Burgar Park (Welland, ON)

This article was written by Kurt Blumenau


People gather for a ceremony at Burgar Park in Welland, Ontario, circa 1958. (Courtesy of Welland Public Library)

People gather for a ceremony at Burgar Park in Welland, Ontario, circa 1958. (Courtesy of Welland Public Library)

 

If the local weather had been clement in May 1989, Burgar Park—an amateur diamond in Welland, Ontario, Canada—would never have had a connection to affiliated professional baseball.

But the rainiest May in Welland’s history to that time delayed construction of the Welland Sports Complex, the park being built for the city’s newly arriving team in the short-season Class A New York-Penn League.1 With Opening Day looming and the new facility unfinished, Burgar Park received a package of hasty upgrades and hosted the Welland Pirates’ first 11 home games that June and July until the Sports Complex was completed.2 Future big-leaguers who played there included Tim Wakefield and Hall of Famer Jeff Kent.

In professional terms, Burgar Park is a footnote, the equivalent of a cup-of-coffee player with just a few games to his credit. Still, the facility boasts a long, rich history of local competition dotted with recognizable names like Sal Maglie, Ed Runge, and Clyde Sukeforth, as well as a few close calls with minor-league baseball before the Pirates arrived. There’s enough in Burgar Park’s history to occupy any baseball fan on a rainy day—in May or otherwise.

First, the setting. Welland is a city in southern Ontario, about 11 miles as the crow flies from Niagara Falls and about 20 from Buffalo, New York.3 The city is home to a series of canals that connected Lake Ontario and Lake Erie, enabling ship travel between Toronto and major U.S. Great Lakes ports.4 Although the canal remains a landmark that divides downtown Welland into east and west sides, major commercial shipping no longer passes through the downtown area; a bypass waterway built to the east of the city has carried that traffic since 1973.5

In the early years of the 20th century, the city’s population grew more than fivefold, from 1,863 in 1901 to 10,668 in 1931.6 It’s common for fast-growing communities to struggle with municipal services, and one area where Welland officials found themselves short was public park space for sports and games.7 (Perhaps driven by a similar spirit, the neighboring city of Port Colborne, also fast-growing, was building a hockey arena at around the same time.8)

On Welland’s east side, a property of about 3¾ acres on Burgar Street had been informally used for games and carnivals. In early 1930, the city’s parks board agreed to buy the land for $7,000 for development into the city’s first municipally owned sports park, to be known as Burgar Park.9 The name “Burgar” originates with one of the region’s founding families, whose members held prominent roles in the developing city. News reports specified that the park was named in honor of the family, not for its street address.10

At purchase, the park was described as “just a grass and stubble field,” but the city immediately began to improve it by adding a fence and seeding the ground.11 Home plate for baseball games was set in the property’s southeast corner, where it remained almost a century later. Initial plans called for a 500-seat grandstand.12 Soccer was played there before baseball, but when the booters damaged the baseball infield, the soccer field was realigned to protect the diamond.13

Featuring teams in the Niagara District Intermediate Baseball League, the first organized ballgame at Burgar Park was scheduled for May 1932.14 The facility was gradually upgraded, receiving infield drainage improvements in 1933; a dressing room and water and sewer connections in 1936; a new scoreboard, upgraded bleachers, and improved fencing in 1940; and concrete dugouts in 1945.15 Floodlights followed in the summer of 1948, and capacity was increased from 1,700 to 2,500 the following year.16

A variety of youth, amateur, and semipro teams took advantage of the ballpark’s presence in its early years. Though most participants achieved only local fame, a few loom larger. Among them was Sal Maglie, who starred with the Welland Atlas Steels team in the Niagara District Senior Baseball League from 1943 through 1945. A veteran of five minor-league seasons but not yet a major-leaguer, he’d left pro ball after the 1942 season and gone home to nearby Niagara Falls to take a defense-plant job. Maglie led the Welland team to a league championship in 1944 and pitched many memorable games. In 1943, he shut out the St. Catharines-Merritton team five times, and a story published in the mid-1950s claimed that St. Catharines had scored just one run off him in two entire seasons.17 In 1945 Maglie beat a Baltimore Elite Giants team at Burgar that included his future Brooklyn Dodgers batterymate Roy Campanella.18

