SABR Digital Library: Inventing Baseball: The 100 Greatest Games of the 19th Century

Inventing Baseball: The 100 Greatest Games of the 19th Century
Edited by Bill Felber

Inventing Baseball: The 100 Greatest Games of the 19th Century
Edited by Bill Felber
Associate editors: Bob Bailey, Mark Fimoff, Jerry Casway, Len Levin, Robert L. Tiemann, Peter Mancuso and Craig Waff
Foreword by John Thorn
Publication Date: July 13, 2013

ISBN (paperback): 978-1-93359-942-7, $19.95
ISBN (ebook): 978-1-933599-43-4, $9.99
8.5″ x 11″, 308 pages

A project of SABR’s Nineteenth Century Committee and published through the SABR Digital Library, Inventing Baseball brings to life the greatest games to be played in the game’s early years. From the “prisoner of war” game that took place among captive Union soldiers during the Civil War, to the first intercollegiate game (Amherst versus Williams), to the first professional no-hitter, the games in this volume span 1833-1900 and detail the athletic exploits of such players as Cap Anson, Moses “Fleetwood” Walker, Charlie Comiskey, Mike “King” Kelly, and John Montgomery Ward.

Forty-two SABR members contributed chapters to the effort.

SABR members, get this e-book for FREE!

Buy the book

Below: Find memorable game stories from SABR’s Inventing Baseball

Game Recaps

July 4, 1833: In the beginning, Olympics vs. Camden

Circa 1840: The legendary Doubleday Game

October 1845: The first recorded baseball games in New York

June 3, 1851: Match play, Knickerbockers vs. Washington Club (NY)

Summer 1858: The Brooklyn-New York baseball rivalry begins

September 9, 1858: The New York rules in New England

June 30, 1859: Caught on the fly: Knickerbockers vs. Excelsiors

July 1, 1859: Baseball goes to college

October 11, 1859: Upton Excelsiors become the Massachusetts champions

July 1860: The Grand Excursion of the South Brooklyn Excelsiors

August 23, 1860: No gentlemen’s game, Excelsior vs. Atlantic

July 24, 1860: The first enclosed ballpark

September 1860: The Grand Excursion, part 2: Excelsiors of South Brooklyn

July 4, 1862: The Civil War POW Game

September 18, 1862: The ‘Silver Ball’ Game

October 14, 1862: The Martyrdom of Jim Creighton

September 28, 1865: The first fixed baseball game

July 16, 1866: Lipman Pike’s home run record

October 1866: A return on their investment

July 25, 1867: The most important game in baseball history?

October 3, 1867: “The First Colored Baseball Championship”

October 7, 1867: Candy Cummings debuts the curve

June 15, 1869: A cunning play saves Cincinnati’s streak

August 26, 1869: Cincinnati Red Stockings: Unbeaten, But Tied

September 3, 1869: Inter-racial baseball in Philadelphia

June 14, 1870: The Atlantic Storm: Red Stockings suffer first defeat

July 23, 1870: The first ‘Chicago’ game

November 1, 1870: The birth of the National Association

May 4, 1871: Association Ball: Kekionga vs. Forest City

October 30, 1871: The first pennant race: Chicago White Stockings vs. Philadelphia Athletics

Summer 1874: New game in the Old Country: U.S. teams tour England

May 29, 1875: The first recorded no-hitter: Princeton vs. Yale

June 3, 1875: The unbeatable Boston Red Caps

June 19, 1875: The ‘Model’ Game: Hartford vs. Chicago

April 22, 1876: A new age begins with inaugural National League game

July 15, 1876: Wearin’ of the ‘Grin’: George Bradley’s no-hitter

August 20, 1877: Gray outcomes for ‘Louisville Four’

