The Mystery of Jackie Mitchell and Babe Ruth

 

On April 2, 1931 history was made in Chattanooga, Tennessee. That same day a mystery was also born. Seventeen-year-old Jackie Mitchell took the mound against the New York Yankees, striking out Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig before walking Tony Lazzeri. Mitchell placed her name in the record books with the strikeouts but also became part of an ongoing debate and mystery regarding the circumstances surrounding the game. Who was Jackie Mitchell? Where did she come from? Did she really strike out the Yankee stars or was it all a publicity hoax?

Born Virne Beatrice Mitchell on August 29, 1913, Mitchell grew up in Memphis, Tennessee. Her mother sold hosiery and her father was an optician. Mitchell was encouraged by her father to take part in sports. Growing up, she played basketball, tennis, and baseball, and swam. As a youngster Mitchell supposedly learned to pitch from one of the family’s neighbors, Dazzy Vance. She later told reporters that Vance taught her a drop ball, or sinker. Vance had pitched for the Dodgers, winning the National League MVP in 1924. When she was a teenager, Mitchell’s family moved to Chattanooga. Mitchell joined a local baseball school and it was here that the new president of the Chattanooga Lookouts saw her pitching.

Joe Engel signed on as the new president of the Lookouts in 1929 and in 1931 he followed a common practice of minor-league teams arranging exhibition games with major-league clubs. The New York Yankees were returning north after spring training in 1931 and Engel was able to sign a contract for two exhibition games. Shortly after setting up these games, Engel signed Mitchell to a contract, announcing that she would pitch in one of the games. And here is where the real debate begins. Did Engel sign Mitchell for real or was she just a publicity stunt? It was the heart of the Great Depression and teams everywhere were adding special events and exhibitions to make money. Signing Mitchell could certainly be seen in that light.

When Mitchell signed her contract, she became only the second woman to sign an Organized Baseball contract. The first was Lizzie Arlington, who signed to play with the Reading Coal Heavers in 1898. Female baseball players on men’s teams were not a common sight. Most women playing baseball were part of the bloomer teams that barnstormed the country from the 1910s through the 1930s. Engel would have certainly seen the opportunity to bring in fans to watch Mitchell pitch, especially against the Yankees. About 4,000 fans were reported in the stands to watch Mitchell get a chance to pitch against Babe Ruth.

Engel had a reputation for pulling off crazy stunts, so the strikeouts could have been staged. Engel raffled off a house to a fan and traded a shortstop for a turkey. He then cooked the turkey and served it to the local reporters. He later sold “stock” to fans to save the ballclub from being sold. He held an elephant hunt in the outfield before a game, offering fans the chance to hunt some papier-mache animals. Engel’s willingness to try just about anything to generate publicity has led many researchers and fans to believe the strikeouts were staged. An added fact was that the game was originally supposed to take place on April 1 but was postponed due to cold. The exhibition could have been an April Fool’s Day joke.1

So what actually took place on April 2, 1931? The Lookouts started Clyde Barfoot against the Yankees but Barfoot never got past the first two batters. He gave up a leadoff double and then a single before Engel called Mitchell in to the game. Mitchell entered the game as a 17-year-old southpaw preparing to pitch to the Sultan of Swat, Babe Ruth. Prior to the game, publicity photos were taken of Mitchell with Ruth and Gehrig. The photos showed a slight young girl in an oversized uniform with a grin on her face and Ruth and Gehrig looking more solemn. They even had her take out a mirror and powder her nose.2

After throwing a few warm-up pitches, Mitchell threw two pitches that Ruth swung at and missed. She followed that with a called third strike. Ruth threw his bat in disgust and stormed back to the dugout. Some stories at the time claimed he turned and smiled before he left the field, adding to the idea that the whole thing was staged. Next up was Lou Gehrig and Mitchell struck him out with three pitches as well. She then walked Tony Lazzeri and Engel took her out of the game in favor of bringing back Barfoot. The Lookouts went on to lose, 14-4, making the game less than memorable except for Mitchell’s pitching. A few days after the game, Mitchell’s contract was voided but she did not leave baseball. She continued to pitch for another Engel team, the Junior Lookouts. After barnstorming the rest of the 1931 season and some of 1932, Mitchell signed with the well-known bearded House of David nine. She was promoted as the famous girl pitcher. After playing with the House of David on and off for a few years, Mitchell retired from baseball in 1937 and went to work for her father. She claimed until the day she died in 1987 that the strikeouts were legitimate. Her own claims added to the debate.3

Other ideas that have been proposed to support the legitimacy of the strikeouts include her pitching itself but also Ruth and Gehrig. There were two runners on base when Ruth came up; would he have deliberately struck out to leave the runners stranded? Ruth hit a lot of home runs but he also struck out a great deal, making it believable that Mitchell could have struck him out. Add to that Gehrig’s strikeout, which many believed he would never have agreed to stage. Teammate Lefty Gomez later stated in an interview that Yankee manager Joe McCarthy was too competitive to ever stage such strikeouts. Then there was Mitchell herself. She was a southpaw pitcher who had a good sinker/curveball-style pitch. She was also someone they had never faced before. Often pitchers do well the first time they face new hitters but not so much the second time around. She never faced them again since she was taken out of the game.4

The publicity before and after the game did not help either. One paper called the stunt a one-time deal. Another said she was a girl with a good changeup pitch but “swings a good lipstick.”5 The local paper took a different approach and talked about her pitching style and how unusual it was. The reporter also stressed her great control as a big asset for her. This reporter seemed to make the case for why she had a chance to strike out The Babe.6

So one thing is clear, 17-year-old Jackie Mitchell struck out Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig on April 2, 1931. Her name went into the record books for that feat but the mystery remains. Were the strikeouts legitimate or staged? Even the film footage that exists cannot solve the debate, since it was too grainy to be any real help.

 

Sources

In addition to the sources cited in the Notes, the author also consulted:

Aubrecht, Michael. “Jackie Mitchell-The Pride of the Yankees,” Baseball-Almanac.com, November 2003. baseball-almanac.com/articles/aubrecht8.shtml.

Cronin, Brian. “Sports Legend Revealed: Did a Female Pitcher Strike Out Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig?” February 23, 2011. latimesblogs.latimes.com/sports_blog/2011/02/sports-legend-revealed-did-a-female-pitcher-strike-out-babe-ruth-and-lou-gehrig.html.

Doster, Adam. “The Myth of Jackie Mitchell, the Girl Who Struck Out Ruth and Gehrig,” Daily Beast, May 18, 2013. thedailybeast.com/the-myth-of-jackie-mitchell-the-girl-who-struck-out-ruth-and-gehrig.

Garau, Annie. “Did This 17-Year-Old Girl Really Strike Out Babe Ruth?” December 18, 2016, updated March 25, 2018. allthatsinteresting.com/jackie-mitchell.

Hiskey, Daven. “There Once Was a 17 Year Old Girl Who Struck Out Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig Back to Back,” Today I Found Out, July 12, 2012. todayifoundout.com/index.php/2012/07/there-once-was-a-17-year-old-girl-who-struck-out-babe-ruth-and-lou-gehrig-back-to-back/.

Pickles, Cathy, and Elissa Blattman. “Jackie Mitchell and the Bloomer Girls.” June 27, 2017. womenshistory.org/articles/jackie-mitchell-and-bloomer-girls.

Schoenfield, David. “The Girl Who Struck Out Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig.” espn.com/blog/sweetspot/post/_/id/56180/tbt-the-girl-who-struck-out-babe-ruth-and-lou-gehrig.

YouTube Video. youtube.com/watch?v=qeDnHg7nubE.