August 8, 1944: At age 45, Hod Lisenbee throws first career no-hitter for Syracuse
Horace “Hod” Lisenbee
could easily have spent August 8, 1944, tending to his farm in Clarksville, Tennessee. The well-traveled right-handed pitcher had retired from professional baseball after the 1941 season and gone home to Clarksville, apparently finished after a pro career spanning 18 seasons.1
But the Syracuse Chiefs of the International League2 talked Lisenbee into returning for 1944 after two seasons off, and he spent August 8 making a small piece of minor-league history. Lisenbee, approaching his 46th birthday, pitched a seven-inning no-hitter to carry the Chiefs to an 8-0 victory over the Montreal Royals in the first game of a doubleheader.3 It was his first no-no in a career that spanned more than 600 professional appearances.4
Lisenbee’s milestone start almost didn’t happen. At the end of July, he’d told Chiefs manager Jewel Ens that he needed to get back to his farm because he couldn’t find help to do the chores there, and that his start on August 1 would be his last.5 Available news accounts don’t explain what kept Lisenbee in baseball. One report indicated that he went back to Tennessee briefly and then returned to the Chiefs. Perhaps he was able to hire farmhands after all.6
The team needed him. Lisenbee, apparently strengthened by his time off, was one of the workhorses of the 1944 Chiefs staff. Relying primarily on his curveball, he entered the August 8 game with an 11-10 record.7 At the time, Lisenbee had a 36-55 career major-league record across parts of seven seasons. He hadn’t pitched in the bigs since September 22, 1936, his last of 19 appearances with the Philadelphia Athletics that season. Since then he’d knocked around the minors, pitching for five different teams at three levels before his two-year layoff.8
Lisenbee’s catcher for the day was Gilberto Valdivia, a 29-year-old Cuban playing his first season in American professional baseball. Valdivia was the Chiefs’ second-busiest catcher that season, his 53 games at the position trailing only Len Rice’s 78.9
Ens had steered the 1942 and 1943 Chiefs to IL playoff championships but was not faring as well in 1944.10 Syracuse, a Cincinnati Reds affiliate, was seventh in the eight-team league with a 49-61 record. The Royals, a Brooklyn Dodgers affiliate managed by Bruno Betzel, entered the day in fifth place at 52-57.11
Both teams were getting through World War II with help from players who were either too old or too young to contribute to the US war effort. Montreal’s starting pitcher against Lisenbee was one such player. Eighteen-year-old Ralph Brancahad signed with the Dodgers out of New York University the year before, beginning his career with Class D Olean, New York, before moving up to Montreal.12
Such was the sad state of Brooklyn’s pitching in 1944 that teenager Branca made the majors from mid-June through early August.13 Just three days before opposing Lisenbee in Syracuse, he’d pitched against the Boston Braves at Ebbets Field.14 The pitcher called on to relieve Branca on August 8, Charlie Osgood, was even younger at 17. He’d been exactly five months old when Lisenbee pitched his first big-league game in April 1927.15 Osgood had been called up for one game in Brooklyn in June, which turned out to be his only major-league experience.16
About 2,500 fans17 came to Syracuse’s MacArthur Stadium for the first game, and the Chiefs rewarded them by jumping out to an immediate lead. Third baseman Herb Moore drew a walk, then was forced at second on a sacrifice attempt by Venezuela-born left fielder Chucho Ramos. Center fielder Johnnie Tyler, a 37-year-old who had brief stints with the Braves in 1934 and 1935, drew a walk to put runners on first and second. Right fielder Dutch Mele followed with a single that scored Ramos for a 1-0 lead. The Chiefs’ rally died on a double-play grounder by first baseman Al Lakeman.18
Twenty-eight-year-old Royals third baseman Morrie Aderholt, who also spent time with the Dodgers later that season,19led off the second by chopping a grounder to Chiefs second baseman Charlie Fitzgerald. Fitzgerald, a 23-year-old playing the first of two minor-league seasons, had entered the game after starter Ben Geraghty turned his ankle making a play in the first inning.20 Fitzgerald threw wildly on a play described as “easy,” allowing Aderholt to reach first base.21 It was one of 16 errors Fitzgerald committed in 50 games at second base that season.