May 8, 1878: Three in one? Paul Hines’ unassisted triple play

September 14, 1878: Farewell to old-style ball

June 2, 1879: Lee Richmond’s no-hit debut

June 21, 1879: The cameo of William Edward White

June 12, 1880: Baseball perfection by Lee Richmond

June 17, 1880: Perfection revisited by John Ward

September 2, 1880: Night baseball at Nantasket Beach

June 25, 1881: George Gore’s theft spree

June 26, 1881: Mullane vs. Reccius for 18 innings

September 10, 1881: Roger Connor’s ‘ultimate’ grand slam

May 1, 1877: The double shutout

May 2, 1882: The Beer and Whiskey League: Day One

July 18, 1882: Tony Mullane goes both ways

August 17, 1882: Radbourn The Slugger

September 13, 1882: The innovative mind of King Kelly

October 6, 1882: The first meeting of champions

August 10, 1883: Cap Anson vs. Fleet Walker

September 10-13, 1883: Grasshopper Jim Whitney snatches the pennant

September 13, 1883: One hand, no hits for Hugh Daily

September 21-23, 1883: St. Louis Browns dynasty nipped at the wire

May 1, 1884: Fleet Walker’s major-league debut

June 7, 1884: Charlie Sweeney strikes out 19 for Providence

July 7, 1884: One-Arm Daily strikes out 19 (or 20)

July 28, 1884: Old Hoss Radbourn: 59 or 60 victories?

October 23-25, 1884: The first “World Series”

September 29-October 3, 1885: White Stockings cap a pennant chase

July 21, 1886: “A Glorious Victory”: Cuban Giants beat the Red Stockings

August 15, 1886: Guy Hecker: hitting pitcher

October 3, 1886: Matt Kilroy, strikeout king

October 23, 1886: Curt Welch’s winning slide

May 2, 1887: The first African-American battery

July 14, 1887: The color line is drawn in baseball

October 21, 1887: Sam Thompson’s triple trouble

August 14, 1888: Tim Keefe finally loses and “Casey at the Bat” premieres

September 4, 1888: The Little Steam Engine That Could: Pud Galvin’s 300th victory

February 9, 1889: A Wondrous Ball Park: The Pyramid Game in Giza, Egypt

June 22, 1889: Sad-sack Louisville Colonels lose 26th game in a row

September 7, 1889: The Candlelight Game

October 2, 1889: King Kelly’s Downfall

October 5, 1889: The Giants win the pennant on the last day

October 18, 1889: Genesis of a rivalry: Brooklyn vs. New York

October 29, 1889: Giants win back-to-back World’s Series

April 19, 1890: Debut of the Players League

May 12, 1890: The Kid, the Bolt, and Silent Mike

June 21, 1890: No hits — but no win for Silver King

October 6, 1890: The first worst-to-first team

September 28-30, 1891: The Clouded Finish: Beaneaters take over first place

June 10, 1892: Seven hits in seven tries for Wilbert Robinson

October 15, 1892: Bumpus Jones, the no-hit phenom

October 1892: The Split-Season Playoff

August 16, 1893: Bill Hawke’s no-hitter

May 15, 1894: “It Was a Hot Game, Sure Enough!”

May 30, 1894: Four home runs for Bobby Lowe

July 13, 1896: Ed Delahanty’s four-home run game

May 16, 1897: Arrested on a day of rest: Cleveland Spiders challenge Sunday baseball

April 19, 1900: A “Basket of Fresh Goose Eggs”

June 19, 1897: Wee Willie Keeler’s 44-game hitting streak ends

June 29, 1897: The Chicago Colts’ record romp for 36 runs

September 19, 1897: Cap Anson’s 3,000th hit?

September 27, 1897: Good (Beaneaters) versus Evil (Orioles)

July 25, 1898: The Ducky Holmes Game

September 16, 1899: Misfit Cleveland Spiders lose 24th in a row


Contributors: Bill Felber, Bill Nowlin, Bob Bailey, Bob Tiemann, Casey Tibbitts, Charles Faber, Cliff Blau, Craig Waff, David Arcidiacano, Dick McBane, Donald Jensen, Edward Achorn, Frank Vaccaro, Greg Rhodes, Irv Goldfarb, James Rygelski, Jean-Pierre Caillault, Jeff Samoray, Jerry Casway, Jerry Grillo, Jim Overmyer, Jimmy Keenan, Joanne Hulbert, John Bauer, John Husman, John Thorn, John Zinn, Jon Barnes, Kathy Torres, Lyle Spatz, Mark Pestana, Mike Harrington, Parker Bena, Patricia Millen, Paul Browne, Peter Mancuso, Phil Dixon, Rich Bogovich, Richard Hershberger, Terry Gottschall, W. Lloyd Johnson, and William Lamb.

 

Donate Join

© 2026 SABR. All Rights Reserved.