the plate, just relaxed and let the pitcher worry.”
He said he was also working hard at protecting his right hand. By his own count, he suffered eight broken fingers in his 11 seasons in the major leagues. In addition, he was plagued constantly by sprained or jammed fingers. Westrum said he might have done better at Jacksonville but that an early-season jammed finger slowed him the rest of the year.
Catching gloves of the 1940s and 1950s demanded a two-handed catching style, with the right hand (only five left-handers have caught more than 100 games in major-league history) used to trap the ball in the pocket. Catchers waited for the pitch with their bare hand clenched in a fist next to the glove and opened the hand at the last possible instant to trap the ball or to grab it to prepare to throw out a potential base stealer. In theory, the hand would still be in a fist when a foul tip was struck, but frequently the catcher would be opening his fist at the same time, exposing his fingers to possible injury. Flex-hinged designs that began to resemble first-basemen’s gloves didn’t come along until the late 1960s, when today’s one-handed catching style was pioneered by the Cubs’ Randy Hundley and Cincinnati Hall-of-Famer Johnny Bench.
Some old-time catchers were better or luckier at avoiding right-hand injuries, but bent and gnarled fingers were definitely an occupational hazard. It was easy to pick out a retired catcher in a room full of retired players by observing his hands.
Westrum had a break-out season with the Millers in 1947, hitting .294 with 22 home runs and 87 RBIs. He was the top vote-getter at catcher in the All-Star voting. (The American Association did not play an All-Star game, however.) The Giants called Westrum up in September, but he played little as five-time All-Star Walker Cooper was chasing Gabby Hartnett’s record 37 home runs in a season by a catcher. (He fell short with 35.) However, Westrum did get five hits in 12 at-bats and was virtually given the job as Cooper’s backup in 1948. Giants farm director Carl Hubbell drooled when he talked about Westrum. The team was convinced that Westrum was the best young catcher to come into the league in years.
The 1948 season, unfortunately, turned out as disappointing as 1947 was promising. Westrum did win the number-two catching spot in spring training, beating out 33-year-old journeyman Mickey Livingston, who’d played 467 games in the majors over seven seasons, and 24-year-old prospect Sal Yvars, another September call-up in 1947. Westrum got a big opportunity when Cooper had knee surgery in early May, but he hit only .127 in his first 34 games of the season, and lost playing time to Livingston, who at least kept his batting average over .200. Cooper wound up catching in 79 games, Westrum 63, and Livingston 42. For the season, Westrum hit only .160 in 125 at bats.
The Giants sent him to Jersey City in the Class AAA International League at the start of the 1949 season, where he got off to a great start, hitting .308 with 15 home runs—five of them grand slams—in just 51 games. Westrum was called up on June 14 just after Walker Cooper, who was not getting along with Giants manager Leo Durocher, was traded to Cincinnati for 12-year veteran catcher Ray Mueller. Westrum told a wonderful story to Steve Bitker for his 2001 book, The Original San Francisco Giants: The Giants of ’58. Westrum said he had just broken a finger prior to the call-up, but Durocher told him to “just put a piece of tape around it, and rub it in the dirt. You’re catching [Giants ace Larry] Jansen.”
Bob Mayer related a similar story in his November 2001 Baseball Digest article, “Turn Back the Clock: Former Catcher Wes Westrum Recalls Career With Giants—Interview.” However, in this version of the story, the events took place after Westrum’s late September call-up in 1947, in the second game of a doubleheader at Chicago when the Giants’ manager was Mel Ott. The facts are that Westrum did catch his first major-league game on September 17, 1947, in Chicago. He went 2-for-4 in the Giants’ 12-10 loss, but Jansen did not pitch in the game. On the other hand, Westrum caught Jansen’s 2-0 win over Cincinnati on June 14, 1949.
