August 27, 2017: Rookie Rhys Hoskins shines with bat and glove in Phillies’ win over Cubs
During his formative years, Rhys Hoskins was an underappreciated baseball player. He excelled as a three-sport star at Jesuit High School in Carmichael, California, yet went undrafted by Major League Baseball after his senior year. Determined to continue playing, he found just one college — nearby Sacramento State University — that offered him a baseball scholarship. After leading the Hornets to the NCAA Tournament for the first time in their history, he still lasted until the fifth round of the June 2014 amateur draft before the Philadelphia Phillies selected him.1
Summarizing the unheralded journey that finally landed Hoskins with a major league organization, Joe Potulny, his high school coach, said, “I think people just missed him along the way.”2
Even during his first two seasons in Philadelphia’s organization, Hoskins was overshadowed by more highly regarded prospects such as Maikel Franco, J.P. Crawford, and Nick Williams. Then, after belting 38 home runs at Double-A Reading in 2016, he finally cracked the Phillies’ Top 10 prospect list.3
Hoskins began 2017 in Triple-A Lehigh Valley, where he remained into the late days of summer. He again posted impressive power numbers,4 but failed to get a promotion, even though the Phillies were bound for last place in the National League East Division for the third time in four seasons. Finally on August 10, prior to the start of a four-game series against the New York Mets, the Phillies summoned Hoskins.
He collected just one hit against the Mets before catching fire. Over the next 13 games, Hoskins hit 10 home runs and quickly captured the hearts of the Philly fans. On August 27, with Philadelphia wrapping up a three-game home series with the defending World Series champion Chicago Cubs, he was ‘an integral part of the Phillies’ lineup.
Hoskins was one of three rookies in manager Pete Mackanin’s lineup for the Sunday afternoon game. Williams, who had joined the team on June 30, was batting third and playing right field, while Nick Pivetta, who had debuted on April 30, was the starting pitcher. Hoskins was batting cleanup and playing left field.
Chicago, which led the NL Central Division by three games over the Milwaukee Brewers, struck quickly in the top of the first. Ben Zobrist reached on an error by first baseman Tommy Joseph, future Phillie Kyle Schwarber walked on four pitches, and Kris Bryant singled up the middle to load the bases. Cleanup hitter Anthony Rizzo singled to right, driving in the first two runs, and Tommy La Stella grounded to short, scoring Bryant and giving the Cubs a 3-0 lead.
Pivetta walked the next two batters, loading the bases again, before striking out René Rivera and retiring opposing starting pitcher John Lackey on a grounder.
In the bottom of the first, Lackey struck out César Hernández, Freddy Galvis, and Williams, who went down swinging on a 2-and-2 pitch. In the second, Hoskins and Joseph fanned before Franco smashed a line drive single to left and Pedro Florimón grounded a single up the middle. Catcher Cameron Rupp grounded out, stranding the runners.
Lackey, who entered the game with a 10-9 record and a 4.90 ERA, continued his scoreless pitching into the third and fourth innings, retiring six of the next seven batters. Williams, who stroked a fourth-inning leadoff single, was the only Philadelphia batter to reach base.
Pivetta settled down after the rocky first inning, holding the Cubs scoreless over the next four frames despite allowing numerous base runners. “He found himself on the mound,” Rupp said later. “He didn’t do more than he can do. He made pitches when he needed to.”5
Pivetta retired the Cubs in order in the second. La Stella and Javier Báez singled in the third but were stranded. Lackey singled leading off the fourth, but Pivetta dispatched the next three batters.
After four innings the score remained 3-0. In the fifth the action intensified.
Rizzo drew a leadoff walk and La Stella lined a sharp single to center, putting runners on first and second. Baez hit a sinking liner to left, and both runners took off. Hoskins, running full tilt, made a shoestring catch but dropped the ball as he attempted the transfer. He casually retrieved it and lobbed to second baseman Hernández, who stepped on second and threw to first to complete a rare 7-4-3 triple play6—one of only six in major-league history recorded in SABR’s Triple Play Database as of 2026.
Rizzo was distraught about his base-running blunder. “I saw the topspin. I read it wrong but I thought it was down. I was thinking to score,” he said.7
Cubs manager Joe Maddon challenged the ruling that it was a catch, but after review the call was confirmed. The unusual play revitalized the Phillies and seemed to rattle the Cubs.
“They grabbed the momentum right there,” Maddon said.8
“Anytime something like that happens,” Mackanin said, “it kind of gets everyone’s energy up.”9
Florimón, playing center in place of the injured Odúbel Herrera, led off the bottom of the fifth with a well-placed bunt single. Rupp bounced a ball to third that rolled under Bryant’s glove as Florimón raced to third on the error.
