SABR Digital Library: Baseball’s Greatest Comeback Games

Baseball’s Greatest Comeback Games, edited by Bill Nowlin

Baseball’s Greatest Comeback Games
Edited by Bill Nowlin
Associate editors: Len Levin and Carl Riechers
Publication Date: March 31, 2021
ISBN (ebook): 978-1-9701-5946-2, $9.99
ISBN (paperback): 978-1-9701-5947-9, $29.95
8.5″ x 11″, 251 pages

What are Major League Baseball’s greatest comeback games? This SABR Digital Library book set out to collect the stories of those games, but rather than throw together an anecdotally-determined collection of games, SABR decided to see if there was an objective measure, a way to determine which was the greatest comeback game of all time, and to rank the games. Retrosheet’s Tom Ruane created a master list of 630 games and ranked them mathematically in terms of how unlikely the win was, and therefore how great the comeback had been. The games in this volume are presented in rank order, from number 1 through 64.

We also added the greatest postseason comeback games. These seven contests are presented in a separate section devoted to postseason games. And to make sure that every current team in MLB was represented in this volume, we treated the Los Angeles Dodgers and San Francisco Giants as different from the Brooklyn Dodgers and New York Giants, and added the greatest comeback by the Colorado Rockies, Texas Rangers, and several other teams.

In the end, every major-league team is represented in Baseball’s Greatest Comeback Games, but the Phillies lead the list with six comeback wins in the top 64. Tied for second for most comebacks are four American League teams: the Red Sox, Indians, Tigers, and Yankees.

This book was a team effort by 60 members of the Society for American Baseball Research, who researched and wrote about all 80 games presented herein.

SABR members, get this e-book for FREE!

Buy the book


Below: Find memorable game stories from Baseball’s Greatest Comeback Games

Game Recaps

April 15, 1994: Angels score seven in ninth and beat Blue Jays in 10th

April 17, 1976: Phillies slugger Mike Schmidt hits four home runs at Wrigley Field

April 20, 1961: Milwaukee Braves make dramatic comeback in 9th, win in 11

April 21, 2012: Yankees rally from 9 runs down to blow out Red Sox

April 25, 1901: Tigers stage 9th-inning comeback in AL opener

April 28, 2015: Dan Uggla homer beats the team paying him

April 29, 1979: Bobby Murcer’s 9th-inning home run shocks Braves

August 16, 1918: Tigers rally for six in 9th, beat Walter Johnson and Senators in 16 innings

August 18, 1953: For a day, Senators slam brakes on Yankees’ steamroller

August 18, 2000: Yankees and Rivera stumble as Angels rally to win in 11

August 20, 1947: Down by eight runs, Yankees rally to win in extra innings

August 21, 1934: Cleveland scores nine runs in 9th to rally past A’s

August 21, 1990: Phillies score 9 in ninth against Dodgers, overcoming a 10-run deficit

August 26, 1998: Marlins shock Cardinals with four ninth-inning home runs

August 29, 1986: Angels stun Tigers, 13-12, with ninth-inning comeback

August 30, 1919: Outburst by Tigers’ inert offense stuns St. Louis

August 31, 1999: Cleveland rallies from 8 runs down in eighth inning to beat Angels

August 31, 2016: For whom the bell Toles: Dodgers rally to beat Rockies

August 5, 1938: Boston’s Joe Cronin transforms self from goat to hero

August 5, 2001: Cleveland overcomes 12-run deficit to beat Mariners

August 5, 2007: Phillies leave Brewers flat with payback comeback

July 13, 1937: Phillies snatch defeat from the hands of victory

July 17, 1973: Mets score 7 runs in 9th inning to beat Braves, 8-7

July 2, 1995: Orioles score 7 runs in 9th to thwart Blue Jays

July 24, 2018: Athletics erase 8-run deficit, beat Rangers 13-10

July 25, 1980: Seven-run 9th inning launches Astros to 9-8 victory over Expos

July 25, 2009: Rays come back to beat the Blue Jays in 12th inning

July 27, 1975: Al Bumbry breaks 0-for-23 skid with rare homer in Orioles’ comeback

July 28, 1931: Bob Fothergill leads White Sox in 11-run rally to beat Yankees

July 3, 1923: Ailing Tigers rally to top Cleveland

July 3, 2008: Diamondbacks’ late heroics tap Brewers

July 5, 1978: Braves blast Dodgers for 6 runs in ninth for epic comeback

July 6, 2010: Altitude decides another one as Rockies rally to beat Cardinals

July 7, 1922: Tigers roar back with win over Senators

June 10, 1946: No no-hitter for Borowy as Phillies rally at Wrigley

June 10, 1974: Padres overcome 8-0 deficit in eighth inning to win

June 11, 1933: Pirates score 10 in ninth to beat the Cardinals

June 14, 2019: Padres score 12 unanswered runs to rally at Coors Field

June 15, 1925: Athletics overcome 12-run deficit to knock off Cleveland

June 15, 1979: Royals stage ‘a comeback for all seasons’ in defeating Brewers

June 17, 1936: Browns overcome 11-run deficit to beat A’s

June 18, 1961: Red Sox sweep Senators in a double walk-off doubleheader

June 19, 2010: Twins’ bench is twice as nice in comeback against Phillies

June 2, 2016: Mariners storm back from 10-run deficit to defeat hapless Padres

June 23, 1961: Phillies stun Pirates, 12-11

June 25, 1929: Robins stun Giants with 5 ninth-inning runs to tie game, then win in 10th