It’s possible that Westrum just got his facts confused in the Mayer interview. It’s also possible that the episode never happened—another of baseball’s apocryphal tales that acquire the status of truth from their continued telling. What is clear, however, is that players and fans who knew Westrum could easily believe the story was true because he played so often with injured and broken fingers.
Westrum split catching duties with Ray Mueller for the balance of the 1949 season. After a slow start, his hitting picked up in the last two months of the season, and he finished with a .243 batting average and showed some power, with seven home runs in 169 at-bats.
Westrum became the regular Giants catcher in 1950 and had a banner year. He caught 139 games and set a major-league record for catchers with only one error in 680 chances, a .999 fielding percentage. (Florida catcher Charles Johnson went errorless in 1997 to break that record, and St. Louis’s Mike Matheny went errorless in 2003.) Westrum was hitting about .270 until injuries brought him down to .236, but he hit 23 home runs and drove in 71 runs with just 103 hits. He had his career day in a game against Cincinnati on June 24 in the Polo Grounds in New York, when he went 4-for-4, with three home runs and a triple, and scored five runs in the Giants’ 12-2 romp.
Westrum lost some time early in the 1951 season due to a broken fingertip caused by a foul tip, and both hands were beaten up most of the season, but he caught 122 games and was a key player in the Giants’ miracle pennant drive. The team was 13 games behind the Dodgers on August 12, which was observed as Wes Westrum Day at the Polo Grounds, sponsored by Dutchess County. Westrum often joked that the pennant drive began when he was given a car by his hometown fans and friends—as the Giants won the game to begin a 14-game winning streak that cut the Dodgers’ margin to five games. (How times had changed—when his Clearbrook friends sponsored a “day” for the young catcher at Crookston back in 1940, his gift was a pen-and-pencil set.) The Giants wound up tied with the Dodgers, and their fairy-tale season was climaxed by Bobby Thomson’s three-run homer in the bottom of the ninth for a 5-4 win of the third and final playoff game. After that the World Series seemed like an anti-climax, and the Giants lost to the Yankees, four games to two.
Westrum’s hands were so sore during the season that he often had a hard time gripping the bat. He hit only .219 for the year, but he hit 20 home runs and was a tough clutch hitter—driving in 70 runs with only 79 hits. He also drew 104 walks and had a career-high .400 on-base percentage. Westrum’s teammates heaped praise on their unsung hero. “Pitching was what took us over the hill in this race,” Eddie Stanky said, “and it was Wes’s handling of the pitchers that played a tremendous part in their success. . . . I think he’s the best defensive catcher in baseball.”
Monte Irvin marveled at Westrum’s ability to play while hurt. “He’ll hit around .280 and hit maybe 30 homers if he can keep his hands in shape,” Irvin said.
But Westrum could not keep his hands in shape. His 1952 season got off well. He played in 54 of the Giants’ first 55 games, with 12 home runs and 29 RBIs. Then he broke another finger, re-injured it when he returned to action, broke a thumb, and then suffered a split finger. He managed only two home runs and 14 RBIs in his last 60 games and wound up with a .220 batting average. He caught only 112 games.
Westrum retained his starting position the next two years, but his injuries had taken their toll, and he was pressed by Ray Noble, Sam Calderone, and Sal Yvars in 1953 and Ray Katt and Ebba St. Claire in 1954. Westrum caught all four games in the Giants’ sweep of the Cleveland Indians in the 1954 World Series although he’d only hit .187 in 98 games during the season. He was backup to Katt in 1955, Bill Sarni in 1956, and Valmy Thomas in 1957.
When the Giants moved to San Francisco in 1958, manager Bill Rigney, who’d taken over for Leo Durocher in 1956, told Westrum he would keep him as the third-string catcher if he still wanted to play but preferred to have him as a coach. Westrum thought it over for a few days and decided to retire and accept the coaching position. His career line, with 11 seasons in the majors, showed him with 919 games played, 302 runs, 503 hits, 96 home runs, and 315 RBIs. He had a batting average of .217 and an on-base percentage of .356.