The next three Royals were retired in order, and the three after that. Lisenbee didn’t walk a batter all game, and the Chiefs didn’t make any more errors behind him. Branca, meanwhile, got through the second inning but ran into trouble in the third. He gave up hits to the first four batters—singles to Tyler and Ramos, a triple by Mele, and a double by Lakeman—to make the score 4-0. Osgood replaced him two outs later, then gave up a single to 17-year-old rookie shortstop Bob Carson that scored Lakeman. That brought matters to 5-0.22
Osgood, who played for four different teams that season, pitched the rest of the way for Montreal and didn’t fare much better than Branca.23 The Chiefs threatened in the fifth, when Mele was hit by a pitch and advanced on two groundouts. He tried to score on a passed ball, but Montreal catcher John Cummings recovered the ball and tagged him out.
The home team had better luck in the sixth. They assembled three more runs by stringing together a single by Carson, an error by Cummings on Lisenbee’s sacrifice attempt, a fly out by Moore, a walk by Tyler, another hit-by-pitch by Mele,and a single by Lakeman.24
News stories do not detail the game’s final three batters. But, based on the box score and game stories, Lisenbee would have had to retire Eddie Basinski, Red Durrett, and Aderholt to nail down his no-hitter in the seventh and final frame.25Other than Fitzgerald’s error and a running catch made by Mele in right field, the game seems to have been tension-free, with only six balls hit to the outfield. Lisenbee did not strike out a batter.26
In just 1 hour and 20 minutes, Lisenbee had pitched the second no-hitter in the IL that season, and the first by a Syracuse pitcher since Lloyd “Whitey” Moore against Jersey City in 1937. “Hod works hastily,” the Montreal Star observed. A headline in the French-language Montreal newspaper Le Devoir hailed “Bel exploit du lanceur Hod Lisenbee.” (“A Fine Feat by Pitcher Hod Lisenbee.”27)
Lisenbee achieved his no-hitter against a lineup in which all starters but one reached the majors at some point28—although some of those careers were achieved during the war-related absences of top-rank players.29 For what it’s worth, none of the three umpires who worked the game—plate ump Tom Kenny and base umpires John Winters and Chuck Solodare—reached the majors.30
The Chiefs’ triumph was short-lived. The Royals started the same eight position players in the nightcap, with a few changes to the batting order, and banged out 14 hits in a 10-3, nine-inning win.31 The Royals usually had a decent offensive attack: For the full season, Montreal’s team offense ranked in the middle of the league in many categories, including a team batting average and team on-base percentage that closely tracked the league average.32
At season’s end, neither team qualified for the IL’s four-team Shaughnessy-style playoffs. Montreal finished sixth at 73-80, 11½ games back, while Syracuse closed eighth and last at 68-84, 16 games back.33
Branca went on to pitch parts of 12 seasons in the majors. He made three All-Star teams, winning 21 games in 1947 and pitching for Brooklyn in the 1947 and 1949 World Series. He surrendered the walk-off home run by Bobby Thomson in the deciding game of the 1951 National League tiebreaker series that gave the New York Giants the NL championship.
As for Lisenbee, his 15-15 record tied him for the Chiefs’ team lead in wins, and his 34 games pitched and 248 innings led the staff outright.34 He was not called to the majors in 1944, but the Reds signed him the following season. In his final big-league action, the 46-year-old went 1-3 with one retroactively credited save35 in 31 appearances. Remarkably, he still wasn’t done: After another season off, he pitched for, managed, and co-owned a Class D team back home in Clarksville for three more seasons, finishing at age 50 in 1949.36
Acknowledgments
This story was fact-checked by Kevin Larkin and copyedited by Mike Eisenbath.
Sources and photo credit
In addition to the sources cited in the Notes, the author consulted Baseball Reference and Retrosheet for general player, team and season data.
Neither Baseball Reference nor Retrosheet provides box scores of minor-league games, but the Syracuse (New York) Herald-Journal and Montreal Gazette published box scores in their editions of August 9, 1944.
Image of 1966 James T. Elder postcard #238 downloaded from the Trading Card Database.