Maglie’s time in Welland ended in June 1945, when New York Giants owner Horace Stoneham re-signed him for the Giants’ top farm team in Jersey City.19 By early August, Maglie was in the majors, beginning a career that included the 1950 National League ERA title, an NL-leading 23 wins in 1951, two All-Star Game appearances, a World Series championship in 1954, and a no-hitter caught by Campanella in 1956. Visiting in retirement, he said, “I have always considered Welland as my second home town.”20

The manager of Maglie’s Atlas Steels teams at Burgar Park also reached the majors, though not as a player. Ed Runge, a New York City native, played first base in the Niagara District League and worked as a firefighter in Welland in the 1940s. He moved to southern California later in the decade and turned his continued interest in baseball into a career as an umpire.21 Runge worked as an American League ump from 1954 to 1970, umpiring four All-Star Games and three World Series.22

Burgar Park showed up on the Dodgers’ radar screen during these glory years. A Welland newspaper reported in November 1945 that the Dodgers would have put a Class D Pennsylvania-Ontario-New York League team in Welland for 1946 if the park’s seating and lights had been better.23 The PONY League was the predecessor of the New York-Penn League, which finally brought minor-league ball to town more than 40 years later.24

Another report in 1951 claimed that Welland had turned down an offer on short notice to accept the struggling Youngstown, Ohio, team of the Class C Middle Atlantic League.25 The city was capable of crowds that minor-league teams would have envied: A district title game at Burgar Park in the late 1940s drew 4,000 people.26

Burgar Park had decades more to wait for minor-league ball, but it did get annual Dodgers tryout camps in the 1940s and 1950s, attended by big-league and organizational coaches including Sukeforth.27 After general manager Branch Rickey left Brooklyn for Pittsburgh, the camp briefly became a Pirates tryout site before the Dodgers took it back for a final few seasons.28 A 1951 article indicated that 23 young players had been signed to that time, though it doesn’t appear that any of them made the bigs as players.29

The city of Welland marked its centennial in July 1958, and Burgar Park hosted a track and field meet, sports games, and a band concert.30 These were just a few of many non-baseball events held at the park. They included circuses, wrestling, cricket matches, political rallies, religious events, and a war bond rally that drew 8,000 people in 1941.31 Other attractions included Black baseball teams of Negro League and “clown” varieties, the House of David barnstorming team, fundraising softball games with National Hockey League stars like Turk Broda and Eddie Shack, and well-traveled softball showman Eddie Feigner, centerpiece of The King and His Court.32

By the 1960s, the ballpark was showing age, and the city spent much of the decade debating whether to upgrade it or be rid of it. The backstop, lights, and fencing were all in poor shape, and the park was also criticized for its lack of parking.33 A fire damaged the clubhouse and bathroom building in 1963.34 On top of that, the appeal of amateur baseball had dwindled, with teams dropping out of several levels of play.35 A section of Burgar Park’s stands was moved to a soccer field, where demand for seating was presumably higher.36 One city official suggested the Burgar property would be better used as a pool and playground, saying the city “has just about had the biscuit” for sports.37

Near the end of the decade, the city invested in the park, replacing its lights, resodding the field, and installing a new clubhouse and concessions building.38 These improvements might have saved Burgar Park in the mid-1970s, when another wave of talk about redeveloping the property emerged.39 By that time, junior baseball games were drawing crowds of 50 to 60, and a crowd of 300 was noted as the park’s largest in years.40 “Finding a seat is never a problem,” one sportswriter wrote. “In fact there’s usually more players in the park than spectators.”41 Officials decided that building a new ballpark from scratch at another site would be too expensive. Chronic parking hassles aside, the city was best served by keeping what it had.42

The late ’70s brought another close-but-no-cigar flirtation with professional ball. In September 1977, the AL’s expansion Toronto Blue Jays were said to be looking at Welland as the potential home for a Class A affiliate. The city was interested but the Jays went elsewhere, establishing a Class A team in Dunedin, Florida, and a rookie-level team in Medicine Hat, Alberta, in 1978.43 The subpar condition of Burgar Park’s bleachers, which received repair in early 1978, might have factored into the decision.44 The Jays never came to town, but the team had ties to Welland: President and chief executive officer Paul Beeston was a native who’d played at Burgar Park as a youth.45 And in 1980, a “J.D. Yari Day” at Burgar Park honored a local player who’d signed with Toronto.46