Westrum started as the bullpen coach at San Francisco in 1958 but was made the first-base coach in 1959. As a catcher he was respected for his astute baseball sense and field generalship. He claimed he could often tell when a baserunner was going to attempt a steal by the way he took his lead from the base. As a first-base coach he quickly acquired the reputation as a great pitch-stealer. He said that many pitchers unknowingly telegraphed their pitches by the way they gripped the ball or stood on the rubber. Even if they tried to hide their grip, some tilted their glove or wrist a little differently from one pitch to another.
There were other indicators, as well. New York Mets catcher Chris Cannizzaro said that Westrum, who was with the Giants at the time, gave him some friendly advice while walking off the field after a 1962 game at the Polo Grounds. “Watch your feet when you come out after giving signs,” Westrum told Cannizzaro, who hadn’t realized he took a different catching stance for a fastball than he did for a curveball.
There wasn’t much time to relay the pitch information to a batter. Westrum would use voice signals for left-handed hitters, who could not see him in the first-base coaching box. For right-handers he might use his posture as a cue—bending over for a curve, for example, or standing straight up for a fastball. Of course, there would have to be an indicator to tell the hitter when he actually knew what pitch was coming.
Westrum and his family moved to the Phoenix, Arizona, area during his Giants coaching days, and he worked for the Arizona State Highway Department in the offseason. After the 1963 season, he was involved in a rare coaching trade of sorts. Mets coach Cookie Lavagetto, who had just recovered from a serious illness, asked if he could be moved to San Francisco to get back to his hometown in Oakland. After some discussions with the owners and managers of the two teams, the Giants agreed to take Lavagetto as a coach to replace Westrum, who was made a coach with the Mets for manager Casey Stengel.
In July 1965 the 75-year-old Stengel fell and broke his left hip while stepping out of a car. Major surgery was required to insert a metal ball in the hip to reduce the displaced fracture, and Stengel pulled a surprise when he called Mets president George Weiss and recommended Westrum as the interim manager. Most thought that his choice would be Mets coach Yogi Berra, whom Stengel had once called his “assistant manager” when Berra played for Stengel with the New York Yankees. Picking Westrum, though, seemed to indicate that Stengel planned to return as manager in 1966, figuring it would be easier for Westrum to step down than for the popular and ambitious Berra.
Five weeks later, however, Stengel announced his retirement. Westrum, in the meantime, promised to telephone Stengel regularly for advice and tried to get the team to focus more on baseball. “I want the players to talk more baseball, particularly in the clubhouse. . . . Every time we lose, I want them to spend five minutes in front of their locker trying to find out what they did wrong,” Westrum said. If the players followed through, it didn’t show on the field. The team that had won 40, 51, and 53 games in Stengel’s first three years finished 19-48 under Westrum for a 50-112 overall record and the team’s fourth consecutive last-place finish.
It wasn’t until November 19, 1965, that the Mets finally made it official and named Westrum to be Stengel’s successor. He said the team would think positive and run more, and he set an ambitious goal of 70 wins and a first-division finish. Stengel’s fractured phrasing, affectionately called Stengelese, had been great copy for reporters covering the Mets, but the shy and reserved Westrum provided them with some malapropisms of his own. He paid tribute to Stengel by saying “They broke the molding when they made that man.” In his first spring training as manager in 1966, after a string of close games, Westrum observed, “We keep playing those cliff dwellers.”
Westrum was the fourth of five players on Leo Durocher’s remarkable 1951 Giants team to become a major-league manager. Eddie Stanky (1952), Bill Rigney (1956), Alvin Dark (1961), and Whitey Lockman (1972) were the others.