June 28, 2003: Marlins redeem themselves from blowout with late rally against Red Sox

June 29, 1952: Cubs’ ninth-inning comeback spoils Bubba Church’s outing

June 30, 2009: One Sugarcoated Game: Orioles rally from 9 runs down to beat Boston

June 4, 1951: Connie Ryan returns to Boston, helps Reds flip standings

June 4, 1989: Down 10-0, Ernie Whitt and Blue Jays slam Red Sox

June 8, 1937: Moose becomes goat after Cleveland gives up 6-run lead to Red Sox

May 10, 1994: Braves beat Phillies in 15th inning on Mike Stanton’s walk-off bunt

May 13, 1911: Ty Cobb’s 5 RBIs not enough to withstand Red Sox comeback

May 18, 1950: Rough inning for Cardinals leads to improbable Dodgers comeback

May 18, 1976: Yankees score 5 runs in 9th to tie and 5 in 16th to win

May 2, 2005: Cardinals score 7 runs in 9th to complete comeback against Reds

May 22, 2000: Brewers treat ex-teammate poorly in 10-9 comeback win

May 23, 1901: Cleveland Blues turn hopeless defeat into glorious victory

May 25, 2009: Cleveland battles back from 10-run deficit to defeat Rays

May 27, 1933: Yankees score 12 runs in eighth for big comeback win

May 28, 2008: Twins cause a Royal ruckus with large comeback win

May 5, 1919: Cincinnati is red as Cubs overcome 6-0 deficit in the 9th

May 7, 1925: A Baker Bowl lead is never big enough, especially for the Phillies

May 8, 1918: The wildest, wobbliest, weirdest windup as Reds score nine in 9th

May 8, 1958: Smoky Burgess homer caps 8-run ninth for Cincinnati Redlegs

May 8, 2004: Rangers, Tigers combine for 31 runs as Texas overcomes 10-run deficit

October 11, 1992: Alomar, Blue Jays emerge out of shadows in ALCS Game 4

October 11, 2016: Cubs score 4 in ninth to beat Giants in Game 4 of NL Division Series

October 12, 1929: A’s stage historic World Series comeback with 10-run inning

October 12, 1986: Dave Henderson’s homer keeps Red Sox hopes alive in Game Five

October 15, 1986: Mets win NLCS thriller in 16 innings

October 16, 2008: J.D. Drew walk-off caps Game 5 comeback, keeps Red Sox’s repeat hopes alive

October 20, 1993: Blue Jays battle back to win 15-14 in highest-scoring game in World Series history

September 10, 1916: Pirates’ 6-run ninth completes comeback and makes Burleigh Grimes a winner in debut

September 2, 1972: Mets’ Ken Boswell has ‘the kind of a night you dream about’

September 20, 1942: War worries overshadow Senators’ huge 9th inning against A’s

September 23, 1970: Dodgers lose to Giants, 14-10, after leading by 8 runs

September 8, 1921: Phillies rally for eight runs in ninth inning for comeback victory

September 8, 1947: Giants stage surprising comeback to beat Pirates


Contributors: Gary Belleville, Charlie Bevis, Nathan Bierma, David Black, Stephen D. Boren, Thomas J. Brown Jr., Dr. John J. Burbridge Jr., Frederick C. Bush, JP Caillault, Ralph Caola, Ken Carrano, Alan Cohen, Rory Costello, Richard Cuicchi, Rich D’Ambrosio, Scott Ferkovich, James Forr, Brian Frank, Adrian Fung, Gregory Funk, Gordon J. Gattie, Nate Gilman, Steven Glassman, Irv Goldfarb, William Grmek, Vince Guerrieri, Michael Hanks, Paul Hofmann, Mike Huber, Ronnie Joyner, Russ Lake, Kevin Larkin, Bob LeMoine, Len Levin, Justin Mattingly, Madison McEntire, Bill Nowlin, Tony S. Oliver, Dennis Pajot, Laura H. Peebles, Matthew Perry, Alan Raylesberg, Carl Riechers, Richard Riis, Tom Ruane, Tom Schott, Peter Seidel, Andrew Sharp, Mark S. Sternman, Andrew Stockmann, Jim Sweetman, Bruce Thompson, Michael Trzinski, Joseph Wancho, Brian Williams, Jim Wohlenhaus, Gregory H. Wolf, Allan Wood, and Jack Zerby.

Donate Join

© 2026 SABR. All Rights Reserved.