This article was written by Jimmy Keenan
The 1970 Cincinnati Reds [102-60] ran away with the National League East by 14½ games before taking three straight from the Pittsburgh Pirates in the playoffs. Their opponents in the upcoming fall classic were the Baltimore Orioles who were attempting to rebound from a demoralizing World Series loss to the New York Mets the previous season. Baltimore [108-54] was as equally impressive as Cincinnati in 1970, winning the American League by 15 games. The Orioles went on to sweep the Minnesota Twins in the playoffs for the second year in a row.
When asked about the Orioles, Reds manager Sparky Anderson told the Associated Press, “Our scouting report is that Baltimore is the best defensive club in baseball, has the best front line pitching in the game and is the third or fourth best offensive team.” 1
The Orioles finished the regular season with 11-straight wins. When asked by a reporter about his team’s strong finish, Orioles manager Earl Weaver replied, “Sure we’ve won 14 in a row [including the playoffs]. But they don’t count now. Its not the winning streak I like it’s the type of people we have on the ballclub. If we had lost 14 in a row I’d still think this team could beat Cincinnati.” 2
Game One was played at Riverfront Stadium in Cincinnati. It was the first time in the history of the fall classic that a game would be played on artificial turf. Another notable milestone occurred during this series when Emmett Ashford became the first African-American to umpire a World Series game. The Orioles came out on top in the first two tilts by the scores of 4-3 and 6-5. The series then moved to Memorial Stadium in Baltimore where the O’s won Game Three 9-3. It appeared a sweep was imminent but a three-run homer by Lee May off reliever Eddie Watt in the eighth inning of Game Four propelled the visiting Reds to a 6-5 victory.
The stage was now set for Game Five at Memorial Stadium. Baltimoreans woke up on the morning of October 15 to a steady downpour that was coming down all over the city. The showers continued intermittently throughout the morning and early afternoon. A sign reading “Make the Reds Blue” hung outside of Memorial Stadium as the rain-soaked fans made their way through the turnstiles into the ballpark.
Head groundskeeper Pat Santarone and his crew were able to keep the infield covered but the rest of the field was a different story. The umpires gave the soggy outfield the once over and after considerable deliberation deemed the grounds playable. The Memorial Stadium lights were turned on a few minutes before game time in order to offset the dark storm clouds that were looming overhead. A light drizzle started coming down as the Orioles took the field in the top of the first inning, causing umbrellas to pop up all over the ballpark.
Oriole manager Earl Weaver chose lefty Mike Cuellar [24-8] as his starter while Reds manager Sparky Anderson went with southpaw Jim Merritt [20-12]. Cuellar was hoping to rebound from a poor Game Two performance where he allowed four runs in 2 1/3 innings. After leadoff hitter Bobby Tolan struck out, Pete Rose sliced a fly ball to right that skipped on the wet grass before caroming off Frank Robinson’s glove. Rose, hustling all the way, slid head first into second for a double. After Tony Perez flew out, Johnny Bench stroked a hard shot into right center for an RBI single. Lee May and Hal McRae followed with back-to-back two-baggers that plated a pair of runs.
With the rain finally subsiding and Cuellar struggling, Earl Weaver got Tom Phoebus up in the Orioles bullpen. The Cuban-born portsider was able to keep his composure retiring the next batter, Tommy Helms, on a groundball to shortstop Mark Belanger. After the game Weaver told the media, “If Helms had hit the ball hard for extra bases I guess Mike would’ve had to come out. But if he had hit another double like Pete Rose’s I’d have gone with him another batter.” 3
The Orioles got on the board in the bottom of the first thanks to a two-run homer by a Frank Robinson. The Reds wouldn’t score for the rest of the game as Cuellar retired 24 out of the next 27 batters. With two on and two out in the second inning, Anderson took Merritt out of the game. He was replaced by Wayne Granger who was tagged for RBI base hits by Mark Belanger and Paul Blair before retiring the side. Merritt, who been battling elbow problems, spoke to the press after the game,“I was throwing free and easy and there was no pain. I wouldn’t have pitched if my arm was hurting. I was however disappointed in my control.”4
After Granger was touched up for two more runs in the third Anderson brought in Milt Wilcox. The 20-year old right-hander dispatched five straight batters before giving way to Tony Cloninger in the top of the fifth. Cloninger pitched the next two frames allowing one run on a Merv Rettenmund solo shot over the high wall in the right field corner.