By some accounts, the attempt to lure a Jays affiliate made city officials realize that they would need a better facility than Burgar, with its limited parking and bobtailed, 297-foot right-field fence, if they hoped to attract a pro team.47 This slow-building dream became a reality in 1988, when Welland landed a $1.4-million federal grant that covered about half the cost of the Sports Complex—a facility featuring a 2,500-seat baseball park and slow-pitch softball fields.48 Construction began without a commitment from a pro team, but the Pirates completed the picture in September 1988, when plans were announced to move Pittsburgh’s New York-Penn affiliate out of Watertown, New York.49 All signs seemed encouraging, with early reports indicating that warm, dry weather was allowing work to proceed faster than planned.50

Then came the rains of spring 1989, which prevented crews at the Sports Complex from laying sod for the field. That halted other construction work in turn, and eventually canceled a grand opening ceremony and laser show planned for Canada Day, July 1.51

On June 8, the Pirates’ first few games were officially shifted to Burgar Park, as city officials agreed to add bullpens there and make last-minute improvements to the seating and infield to bring the facility closer to pro standards.52

Nine days later—and 59 years after its acquisition by the city—Burgar Park hosted its first affiliated professional game. Home runs by shortstop Mike Fortuna and left fielder Valentine Henderson lifted the Pirates to a 9-3 win over the Niagara Falls Rapids. The team had hoped for 1,500 to 2,000 fans at the home opener, but paid attendance was a disappointing 633.53 Throughout the Pirates’ stay at Burgar Park, players dressed at the Sports Complex and took a bus to their temporary home field.54

Team and city officials had hoped to limit the Pirates’ use of Burgar to four games, but the team had to play there 11 times.55 The Pirates, skippered by former big-league shortstop U.L. Washington, went 5-6 at Burgar Park.56 The last New York-Penn League game there took place on July 13, and the Pirates left on a high note, scoring in the sixth, seventh, and eighth innings to beat the St. Catharines Blue Jays, 4-3, before 503 fans.57

All told, only 6,006 fans paid to see the Pirates at Burgar Park for an average attendance of 546 per game, worst in the league to that point in the season.58 Attendance perked up with the opening of the Sports Complex on July 17, when 3,162 fans turned out to see the Pirates beat the Auburn Astros, 5-1.59

Although short-season Class A is a long way from the majors, those fans who made the trip to Burgar Park got to see future big-leaguers. The visiting St. Catharines team included Kent—later National League MVP, four-time Silver Slugger Award winner, and five-time All-Star—along with Ryan Thompson, Greg O’Halloran, and Nigel Wilson.60 The latter two were Canadian-born; Wilson went on to become the second pick in the November 1992 expansion draft, chosen from the Blue Jays by the Florida Marlins. Other future major-leaguers who played at Burgar included the Pittsfield Mets’ Dave Telgheder, Alan Zinter, and John Johnstone, the Erie Orioles’ Mike Oquist, the Batavia Clippers’ Joe Millette, and Iván Cruz of the Niagara Falls Rapids.61

As for the home team, outfielder Will Pennyfeather hit just .190 in 75 games and averaged a strikeout per game, but reached the parent club in Pittsburgh from 1992 to 1994.62  Paul Wagner earned the win in relief on June 26 against Batavia; he spent parts of eight seasons in the majors in the 1990s, mostly with Pittsburgh.63

The most memorable Pirate in retrospect was Wakefield, who’d been Pittsburgh’s eighth-round pick in the June 1988 amateur draft and came to Welland as a 22-year-old rookie third baseman with a sideline in knuckleball pitching. He didn’t lack for confidence: Asked to name his favorite major-league player, he replied, “Tim Wakefield in the future.”64 He also didn’t mince words about Burgar Park, calling it “a dump” compared to the promised new ballpark.65

Wakefield hit only .206 in 67 plate appearances, and news coverage of the Pirates’ 4-3 home loss on June 19 included a photo of him misplaying a groundball for a run-scoring error.66 He proved more useful on the mound, going 1-1 with two saves and a 3.40 ERA in 18 appearances, including at least one at Burgar Park.67 Wakefield converted to full-time pitching the following season and reached the majors in 1992, winning 200 games and two World Series titles over 19 seasons. He spent most of his career with the Boston Red Sox, where he ranked in the franchise’s top 10 in many pitching categories as of 2026.68

