
SABR All-Time Eras Teams:
Segregation Era (1920-1946)
Throughout the 2026 season, SABR members will have a chance to vote on SABR’s All-Time Eras Teams as we celebrate the 150 years of baseball and American history since the founding of the National League in 1876.
The All-Time Eras Teams project is an interactive opportunity for all SABR members to participate in, debate with one another, and learn more about the iconic players and figures from different eras.
Voting for the Segregation Era took place between May 29–June 13, 2026, and the team was revealed in an online webinar on June 24 with a presentation by Seth S. Tannenbaum of Manhattanville University. More than 840 SABR members cast a vote on this ballot. The top vote recipients at each position were selected for the first team. Click here to view the full list of players included on the ballot.
Each of the six All-Time Eras Team ballots will be released throughout the baseball season. SABR members will be able to vote for players at every position on the diamond, as well as the top manager and executive from that era.
Learn more about the Segregation Era team selected by SABR members below.
Outfielders

Babe Ruth

Joe DiMaggio

Oscar Charleston
Infielders

Josh Gibson (C)

Lou Gehrig (1B)

Rogers Hornsby (2B)

Pie Traynor (3B)

Arky Vaughan (SS)
Pitchers

Bob Feller

Satchel Paige

Lefty Grove

Carl Hubbell

Dizzy Dean
Manager/Executive

Joe McCarthy

Branch Rickey
Second Team
- Outfielders: Mel Ott, Cool Papa Bell, Turkey Stearnes
- Infielders: Mickey Cochrane (C), Jimmie Foxx (1B), Charlie Gehringer (2B), Judy Johnson (3B), Willie Wells (SS)
- Pitchers: Bullet Rogan, Martín Dihigo, Dazzy Vance, Hal Newhouser, Lefty Gomez
- Manager: Miller Huggins
- Executive: Rube Foster
Third Team
- Outfielders: Al Simmons, Harry Heilmann, Paul Waner
- Infielders: Bill Dickey (C), Buck Leonard (1B), Newt Allen (2B), Ray Dandridge (3B), Luke Appling (SS)
- Pitchers: Leon Day, Red Ruffing, Stan Coveleski, Bill Foster, Hilton Smith
- Manager: Vic Harris
- Executive: Effa Manley
Team Reveal and Video Presentation
Click here to watch the unveiling of the Segregation Era team and a presentation by Seth S. Tannenbaum of Manhattanville University.
More about the Segregation Era (1920-1946)
Baseball was a game of contrasts and innovations during the period between the two world wars of the twentieth century. On the field, a growing trend toward home run-happy offenses affected all levels of the sport. Led by Babe Ruth’s record-setting exploits, the New York Yankees began establishing a dynasty. They also became the first major league team to draw more than 1 million fans in home attendance in 1921. Soon, they would have a new ballpark to call their own, Yankee Stadium, which opened two years later.
The Negro National League, led by pioneering player, manager, and executive Rube Foster, opened its first season in 1920. The league served as the pinnacle for thousands of elite players who were denied entry into the White major leagues because of their race. The segregated all-Black leagues operated during an era of horrific racial violence around the United States, but they thrived with stars like Satchel Paige, Josh Gibson, Oscar Charleston, and Buck Leonard.
The sport also became more widely accessible to fans who were able to follow along from their homes by tuning in to games on the radio. The first baseball broadcast on commercial radio took place in the summer of 1921 at Forbes Field in Pittsburgh. By the end of the decade, Arlin and other broadcasting pioneers were calling World Series games for the entire nation, bringing in millions of new fans to the national pastime.
Finally, the hiring of new commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis changed the landscape of baseball’s power structure forever. His iron-clad rule for the next two decades affected the sport’s relationship with gambling, the minor leagues, and fans. However, the American League and National League remained segregated throughout Landis’s entire reign.