Notes
1 Bill Nowlin, “Hod Lisenbee,” SABR Biography Project, accessed September 2026, https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/Hod-Lisenbee/. Clarksville is in northern Tennessee, on the state’s border with Kentucky.
2 In 1944 the IL was classed as Double A, which at that point was the highest level below the majors.
3 Lisenbee was born on September 23, 1898.
4 “Hod Lisenbee Near Perfect in No-Hitter,” Syracuse (New York) Herald-Journal, August 9, 1944: 18. The closest Lisenbee came to a no-hitter at the major-league level was the complete-game, nine-inning three-hitter he threw for the Boston Red Sox against the Detroit Tigers on July 28, 1931.
5 “Lisenbee Hurls Last Game for Chiefs Tonight,” Syracuse Herald-Journal, August 1, 1944: 16; “International News,” Baltimore Evening Sun,August 4, 1944: 18.
6 “Wings Outhit Syracuse, 13-10, But Lose 7-4 Tilt,” Rochester (New York) Democrat and Chronicle, August 6, 1944: C1.
7 Lloyd McGowan, “Lisenbee No-Hitter No Ordinary Feat,” Montreal Daily Star, August 9, 1944: 20.
8 Lisenbee spent 1937 with Montreal in the IL. He split 1938 between Montreal and Rochester in the IL and Indianapolis in the American Association, all Double A. 1939 found him in Indianapolis again. In 1940 he pitched for Shreveport in the Class A-1 Texas League, and in 1941 he pitched for Portsmouth in the Class B Piedmont League. After that, he went back to his farm for two seasons, as previously mentioned.
9 Rice started the second game of the doubleheader for the Chiefs.
10 Baseball Reference B-R Bullpen, “Governors’ Cup,” accessed September 2026, https://www.baseball-reference.com/bullpen/Governors%27_Cup. The Chiefs finished third in the regular season in both years.
11 Only the Rochester Red Wings were worse, at 49-66. Baltimore occupied first place at 64-45. “League Races,” Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, August 8, 1944: 16.
12 Paul Hirsch, “Ralph Branca,” SABR Biography Project, accessed September 2026, https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/Ralph-Branca/.
13 The 1944 Dodgers went 63-91. Their pitching staff was either worst or tied for worst in the NL in ERA, shutouts, earned runs allowed, walks, and hit batsmen.
14 Branca compiled an 0-2 record and 7.65 ERA in 18 big-league games before being sent down to Montreal. He subsequently returned to Brooklyn for three more appearances in late September and early October.
15 Osgood was born on November 23, 1926, and Lisenbee broke into the majors on April 23, 1927.
16 According to Retrosheet, Osgood was the nephew of Clyde Sukeforth, who in 1944 was serving on Brooklyn’s coaching staff. At various times, Sukeforth served the Dodgers as a player, manager, coach, and scout, playing a key role in the Dodgers’ signing of Jackie Robinson. As the Dodgers’ bullpen coach in 1951, Sukeforth also made the fateful recommendation to bring in Ralph Branca instead of Carl Erskine in the deciding game of the NL tiebreaker series, in which Branca surrendered a walk-off, season-ending homer to Bobby Thomson of the New York Giants. James Lincoln Ray, “Clyde Sukeforth,” SABR Biography Project, accessed September 2026, https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/clyde-sukeforth/.
17 Box scores in the Montreal Gazette and the French-language paper Le Devoir give separate attendance figures for the first game (2,500) and the second (3,263). The Syracuse Herald-Journal gives only one attendance figure, 3,263 for the second game.
18 All play-by-play descriptions in this story, unless otherwise specified, are based on “Hod Lisenbee Near Perfect in No-Hitter”; McGowan, “Lisenbee No-Hitter No Ordinary Feat”; and Associated Press, “Royals, Chiefs Split Twin Bill, Lisenbee Hurling No-Hit, No-Run Game,” Montreal Gazette, August 9, 1944: 14. Of these stories, the most detailed play-by-play summaries are found in “Hod Lisenbee Near Perfect in No-Hitter.”
19 Aderholt appeared in 17 games for the 1944 Dodgers between September 16 and October 1, hitting .271 in 59 at-bats. In Montreal, he hit .289 in 150 games, leading the team with 20 homers.