Once the Sports Complex was up and running, pro ball did not return to stopgap Burgar Park. Welland kept the Pirates through 1994, after which Pittsburgh shifted its New York-Penn team to Erie, Pennsylvania. The city has not hosted affiliated minor-league ball since, though it has been home to independent teams. The Sports Complex field has since become known in some settings as Welland Stadium; it was used as a host park for the 2022 Canada Games.69

After its moment in the pro spotlight, Burgar Park went back to hosting local ballgames—though it was no longer the only park in town, nor the newest and shiniest.70 The organizers of a high school-age tournament in 2002 called the newer Welland Stadium “an absolute gem,” while offering more limited praise to Burgar Park—“a step above…high school fields.”71 News coverage related to the park took a nostalgic turn: As the generation that had made the park a community hub in the 1940s passed away, the stories of Sal Maglie, Ed Runge, and their peers resurfaced.72

The up-and-down fortunes of amateur baseball also seem to have ebbed in the 21st century, in part because of the many other entertainment options available. A Welland sportswriter wrote disgustedly in 2002: “Why spend money watching your neighbours and the guys from across the canal hustling to stretch a single into a double at Burgar Park when you can watch a big leaguer on steroids strike out for free on TV?”73

Another sign of the ballpark’s changed role in its community arose in 2025, when the city announced plans to tear down Burgar Park’s gatehouse—the squat, two-window cement-block building where admissions were taken. Clearing the building was expected to prevent break-ins and vandalism by improving visibility into the park. Officials also noted that the building hadn’t been used to collect paid entry to an event in more than 25 years.74

Still, it might be misleading or unfair to suggest that Burgar Park has declined in stature. The role it fills as a youth baseball field is a role it has filled for decades; its time as a professional ballpark was the exception, not the norm.75 Approaching its 100th anniversary, it remained in harness, which is its own kind of victory.

 

Acknowledgments

This story was reviewed by Rory Costello and Bill Lamb and fact-checked by Brian Dunn.

 

Sources

In addition to the sources cited in the Notes, the author used the Baseball Reference and Retrosheet websites for general player, team and season data.

 

Notes

1 Wayne Redshaw, “It’s One Big Headache for Pirates’ Bill Kuehn,” Welland (Ontario) Evening Tribune, June 13, 1989: 25. The story quotes Welland Pirates general manager Kuehn as saying: “There’s been more rain than we have ever had or since records have been kept.” A similar claim was made by city parks manager Dan Ryan in “Blame It on Nature: Ryan,” Welland Evening Tribune, June 22, 1989: 1. Ryan indicated heavy rain had continued into June.

2 Redshaw, “It’s One Big Headache for Pirates’ Bill Kuehn”; Wayne Redshaw, “No Excuse Now,” Welland Tribune, July 15, 1989: 21.

3 As of September 2026, Retrosheet did not list Welland as the birth or burial place of any former major-league player, manager, coach, or umpire.

4 “The Welland Canal Section of the St. Lawrence Seaway,” Great Lakes St. Lawrence Seaway website (operated by the St. Lawrence Seaway Management Corporation), accessed October 2026, https://greatlakes-seaway.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/welland.pdf.

5 “The Welland Canal Section of the St. Lawrence Seaway”; “Welland Welcomes First Ship,” Welland Evening Tribune, March 28, 1973: 1. A reference to the last ship passing under the downtown Main Street bridge on December 15, 1972, can be found in Joe Barkovich, “After 150 Years, What Makes Welland Welland?” Welland Tribune, July 26, 2008: A1.

6 “The Growth of Ten Years,” Welland (Ontario) Telegraph, August 23, 1901: 6; “Welland’s Population Given in 1931 Assessment Roll as 10,668; Is Increase of 330,” Welland-Port Colborne (Ontario) Evening Tribune, October 7, 1931: 1.

7 Margaret Deitch, “City Well-Served in Parks and Recreation,” Welland Evening Tribune, July 19, 1958: 17.

8 “1500 Fans Present when Port Colborne’s Modern Arena Officially Opened,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, November 14, 1930: 1.

9 “George Allen Is Named Gardener for Parks Board,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, February 25, 1930: 1; “Purchase of Burgar St. Property Approved by Welland Parks Board,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, March 7, 1930: 1; “Newly Acquired Property to Be Known as Burgar Park,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, May 2, 1930: 1; “Welland Fair Grounds Home of Many Sports,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, September 22, 1933: 6. All dollar figures in this story are in Canadian dollars unless otherwise specified.