“I should have totally stayed back on it, knowing the speed of [Rupp],” Bryant said.10
Hyun Soo Kim, batting for Pivetta, lined out to second. With Hernández batting, Lackey tossed a wild pitch, allowing Florimón to score and Rupp to move to second. Hernández walked, and when Lackey unleashed another wild pitch,11the runners advanced.
Galvis singled to right, driving home Rupp and Hernández, then Williams blasted a line-drive home run, his eighth of the season, over the right field wall.
Lackey retired Hoskins and Joseph, and the inning ended with the Phillies on top 5-3.
Three Philadelphia relievers held the Cubs in check through the eighth. Héctor Rondón replaced Lackey and he, along with Justin Wilson, kept the Phillies off the board in the sixth and seventh.
In the eighth Hoskins belted a leadoff homer off new Cubs reliever Koji Uehara, extending Philadelphia’s lead to 6-3. The home run was Hoskins’ 11th since joining the Phillies, making him the fastest player in National or American League history to reach that mark. He had reached 11 home runs in 18 games.
Uehara finished the eighth without further damage, then Hector Neris secured the save, his 16th of the season, with a clean top of the ninth. Pivetta earned the win and Lackey took the loss.
Maddon had high praise for the Phillies’ newest slugger. “I don’t think I’ve ever seen a young guy look that profound at home plate,” he said.12
Hoskins’ historic first season rolled on as he continued to hit home runs at an unprecedented clip.13 When the season concluded Hoskins had tallied 18 homers, in only 50 games, and finished fourth in NL Rookie of the Year voting.14
Across six seasons in Philadelphia, Hoskins launched 148 home runs and added six more in the 2022 postseason to help power the Phillies to the World Series. During spring training in 2023 he suffered a torn ACL in his left knee, which cost him the season. He became a free agent at the end of the season and signed with the Milwaukee Brewers.15
Despite being overlooked by college recruiters and MLB scouts, Hoskins never doubted himself. “I’m confident in the ability I have,” he said during his record-breaking rookie season. “I’m trying to just lose myself in the routine and the preparation and let the ability shine through when it’s game time.”16
Acknowledgments
This article was fact-checked by Laura Peebles and copy-edited by Keith Thursby.
Photo credit: Rhys Hoskins, Trading Card Database.
Sources
In addition to the sources cited in the Notes, the author consulted Baseball Reference.com and Retrosheet.org for information including the box score and play-by-play.
https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/PHI/PHI201708270.shtml
https://www.retrosheet.org/boxesetc/2017/B08270PHI2017.htm
Notes
1 Dave Sheinen, “Rhys Hoskins’ First Month with Phillies One for the Ages,” Toronto Star, August 30, 2017, https://www.thestar.com/sports/baseball/rhys-hoskins-first-month-with-phillies-one-for-the-ages/article_0c354a6e-8d0d-50f7-bedb-c78a174a83a8.html.
2 Sheinen, “Rhys Hoskins’ First Month with Phillies One for the Ages.”
3 Baseball America ranked Hoskins sixth on the Phillies 2017 top prospects list.
4 Hoskins had 29 home runs and 91 RBI in 115 games at Triple-A Lehigh Valley in 2017.
5 Matt Gelb, “After First Inning Woes, Pivetta Finds Footing and Beats Cubs,” Philadelphia Inquirer, August 28, 2017: D5.
6 Matt Gelb, “Awesome,” Philadelphia Inquirer, August 28, 2017: D1.
7 Mark Gonzales, “Great Start Only Leads to Grating Finish,” Chicago Tribune, August 28, 2017: 3-1.
8 Gelb, “Awesome,” Philadelphia Inquirer, August 28, 2017: D1.
9 Gelb, “Awesome.”
10 Gonzales, “Great Start Only Leads to Grating Finish.”
11 Lackey finished in the top 10 in wild pitches seven times in his 15-season career.
12 Gelb, “Awesome.”
13 Hoskins hit 18 home runs in his first 34 games.
14 Cody Bellinger won Rookie of the Year, receiving all 30 first-place votes.
15 Hoskins signed with the Brewers on January 26, 2024.
16 SI Staff, “Rhys Hoskins Shines in First Month in Majors” Sports Illustrated, September 2, 2017, https://www.si.com/mlb/2017/09/03/ap-bbn-phillies-hoskins.
Additional Stats
Philadelphia Phillies 6
Chicago Cubs 3
Citizens Bank Park
Philadelphia, PA
Box Score + PBP:
Corrections? Additions?
If you can help us improve this game story, contact us.

