
SABR All-Time Eras Teams:
Deadball Era (1901-1919)
Throughout the 2026 season, SABR members will have a chance to vote on SABR’s All-Time Eras Teams as we celebrate the 150 years of baseball and American history since the founding of the National League in 1876.
The All-Time Eras Teams project is an interactive opportunity for all SABR members to participate in, debate with one another, and learn more about the iconic players and figures from different eras.
Voting for the Deadball Era took place between April 17–May 4, 2026, and the team was revealed in an online webinar on May 13 with a presentation by Brian M. Ingrassia of West Texas A&M University. More than 650 SABR members cast a vote on this ballot. The top vote recipients at each position were selected for the first team. Click here to view the full list of players included on the ballot.
Each of the six All-Time Eras Team ballots will be released throughout the baseball season. SABR members will be able to vote for players at every position on the diamond, as well as the top manager and executive from that era.
Learn more about the Deadball Era team selected by SABR members below.
Outfielders

Ty Cobb

Tris Speaker

Joe Jackson
Infielders

Roger Bresnahan (C)

Frank Chance (1B)

Nap Lajoie (2B)

Home Run Baker (3B)

Honus Wagner (SS)
Pitchers

Walter Johnson

Christy Mathewson

Grover Alexander

Mordecai Brown

Eddie Plank
Manager/Executive

John McGraw

Ban Johnson
Second Team
- Outfielders: Sam Crawford, Pete Hill, Zack Wheat
- Infielders: Jimmy Collins (3B), John Henry Lloyd (SS), Eddie Collins (2B), Jake Daubert (1B), Louis Santop (C)
- Pitchers: Ed Walsh, Rube Waddell, Andrew “Rube” Foster, Addie Joss, Smokey Joe Williams
- Manager: Connie Mack
- Executive: Barney Dreyfuss
Third Team
- Outfielders: Spotswood Poles, Fred Clarke, Harry Hooper
- Infielders: Heinie Groh (3B), Joe Tinker (SS), Johnny Evers (2B), Hal Chase (1B), Wally Schang (C)
- Pitchers: Charles Bender, Jack Chesbro, John Donaldson, Smoky Joe Wood, Joe McGinnity
- Manager: Fred Clarke
- Executive: Charles Comiskey
Team Reveal and Video Presentation
Click here to watch the unveiling of the Deadball Era team and a presentation by Brian M. Ingrassia of West Texas A&M University.
More about the Deadball Era (1901-1919)
The Deadball Era from 1901 to 1919 is one of the most popular, colorful, important, and distinct eras in baseball history. The pitcher-dominated era earned its name because game balls were rarely removed from play, resulting in grimy, softening baseballs that played as if they were “dead.”
The era began with the formation of the American League and the establishment of the original 16-franchise structure that lasted the first half of the twentieth century. The World Series became an annual tradition and the sport became entrenched as America’s national pastime. The challenge of the upstart Federal League led to a legal battle that went to the Supreme Court and eventually resulted in the sport’s exemption from United States antitrust laws. Finally, the era culminated with the emergence of Babe Ruth as a home run hitter and the scandalous 1919 World Series. Baseball would never go back to the tactical style of play required by the “dead” ball.
SABR’s Deadball Era Committee encourages research on all facets of baseball between 1901 and 1919. The committee’s efforts produced the books Deadball Stars of the National League and Deadball Stars of the American League, which helped to inspire the popular SABR Baseball Biography Project. Another committee book, a pictorial history titled The World Series in the Deadball Era, was published in 2018.