10 Brief summaries of the Burgar family’s role in Welland history can be found in “Two Score Years a Doctor,” Welland Telegraph, March 16, 1909: 1, and Mrs. A.E. Hern, “Man-Made Island Once Prosperous Farming Land,” Welland Evening Tribune, March 1, 1958: 10. The origin of the park’s name is specified in “Newly Acquired Property to be Known as Burgar Park.” The park’s street address is 126 Burgar St.

11 “Beautification Work Proceeds Chippewa Park,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, November 14, 1930: 1.

12 “Grandstand and Gate Receipts to Be Divided,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, April 2, 1932: 1; “Parks Board Estimates Provide for the Equipping of New Burgar Park as Sports and Recreation Centre,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, January 14, 1932: 6. Google Maps imaging at the time this article was prepared in autumn 2026 indicated that home plate was still in the property’s southeast corner.

13 “Burgar Park Problems to Be Discussed,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, May 12, 1932: 6; “Satisfactory Settlement of Burgar Park Problem,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, May 19, 1932: 16.

14 “First Baseball Game at Burgar Park Tomorrow,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, May 20, 1932: 6.

15 “Will Continue Rent West Merritt Park,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, May 6, 1933: 1; “Again Chairman of Parks Board,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, January 18, 1936: 1; “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, January 6, 1936: 5; “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, June 22, 1940: 7; “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, April 27, 1945: 9.

16 “Shamrock,” “Kimberly Here Tomorrow for First Floodlight Game,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, June 30, 1948: 9; “Seating at Baseball Park to Be Increased to 2,500,” Buffalo Evening News, February 16, 1949: 4.

17 “Shamrock,” “Giants Recalled Sal Maglie from Welland Nine Years Ago This Week,” Welland Evening Tribune, June 9, 1954: 16; Judith Testa, “Sal Maglie,” SABR Biography Project, accessed September 2026, https://sabr.org/bioproj/person/sal-maglie/; “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, August 12, 1943: 9.

18 Lloyd Johnson, “Negro National League Swatsmiths Are Tamed by Maglie and Evans,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, June 5, 1945: 9.

19 “Shamrock,” “Giants Recalled Sal Maglie from Welland Nine Years Ago This Week.”

20 “Marshall Urges Fair Play; Sal Recalls Welland Homer,” Welland Evening Tribune, October 25, 1960: 16.

21 Greg Furminger, “Ed Runge: First in Long Line of Umps Dies at 84,” Welland Tribune, June 30, 2002: B1; Bernd Franke, “Legendary Ump Had Welland Roots,” Welland Tribune, September 6, 2002: B3. Runge’s son Paul, a National League ump from 1973 to 1997, was born in St. Catharines, Ontario, during his father’s time in Canada.

22 Runge and Maglie’s paths recrossed in dramatic circumstances in the 1950s. Runge was stationed along the right-field line for Game One of the 1956 World Series at Ebbets Field, when Maglie pitched a complete-game 6-3 win over the New York Yankees, and again during Game Five, when Maglie came out on the losing end of Don Larsen’s perfect game.

23 “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, November 21, 1945: 7. The Dodgers chose to keep their PONY League affiliate in Olean, New York, for the 1946 season.

24 The PONY League changed its name to the New York-Penn League following the 1956 season.

25 “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, May 23, 1951: 13. The six-team loop also included teams in Niagara Falls and Lockport, New York, near Buffalo, so Welland would have been a geographic fit.

26 “Successful Baseball Season Ended in Welland,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, September 22, 1948: 2.

27 “Brooklyn to Open Baseball Camp in Welland July 30,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, June 19, 1945: 9; “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, August 1, 1945: 7.

28 “Pittsburgh Pirates’ Tryout Camp Opens at Burgar Park Thursday,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, July 7, 1951: 13; “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland Evening Tribune, July 27, 1954: 10.

29 “Branch Rickey Anxious to Get Young Canadians for Organized Baseball,” Welland Evening Tribune, July 7, 1951: 13. The article identifies several young players signed from the camps, none of whom reached the majors as a player. One, Toronto-born outfielder and third baseman Jimmy Williams, played 18 minor-league seasons; he reached the majors for eight seasons as a coach with the Houston Astros and Baltimore Orioles. “Jimmy Williams (minors02),” Baseball Reference B-R Bullpen, accessed October 2026, https://www.baseball-reference.com/bullpen/Jimmy_Williams_(minors02).