The 1966 Mets did not make it to 70 wins or the first division, but they made a 16-game improvement to finish at 66-95 and in ninth place, 7½ games ahead of the last-place Cubs. They went backwards in 1967, though, and the local press and long-suffering Mets fans were unhappy. “On September 1, 1967, the Mets were 51-79,” Peter Golenbock observed in Amazin’, his 2002 history of the Mets. “Fans, no longer the rebels they once were, and no longer interested in lovable losers, stayed home in droves. Without Stengel these Mets were no longer lovable. Under the colorless Westrum, they were just another bad ball club.”
As the season drew to a close, Westrum was looking for assurance that he would be rehired for 1968. Mets president Bing Devine, hired from the Cardinals in 1966 to succeed George Weiss, would not make a commitment, however, and on September 21 Westrum resigned, tired of losing and tired of waiting for a decision. His old friend, San Francisco Giants owner Horace Stoneham, hired him shortly to be the team’s first-base coach.
Westrum remained a coach for four years, and then became the Giants’ major-league scout in 1972. The Giants tapped him to replace manager Charlie Fox on June 28, 1974. The Giants had won the National League West Division under Fox in 1971 but lost to Pittsburgh in the National League Championship Series, then finished fifth in the division in 1972 and third in 1973, and were eight games under .500 at midseason in 1974. Fox, who had been in the Giants organization as a player, coach, and manager for 33 years, “resigned in the best interest of the club.” The managerial change didn’t change things on the field. The team went 38-48 under Westrum and finished in fifth place in the West Division.
These were tough times for Giants owner Horace Stoneham, who was struggling financially. Rumors circulated that the team was for sale or was being relocated. Although players and team employees were being paid, the team cut costs in many areas. Despite all the off-field distractions, Westrum guided the team to third place in the West in 1975, finishing with an 80-81 record. Anticipating a sale of the team, Stoneham asked Westrum and his coaching staff to submit their resignations just before the end of the season. They refused, fearing a voluntary resignation would make them ineligible for unemployment insurance. Just prior to the Thanksgiving holiday, Westrum and his staff were finally fired, and shortly thereafter Stoneham sold the team to a minority stockholder, Bob Lurie, a local real-estate developer.
Westrum was retained by the Giants as a major-league scout in 1976, but in 1977 he signed with the Atlanta Braves to become a part-time scout, working out of his home in Mesa, Arizona. He served in that capacity until the 1994 players’ strike. He died of cancer on May 28, 2002 in Clearbrook, Minnesota, where he’d maintained a summer lake cottage. At his funeral, old friends and neighbors reminisced about their hometown hero. They said he remained a modest and unassuming fellow even after he made the big time. “If you asked him about baseball, he’d tell you stories,” said his old friend Al Bergman. “But he never bragged about it. You had to ask him about baseball for him to talk about it.”
His old friends had set up the Wes Westrum Baseball Museum in a 25-by-50 foot room in the local Clearbrook 256 American Legion Post in 1990, consisting mainly of items removed from Westrum’s lake cottage. “You don’t want to take all this junk to town,” Westrum marveled at the time. He hadn’t looked at some of the items for years. Some were just stored in old boxes.
The museum was a great source of pride for the community, but dwindling membership forced the Legion post to sell the building, and the space for the exhibits was no longer available for the museum. It was a bittersweet day in April 2007 when most of the friends who’d set up the displays in 1990 got back together, this time to carefully take them down to pack and ship to Westrum’s daughter and family back in Arizona.
A version of this biography appeared in the book Minnesotans in Baseball, edited by Stew Thornley (Nodin, 2009).
Bitker, Steve, The Original San Francisco Giants: The Giants of ’58
Golenbock, Peter, Amazin’: The Miraculous History of New York’s Most Beloved Baseball Team
Johnson, Lloyd, and Miles Wolff, editors, The Encyclopedia of Minor League Baseball
The Sporting News
New York Times
Grand Forks Herald
San Francisco Business Times
Crookston Daily Times
Old-Time Data: The Professional Baseball Player Database [CD]
The Topps Company