20 “Hod Lisenbee Near Perfect in No-Hitter.”
21 Associated Press, “Royals, Chiefs Split Twin Bill, Lisenbee Hurling No-Hit, No-Run Game.”
22 “Hod Lisenbee Near Perfect in No-Hitter.” It might seem odd that Branca was pulled from the game after getting two outs, especially with the eighth-place hitter Carson coming up. But the box score confirms this run of events, with two batters (catcher Valdivia and second baseman Fitzgerald) coming between Lakeman and Carson.
23 In addition to Montreal and Brooklyn, Osgood also appeared with two Class B teams in 1944—Newport News of the Piedmont League and Trenton of the Interstate League.
24 “Hod Lisenbee Near Perfect in No-Hitter.” This story does not specify whether Cummings’ error was throwing or fielding, nor does it say specifically that Lisenbee reached on the error. It also does not specifically say that Moore’s fly advanced the runners, but the fly is included in a list of plays that “figured in the Chiefs scoring three more runs,” so presumably it was a productive out. Game stories from Montreal papers do not discuss the Chiefs’ last three runs.
25 Box scores, and multiple game stories indicating that Aderholt was Montreal’s only baserunner, can be used to extrapolate the Royals batters who came to the plate in each of the seven innings.
26 Associated Press, “Royals, Chiefs Split Twin Bill, Lisenbee Hurling No-Hit, No-Run Game”; McGowan, “Lisenbee No-Hitter No Ordinary Feat.”
27 “Hod Lisenbee Near Perfect in No-Hitter”; McGowan, “Lisenbee No-Hitter No Ordinary Feat”; “Bel Exploit du Lanceur Hod Lisenbee,” Le Devoir (Montreal, Quebec), August 9, 1944: 7. In the IL’s previous 1944 no-hitter, Stanley “Sid” West of the Baltimore Orioles had no-hit Jersey City on July 18.
28 The only Royals starter who never reached the majors was shortstop and eighth-place hitter Stan Breard. Catcher Cummings also never reached the majors, but he didn’t start; he replaced Stan Andrews at an unspecified point in midgame. (Each catcher is credited in box scores with one at-bat.)
29 In addition to those already mentioned in the story (Branca, Aderholt, Basinski, and Durrett), Royals starters who reached the majors were catcher Stan Andrews, right fielder John Corriden, first baseman Ed Stevens, and center fielder Walt Chipple. Those with relatively brief major-league careers included Chipple (18 games with the 1945 Washington Nationals), Corriden (one game with Brooklyn in 1946), Durrett (19 games with Brooklyn in 1944-45); and Andrews (70 games across four seasons between 1939 and 1945). Reliever Osgood’s one-game career has previously been mentioned, as well.
30 Kenny’s role as plate umpire is extrapolated from the box score, which lists Kenny first among the umpires but is not alphabetized (i.e., Kenny, Winters, and Solodare). Winters is listed first among umpires in the nightcap. Kenny is not mentioned in game coverage, but news stories from several IL cities in 1944 provide his first name, including one from later that same week: Lloyd McGowan, “Moe Aderholt Mystery Has Betzel Stumped,” Montreal Daily Star, August 12, 1944: 10.
31 Associated Press, “Royals, Chiefs Split Twin Bill, Lisenbee Hurling No-Hit, No-Run Game.”
32 The 1944 Royals posted a team batting average of .255 (compared to a leaguewide average of .258) and an OBP of .342 (compared to a league average of .346).
33 The Baltimore Orioles eked out the IL’s regular-season championship by one-one-hundredth of a percentage point. Their 84-68 record (.553) provided the thinnest of margins over the Newark Bears (85-69, .552). Baltimore also defeated Newark in the final round of the playoffs.
34 Bob Malloy also posted 15 wins for the Chiefs, going 15-7.
35 Saves were not an official major-league statistic until 1969.
36 Nowlin, “Hod Lisenbee.”
Additional Stats
Syracuse Chiefs 8
Montreal Royals 0
MacArthur Stadium
Syracuse, NY
Corrections? Additions?
If you can help us improve this game story, contact us.