30 Souvenir booklet, Welland Centennial 1858-1958, accessed in September 2026 via the Internet Archive, https://archive.org/details/welland-centennial-souvenir-booklet-1958/: 41-44.

31 “Legion Show Opens; Crowds Enjoy the Fun,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, May 14, 1930: 1; “Out Door Wrestling at Burgar Park” (advertisement), Welland Evening Tribune, June 26, 1958: 15; “Mount Hope Flyers Are Beaten by 9,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, August 10, 1942: 7; “George Drew to Visit Welland” (advertisement), Welland Evening Tribune, July 27, 1953: 3; “Corpus Christi Arch on Empire Street” (photo and caption), Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, July 2, 1948: 2; “8,000 Take Part in Successful Welland Victory Loan Inaugural,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, July 2, 1941: 1.

32 Many of these attractions returned to Burgar Park more than once. Representative stories and advertisements include “Whiskered Men to Play in Welland,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, July 6, 1940: 9; “Power-Packed Giants of Negro National League to Visit Burgar Park,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, June 2, 1945: 9; “Zulu Clowns at Burgar Park Tonight,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, August 14, 1948: 7; “NHL All-Stars Here Thursday,” Welland Evening Tribune, August 15, 1961: 8; and “King and His Court to Show at Burgar,” Welland-Port Colborne Evening Tribune, August 31, 1954: 12.

33 Jack Montgomerie, “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland Evening Tribune, May 25, 1960: 10; “See Once-Proud Burgar Park Becoming Minor Ball Field,” Welland Evening Tribune, February 12, 1962: 5; “Board to Study Feasibility of Disposing of Burgar Pk.,” Welland Evening Tribune, May 16, 1961: 5.

34 “City-Peninsula-Border,” Welland Evening Tribune, July 2, 1963: 5.

35 Jack Montgomerie, “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland Evening Tribune, July 21, 1960: 14.

36 “Hungarians Grab 4-2 Win Over Falls Team,” Welland Evening Tribune, June 18, 1962: 9.

37 “Hydro Board Members Oppose Burgar Pk. Sale,” Welland Evening Tribune, October 27, 1965: 14. The colloquial expression “had the biscuit” is used to refer to something that is moribund, useless, or near death. Noor-E Ferdous, “Adventures in Canadianisms: Had the Biscuit,” Queen’s University Strathy Language Unit website, accessed September 2026, https://www.queensu.ca/strathy/blog/adventures-canadianisms.

38 “Burgar Lights Are Torn Down,” Welland Evening Tribune, May 1, 1967: 14; “Weatherman Hits Seeding Plan for New Ball Fields,” Welland Evening Tribune, November 13, 1968: 5; “City-Peninsula-Border,” Welland Evening Tribune, April 23, 1970: 4.

39 “Future of Burgar Park Still in Doubt,” Welland Evening Tribune, April 17, 1975: 3.

40 Jerry Lodboa, “Down the Sport Trail,” Welland Evening Tribune, July 6, 1973: 6; Wayne Redshaw, “Bob Blasko Hurls Optimists to Niagara District Crown,” Welland Evening Tribune, August 20, 1973: 8.

41 Wayne Redshaw, “Santos Need a Release,” Welland Evening Tribune, January 19, 1972: 12.

42 “City Can’t Afford Burgar Field Move,” Welland Evening Tribune, February 19, 1976: 3; “Parks Budget $833,505 Forestry Crew Priority,” Welland Evening Tribune, May 11, 1977: 3.

43 Jerry Lodboa, “Jays’ Farm Club Here a Possibility,” Welland Evening Tribune, September 2, 1977: 8; “City Should Make Input to Get Jays Farm Club,” Welland Evening Tribune, September 13, 1977: 1. The Blue Jays eventually did establish a farm team on the Niagara Peninsula—not in Welland, but in St. Catharines, where the Jays operated a short-season Class A affiliate from 1986 through 1999. (As mentioned later in the story and endnotes, the St. Catharines Blue Jays were among the visiting teams playing at Burgar Park during its brief period as a pro ballpark.)