Ray Washburn replaced Cloninger in the seventh. Washburn tossed one scoreless frame before giving up a run in the bottom of the eighth. With two on and one out Clay Carroll came in for Washburn. Carroll allowed the Orioles ninth run to score before finishing out the inning.
In the top of the ninth Johnny Bench led off with a line drive down the third base line. Oriole third baseman Brooks Robinson lunged to his right back-handing the hot liner just inches above the ground in foul territory. Robinson made a number of phenomenal defensive plays like this during the series. Thanks to the national television coverage people from around the country were now getting a glimpse of what Baltimore fans had been witnessing first-hand for years. The next batter Lee May whiffed on a tantalizing curve ball from Cuellar for the second out. Anderson inserted pinch-hitter Pat Corrales for McRae. Corrales proceeded to ground out to Robinson at third, clinching the series for Baltimore.
The Oriole victory erased all the bad memories from the previous year’s World Series loss to the Mets. Baltimore amassed 50 hits in five games against the Reds pitching staff, including a record ten home runs and seven doubles.
Brooks Robinson was named Most Valuable Player of the series. Aside from his amazing glove work he set a five-game fall classic record with 17 total bases, which included two home runs, two doubles and five singles. He and teammate Paul Blair tied the mark for most hits in a five-game set with nine. “I’m the happiest I’ve ever been” exclaimed Robinson during the Orioles clubhouse celebration. Nothing will ever the replace the first one [1966 World championship]. But it does make up for everything last year.” 5
Winning pitcher Mike Cuellar talked with reporters after the game about his first inning troubles,“I knew that the team would get me some runs. I had to stop using my screwball but I knew that Brooksie and the other guys would catch my mistakes.” 6
A dejected Pete Rose spoke to Baltimore Sun sports writer Ken Nigro in the visitors clubhouse, ”Deep down in my heart I don’t think they’re 4-1 better than we are. I think when two teams are as evenly balanced as we are it has to be closer.” 7
Reds manager Sparky Anderson closed out his press conference by saying, “It’s about time you gave Earl Weaver the credit he deserves. He’s won 217 games in two years and now he’s won the World Series. I know they say he has a great team, but I’ve got a great team too, and he beat us. Give him the credit.” 8
1970 Orioles Media Guide
Newspapers and Magazines
The Bend (Oregon) Bulletin
Lakeland (Florida) Ledger
Rome (Georgia) News-Tribune
The Lewiston (Maine) Daily Sun
The Spokane (Washington) Spokesman Review
The Sporting News
The author, Jimmy Keenan, attended this game with his cousin Bill Stieren and grandfather, former Oriole Jimmy Lyston. My granddad and I had two tickets for the game purchased through the Oldtimers Baseball Association of Maryland. However we needed one more ticket for my cousin. My granddad was able to buy the third ticket at the stadium the day of the game. My cousin Bill (age 11) and myself (age 10) sat in our original seats in the Preferred Reserve section on the third base side. In addition to being a former pro baseball player my granddad was a retired Captain in the Baltimore City Police Department. He had been in command of the Traffic Division, which included all of the motorcycle and mounted police in Baltimore City, from 1960-1964. Knowing nearly every usher and policeman who was working the game he was able to walk throughout the ballpark unimpeded. He told us later that he spent a few innings sitting with his former Oriole and barnstorming teammate Lefty Grove before moving on to chat with other friends. During the game my cousin Bill and I talked about running onto the field when the Orioles won. When the final out was recorded we decided that discretion was the better part of valor. While the hoardes of jubilant Oriole fans were swarming the field my cousin and I made our way through the crowd inside the stadium to link up with our grandfather at our predetermined meeting place.
1 Associated Press,“Reds Orioles Match Set For World Series,” Rome News-Tribune, October 6, 1970,6-7.
3 Lou Hatter, “Mike Junks Screwball After First,” Baltimore Sun, October 16, 1970,C1.
4 Seymour S. Smith, “Lack Of Control Hurts Merritt,” Baltimore Sun, October 16, 1970, C1.
5 Mike Rathet, “Orioles Capture Series By Winning Fifth Game,” Observer- Reporter, October 16, 1970, AI, B6.
6 Lou Hatter,“Mike Junks Screwball After First,” Baltimore Sun, October 16, 1970,C1,C6.
7 Ken Nigro, “Red’s Manager Refuses to Alibi,” Baltimore Sun, October 15. 1970, C1, C6.
8 Bob Maisel,“Morning After,” Baltimore Sun, October 16, 1970, C1,C6.