44 “Burgar Park Bleachers Do Not Meet Standards,” Welland Evening Tribune, October 6, 1977: 3; “Burgar Park Bleachers Renovated” (photo and caption), Welland Evening Tribune, April 29, 1978: 3.

45 Derek Swartz, “Made in Welland!” Welland Tribune, June 4, 2010: A11.

46 “J.D. Yari Day Tomorrow at Burgar Park,” Welland Tribune, July 26, 1980: 8. John “J.D.” Yari, an outfielder, played two seasons with Toronto’s rookie-level team in Medicine Hat in 1981 and 1982, hitting a combined .246 in 79 games.

47 John Sherwin, “Sports Promotion Committee Wants Bases Loaded at the Ballpark,” Welland Tribune, March 29, 1990: 28A; Joe Barkovich, “Oh Is Japan’s New Folk Hero,” Welland Evening Tribune, September 1, 1977: 12. The latter story gave Burgar Park’s dimensions as 297 feet to right, 400 to center field, and 337 feet to left.

48 “Sports Complex Dream Pursued and Caught,” Welland Evening Tribune, March 8, 1988: 4; Wayne Redshaw, “New City Sports Complex Really Impressive,” Welland Tribune, August 31, 1988: 19.

49 Wayne Redshaw, “Pirates Switch Divisions,” Welland Tribune, September 30, 1988: 9; Wayne Redshaw, “The Doctor Speaks,” Welland Tribune, September 28, 1988: 19.

50 Ken Avey, “Sports Complex Ahead of Schedule: Marshall,” Welland Tribune, July 13, 1988: 3.

51 Redshaw, “It’s One Big Headache for Pirates’ Bill Kuehn”; Carolyn Abraham, “Everything Is Canceled, Moved to Memorial Park,” Welland Evening Tribune, June 28, 1989: 1.

52 Ken Avey and Charles Muggeridge, “Batter Up at Burgar Park—For Now,” Welland Tribune, June 9, 1989: 1. This story credits the Niagara District Weather Office with the information that May’s local rainfall had set a record. Also, the lighting at the ballpark was judged not to be up to professional standards: It was decided that day games could be finished under the lights, but they were not suited for full-game night play. Wayne Redshaw, “Where Were the Fans for the Home Opener?,” Welland Tribune, June 19, 1989: 14C.

53 Redshaw, “Where Were the Fans for the Home Opener?”; Wayne Redshaw, “Pirates Are Impressive,” Welland Tribune, June 19, 1989: 14C.

54 Redshaw, “No Excuse Now.”

55 Avey and Muggeridge, “Batter Up at Burgar Park—For Now.”

56 In “No Excuse Now,” Redshaw listed the Pirates’ record at Burgar Park as 5-6, and a review of game-by-game recaps from the Welland Tribune confirms that. The Pirates won on June 17 against Niagara Falls, June 26 against Batavia, July 2 against Erie, July 6 against Jamestown, and their Burgar Park finale on July 13 against St. Catharines. They lost on June 19 to Niagara Falls, June 24 to Batavia, June 28 and 29 to Pittsfield, July 8 to Jamestown, and July 11 to St. Catharines.

57 Wayne Redshaw, “Pirates Show Character,” Welland Tribune, July 14, 1989: 21.

58 The 6,006 attendance figure was used several times in contemporary news stories, including Redshaw’s “No Excuse Now” and Wayne Redshaw, “Pirates’ Last Game Is Still Remembered,” Welland Tribune, June 19, 1990: 2A. The author of this story tried to independently confirm that attendance but could not find gate totals for four of the Pirates’ 11 games at Burgar Park. Attendance for the seven games that could be found was consistent with the average of 546 fans per game and offered no reason to doubt or second-guess the 6,006 total reported at the time.

59 Wayne Redshaw, “Pirates Christen New Complex in Fine Style,” Welland Tribune, July 18, 1989: 23.

60 Wayne Creighton, “Pirates Get Belted,” Welland Tribune, July 12, 1989: 30. All major-leaguers listed in this section were specifically mentioned in game stories as having played in games at Burgar Park.

61 Wayne Creighton, “Failure to Convert Opportunities Costly to Pirates,” Welland Tribune, June 29, 1989: 11; Barry Tuttle, “Pirates’ Rally Falls Short in Slugfest with Mets,” Welland Tribune, June 30, 1989: 31; “Welland Extends O’s Woes,” Erie (Pennsylvania) Times, July 2, 1989: 2S; Wayne Creighton, “Pirates’ Bats Come Alive,” Welland Tribune, June 27, 1989: 10; Barry Tuttle, “A Ninth Inning Homer Sinks Pirates,” Welland Tribune, June 20, 1989: 8. This list is based on players identified in game stories, and may not be comprehensive or complete.

62 Pennyfeather is mentioned in multiple game stories, including Redshaw, “Pirates Are Impressive.”

63 Creighton, “Pirates’ Bats Come Alive.” Wagner shared Welland roots with Sal Maglie, but that might have been all: Where Maglie led the NL in wins, Wagner led it in losses (16, with the 1995 Pirates).

64 This exchange is captured on the back of Wakefield’s card (No. 27) in the 1989 Pucko Welland Pirates set. As of September 2026, the card could be seen on the Trading Card Database: https://www.tcdb.com/ViewCard.cfm/sid/71669/cid/5164601/1989-Pucko-Welland-Pirates-27-Tim-Wakefield.

65 Carolyn Abraham, “Rain Throwing Team’s Money Down the Drain,” Welland Tribune, June 29, 1989: 1.

66 Tuttle, “A Ninth Inning Homer Sinks Pirates.”

67 Wakefield making a pitching appearance at Burgar Park is mentioned in Barry Tuttle, “Pirates’ Rally Falls Short in Slugfest with Mets,” Welland Tribune, June 30, 1989: 31.

68 Among other things, Wakefield ranked first in Red Sox history in innings pitched (3,006) and games started (430), second in strikeouts and games pitched, and third in wins. His longevity, and his reliance on the unpredictable knuckleball, also made him the team’s all-time leader in less desirable categories, such as hits, home runs, and walks surrendered; earned runs; hit batsmen; wild pitches; and losses.

69 “Welland Baseball Stadium,” SportsNiagara website, accessed September 2026, https://sportniagara.ca/facilities/facility/welland-baseball-stadium. While this site refers to the park more formally as Welland Baseball Stadium, the shorter name Welland Stadium prevails in many other online references. The city of Welland’s website still used the Welland Sports Complex name as of 2026 (https://www.welland.ca/community-and-recreation/facilities-and-halls/sports-fields/#Baseball), and a Google Street View photo of the site taken in June 2025 showed the entrance to the facility still signed as the Welland Sports Complex.

70 As of September 2026, the city of Welland had 15 baseball diamonds available, though its website did not specify how many of them were the size and capacity of Burgar Park as opposed to, say, Little League fields. “Sports Tourism,” City of Welland website, https://www.welland.ca/community-and-recreation/tourism/sports-tourism/.

71 Bernd Franke, “Renegades Hope for Visit from World Series Winner,” Welland Tribune, July 11, 2002: B1.

72 Examples include Bernd Franke, “Champs Solid as Steel,” Welland Tribune, April 30, 2012: B1; and Terry Hughes, “Burgar Park: One-Time Scene of Welland’s Illegal Sports,” Welland Tribune, April 5, 2008: A7.

73 Bernd Franke, “Not Teeming with Teams,” Welland Tribune, May 31, 2002: B3. Franke made this observation while noting that a local sports wall of fame was switching its focus from outstanding Welland-area teams to outstanding individual athletes.

74 Dave Johnston, “Welland’s Burgar Park Gatehouse to Be Demolished,” Welland Tribune, updated August 15, 2025, and accessed September 2026, https://www.wellandtribune.ca/news/council/wellands-burgar-park-gatehouse-to-be-demolished/article_24c0078c-1347-5440-9e56-1d533b027697.html.

75 As of September 2026, Burgar Park appeared to be most frequently used as a practice and game site for Welland Minor Baseball, an operator of youth leagues ranging from 4-and-under tee ball to 18-and-under baseball. Burgar Park was one of numerous facilities listed on the organization’s online calendar, viewable at https://www.wellandminorbaseball.ca/mastercalendar. The park also showed up on the calendars of visiting youth baseball organizations, such as St. Catharines Minor Baseball: https://www.stcatharinesbaseball.ca/team/12464/1333/12544/372956/leaguegames.

Donate Join Shop

© 2026 SABR. All Rights Reserved.